Method and apparatus for testing software on a computer network

• US 5,630,049 A
• Filed: 11/30/1994
• Issued: 05/13/1997
• Est. Priority Date: 11/30/1994
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. (HP Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Digital Equipment Corporation (HP Inc.)
• Inventors: Nelson, Jeffrey E., Fisher, Wendell B. Jr., Diewald, Jeffrey M., McElearney, Anne E., Goddard, James R., DiPirro, Steven D., Sayde, Richard, Cardoza, Wayne M.
• Primary Examiner(s): Nguyen, Hoa T.
• Application Number:
  US08/347,614
• Time in Patent Office: 895 Days
• Field of Search: 395/183.01, 395/183.1, 395/183.11, 395/183.12, 395/183.14, 395/183.15, 395/184.01, 364/550, 364/570, 364/580
• US Class Current: 714/25
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/2294 by remote test
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 11/3664 Environments for testing or debugging software

Abstract

A method of remote debugging comprises a first computer system that communicates with a second computer using a network connection. The first computer system controls the remote debugging and comprises a first operating system. The second computer system comprises a second operating system and software being tested. User input, in the form of debug commands, is received using a remote debugger in the first computer system to control the remote debugging session. The remote debugger translates a debug command into messages that are sent from the first computer system to the second computer system. The messages correspond to tasks that the target computer system performs to complete the debug command. During debugging, the target computer system transitions between polling or stopped mode and interrupt-driven mode by transitioning both the target operating system and network hardware in the target computer system that interfaces with the network.

Claims

1. A method of testing software on a network comprising a target computer system and a host computer system, said target computer system comprising a target operating system and the software being tested, said host computer system comprising a host operating system and a software debugger that controls testing of said software, the method comprising:

establishing, using said software debugger, a network connection for communications between said host computer system and said target computer system;

transitioning, in response to said establishing, said target computer system into a stopped state in which it awaits input from said host computer system and in which system interrupts are masked;

issuing to said software debugged a debug command that indicates a function to be performed by said target computer system;

determining, in response to said issuing, one or more network debugging protocol messages defining steps necessary for the target computer system to perform said function indicated by said debug command;

communicating to said target computer system using said network connection said network debugging protocol messages;

performing said steps in said target computer system to complete said function indicates by said debug command;

transitioning, in response to performing said steps, the target computer system between said stopped state and an interrupt-driven state in which said target computer system is in a normal system processing and execution state and in which a network hardware device that interfaces said target computer system with said network signals interrupts; and

reporting to said host computer system results of performing said steps and state information upon transitioning about said target computer system.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein said stopped state of said target computer system comprises a first target operating system state and a corresponding first network hardware state of said network hardware in said target computer system wherein said target computer system communicates over said network to said host computer system using said network hardware, said first target operating system state being a state that masks out system interrupts and freezes said target operating system, said corresponding first network hardware state in which said target computer system polls said network hardware to retrieve a message received by said target computer system.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein said interrupt-driven state of said target computer system comprises a second operating system state and a corresponding second network hardware state of said network hardware, said second operating system state being a state that does not mask out system interrupts and represents a normal operating system processing and execution mode, said corresponding second network hardware state in which said network hardware functions as an interrupt-driven device when a message is received by said target computer system.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein said network debugging protocol messages include device protocol data corresponding to a device protocol layer, said network connection is an Ethernet network connection and said device protocol data includes a protocol type number that identifies said network debugging protocol as an Ethernet messaging protocol, and wherein said target computer system communicates with said host computer system over said network using Ethernet hardware.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein said software debugger comprises a main debugger and a secondary debugger, and wherein said main debugger translates said debug command into messages, performs said determining step, and calls said secondary debugger to interface with a first network library that resides in said host computer system to package messages to be sent to said target computer system.

6. The method of claim 5 wherein a second network library resides in said target computer system, and the method further comprises calling, by said secondary debugger, routines in said first network library to communicate a network debugging protocol message to said target system using said network connection, said network debugging protocol message being one of said network debugging protocol messages;

and retrieving and passing by said secondary debugger said network debugging protocol message to said target operating system.

7. The method of claim 6 further comprising packaging, using routines from said first and second network libraries, said network debugging protocol message to be communicated between said host and target computer systems, said packaging comprising placing a message header and message trailer in said network debugging protocol message, said message header including a value that represents the quantity of bytes of user data included in said network debugging protocol message.

8. The method of claim 1 wherein said debug command is a single step debug command and the method further comprises single stepping through a portion of said software being tested.

9. The method of claim 1 further comprising said target computer system sending, in response to one of said network debugging protocol messages, a reply network debugging protocol message that acknowledges receipt of said one of said network debugging protocol messages.

10. The method of claim 1 wherein said establishing further comprises:

communicating, by said host computer system, a first network connection request network debugging protocol message to said target computer system to establish said network connection; and

acknowledging, by said target computer system, receipt of said first network connection request network debugging protocol message by sending a first initialization response network debugging protocol message that comprises a first incarnation number identifying a particular boot of the target computer system and a connection status that indicates acceptance or rejection of said first network connection request network debugging protocol message.

11. The method of claim 10 wherein said first initialization response network debugging protocol message indicates acceptance of said first network connection request network debugging protocol message, and the method further comprises:

storing, by said host computer system, said first incarnation number received in said first initialization response network debugging protocol message;

detecting, by said host computer system, that said network connection is lost; and

re-establishing, coupled to said storing step, said network connection using said first incarnation number by;

sending, by said target computer system, a second network connection request network debugging protocol message to said target computer system;

receiving, from said target computer system, a second initialization response network debugging protocol message comprising a second incarnation number;

determining, by said host computer system, if said first and said second incarnation numbers are equivalent by comparing them;

terminating, by said host computer system in response to said determining, said remote debugging session if said first and second incarnation numbers are not equivalent; and

continuing, by said host computer system in response to said determining, said remote debugging session if said first and second incarnation numbers are equivalent.

