Intermodulation distortion reduction circuit utilizing variable attenuation

• US 5,697,081 A
• Filed: 12/13/1995
• Issued: 12/09/1997
• Est. Priority Date: 09/12/1995
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Canon Kabushiki Kaisha (Canon Inc.)
• Original Assignee: OKI Telecom, Inc. (OKI Electric Industry Company Limited)
• Inventors: Lyall, Robert L. Jr., Bain, Richard I.
• Primary Examiner(s): Eisenzopf, Reinhard J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Nguyen, Lee
• Application Number:
  US08/571,511
• Time in Patent Office: 727 Days
• Field of Search: 455/89, 455/232.1, 455/234.1, 455/234.2, 455/239.1, 455/237.1, 455/245.1, 455/248.1, 455/249.1, 455/240.1, 455/252.1, 455/254, 455/63, 455/295 , 455/33.1, 455/74, 375/345, 375/205, 330/284, 330/144, 330/145, 330/149, 370/18
• US Class Current: 455/249.1
• CPC Class Codes: H03G 3/3052 in bandpass amplifiers (H.F. or I.F.) or in frequency-changers used in a (super)heterodyne receiver H03G3/32, H03G3/34 take precedence
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 1/109 by improving strong signal performance of the receiver when strong unwanted signals are present at the receiver input

Abstract

A variable attenuator circuit provides variable attenuation responsive to received signal strength in a receiver to reduce intermodulation (IM) distortion. In a dual-mode frequency modulation/code division multiple access (FM/CDMA) cellular telephone implementation, the variable attenuator circuit decreases IM distortion by variably attenuating received radio frequency (RF) signals before an initial RF amplification stage to reduce the level of undesirable frequency mixing products. The variable attenuator circuit is turned on (activated) and off (deactivated) at a single, relatively low, input power level. An attenuator enable signal is also supplied from a logic unit of the mobile station to enable operation of the variable attenuator circuit throughout operation in a digital mode. Thus, while enabled, as soon as the input signal power level rises above a defined activation threshold amount, the variable attenuator circuit is activated and begins attenuating the input signal responsive to input signal power levels based upon a received signal strength indication output from a separate automatic gain control circuit. After the attenuation begins gradually, thus avoiding excessive chattering without the need for hysteresis, the attenuation rises non-linearly and continuously to quickly mitigate IM distortion problems.

Claims

1. An intermodulation (IM) distortion reduction circuit for a radio frequency (RF) receiver having an RF input signal receiver line, said IM distortion reduction circuit comprising:

a variable attenuator connected to attenuate and reduce IM distortion for RF signals on the RF input signal receiver line of the RF receiver; and

an attenuation controller coupled to said variable attenuator to control attenuation by said variable attenuator responsive to RF input signal power levels,

wherein said attenuation controller includes an operational amplifier, wherein said operational amplifier includes an attenuator control input coupled to a received RF signal strength indication source, a threshold level input, and an amplified comparison output coupled to an input of said variable attenuator,

wherein said attenuator controller further includes an attenuator enabler coupled to said attenuator control input, wherein said attenuator enabler includes an amplifier with a control input, a ground input, and an enabling output coupled to said attenuator control input.

2. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 1, wherein said variable attenuator includes a variable impedance path to ground for the RF input receiver line, and wherein the impedance of said variable impedance path to ground varies in response to the RF input signal power levels.

3. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 1, wherein said variable attenuator includes a variable impedance element which varies continuously in impedance throughout a range of RF input signal power levels.

4. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 3, wherein said variable impedance element is a PIN diode coupled between the RF input receiver line and a ground potential.

5. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 4, wherein said variable attenuator further includes an AC-coupling resonating capacitor interposed between said PIN diode and the RF input signal receiver line.

6. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 3, wherein said variable impedance element varies in impedance according to a control voltage generated by said attenuator controller, and wherein said impedance varies in a non-linearly changing manner throughout the range of RF input signal power levels.

7. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 6, wherein said variable attenuator so attenuates received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner that the received RF signals experience a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength while the received RF signal strength is in a lower portion of the range of RF input signal power levels.

8. The IM distortion reduction circuit of claim 1,

wherein said variable attenuator includes a variable impedance element which varies continuously in impedance throughout a range of RF input signal power levels,

wherein said variable impedance element is a PIN diode coupled between the RF input receiver line and a ground potential, and

wherein said variable attenuator so attenuates received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner that the received RF signals experience a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength while the received RF signal strength is in a lower portion of the range of RF input signal power levels.

9. An RF input circuit for a radio frequency (RF) receiver, said RF input circuit comprising:

an RF antenna;

a duplexer including an antenna input and an RF signal receiver output, wherein said antenna input is coupled to said RF antenna;

an RF amplifier including an RF signal input and an RF signal output, wherein said RF signal input is coupled to said RF signal receiver output of said duplexer, and

a variable attenuator including an attenuator input coupled to both said RF signal receiver output of said duplexer and said RF signal input of said RF amplifier.

an attenuation controller coupled to said variable attenuator to control attenuation by said variable attenuator responsive to RF input signal power levels,

wherein said attenuator controller further includes an attenuator enabler coupled to said attenuation controller, and

wherein said attenuator enabler includes an amplifier with a control input, a ground input, and an enabling output coupled to said attenuator control input.

