Apparatus and method in a radio communication system for distinguishing an identifier of a nearby transmitter from that of a more distant transmitter

• US 5,551,061 A
• Filed: 02/24/1994
• Issued: 08/27/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 02/24/1994
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: Schwendeman, Robert J.
• Primary Examiner(s): Urban, Edward F.
• Application Number:
  US08/201,509
• Time in Patent Office: 915 Days
• Field of Search: 455/33.2, 455/33.4, 455/51.1, 455/54.1, 455/56.1, 342/450, 342/386, 342/457, 342/464
• US Class Current: 455/502
• CPC Class Codes: G08B 3/1083 Pager locating systems

Abstract

An apparatus and a method in a radio communication system repeatedly transmit and receive identifiers including a nearby identifier received by a radio receiver from a nearby transmitter, and distant identifiers received from more distant transmitters. The method and the apparatus distinguish in a probabilistic manner the nearby identifier from the distant identifiers by determining the identifier received most dependably over a predetermined period.

Claims

1. A portable radio receiver for receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted by a nearby transmitter and distant location identifiers transmitted by more distant transmitters in a radio communication system comprising the portable radio receiver and a plurality of the transmitters, the portable radio receiver distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the portable radio receiver comprising:

receiver means for receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

memory means coupled to the receiver means for storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions; and

processor means coupled to the memory means for comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period, and wherein the processor means defines the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are frequency modulated (FM) simulcast transmissions, and

wherein the portable radio receiver has a defined capture ratio, and

wherein the receiver means comprises demodulator means for demodulating a location identifier corresponding to a strongest transmitter producing a highest signal strength at the portable radio receiver during each of the periodic transmissions, wherein the highest signal strength is greater by at least the defined capture ratio than a signal strength produced at the portable radio receiver by the plurality of the transmitters other than the strongest transmitter, and

wherein the processor means comprises;

sorter means coupled to the memory means for sorting into like-valued groups the location values that are equal to one another;

counter means coupled to the sorter means for counting the location values sorted into each of the like-valued groups to determine one of the like-valued groups having a highest count; and

concluder means coupled to the counter means for concluding therefrom that the location value of the one of the like-valued groups having the highest count is the location value received with the greatest dependability.

2. A portable radio receiver for receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted by a nearby transmitter and distant location identifiers transmitted by more distant transmitters in a radio communication system comprising the portable radio receiver and a plurality of the transmitters, the portable radio receiver distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the portable radio receiver comprising:

receiver means for receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

memory means coupled to the receiver means for storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions; and

processor means coupled to the memory means for comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period, and wherein the processor means defines the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are simulcast transmissions comprising digital data bits transmitted at a plurality of predetermined bit positions, and

wherein the processor means comprises;

examiner means coupled to the memory means for examining at one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions the digital data bits corresponding to the location identifiers received and stored during the predetermined period;

determiner means coupled to the examiner means for determining that more than a predetermined percentage of the digital data bits at the one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions have a single coequal value;

designator means coupled to the determiner means for designating the single coequal value to be an estimated bit value for the one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions;

repeater means coupled to the examiner means for repeating the examining, determining, and designating for each of the plurality of predetermined bit positions until a plurality of estimated bit values corresponding to the plurality of predetermined bit positions have been designated; and

concluder means coupled to the repeater means for concluding that the plurality of estimated bit values represent the location value received with the greatest dependability.

3. A portable radio receiver for receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted by a nearby transmitter and distant location identifiers transmitted by more distant transmitters in a radio communication system comprising the portable radio receiver and a plurality of the transmitters, the portable radio receiver distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the portable radio receiver comprising:

receiver means for receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

memory means coupled to the receiver means for storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions; and

processor means coupled to the memory means for comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period, and wherein the processor means defines the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are simulcast transmissions comprising digital data symbols transmitted at a plurality of predetermined symbol positions, and

wherein the processor means comprises;

examiner means coupled to the memory means for examining at one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions the digital data symbols corresponding to the location identifiers received and stored during the predetermined period;

determiner means coupled to the examiner means for determining that more than a predetermined percentage of the digital data symbols at the one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions have a single coequal value;

designator means coupled to the determiner means for designating in response the single coequal value to be an estimated symbol value for the one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions;

repeater means coupled to the examiner means for repeating the examining, determining, and designating for each of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions until a plurality of estimated symbol values corresponding to the plurality of predetermined symbol positions have been designated; and

concluder means coupled to the repeater means for concluding that the plurality of estimated symbol values represent the location value received with the greatest dependability.

4. A portable radio receiver for receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted by a nearby transmitter and distant location identifiers transmitted by more distant transmitters in a radio communication system comprising the portable radio receiver and a plurality of the transmitters, the portable radio receiver distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the portable radio receiver comprising:

receiver means for receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

memory means coupled to the receiver means for storing data derived from the plurality of the periodic transmissions, the data comprising the location identifiers; and

processor means coupled to the memory means for comparing stored portions of the data with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period, and wherein the processor means defines the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier,

wherein the plurality of the periodic transmissions are sequential transmissions occurring in a plurality of predetermined non-overlapping time slots, each time slot dedicated for transmission of a corresponding one of the location identifiers, and

wherein the receiver means comprises a received signal strength indicator (RSSI) for measuring received signal strength of each of the plurality of the periodic transmissions, and

wherein the memory means comprises locations coupled to the RSSI for storing the received signal strength measured for each of the plurality of the periodic transmissions, and

wherein the processor means comprises;

calculator means coupled to the memory means for calculating from the received signal strengths stored, for each of the plurality of predetermined non-overlapping time slots, a mean received signal strength value of the periodic transmissions occurring therein over the predetermined period;

examiner means coupled to the calculator means for examining the mean received signal strength values calculated to determine the time slot having a highest mean received signal strength value; and

designator means coupled to the examiner means for designating the location value received during said time slot to be the location value received with the greatest dependability.

