Method for improving measurement precision in evanescent wave optical biosensor assays

• US 5,631,170 A
• Filed: 12/12/1994
• Issued: 05/20/1997
• Est. Priority Date: 06/10/1992
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Laboratoires Serono SA (Merck & Co., Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Applied Research Systems ARS Holding NV (Merck & Co., Inc.)
• Inventors: Attridge, John W.
• Primary Examiner(s): Chin, Christopher L.
• Application Number:
  US08/351,338
• Time in Patent Office: 890 Days
• Field of Search: 356/317, 356/318, 356/243, 356/246, 385/12, 385/129, 422/57, 422/58, 422/61, 422/82.05, 422/82.08, 422/82.11, 435/808, 435/810, 435/967, 435/975, 435/287.1, 435/287.2, 435/288.7, 436/164, 436/172, 436/518, 436/527, 436/535, 436/805, 436/807, 436/808, 436/809
• US Class Current: 436/518
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 21/7703 using reagent-clad optical fibres or optical waveguides using measurement of total internal reflection or attenuated total reflection G01N21/552; optical fibres or waveguides per se G02B
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/54373 involving physiochemical end-point determination, e.g. wave-guides, FETS, gratings
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 435/808 Optical sensing apparatus
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 435/81 Packaged device or kit
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 435/967 Standards, controls, materials, e.g. validation studies, buffer systems
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 435/975 Kit
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 436/805 Optical property

Abstract

A method for improving measurement precision in an optical biosensor assay for a ligand in a sample is described. The method involves referencing the assay with an artificially raised background level by the labelling of the optical waveguide with an appropriate reference reagent. Devices for use in such a method are also described.

Claims

1. A method of improving measurement precision in an optical biosensor assay for a ligand in a sample which comprises the steps of

i) incubating the sample in contact with a measurement surface which carries a directly or indirectly immobilised measurement reagent appropriate to the assay and which additionally carries an amount of a directly or indirectly immobilised reference reagent which gives rise to a reference signal, independent of the amount of ligand present in the sample, at the measurement surface, and prior to, during, or subsequent to the said incubation of the sample measuring said reference signal by a method appropriate to the assay;

ii) simultaneously with or sequentially to the said incubation of the sample in i) introducing one or more labelled ancillary reagents appropriate to the assay whereby if ligand is present in the sample, a complex involving said measurement reagent and at least one of said ligand or said labelled ancillary reagent(s) is formed giving rise to a detectable assay signal which is a first function of the amount of ligand (if any) present in the sample; and

iii) subsequently monitoring the assay signal arising from the measurement surface by a method appropriate to the assay and, comparing the reference signal with the assay signal, thereby determining using an appropriate algorithm whether and/or the extent to which the ligand under assay is present in the sample.

2. A method as claimed in claim 1 additionally comprising the steps of

iv) simultaneously or sequentially to the incubation in step i), incubating the sample, if desired together with one or more labelled ancillary reagents, with one or more further calibration surface(s) separated from the measurement surface onto each of which is immobilised a calibration reagent appropriate to the assay, the calibration reagent either being such to give rise to a zero or non-zero signal or being such as to form a complex involving at least one of said ligand or said labelled ancillary reagent(s) whereby any such complex gives rise to a non-zero signal (or, where no such complex is formed, which would be formed if ligand were present), the signal being either a second function of or independent of the amount of ligand (if any) present in the sample;

v) monitoring the calibration signal(s) arising from the calibration surface(s); and

vi) subsequently comparing the calibration signal(s) to both the assay signal and reference signal and, using an appropriate algorithm, the measure of the extent to which the ligand under assay is present in the sample, as derived from the assay signal and reference signal is thereby calibrated.

3. A method as claimed in claim 2, the assay being a competition assay, wherein in steps i) and ii) either a) a labelled ligand analogue is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a specific binding partner for the ligand under assay or b) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a ligand analogue;

and wherein in step iv), either a) a labelled ligand analogue is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a specific binding partner for the ligand under assay or b) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a ligand analogue or c) a labelled ligand distinct from the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a specific binding partner for the ligand distinct from the ligand under assay or d) the calibration reagent is a binding partner non-specific for any labelled ancillary reagent(s) present or e) the calibration reagent gives rise to the desired zero or non-zero signal without the need for the presence of a labelled ancillary reagent.

4. A method as claimed in claim 2, the assay being a sandwich assay, wherein

in step i) and ii) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a further specific binding partner for the ligand under assay, said further specific binding partner being directed to an epitope of the ligand under assay different to the epitope to which the labelled specific binding partner is directed;

and wherein in step iv), either a) the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a specific binding partner for the ligand under assay, a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and a known amount of the ligand under assay precomplexed to its labelled specific binding partner is present as a yet further ancillary reagent or b) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a known amount of the ligand under assay precomplexed to its immobilized specific binding partner or c) a ligand distinct from the ligand under assay is present as an ancillary reagent and the calibration reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the calibration reagent) is a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand distinct from the ligand under assay or d) the calibration reagent is a labelled binding partner non-specific for any labelled ancillary reagent(s) present or e) the calibration reagent gives rise to the desired zero or non-zero signal without the need for the presence of a labelled ancillary reagent.

5. A method as claimed in claim 1 wherein time-delayed measurement of the reference signal and assay signal is made.

6. A method as claimed in claim 1 wherein the reference signal, assay signal and calibration signal(s), when present, are fluorescence, phosphorescence or luminescence signals.