10. The RF input circuit of claim 9,

wherein said attenuation controller activates said variable attenuator to begin attenuating received RF signals when the received RF signal strengths rise above an RF signal power level threshold, and

wherein said RF signal power level threshold is below -80 dBm.

11. The RF input circuit of claim 9, wherein said variable attenuator further includes a variable impedance path to ground for an RF input receiver line, and wherein the impedance of said variable impedance path to ground varies in response to the RF input signal power levels.

12. The RF input circuit of claim 9, wherein said variable attenuator further includes a variable impedance element which varies continuously in impedance throughout a range of RF input signal power levels.

13. The RF input circuit of claim 9, wherein said variable impedance element is a PIN diode coupled between said RF signal receiver output of said duplexer and a ground potential.

14. The RF input circuit of claim 13, wherein said variable attenuator further includes an AC-coupling resonating capacitor interposed between said PIN diode and said RF signal receiver output of said duplexer.

15. The RF input circuit of claim 12, wherein said variable impedance element varies in impedance according to a control voltage generated by said attenuator controller, and wherein said impedance varies in a non-linearly changing manner throughout the range of RF input signal power levels.

16. The RF input circuit of claim 9, further comprising a plurality of non-linear elements creating third order products, and wherein said variable attenuator is located to receive RF signals before said non-linear elements.

17. The RF input circuit of claim 9, wherein said attenuator controller so controls said variable attenuator in a non-hysteresis manner that said variable attenuator attenuates received RF signals when the RF signals have a power level of at least an RF signal power level threshold, and that said variable attenuator provides substantially no attenuation when the RF signals have a power level below said RF signal power level threshold.

18. The RF input circuit of claim 9, wherein said attenuation controller includes an operational amplifier, wherein said operational amplifier includes an attenuator control input, a threshold level input, and an amplified comparison output coupled to said attenuator input.

19. The RF input circuit of claim 9, further comprising a received RF signal strength indication (RSSI) source connected to said attenuation controller.

20. The RF input circuit of claim 19, wherein said RSSI source includes an automatic gain control (AGC) circuit.

21. The RF input circuit of claim 20, wherein said attenuation controller activates said variable attenuator to begin attenuating received RF signals when the received RF signal strengths are in a low portion of an effective operating range of said AGC circuit.

22. The RF input circuit of claim 21,

wherein said attenuation controller activates said variable attenuator to begin attenuating the received RF signals when the received RF signal strengths rise above an RF signal power level threshold, and

wherein said RF signal power level threshold is below -80 dBm.

23. The RF input circuit of claim 20, wherein said AGC circuit possesses an effective operating range for received RF signal strengths of, approximately, -110 dBm to -25 dBm.

24. A dual-mode frequency modulation/code division multiple access (FM/CDMA) cellular mobile station intermodulation (IM) distortion reduction circuit for attenuating RF signals on an RF signal receiver line in the mobile station, said circuit comprising:

means for variably attenuating received RF signals on the RF signal receiver line of the dual-mode (FM/CDMA) cellular mobile station to reduce IM distortion, and

means for supplying to said variably attenuating means a varying attenuation control signal to so control attenuation of the received RF signals by said variably attenuating means that a frame error rate (FER) of the received RF signals is less than or equal to 1% with 95% confidence when the power level of a desired RF signal is -90 dBm and two continuous wave (CW) interference tone power levels are at least -35 dBm.

25. The circuit of claim 24, wherein said supplying means includes means for supplying to said variably attenuating means a varying attenuation control signal to so control attenuation of the received RF signals by said variably attenuating means that the FER of the received RF signals is also less than or equal to 1% with 95% confidence when the power level of the desired RF signal is -79 dBm and two CW interference tone power levels are at least -26 dBm.

26. The circuit of claim 24, wherein said attenuation control signal is responsive to received RF signal strengths.

27. The circuit of claim 26, wherein said variably attenuating means includes means for so attenuating the received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner throughout a range of variable change in attenuation that the received RF signals experience a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength in a lower portion of the range of variable change in attenuation.

28. The circuit of claim 26, wherein when the received RF signals include the desired RF signal to be appropriately processed by the mobile station and interfering RF signals, the desired received RF signal is a CDMA signal on an assigned channel frequency, and the interfering RF signals are tones separated from the assigned channel frequency and from each other such that interfering third order IM products are produced in non-linear elements of the mobile station.

29. A method for reducing intermodulation (IM) distortion in a radio frequency (RF) receiver, said method comprising steps of:

coupling a variable attenuator to an RF signal receiver line of the RF receiver;

supplying to the variable attenuator a varying attenuation control signal to control attenuation by the variable attenuator; and

variably attenuating received RF signal receiver line by the variable attenuator at attenuation levels determined by the attenuation control signal to reduce IM distortion,

wherein said variably attenuating step includes a step of so providing attenuation by the said variable attenuator that a frame error rate (FER) of the received RF signals is less than or equal to 1% with 95% confidence when the power level of a desired RF signal is -90 dBm and two continuous wave (CW) interference tone power levels are at least -35 dBm.

