Method for evaluation of health care quality

• US 5,544,044 A
• Filed: 08/02/1991
• Issued: 08/06/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 08/02/1991
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: United Healthcare Incorporated
• Original Assignee: United Healthcare Incorporated
• Inventors: Leatherman, Sheila
• Primary Examiner(s): Hayes, Gail O.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Poinvil, Frantzy
• Application Number:
  US07/739,629
• Time in Patent Office: 1,831 Days
• Field of Search: 364/413.01-413.04, 364/413.02, 364/414.415, 364/413.01, 364/413.02, 128/696
• US Class Current: 705/3
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/08 Insurance
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 20/10 relating to drugs or medications, e.g. for ensuring correct administration to patients
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 40/20 for the management or administration of healthcare resources or facilities, e.g. managing hospital staff or surgery rooms
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 70/60 relating to pathologies

Abstract

A software-based medical information system performs a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population (e.g., HMO, Medicaid) to assess and report on quality of care based on conformance to nationally recognized medical practice guidelines or quality indicators. The system analyzes health care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition by: providing to the system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population; defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events reportable in health care claims records; identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for that health care condition; defining health care quality criteria for that health care condition in terms of health care events reportable in health care claims records; comparing the health care quality criteria for the at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for that health care condition; and developing and outputting from the system a health care quality report based on the comparison and formulating action recommendations to improve care. The system provides an efficient means to supplement claims data with data from patient medical records.

Claims

1. In a medical information system comprising a processing unit, at least one memory unit and means for entering information into said medical information system and for providing commands to said medical information system, a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population to assess quality of care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population;

(b) defining in the medical information system at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(c) identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(d) defining in the medical information system health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in the health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(e) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(f) developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison of step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of providing health care claims records comprises providing records from a group consisting of:

claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions.

3. The method of claim 1 wherein multiple health care conditions and corresponding health care quality criteria for said multiple health care conditions are defined.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records comprises defining a specific health care condition in the nature of a disease or organic dysfunction.

6. The method of claim 5 wherein the at least one health care condition is selected from a group consisting of:

pediatric asthma, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and breast cancer.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records further comprises defining a specific health care condition not in the nature of a disease or organic dysfunction.

8. The method of claim 7 wherein the at least one health care condition is selected from a group consisting of:

prenatal care, caesarian section, breast cancer screening, cervical cancer screening and pediatric immunizations for a specified age group.

9. The method of claim 1 wherein step (f) comprises developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report that reports statistics on at least one adverse event as an indicator of a health care quality problem.

10. The method of claim 1 wherein step (f) comprises developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report that reports a frequency of occurrence of at least one health care quality criterion.

4. The method of claim I further comprising the steps of:

(g) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(h) defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported or reportable in the medical records;

(i) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(j) developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison of step (i) as well as step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

11. In a medical information system comprising a processing unit, at least one memory unit and means for entering information into said medical information system and for providing commands to said medical information system, a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population to assess quality of care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population, said claims records comprising claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions;

(b) defining in the medical information system at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(c) identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(d) defining in the medical information system health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in the health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(e) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(f) developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison of step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein multiple health care conditions and corresponding health care quality criteria for said multiple health care conditions are defined.

13. The method of claim 11 further comprising the steps of:

(g) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(h) defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported in the medical records;

(i) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(j) developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison of step (i) as well as step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

14. A medical information system for analyzing health care claims records for a health care benefit plan to assess quality of care received by plan members having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) a central processing unit;

(b) at least one memory unit connected to said central processing unit;

(c) means for providing to said processing unit health care claims records for a selected enrollee population;

(d) means for defining at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(e) means for identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(f) means for defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(g) means for comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(h) means for developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison performed by means (g) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

15. The system of claim 14 wherein the means for providing health care claims records comprises means for providing records from a group consisting of:

claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions.

16. The system of claim 14 further comprising:

(i) means for providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(j) means for defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported or reportable in the medical records;

(k) means for comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(l) means for developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison performed by means (k) as well as means (g) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

17. A medical information system for analyzing records for a health care benefit plan, wherein said medical information system assesses quality of care received by plan members having a specified health care condition and formulates action recommendations to improve care, said medical information system comprising:

(a) a processor;

(b) a database, accessible by said processor, wherein said database includes information from health care claim records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition;

(c) a data storage medium accessible by the processor, wherein the data storage medium has a program stored on it, and wherein the program is configured to cause the processor to;

define at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported or reportable in said health care claims records,

define health care quality criteria in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in said health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for said at least one health care condition,

identify enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition,

compare health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to said information from said health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition, and

formulate action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria; and

(d) an output device, connected to the processor, for outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report.

18. A medical information system as claimed in claim 17, wherein said output device is a printer.

19. A medical information system as claimed in claim 17, wherein said output device is a computer display.

20. A medical information system as claimed in claim 17, wherein said claims database includes

information from said health care claims records for medical professional services;

information from said health care claims records for hospital services; and

information from said health care claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions.

21. The system of claim 17, wherein said data medium includes at least one random access memory device.

22. The system of claim 17, wherein said data medium includes at least one magnetic media disk.

23. A data storage medium for use with a processor that accesses a database of information from health care claim records for an enrolled population, wherein the data storage medium has a program stored on it that causes the processor to:

(a) define at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported or reportable in said health care claims records;

(b) define health care quality criteria in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in said health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for said at least one health care condition;

(c) identify enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition;

(d) compare health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to said information from said health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(e) formulate action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.