Test sequence optimization process for a circuit tester

• US 5,631,856 A
• Filed: 01/17/1995
• Issued: 05/20/1997
• Est. Priority Date: 01/17/1995
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Original Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Inventors: Mahlbacher, James C., Lo, Jiann-Chang, Keller, Steven A.
• Primary Examiner(s): Teska, Kevin J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): LOPPNOW, MATTHEW CLAY
• Application Number:
  US08/373,338
• Time in Patent Office: 854 Days
• Field of Search: 364/578, 364/488, 364/489, 364/490, 364/491, 364/474.37, 364/468.28, 324/754, 324/758, 324/761, 324/762, 324/158.1, 324/73.1, 324/519, 324/537
• US Class Current: 324/750.22
• CPC Class Codes: G01R 1/04 Housings; Supporting members; Arrangements of terminals
• CPC Class Codes: G01R 1/06705 Apparatus for holding or moving single probes for moving multiple probe heads or ICs under test G01R31/2886

Abstract

The sequential order of movements of a number of probes within a circuit test fixture is optimized through the use of an algorithm which sequentially orders test configurations provided in an input list. Each test configuration corresponds to the locations of probes within the fixture as a particular test is performed. In a first pass of the algorithm, for each test configuration, every other test configuration is considered as a next move candidate for which a weighted distance is calculated from the test configuration. Weighting factors reflect the degree of difficulty in moving one direction instead of another. A need to move one probe before another or to move in one direction before another, in order to prevent a collision within the test fixture, is also considered. A predetermined number of next move candidates having the lowest weighted distances are placed in an intermediate list for the test configuration. In a second pass of the algorithm, test configurations are linked, one to another, to form a list reflecting a preferred order of probe movement. In the process of linking with a test configuration, the available next move candidate having the shortest weighted distance is chosen from the intermediate list of the test configuration. If no available next move candidates remain in the intermediate list, the process returns to the first pass of the algorithm to get more next move candidates. Additionally, the algorithm is used to sequentially order individual points for a test fixture having only a single probe.

Claims

1. A method for optimizing a sequence of test configurations within a circuit tester having structures movable between various of said test configurations, wherein said method comprises the steps of:

reading an input list of said test configurations;

for each test configuration within said input list, establishing each other of said test configurations as a next move candidate, calculating a weighted distance from said test configuration to said next move candidate, wherein said weighted distance reflects a degree of difficulty in movement of said structures within said circuit tester from said test configuration to said next move candidate, and storing an intermediate list having a maximum of a predetermined number of next move candidates, wherein said intermediate list includes said next move candidates with lowest weighted distances from said test configuration, and wherein said predetermined number is less than a total number of test configurations in said input list; and

linking said test configurations into a chain, in a preferred order beginning with an initial said test configuration, wherein each said test configuration following said initial test configuration is chosen from available next move candidates within said intermediate list of a test configuration at an end of said chain, wherein when a said next move candidate is linked, said next move candidate is removed from said available next move candidates, and wherein, until all said test configurations are linked, when said next move candidates have been exhausted from said intermediate list of said test configuration at said end of said chain, an additional said next move candidate is added to said intermediate list of said test configuration at said end of said chain.

2. The method of claim 1:

wherein said method comprises in addition, following said step of calculating a weighted distance, a step of determining a pitch variable representative of a minimum value of said weighted distance by replacing a value of said pitch variable with a value of said weighted distance whenever said weighted distance is less than said pitch variable;

wherein said method comprises in addition, before said step of linking said test configurations into a chain;

a step of calculating a range of weighted distances by multiplying said pitch variable by a multiplier;

wherein, during said step of linking said test configurations into a chain, each said test configuration following said initial test configuration is chosen from next move candidates having weighted distances within said range of weighted distances; and

wherein, whenever said additional next move candidate is added to said intermediate list, said multiplier is increased in value and a new range of weighted distances is calculated by multiplying said pitch variable by said multiplier.

