Method of surface surveying for radioactive sources

• US 5,585,628 A
• Filed: 06/30/1995
• Issued: 12/17/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 06/30/1995
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Company LLC (Brookfield Asset Management Incorporated)
• Original Assignee: Westinghouse Electric Corporation (Paramount Global (f/k/a ViacomCBS Inc.))
• Inventors: Andrews, John P., Policastro, Gerard V.
• Primary Examiner(s): Hannaher, Constantine
• Application Number:
  US08/497,266
• Time in Patent Office: 536 Days
• Field of Search: 250/253
• US Class Current: 250/253
• CPC Class Codes: G01V 5/02 specially adapted for surface logging, e.g. from aircraft

Abstract

A method of surveying a surface to determine the existence of a radiation source, e.g., a radioactive source, providing a procedure for determining an optimum scan velocity for scanning past a source so as to provide the required degree of confidence to detect the presence of radiation sources while avoiding false source detection. A first scan velocity is selected based upon detector information and the nature of the survey surface, following which spreadsheet-type calculations are made based upon the expected maximum source count rate, background rate and the selected velocity. The spreadsheet calculations provide an indication of the confidence of distinguishing source activity from background radiation at the selected scan velocity. The indicated confidence is compared to the required confidence level, and when the indicated confidence is not optimally close to the required confidence, another scan velocity is selected and the spreadsheet calculations are repeated. These steps are repeated iteratively until an indicated confidence is found which is optimally close to the predetermined confidence, following which the last selected scanned velocity is used in actually carrying out the surface survey.

Claims

1. A method of surveying a surface to detect a source of radioactivity, said survey being performed with a detector having predetermined characteristics, comprising:

determining a background count rate for said detector;

determining an expected source count rate from passing said detector over said source;

selecting a first detector scan velocity, and determining a first distribution of counts probability for said detector as a function of said background count rate at said first velocity, and a second distribution of counts probability for said detector as a function of the combination of expected source and background count rates at said first velocity;

obtaining from said first probability distribution a background decision probability distribution as a function of counts, and obtaining from said second probability distribution a combination decision probability distribution as a function of counts;

presenting said decision probability distributions, and determining from them whether the source activity can be identified with a predetermined degree of confidence;

iteratively selecting one or more detector scan velocities, and for each selected velocity repeating the above steps of determining distributions of counts probability and decision probability distributions and determining therefrom the degree of confidence of identifying source activity corresponding to each selected velocity,

selecting, based on said determinations of degree of confidence, an optimum scan velocity at which source activity can be found with about said predetermined degree of confidence; and

surveying said surface at about said optimum detector velocity.

2. The method as described in claim 1, comprising calculating said first and second probability distributions as Poisson distributions.

3. The method as described in claim 2, comprising using a computer and a spreadsheet program in determining said first and second probability distributions.

4. The method as described in claim 1, comprising using a computer and a spreadsheet program in determining said decision probability distributions.

5. The method as described in claim 4, comprising calculating said background decision probability distribution P_b (i) to represent cum p_B (i) for background from i to ∞

, whereby said distribution represents the probability of deciding that the background count is i or greater.

6. The method as described in claim 5, comprising calculating said combination decision probability distribution P_S+B (i) to represent cure p_S+B (i) for source plus background from 0 to i, whereby said distribution represents the probability of deciding that the combined source and background count is i or lower.

7. The method as described in claim 6, wherein said predetermined degree of confidence is 95%.

8. The method as described in claim 6, wherein said presenting step comprises displaying plots of said distributions, and said determining step comprises determining the degree of confidence at the overlap of said plotted decision distributions.

9. The method as described in claim 8, comprising repeating said iterative steps by selecting velocities so as to move said overlap to about a 95% degree of confidence.

10. A method of determining a surveying velocity for scanning a detector past a source of radiation, comprising:

repetitively selecting respective scan velocities;

for each selected scan velocity, performing spreadsheet calculations of (a) the probability P_B (i) of a detector count of i or greater being a true background count and (b) the probability P_S+B (i) of a detector count of i or less being a true source+background count;

determining from said probabilities a decision probability confidence that a selected velocity the source+background count can be distinguished from the background count; and

selecting, on the basis of said determined confidences, a scan velocity that yields a confidence of a least a predetermined degree and is as low as is consistent with assuring said predetermined degree of confidence.