7. A method as claimed in claim 1 wherein the label used for the reference reagent is the same as that carried by the labelled ancillary reagent(s).

8. A method as claimed in claim 1, the assay being a competition assay, wherein in steps i) and ii) either a) a labelled ligand analogue is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a specific binding partner for the ligand under assay or b) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a ligand analogue.

9. A method as claimed in claim 1, the assay being a sandwich assay, wherein in step i) and ii) a labelled specific binding partner for the ligand under assay is present as a labelled ancillary reagent and the measurement reagent (or optionally a reagent precomplexed with or capable of forming a complex involving the measurement reagent) is a further specific binding partner for the ligand under assay, said further specific binding partner being directed to an epitope of the ligand under assay different to the epitope to which the labelled specific binding partner is directed.

10. A biosensor device comprising a measurement surface carrying a directly or indirectly measurement reagent appropriate to an assay and which additionally carries an amount of a directly or indirectly immobilised reference reagent which gives rise to a reference signal, independent of the amount of ligand present in the sample, at the measurement surface.

11. A biosensor device as claimed in claim 10 wherein the device is additionally provided with one or more calibration surface(s) separate from the measurement surface, each calibration surface carrying an immobilised calibration reagent appropriate to the assay, the calibration reagent either being such to give rise to a zero or non-zero signal or being such as to form a complex involving at least one of a ligand and a labelled ancillary reagent(s) whereby any such complex gives rise to a non-zero signal (or, where no such complex is formed, which would be formed if ligand were present), the signal being either a function of or independent of the amount of ligand (if any) present in the sample.

12. A device as claimed in claim 10, being a specifically-reactive sample-collecting and testing device possessing a cavity or cavities, one surface of each cavity having a zone I carrying a layer comprising, in releasable form, labelled ancillary reagent(s) suitable for the desired assay, said surface being a surface of a first solid plate fashioned of transparent material, wherein the wall of each cavity opposite to said first plate comprises a second plate fashioned of transparent material and acts as a light-transmissive waveguide, the second plate having on its surface adjacent the cavity a zone II corresponding in orientation to the aforementioned zone I, zone II carrying a layer comprising, randomly distributed, an immobilised measurement reagent and an immobilised reference reagent, suitable for a desired assay.

13. A device as claimed in claim 12, additionally carrying on said first plate one or more further zone(s) carrying a layer comprising, in soluble releasable form, labelled ancillary reagent(s) suitable for the desired assay and additionally carrying on said second plate one or more further zone(s) each of which is corresponding in orientation to one of said further zone(s) on said first plate, and each of which is carrying a layer comprising an immobilised calibration reagent, the calibration reagent either being such to give rise to a zero or non-zero signal or being such as to form a complex involving at least one of a ligand and a labelled ancillary reagent(s) whereby any such complex gives rise to a non-zero signal (or, where no such complex is formed, which would be formed if ligand were present), the signal being either a second function of or independent of the amount of ligand (if any) present in the sample.

14. A device as claimed in claim 12 wherein the first plate carries on its surface remote from the cavity a layer of light-absorbing or opaque material.

15. Apparatus which comprises a device as claimed in claim 10;

a source of radiation capable of being arranged such that, in use, radiation enters said device such that optically labelled species in the device are excited; and

means for monitoring the emerging radiation.

16. A kit for performing a method of assay comprising a device as claimed in claim 10 together with appropriate labelled ancillary reagents.

17. A method of manufacturing specifically-reactive sample-collecting and testing devices possessing a cavity or cavities, one surface of each cavity having a zone I carrying a layer comprising, in releasable form, labelled ancillary reagent(s) suitable for the desired assay, said surface being a surface of a first solid plate fashioned of transparent material, wherein the wall of the or each cavity opposite to said first plate comprises a second plate fashioned of transparent material and acts as a light-transmissive waveguide, the second plate having on its surface adjacent the cavity a zone II corresponding in orientation to the aforementioned zone I, zone II carrying a layer comprising, randomly distributed, an immobilised measurement reagent and an immobilised reference reagent suitable for the desired assay

comprising the steps of (a) forming a patch of suitable reagent(s), carried by zone I on the surface of a sheet material which is to provide part of a multiplicity of the devices,

(b) forming a patch of suitable reagent(s), carried by zone II on the surface of an additional structure, involving immobilisation of the measurement reagent and reference reagent, said additional structure together with said sheet material providing for each of the multiplicity of devices a cavity for collecting and retaining a volume of sample liquid in contact with said layers of suitable reagents, and

(c) separating the sheet material together with the additional structure into portions each providing one or a plurality of the sample-collecting and testing devices.

18. A method of manufacturing specifically-reactive sample-collecting and testing devices as claimed in claim 17, including the additional steps of forming the patch of suitable reagents in the further zone(s) on the surface of the sheet material and immobilizing a calibration reagent in the further zone(s) on the surface of the additional structure, the calibration reagent either being such to give rise to a zero or non-zero signal or being such as to form a complex involving at least one of a ligand and a labelled ancillary reagent(s) whereby any such complex gives rise to a non-zero signal (or, where no such complex is formed, which would be formed if ligand were present), the signal being either a second function of or independent of the amount of ligand (if any) present in the sample.

19. A method of manufacturing specifically-reactive sample-collecting and testing devices as claimed in claim 17, wherein the cavity is of capillary dimension.