3. The method of claim 1:

wherein, for each said test configuration, said next move candidates are stored in said intermediate list in a sequentially increasing order of said weighted distance to said next move candidates from said test configuration; and

wherein, during said step of linking said test configurations into a chain, said next move candidates are selected in said sequentially increasing order.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein said step of linking said test configurations includes a step of defining a next variable associated with each said test configuration to indicate a next move candidate linked to said test configuration and following said test configuration in said preferred order.

5. The method of claim 4, wherein said step of linking said test configurations additionally includes a step of traversing said test configurations sequentially according to said next variables associated therewith to construct aa output list of said test configurations in said preferred order.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein said weighted distance is calculated to form a value indicating a time required to move said structures within said circuit tester from positions defined by said test configuration to positions defined by said next move candidate.

7. The method of claim 6:

wherein each said test configuration specifies a position of a single probe included in said structures; and

wherein said weighted distance is calculated to form a value indicating a time required to move said single probe from a position indicated by said test configuration to a position indicated by said next move candidate, said single probe being driven by X- and Y-directional drives operating perpendicularly to one another, said weighted distance being derived from a longer of first and second times, said first time being a time required for operation of said X-directional drive, and said second time being a time required for operation said Y-directional drive.

8. The method of claim 7, comprising in addition a step of driving said single probe sequentially between positions represented by said test configurations in said preferred order.

9. The method of claim 6:

wherein each said test configuration specifies positions of a plurality of probes included in said structures; and

wherein said step of calculating a weighted distance includes a determination of whether one probe movement must be made before another to avoid a collision of said probes and of associated structures moving with said probes, with said weighted distance being calculated as a sum of sequential probe movement distances as said probes are moved within said circuit tester from said positions defined by said test configuration to said positions defined by said next move candidate when one probe movement must be made before another, and with said weighted distance being calculated according to a longest time required to move a said probe as various of said probes are moved within said circuit tester from said positions defined by said test configuration to said positions defined by said next move candidate when said probe movements may occur simultaneously without collision of said probes and of said associated structures.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein a time required to move each said probe is derived from the longer of first and second times, said first time being a time required for operation of an X-directional drive moving said probe in an X-direction, and said second time being a time required for operation of a Y-directional drive moving said probe in a Y-direction, perpendicular to said X-direction.

11. The method of claim 10, comprising in addition a step of driving said probes sequentially between positions represented by said test configurations in said preferred order.

12. Apparatus for testing electrical circuits on a substrate, wherein said apparatus comprises:

clamping means holding said substrate in a fixed location;

a probe movable from a location defined by a first test configuration to a location defined by another test configuration;

data processing means including data reading means;

a first input list of test configurations, read by said data reading means, wherein each test configuration within said first input list describes a location of said probe during a test procedure within said apparatus;

a program executing on said data processing means, wherein said program includes a first pass subroutine reading said first input list, and, for each said test configuration, establishing each other of said test configurations as a next move candidate, calculating a weighted distance from said test configuration to said next move candidate, storing an intermediate list having a maximum predetermined number of next move candidates, said predetermined number being less than a total number of test configurations in said input list, with said intermediate list including said next move candidates with lowest weighted distances from said test configuration, wherein said program additionally includes a second pass subroutine linking said test configurations into a chain, in a preferred order beginning with an initial said test configuration, with each test configuration being chosen from available next move candidates within said intermediate list of a test configuration at an end of said chain, with said next move candidates being removed from availability as they are linked to said chain, and with said second pass subroutine calling said first pass subroutine to refill said intermediate list when next move candidates have been exhausted from said intermediate list of said test configuration at said end of said chain; and

means for moving said probe between positions indicated by said test configurations in said preferred order.