11. A method of surveying a surface which comprises scanning said surface with a detector at a selected velocity to determine the existence of a source of radiation from within said surface, said source having an expected maximum source count rate and said detector having a predetermined background count rate, said method including determining an optimum velocity for scanning said surface with said detector past said source to provide a predetermined confidence of distinguishing said source from said background radiation, said velocity determining step further comprising:

selecting a first scan velocity;

making spreadsheet type probability calculations based upon said expected source rate, said background rate and said selected velocity;

providing from said calculations an indication of the confidence of distinguishing source from background radiation at said selected velocity;

comparing the indicated confidence to a predetermined confidence; and

when said indicated confidence is not optimally close to said predetermined confidence, selecting another scan velocity and repeating said making, providing and comparing steps iteratively until a said indicated confidence is optimally close to said predetermined confidence, and using the scan velocity corresponding to said indicated optimally close confidence in said surveying.

12. The method as described in claim 11, wherein said making comprises making a calculation of the distribution of probabilities that a background count of i or more is a true background count, and making a calculation of the distribution of probabilities that a source plus background count of i or less is a true count.

13. The method as described in claim 12, wherein said indication providing comprises providing a display of said distribution probabilities.

14. The method as described in claim 13, comprising providing said display as plots that show when the background distribution probability overlaps with the source plus background distribution probability.

15. The method as described in claim 13, comprising printing plots of said distribution probabilities.

16. The method as described in claim 11, wherein said making comprises first making poisson calculations of the count probabilities for the background, and the source plus background counts respectively.

17. The method as described in claim 11, comprising selecting said each another scan velocity so as to move toward the fastest velocity that yields said predetermined confidence.

18. The method as described in claim 17, wherein said predetermined confidence is about 95%.

19. The method as described in claim 11, comprising performing said calculations on a computer, and presenting said indication as plots.

20. The method as described in claim 11, comprising supplementing said scanning by stopping and leaving the detector in one location for a period of time to repeat the count of a source.

21. A method of surveying a site for a radiation source, comprising scanning said site with a detector at a scan velocity, said method comprising:

selecting a first scan velocity, and for said first velocity making a set of calculations which indicate the probability that a detected radiation count represents source radiation and not just background radiation;

selecting at least one more scan velocity and making said set of calculations for each selected scan velocity;

choosing a scan velocity of about a selected scan velocity for which a said set of calculations indicates an acceptable said probability; and

scanning said site with said detector at said chosen velocity.

22. The method of surveying as described in claim 21, wherein said probability must be at least a predetermined probability, and said repeated selecting step comprises changing the last selected scan velocity in a direction so that the next scan velocity yields a calculated probability that is closer to said predetermined probability.

23. The method of surveying as described in claim 22, wherein said choosing comprises choosing a velocity that yields a said determined probability between 95 and 96%.

24. The method of surveying as described in claim 21, wherein said choosing comprises extrapolating from a plurality of said selected scan velocities.

25. The method of surveying as described in claim 21, comprising presenting graphs corresponding to each said set of spreadsheet calculations, and which graphs indicate the said probability.

26. The method of surveying as described in claim 21, wherein each step of making a set of calculations comprises computer spreadsheet calculations.

27. A computer system for determining whether scanning a predetermined surface with a given radiation detector at a selected detector scan velocity provides a predetermined degree of confidence of distinguishing a source plus background count from a background count, comprising:

first means for determining for a probability P_B (i) of a detector count of i or greater being a true background count for said selected detector scan velocity;

second means for determining a probability P_S+B (i) of a detector count of i or less being a true source background count for said selected detector scan velocity;

third means for determining a degree of confidence that for said selected detector scan velocity a source plus background count can be distinguished from a background count; and

fourth means for determining whether said determined degree of confidence provides said predetermined degree of confidence.

28. The system as described in claim 27, further comprising fifth means for determining when said selected detector scan velocity should be higher or lower in order to achieve said predetermined degree of confidence.

29. The system as described in claim 28, comprising display means for displaying said determined degree of confidence.

30. The system as described in claim 27, comprising iteration means for selecting a different detector scan velocity and causing operation of said first means, said second means, said third means and said fourth means to determine whether said different scan detector velocity provides said predetermined degree of confidence.

31. The system as described in claim 27, wherein:

said first means comprises P_B (i) means for determining a probability distribution P_B (i) of observing a background count at said selected detector scan velocity, and means for cumulating P_B (i) to determine said P_B (i); and

said second means comprises P_S+B (i) means for determining a probability distribution P_S+B (i) Of observing a source plus background count at said selected detector scan velocity, and means for cumulating P_S+B (i) to determine said P_S+B (i).

32. The system as described in claim 31, wherein each of said P_B (i) and P_S+B (i) means comprises respective means for calculating a Poisson probability distribution of counts.

33. The system as described in claim 27, further comprising display means for displaying a plot of said P_B (i) and P_S+B (i) values.

34. The system as described in claim 27, wherein said third means comprises overlap means to determine an overlap of P_B (i) and P_S+B (i).