Method and apparatus for scheduling message traffic in a multicell radio communication system

• US 5,666,651 A
• Filed: 06/07/1995
• Issued: 09/09/1997
• Est. Priority Date: 06/07/1995
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: Wang, Zhonghe
• Primary Examiner(s): Eisenzopf, Reinhard J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): LE, THANH C
• Application Number:
  US08/476,771
• Time in Patent Office: 825 Days
• Field of Search: 455/33.1, 455/33.2, 455/34.1, 455/54.1, 455/54.2, 455/56.1, 455/63, 455/62, 455/67.1, 455/67.3, 455/67.6, 340/825.44, 379/59
• US Class Current: 455/512
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 84/022 One-way selective calling networks, e.g. wide area paging

Abstract

In a system controller (102) for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective-call radios (106) in a radio communication system (100), a set of interference coefficients is determined in which an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit (202) of a pair of transmission units (202) from a second transmission unit (202) of the pair of transmission units (202). A set of transmission unit assignments is modified to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit (202). The assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients.

Claims

1. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein, in said step of determining, the interference coefficient is determined as a binary value, and wherein a first binary value represents a low likelihood of interference from the first transmission unit to the second transmission unit.

2. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein, in said step of determining, the interference coefficient is determined to represent interference as a value relative to a signal to interference threshold, and wherein the interference coefficient is determined such that when a sum of a subset of the set of interference coefficients representing interference to a transmission unit is below a first predetermined value, a likelihood of interference to the transmission unit is low.

3. The method according to claim 2, wherein the interference coefficient is calculated as ##EQU9## and wherein C_i,j is the interference coefficient representing interference at the first transmission unit, TU_j, from the second transmission unit, TU_i, and wherein SC_i,j is a signal to interference level determined in decibels for the first transmission unit and the second transmission unit, and wherein SI_th is a predetermined signal to interference threshold.

4. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein said step of determining a set of interference coefficients comprises the step of;

generating by a coefficient generating element, the interference coefficient from a signal to interference value determined at a critical point location associated with the first transmission unit of the pair of transmission units.

5. The method according to claim 4, wherein said step of generating the interference coefficient comprises the step of:

determining the critical point location for the first transmission unit as a point on or within a boundary of a cell associated with the first transmission unit for which the signal to interference value has a minimum value compared to signal to interference values determined at all points on or within the boundary of the cell associated with the first transmission unit.

6. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein said step of determining a set of interference coefficients comprises the step of;

formulating a set of co-channel interference coefficients comprising one subset of co-channel interference coefficients for each transmission unit, wherein each co-channel interference coefficient in a first subset of co-channel interference coefficients represents a measure of co-channel interference at a first transmission unit which is generated from another of the transmission units, wherein the first transmission unit is common to all co-channel coefficients in the first subset.

7. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein said step of determining a set of interference coefficients comprises the step of;

formulating a set of adjacent channel interference coefficients comprising one subset of adjacent channel interference coefficients for each transmission unit, wherein each adjacent channel interference coefficient in a first subset of adjacent channel interference coefficients represents a measure of adjacent channel interference at a first transmission unit which is generated from any transmission unit, wherein the first transmission unit is common for all adjacent channel coefficients in the first subset.

8. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units;

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

selecting the proposed transmission unit from the set of transmission units using a priority function based on a transmission unit parameter which is determined from the set of interference coefficients, wherein the transmission unit parameter is a damage measurement which measures a difficulty of assigning the proposed transmission unit due to interference from other transmission units.

9. The method according to claim 8, wherein the transmission unit parameter is a sum of all interference coefficients in the set of interference coefficients which represent interference values from other transmission units to the proposed transmission unit.

10. The method according to claim 8, wherein in said step of selecting, the transmission unit parameter is a number of free channels determined from the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, and wherein the number of free channels represents a number of outbound radio channels for the proposed transmission unit which have an existing interference less than a second predetermined value.