13. The apparatus of claim 12:

wherein, after said weighted distance has been calculated, said weighted distance is compared with a pitch variable, with said pitch variable being replaced by said weighted distance if said weighted distance is smaller than said pitch variable;

wherein, before said test configurations are linked into a chain, a range of weighted distances is calculated, multiplying said pitch variable by a multiplier;

wherein, each said test configuration following said initial test configuration is chosen for linking from said next move candidates having weighted distances within said range of weighted distances; and

wherein, whenever said second pass subroutine executes a single cycle, said multiplier is increased in value and a new range of weighted distances is calculated by multiplying said pitch variable by said multiplier.

14. The apparatus of claim 13:

wherein, for each said test configuration, said intermediate list holds said next move candidates in a sequentially increasing order of said weighted distance from said test configuration; and

wherein, within said second pass subroutine, as said next move candidates are linked into a chain, said next move candidates are selected in said sequentially increasing order.

15. The apparatus of claim 12, wherein said test configurations are linked during said second pass routine as a next variable associated with each said test configuration is given a value to indicate a following next move candidate linked to said test configuration.

16. The apparatus of claim 15, wherein after said test configurations are linked, additionally, said test configurations are traversed using each said next variable as an output list of test configurations sequentially ordered in said preferred order is formed.

17. The apparatus of claim 12, wherein said weighted distance is calculated to form a value indicating a time required to move said probe within said circuit tester from a position defined by said test configuration to a position defined by said next move candidate.

18. The apparatus of claim 17,

wherein said means for moving said probe includes X- and Y-directional drives operating perpendicularly to one another, moving said probe according to a resultant of motions from said X- and Y directional drives;

and

wherein said weighted distance being derived from a longer of first and second times, said first time being a time required for operation of said X-directional drive, and said second time being a time required for operation said Y-directional drive.

19. The apparatus of claim 12:

wherein said apparatus comprises a plurality of said probes movable from said locations defined by a first test configuration to said locations defined by another test configuration; and

wherein each said test configuration within said first input list describes a location of each said probe during said test procedure within said apparatus.

20. The apparatus of claim 19, wherein, before said weighted distance is calculated, a determination is made of whether one probe movement must occur before another to avoid a collision of said probes and of associated structures moving with said probes, with said weighted distance being calculated as a sum of sequential probe movement distances as said probes are moved within said circuit tester from said positions defined by said test configuration to said positions defined by said next move candidate when one probe movement must be made before another, and with said weighted distance being calculated according to a longest time required to move a said probe as various of said probes are moved within said circuit tester from said positions defined by said test configuration to said positions defined by said next move candidate when said probe movements may occur simultaneously without collision of said probes and of said associated structures.

21. The apparatus of claim 20, wherein a time required to move each said probe is derived from the longer of first and second times, said first time being a time required for operation of an X-directional drive moving said probe in an X-direction, and said second time being a time required for operation of a Y-directional drive moving said probe in a Y-direction, perpendicular to said X-direction.

22. The apparatus of claim 19, wherein said plurality of probes includes a first pair of independently movable probes contacting a first side of said substrate.

23. The apparatus of claim 22:

wherein said plurality of probes includes a second pair of independently movable probes contacting a side of said substrate opposite said first side; and

wherein each said test configuration includes points locating four said probes during a test procedure.

24. The apparatus of claim 19:

wherein said first pair of independently movable probes and first stages moving with said first pair of movable probes move with a first space;

wherein said plurality of probes additionally includes a second pair of independently movable probes contacting said substrate in a region displaced along said substrate from said first pair of independently movable probes, so that said first said second pair of independently movable probes and second stages moving with said second pair of movable probes move within a second space separated from said first space, and so that circuits contacted by said second pair of independently movable probes are separated from circuits on said substrate simultaneously contacted by said first pair of independently movable probes;

wherein said apparatus additionally includes a second input list of test configurations, read by said data reading means, with each test configuration within said second input list describing simultaneous locations of said second pair of independently movable probes during a test procedure using said second pair of independently movable probes; and

wherein said program is executed a first time with data input from said first input list to link test configurations from said first input list and a second time with data input from said second input list to link test configurations from said second input list.