Method and apparatus for controlling power in a variable rate communication system

• US 5,528,593 A
• Filed: 09/30/1994
• Issued: 06/18/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 09/30/1994
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Qualcomm, Inc.
• Original Assignee: Qualcomm, Inc.
• Inventors: DeJaco, Andrew P., English, Sean
• Primary Examiner(s): Safourek, Benedict V.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Patel, Ajit
• Application Number:
  US08/316,168
• Time in Patent Office: 627 Days
• Field of Search: 370/84, 370/112, 370/110.1, 375/200, 375/205, 455/69, 455/33.1, 455/70, 455/54.1, 455/33.2, 380/34, 341/61, 379/59, 379/60
• US Class Current: 370/391
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 24/00 Supervisory, monitoring or testing arrangements
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 28/06 Optimizing the usage of the radio link, e.g. header compression, information sizing , discarding information system modifying transmission characteristic according to link quality by modifying frame length H04L1/0007; dynamic adaptation of the packet size for flow control or congestion control H04L47/365
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 28/22 Negotiating communication rate
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 52/267 taking into account the information rate
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 52/36 with a discrete range or set of values, e.g. step size, ramping or offsets

Abstract

A method and apparatus for controlling transmission power in a variable rate communication system is disclosed. The method disclosed provides for a closed loop power control method. A first remote station controls the transmission power of a second remote station by transmitting a rate dependent power control signal to the second remote communication station. Since only the second communication knows its transmission rate a priori, it must determine its course of action in accordance with both the received power control signal and the knowledge of its transmission rate. In the present invention, the power control system reduces the amount of overhead required by restricting the possible rate transition of the variable rate communication system. The power control system further increases its efficiency by allocating the power control bits top various rate hypotheses in accordance with the probability of the rate hypothesis and the perceptual impact of power control for frames of data transmitted at the hypothetical rate.

Claims

1. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for controlling said transmission power of said first communication device at said second communication device comprising:

receiver means for receiving said data frame;

power measurement means for measuring power of said received data frame;

comparison means for comparing said measured power against a set of threshold values wherein each threshold value of said set of threshold values corresponds to a different rate hypothesis of a set of rate hypotheses determined in accordance with a set of allowed rate transitions to provide a power control signal; and

transmitter means for transmitting said power control signal.

2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said comparison means is further responsive to a signal indicating a rate of each of a plurality of previous received data frames.

3. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said comparison means is further responsive to a signal indicating a rate of a previous received data frame.

4. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said set of allowed rate transitions comprises 2ⁿ -1 allowed transitions, where n is an integer.

5. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said set of allowed rate transitions comprises 3 allowed transitions.

6. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for adjusting said transmission power of said first communication device comprising:

data source means for generating frames of data at a variable data rate wherein said frames of data are generated in accordance with a set of allowed transition rates;

receiver means for receiving a power control signal;

control processor means for determining a power adjustment signal in accordance with said power control signal; and

transmitter means responsive to said power adjustment signal, for transmitting each of said frames of data at a corresponding predetermined power level.

7. The apparatus of claim 6 wherein said control processor means is responsive to said set of allowed rate transitions.

8. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for controlling said transmission power of said first communication device at said second communication device comprising:

receiver means for receiving said data frame;

power measurement means for measuring power of said received data frame;

comparison means for comparing said measured power against a set of threshold values wherein each threshold value of said set of threshold values corresponds to a different rate hypothesis of a set of rate hypotheses to provide a power control signal wherein said power control signal is indicative of a power adjustment command for a rate hypothesis and wherein said rate hypothesis is selected in accordance with the probability of said data frame being of a rate equal to said rate hypothesis; and

transmitter means for transmitting said power control signal.

9. The apparatus of claim 8 wherein said rate hypothesis selection is further a function of a level of data packet bit repetition associated with frames transmitted at said rate hypothesis.

10. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for adjusting said transmission power of said first communication device comprising:

receiver means for receiving a power control signal for a rate hypothesis;

control processor means for determining a power adjustment signal in accordance with said power control signal and with a predetermined rate hypothesis format determining the rate of said rate hypothesis and wherein said rate hypothesis format is determined in accordance with the data frame having been transmitted at a rate equal to the rate hypothesis to provide a transmitter adjustment signal; and

transmitter means responsive to said transmitter adjustment signal, for transmitting said data frame at a predetermined power level.

11. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a method for controlling said transmission power of said first communication device at said second communication device comprising the steps of:

receiving said data frame;

measuring power of said received data frame;

comparing said measured power against a set of threshold values wherein each threshold value of said set of threshold values corresponds to a different rate hypothesis of a set of rate hypotheses determined in accordance with a set of allowed rate transitions to provide a power control signal; and

transmitting said power control signal.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of comparing is responsive to a signal indicating a rate of each of a plurality of previous received data frames.

13. The method of claim 11 wherein said step of comparing is responsive to a signal indicating a rate of a previous received data frame.

14. The method of claim 11 wherein said set of allowed rate transitions comprises 2ⁿ -1 allowed transitions, where n is an integer.

15. The method of claim 11 wherein said set of allowed rate transitions comprises 3 allowed transitions.

16. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a method for adjusting said transmission power of said first communication device comprising the steps of:

determining a current data rate of a plurality of variable data rates in accordance with a set of allowed transition rates;

generating frames of data at said current data rate;

receiving a power control signal;

determining a power adjustment signal in accordance with said power control signal;

determining a transmit power level in response to said power adjustment signal; and

transmitting said frames of data at said power level.

17. The method of claim 16 wherein said step of determining a power adjustment signal is responsive to said set of allowed rate transitions.

18. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a method for controlling said transmission power of said first communication device at said second communication device comprising the steps of:

receiving said data frame;

measuring power of said received data frame;

comparing said measured power against a set of threshold values wherein each threshold value of said set of threshold values corresponds to a different rate hypothesis of a set of rate hypotheses to provide a power control signal wherein said power control signal is indicative of a power adjustment command for a rate hypothesis and wherein said rate hypothesis is selected in accordance with the probability of said data frame being of a rate equal to said rate hypothesis;

transmitting said power control signal.

19. The method of claim 18 wherein said rate hypothesis selection is further a function of a level of data packet bit repetition associated with frames transmitted at said rate hypothesis.

20. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a method for adjusting said transmission power of said first communication device comprising the steps of:

receiving a power control signal for a rate hypothesis;

determining a power adjustment signal in accordance with said power control signal and with a predetermined rate hypothesis format determining the rate of said rate hypothesis and wherein said rate hypothesis format is determined in accordance with the data frame having been transmitted at a rate equal to the rate hypothesis to provide a transmitter adjustment signal;

determining a power level in response to said transmitter adjustment signal; and

transmitting said data frame at said power level.

21. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for controlling said transmission power of said first communication device at said second communication device comprising:

a receiver for receiving said data frame and having an output;

a power measurement circuit for measuring power of said received data frame, and having an input coupled to said receiver output and having an output;

a comparison circuit having a first input coupled to said power measurement circuit output and having a second input for receiving a set of threshold values wherein each threshold value of said set of threshold values corresponds to a different rate hypothesis of a set of rate hypotheses determined in accordance with a set of allowed rate transitions and having an output to provide a power control signal in response to a comparison of said measured power value to said set of threshold values; and

a transmitter having an input for receiving said power control signal, said transmitter for transmitting said power control signal.

22. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said comparison circuit has a third input for receiving a signal indicating a rate of each of a plurality of previous received data frames.

23. The apparatus of claim 21 wherein said comparison circuit has a third input for receiving a signal indicating a rate of a previous received data frame.

24. In a variable rate communication system wherein a first communication device for the transmission of a data packet of variable rate data in a data frame of a predetermined data capacity to a second communication device wherein when said data packet is less than said data capacity generating repeated versions of bits in said data packet and providing a first version of said data packet bits and said repeated versions of said data packet bits in said data frame and wherein in a transmission power for transmitting said data frame is scaled in accordance with said data rate, a system for adjusting said transmission power of said first communication device comprising:

a variable rate data source for generating frames of data at a variable data rate wherein said frames of data are generated in accordance with a set of allowed transition rates and having an output;

a receiver having an input for receiving a power control signal and having an output;

a control processor for determining a power adjustment signal in response to said power control signal and having an input for receiving said power control signal and having an output; and

a transmitter responsive to said power adjustment signal, having a first input coupled to said a variable rate data source output and having a second input coupled to said control processor output for transmitting each of said frames of data at a corresponding predetermined power level.

25. The apparatus of claim 24 wherein said control processor is responsive to said set of allowed rate transitions.