11. The method according to claim 8, wherein in said step of selecting, the priority function is further based on at least one of a group of transmission unit parameters consisting of a traffic parameter, a latency parameter, and a mobility parameter.

12. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units;

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

selecting an optimum channel for the proposed transmission unit from a set of outbound radio channels using a penalty function based on the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients,

wherein in said step of modifying, the set of transmission unit assignments are further modified to establish an assignment of the optimum channel to the proposed transmission unit; and

wherein said step of selecting the optimum channel comprises the step of;

determining a set of uninterfered channels, each uninterfered channel being an outbound radio channel for which a calculation based on the set of transmission unit assignments, the proposed transmission unit, and the set of interference coefficients results in an interference level which represents interference from all assigned and the proposed transmission unit and which is below a third predetermined value at all assigned transmission units and the proposed transmission unit; and

wherein in said step of selecting the optimum channel, the optimum channel is selected from the set of uninterfered channels, using the penalty function.

13. The method according to claim 12, wherein the set of transmission unit assignments comprises a set of unassigned channels and a set of assigned channels for the proposed transmission unit, and wherein said step of determining the set of uninterfered channels comprises the steps of:

determining a proposed interference value for a proposed channel which is a channel in the set of unassigned channels, wherein the proposed interference value represents interference received at the proposed transmission unit from other transmission units having an interfering assigned channel; and

identifying the proposed channel as an uninterfered channel when the proposed interference value is below the third predetermined value.

14. The method according to claim 13, wherein said step of determining the set of uninterfered channels further comprises the steps of:

determining a set of first interference values for the proposed channel, wherein a first interference value represents an first interference received at an assigned transmission unit which has an assigned channel which is either the proposed channel or adjacent to the proposed channel, wherein the first interference is from assigned transmission units; and

determining a set of corresponding second interference values for the proposed channel, wherein a corresponding second interference value represents a second interference received at the assigned transmission unit from the proposed transmission unit using the proposed channel, and

wherein identification in said step of identifying the proposed channel as an uninterfered channel is further when the proposed interference value is below the third predetermined value and when a sum of each first interference value and the corresponding second interference value is below the third predetermined value.

15. The method according to claim 12, wherein said step of selecting the optimum channel comprises the steps of:

determining a set of newly interfered transmission units associated with an nninterfered radio channel, which are transmission units not assigned to the uninterfered radio channel, and for which a total determined interference has changed from below to above a fourth predetermined value, and wherein the total determined interference is determined from the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients; and

determining the penalty function for the uninterfered channel, wherein the penalty function is determined from a subset of the set of interference coefficients which represent interference values from other transmission units to each transmission unit in the set of newly interfered transmission units, and

wherein in said step of selecting the optimum channel, the optimum channel is identified as one of the set of uninterfered channels having a smallest penalty function value associated therewith.

16. The method according to claim 15, wherein in said step of determining the penalty function, the penalty function is further determined from at least one of a group of channel parameters consisting of a number of free channels associated with the set of newly interfered transmission units and a number of co-channel transmission units assigned to the uninterfered channel.

17. A method used in a system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises a set of transmission units, said method comprising the steps of:

determining a set of interference coefficients wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units;

selecting a proposed transmission unit from the set of transmission units using a priority function based on a subset of the set of interference coefficients which represent interference values from other transmission units to the proposed transmission and based on at least one of a group of transmission unit parameters consisting of a traffic parameter, a latency parameter, and a mobility parameter;

selecting an optimum channel for the proposed transmission unit from a set of outbound radio channels using a penalty function based on a set of transmission unit assigruments and the set of interference coefficients; and

modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of the optimum channel to the proposed transmission unit.

18. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients and from at least one of a group of transmission unit parameters consisting of a traffic parameter, a latency parameter, and a mobility parameter; and

a matrix memory, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients.

19. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

a matrix memory, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, wherein said interference coefficient element generates the interference coefficient having a binary value, and wherein a first binary value represents a low likelihood of interference from the first transmission unit to the second transmission unit.

20. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element, for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

a matrix memory, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, wherein said interference coefficient element generates the interference coefficient to represent interference as a value relative to a signal to interference threshold, and wherein the interference coefficient is determined such that when a sum of a subset of the set of interference coefficients representing interference to a transmission unit is below a first predetermined value, a likelihood of interference to the transmission unit is low.

21. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

a matrix memory,, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, wherein said interference coefficient element further comprises;

a coefficient generation element, coupled to said matrix memory, for generating the interference coefficient from a signal to interference value determined at a critical point location associated with the first transmission unit of the pair of transmission units.

22. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

a matrix memory, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, wherein said scheduler further comprises;

a transmission unit selector element, coupled to said matrix memory, for selecting the proposed transmission unit from the set of transmission units using a priority function based on a transmission unit parameter which is determined from the set of interference coefficients.

23. The system controller according to claim 22, wherein said transmission unit selector element calculates the priority function based on at least one of a group of transmission trait parameters consisting of a damage measurement, a number of free channels, a traffic parameter, a latency parameter, and a mobility parameter, and wherein the damage measurement and the number of free channels are determined from the set of interference coefficients.

24. A system controller for scheduling message traffic for transmission to a plurality of selective call radios in a radio communication system, wherein the radio communication system comprises the system controller, a set of transmission units and a set of outbound radio channels, wherein said system controller comprises:

a scheduler for determining a schedule of outbound traffic transmissions, comprising;

an interference coefficient element for determining a set of interference coefficients, wherein an interference coefficient is a measure of transmission interference at a first transmission unit of a pair of transmission units from a second transmission unit of the pair of transmission units, and

a channel assignment element for modifying a set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of a proposed transmission unit, wherein the assignment is determined from the set of interference coefficients; and

a matrix memory, coupled to said interference coefficient element and said channel assignment element, for storing the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, wherein said scheduler further comprises;

an optimum channel identifier element, coupled to said matrix memory, for selecting an optimum channel for the proposed transmission unit from a set of outbound radio channels using a penalty function based on the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients, and

wherein said channel assignment element further modifies the set of transmission unit assignments to establish an assignment of the optimum channel to the proposed transmission unit.

25. The system controller according to claim 24, wherein said optimum channel identifier element comprises:

an uninterfered channel element, coupled to said matrix memory, for determining a set of uninterfered channels, each uninterfered channel being an outbound radio channel for which a calculation based on the set of transmission unit assignments, the proposed transmission unit, and the set of interference coefficients results in an interference level which represents interference from all assigned and the proposed transmission unit and which is below a third predetermined value at all assigned transmission units and the proposed transmission unit, and

wherein said optimum channel identifier element selects the optimum channel from the set of uninterfered channels, using the penalty function.

26. The system controller according to claim 25, wherein said optimum channel identifier element comprises:

a newly interfered transmission unit element, coupled to said matrix memory, for determining a set of newly interfered transmission units, which are transmission units not assigned an uninterfered channel, and for which a total determined interference of a new interfered transmission unit has changed from below to above a fourth predetermined value, and wherein the total determined interference is determined from the set of transmission unit assignments and the set of interference coefficients; and

a penalty function element, coupled to said matrix memory, for determining the penalty function for the uninterfered channel, wherein the penalty function is determined from a subset of the set of interference coefficients which represent interference values from other transmission units to each transmission unit in the set of newly interfered transmission units, and

wherein said step optimum channel identifier element identifies the optimum channel as one of the set of uninterfered channels having a smallest penalty function associated therewith.

27. The system controller according to claim 26, wherein said penalty function element further determines the penalty function from at least one of a group of channel parameters consisting of a number of free channels associated with the set of newly interfered transmission units and a number of co-channel transmission units assigned to the uninterfered channel.