12. The method of claim 10 wherein said first network connection request network debugging protocol message comprises a first password, and the method further comprising determining, by said target computer system, if said first password is valid by searching, in said target computer system, for a second password that matches said first password, and wherein, as a result of said determining, said connection status indicates a rejection of said first network connection request network debugging protocol message if said first password is not valid.

13. The method of claim 1 further comprising said target computer system sending a report network debugging protocol message to said host computer system, said report network debugging protocol message being initiated by said target computer system due to an occurrence of one or more events in said target computer system.

14. The method of claim 13 wherein said report network debugging protocol message indicates that a breakpoint instruction has been executed in said target computer system returning control to said host computer system for other debug commands.

15. The method of claim 14 wherein said report network debugging protocol message indicates that an operating system exception has occurred while executing said target operating system.

16. The method of claim 1, wherein said host computer system includes a host memory, said messages include a remote procedure call network debugging protocol message that requests the target computer system to execute a remote procedure call and produce a result, said remote procedure call network debugging protocol message comprising a routine name of the remote procedure to be executed and a corresponding routine parameter, and the method further comprises

communicating, by said target computer system to said host computer system, a first remote procedure call response network debugging protocol message that includes said result, said result used by said software debugger to perform said debug command;

and

storing, by said software debugger in said host memory, said result and said corresponding routine parameter;

issuing another debug command and determining additional network debugging protocol messages wherein said additional network debugging protocol messages include another remote procedure call network debugging protocol message that requests the target computer system to execute said remote procedure using said corresponding routine parameter; and

using said result from said storing step to perform the other debug command rather than communicate another remote procedure call network debugging protocol message to execute said remote procedure.

17. The method of claim 1, wherein said debug command is a step command that requests execution in said target computer system of one or more machine instructions that correspond to a portion of said software being tested, said target computer system has a target memory, and the method further comprises:

sending, from said host computer system to said target computer system, a read request network debugging protocol message to read a first portion of said machine instructions from said first memory;

responding by sending to said host computer system a read acknowledgement network debugging protocol message that includes said first portion of said machine instructions;

allocating, in said target computer system, a first segment of target memory;

analyzing, by said software debugger, said first portion of machine instructions to determine the execution flow of said machine instructions and determining a location of an exit point in said first portion;

writing, by issuing a write memory request network debugging protocol message to said target computer system, a modified copy of said first portion of said machine instructions to said first segment of target memory wherein said modified copy contains a breakpoint instruction at said location to cause execution control to transfer to said target operating system;

communicating, from said host computer system, a write request network debugging protocol message to modify a save area in said target memory that contains an address at which the target computer system is to resume execution;

communicating, from said host computer system, a proceed network debugging protocol message that causes the target computer system to transition to said interrupt-driven state and resume executing machine instructions at said address in said save area; and

communicating, in response to said target computer system executing said breakpoint, a report network debugging protocol message to said host computer system and said target computer system transitioning into said stopped state.

18. The method of claim 1 further comprising said software debugger syntactically and semantically verifying for correctness said debug command.

19. The method of claim 1, wherein said software being tested comprises a portion of said target operating system.

20. An apparatus for testing software on a network that comprises a target computer system and a host computer system, said target computer system comprising a target operating system and the software being tested, said host computer system comprising a host operating system and a software debugger that controls testing of said software, the apparatus comprising:

establishing means for establishing, using a software debugger, a network connection for communications between said host computer system and said target computer system;

transitioning means for transitioning, in response to said establishing means, said target computer system into a stopped state in which it awaits input from said host computer system and in which system interrupts are masked;

issuing means for issuing to said software debugger a debug command that indicates a function to be performed by said target computer system;

determining means for determining, in response to said issuing means, one or more network debugging protocol messages defining steps necessary for the target computer system to perform said function indicated by said debug command;

communicating means for communicating to said target computer system using said network connection said network debugging protocol messages;

performing means for performing said steps in said target computer system to complete said function indicating by said debug command;

transitioning means for transitioning, in response to performing means, the target computer system between said stopped state and an interrupt-driven state in which said target computer system is in a normal system processing and execution state and in which a network hardware device that interfaces said target computer system with said computer network signals interrupts; and

reporting means for reporting to said host computer system results of said performing means performing said steps and state information upon transitioning about said target computer system.

21. The apparatus of claim 20, wherein said target computer system includes a first memory and the apparatus further comprises

temporary write memory means for temporarily writing a user specified breakpoint to a first address in said first memory by storing original contents of said first address at a second address prior to writing said user specified breakpoint to said first address;

and

restoration means, coupled to said temporary write means, for restoring said original contents to said first address by using said contents that is saved at said second address if said network connection is lost.

22. The apparatus of claim 20 further comprising a breakpoint detection means that causes said target computer system to transition to said stopped state, said breakpoint detection means comprising:

determining means, coupled to said establishing means, for determining if an executed breakpoint instruction is included in boot code in said target operating system, and if said network connection is established;

reporting means, coupled to said determining means, in said target computer system for issuing a report network debugging protocol message to said host computer system indicating execution of a breakpoint instruction if said network connection is established;

acknowledging means in said host computer system for sending an acknowledgement network debugging protocol message that indicates acceptance or rejection of said breakpoint instruction if said breakpoint instruction is not included in said boot code, and said network debugging protocol message comprising another series of network debugging protocol messages if said breakpoint instruction is included in said boot code.