30. The method of claim 29, wherein the attenuation control signal is responsive to a received RF signal strength indication (RSSI).

31. The method of claim 29,

wherein the attenuation control signal is responsive to a received RF signal strength indication (RSSI), and

wherein the variably attenuating step includes a step of so attenuating the received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner throughout a range of RF signal power levels that the received RF signals experience a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength while the received RF signal strengths are in a lower portion of the range of RF signal power levels.

32. The method of claim 29, wherein the variably attenuating step includes steps of

defining a range of received RF signal strengths over which the RF receiver operates, and

so attenuating the received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner that the received RF signals experience larger changes in attenuation per unit change of received RF signal strength while the received RF signal strength is in a lower portion of the range of received RF signal strengths.

33. The method of claim 29, further comprising a step of enabling the variable attenuator by setting the variable attenuator in an attenuator enable mode during which the variable attenuator is operational.

34. The method of claim 33, wherein the coupling step includes a step of connecting the variable attenuator at the input of a receiver section of a cellular telephone.

35. The method of claim 34, wherein the enabling step includes steps of

determining if the cellular telephone is operating in a digital mode,

generating and supplying to the variable attenuator an attenuator enable signal responsive to determining that the cellular telephone is operating in the digital mode, and

disabling the variable attenuator if the cellular telephone is operating in an analog mode.

36. The method of claim 33, wherein the enabling step includes steps of

defining an excessive frame error rate (FER) threshold level, and

enabling the variable attenuator only when the received RF signal FER is above the excessive FER threshold level, and

disabling the variable attenuator to provide substantially no attenuation when the received RF signal FER is below the excessive FER threshold level.

37. The method of claim 29,

wherein the variable attenuator includes a variable impedance element coupled between the RF signal receiver line and a ground potential, and

wherein the variable impedance element varies in impedance according to a control voltage generated by the varying attenuation control signal, and wherein the impedance varies in a non-linearly changing manner throughout a range of RF input signal power levels.

38. The method of claim 37,

wherein the variable impedance element is a PIN diode, and

wherein the PIN diode provides a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength while the received RF signal strength is in a lower portion of the range of RF input signal power levels.

39. The method of claim 37, wherein the varying attenuation control signal is derived from a received signal strength indication (RSSI).

40. The method of claim 29, wherein the supplying step includes a step of supplying to the variable attenuator a varying attenuation control signal to so control attenuation by the variable attenuator in a non-hysteresis manner that the variable attenuator attenuates the received RF signals when the RF signals have a power level of at least a RF signal power level threshold, and that the variable attenuator provides substantially no attenuation when the RF signals have a power level below the RF signal power level threshold.

41. The method of claim 40, wherein the RF signal power level threshold is below -80 dBm.

42. The method of claim 41, wherein the RF signal power level threshold is above -100 dBm.

43. The method of claim 29, wherein the coupling step includes a step of connecting the variable attenuator at the input of a receiver section of a cellular telephone before an initial RF signal amplification stage.

44. The method of claim 29, wherein the variably attenuating step includes a step of variably attenuating received RF signals before the received RF signals reach non-linear receiver elements creating third order products in the RF receiver.

45. A dual-mode frequency modulation/code division multiple access (FM/CDMA) cellular mobile station intermodulation (IM) distortion reduction method for attenuation RF signals on an RF signal receiver line in the mobile station, said method comprising steps of:

variably attenuating received RF signals on the RF signal receiver line of the dual-mode (FM/CDMA) cellular mobile station to reduce IM distortion, and

supplying a varying attenuation control signal to so control attenuation of the received RF signals by said variably attenuating means that a frame error rate (FER) of the received RF signals is less than or equal to 1% with 95% confidence when the power level of a desired RF signal is -90 dBm and two continuous wave (CW) interference tone power levels are at least -35 dBm.

46. The method of claim 45,

wherein the attenuation control signal is responsive to a received RF signal strength indication (RSSI), and

wherein the variably attenuating step includes a step of so attenuating the received RF signals in a non-linearly changing manner throughout a range of variable change in attenuation that the received RF signals experience a larger change in attenuation per unit change of the received RF signal strength in a lower portion of the range of variable change in attenuation.

47. The method of claim 46, wherein when the received RF signals include a desired RF signal to be appropriately processed by the mobile station and interfering RF signals, the desired received RF signal is a CDMA signal on an assigned channel frequency, and the interfering RF signals are tones separated from the assigned channel frequency and from each other such that interfering third order IM products are produced in non-linear elements of the mobile station.

48. The method of claim 47, wherein the supplying step includes a step of supplying to the variable attenuator a varying attenuation control signal to so control attenuation of the received RF signals by the variable attenuator that the FER of the received RF signals is also less than or equal to 1% with 95% confidence when the power level of the desired RF signal is -79 dBm and two CW interference tone power levels are at least -26 dBm.