5. A probabilistic method in a radio communication system comprising a plurality of transmitters and a portable radio receiver, the method for transmitting and receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted to the portable radio receiver by a nearby transmitter, and distant location identifiers transmitted to the portable radio receiver by more distant transmitters, the method further for distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the method comprising in the portable communication receiver the steps of:

receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions;

comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period; and

defining the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are frequency modulated (FM) simulcast transmissions, and

wherein the portable radio receiver has a defined capture ratio, and

wherein the receiving step comprises the step of demodulating a location identifier corresponding to a strongest transmitter producing a highest signal strength at the portable radio receiver during each of the periodic transmissions, wherein the highest signal strength is greater by at least the defined capture ratio than a signal strength produced at the portable radio receiver by the plurality of the transmitters other than the strongest transmitter, and

wherein the comparing step comprises the steps of;

sorting into like-valued groups the location values that are equal to one another;

counting the location values sorted into each of the like-valued groups to determine one of the like-valued groups having a highest count; and

concluding therefrom that the location value of the one of the like-valued groups having the highest count is the location value received with the greatest dependability.

6. A probabilistic method in a radio communication system comprising a plurality of transmitters and a portable radio receiver, the method for transmitting and receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted to the portable radio receiver by a nearby transmitter, and distant location identifiers transmitted to the portable radio receiver by more distant transmitters, the method further for distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the method comprising in the portable communication receiver the steps of:

receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions;

comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period; and

defining the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are simulcast transmissions comprising digital data bits transmitted at a plurality of predetermined bit positions, and

wherein the comparing step comprises the steps of;

examining at one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions the digital data bits corresponding to the location identifiers received and stored during the predetermined period;

determining during the examining step that more than a predetermined percentage of the digital data bits at the one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions have a single coequal value;

designating the single coequal value to be an estimated bit value for the one of the plurality of predetermined bit positions;

repeating the examining, determining, and designating steps for each of the plurality of predetermined bit positions until a plurality of estimated bit values corresponding to the plurality of predetermined bit positions have been designated; and

concluding that the plurality of estimated bit values represent the location value received with the greatest dependability.

7. A probabilistic method in a radio communication system comprising a plurality of transmitters and a portable radio receiver, the method for transmitting and receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted to the portable radio receiver by a nearby transmitter, and distant location identifiers transmitted to the portable radio receiver by more distant transmitters, the method further for distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the method comprising in the portable communication receiver the steps of:

receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

storing the location identifiers received in the plurality of the periodic transmissions;

comparing stored portions of the location identifiers with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period; and

defining the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier;

wherein the periodic transmissions from ones of the plurality of the transmitters are synchronized with the periodic transmissions from others thereof, and

wherein the periodic transmissions are simulcast transmissions comprising digital data symbols transmitted at a plurality of predetermined symbol positions, and

wherein the comparing step comprises the steps of;

examining at one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions the digital data symbols corresponding to the location identifiers received and stored during the predetermined period;

determining during the examining step that more than a predetermined percentage of the digital data symbols at the one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions have a single coequal value;

designating in response the single coequal value to be an estimated symbol value for the one of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions;

repeating the examining, determining, and designating steps for each of the plurality of predetermined symbol positions until a plurality of estimated symbol values corresponding to the plurality of predetermined symbol positions have been designated; and

concluding that the plurality of estimated symbol values represent the location value received with the greatest dependability.

8. A probabilistic method in a radio communication system comprising a plurality of transmitters and a portable radio receiver, the method for transmitting and receiving information comprising location identifiers each having a location value, the location identifiers including a nearby location identifier transmitted to the portable radio receiver by a nearby transmitter, and distant location identifiers transmitted to the portable radio receiver by more distant transmitters, the method further for distinguishing the nearby location identifier from the distant location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are transmitted repeatedly in periodic transmissions, the method comprising in the portable communication receiver the steps of:

receiving over a predetermined period a plurality of the periodic transmissions comprising the location identifiers, wherein the location identifiers are received multiple times throughout the predetermined period;

storing data derived from the plurality of the periodic transmissions, the data comprising the location identifiers;

comparing stored portions of the data with one another to determine the location value received with greatest dependability relative to all other location values received during the predetermined period; and

defining the location value received with the greatest dependability to be the location value of the nearby location identifier,

wherein the plurality of the periodic transmissions are sequential transmissions occurring in a plurality of predetermined non-overlapping time slots, each time slot dedicated for transmission of a corresponding one of the location identifiers, and

wherein the receiving step comprises the step of measuring received signal strength of each of the plurality of the periodic transmissions, and

wherein the storing step comprises storing the received signal strength measured for each of the plurality of the periodic transmissions, and

wherein the comparing step comprises the steps of;

calculating from the received signal strengths stored, for each of the plurality of predetermined non-overlapping time slots, a mean received signal strength value of the periodic transmissions occurring therein over the predetermined period;

examining the mean received signal strength values calculated to determine the time slot having a highest mean received signal strength value; and

designating the location value received during said time slot to be the location value received with the greatest dependability.