Method and apparatus for performing diversity voting in a communication system

• US 5,719,871 A
• Filed: 04/19/1995
• Issued: 02/17/1998
• Est. Priority Date: 04/19/1995
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Motorola Solutions, Inc.
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: LoGalbo, Robert D., Wilson, Alan L., Helm, David P.
• Primary Examiner(s): Olms, Douglas W.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Patel, Ajit
• Application Number:
  US08/635,105
• Time in Patent Office: 1,035 Days
• Field of Search: 370/479, 370/513, 370/342, 370/441, 370/328, 370/335, 375/205, 375/206, 371/2.1, 371/36, 371/37.1, 371/37.4, 371/41, 455/422, 379/59, 379/60
• US Class Current: 370/479
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/022 Site diversity; Macro-diversity using two or more spaced independent antennas H04B7/04
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 1/06 using space diversity

Abstract

A communication system (200) employs a method and apparatus for performing diversity voting in the communication system. A comparator (206) receives a signal frame (207-209) of code words from each of multiple signal sources (202-204). A prioritized code word of each signal frame occupies a corresponding frame position and has a respective signal quality metric associated therewith. The comparator determines whether each signal quality metric accurately represents the signal quality of its respective prioritized code word. When the signal quality metrics do not accurately represent the signal qualities of their respective prioritized code words, the comparator determines a supplemental signal quality metric for each prioritized code word. The comparator then selects one prioritized code word from all the corresponding prioritized code words based on a comparison of the supplemental signal quality metrics for input into the corresponding frame position of a voted signal frame (330).

Claims

1. A method comprising the steps of:

a) receiving a signal frame from each of a plurality of signal sources to produce a plurality of signal frames, each signal frame of the plurality of signal frames including a group of code words, each group of code words including a prioritized code word to produce a plurality of prioritized code words, each prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words occupying a particular frame position in a respective signal frame and having a corresponding signal quality metric associated therewith to produce a plurality of signal quality metrics;

b) determining whether the plurality of signal quality metrics accurately represent respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words;

c) when the plurality of signal quality metrics do not accurately represent the respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words,

1) determining a supplemental signal quality metric for each prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words to produce a plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics; and

2) selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words based on a comparison of the plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics to produce a voted code word.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising the steps of:

d) when the plurality of signal quality metrics accurately represent the respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words, selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words based on a comparison of the plurality of signal quality metrics to produce the voted code word.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein step (d) comprises the step of:

d1) when the plurality of signal quality metrics accurately represent the respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words, selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words having a signal quality metric associated therewith that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a signal quality metric associated with any other prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words.

4. The method of claim 3, wherein step (d1) comprises the step of:

d1a) when the plurality of signal quality metrics accurately represent the respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words, selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words having a signal quality metric associated therewith that is less than a signal quality metric associated with any other prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words.

5. The method of claim 1, wherein step (c2) comprises the step of selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words having a supplemental signal quality metric associated therewith that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a supplemental signal quality metric associated with any other prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words.

6. The method of claim 5, wherein step (c2) comprises the step of selecting a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words having a supplemental signal quality metric associated therewith that is less than a supplemental signal quality metric associated with any other prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words.

7. The method of claim 1, further comprising the step of using the voted code word to produce a voted signal frame of voted code words, wherein the voted code word occupies the particular frame position in the voted signal frame.

8. The method of claim 1, wherein step (b) comprises the steps of:

b1) determining that the plurality of signal quality metrics do not accurately represent the respective signal qualifies of the plurality of prioritized code words when the plurality of signal quality metrics indicate that the plurality of prioritized code words are of equal or lower signal quality than a predetermined quality threshold.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein step (b1) comprises the step of:

b1a) determining that the plurality of signal quality metrics do not accurately represent the respective signal qualifies of the plurality of prioritized code words when the plurality of signal quality metrics are greater than or equal to the predetermined quality threshold.

10. The method of claim 1, wherein step (b) comprises the step of:

b1) determining that the plurality of signal quality metrics do not accurately represent the respective signal qualities of the plurality of prioritized code words when the plurality of signal quality metrics are substantially equal.

11. The method of claim 1, wherein each signal frame has a signal frame signal quality metric associated therewith and wherein step (c1) comprises the step of determining the supplemental signal quality metric for each prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words as a signal frame signal quality metric of a signal frame that includes the prioritized code word.

12. The method of claim 1, wherein each signal frame has a signal frame signal quality metric associated therewith, wherein each group of code words further includes an unprioritized code word to produce a plurality of unprioritized code words, and wherein each unprioritized code word of the plurality of unprioritized code words occupies a second particular frame position in a respective signal frame, the method further comprising the steps of:

d) determining a signal quality metric for each unprioritized code word of the plurality of unprioritized code words based on a signal frame signal quality metric of the respective signal frame that includes the unprioritized code word and a signal quality metric of a prioritized code word of the plurality of prioritized code words that occupies a frame position in the respective signal frame that includes the unprioritized code word; and

e) selecting an unprioritized code word of the plurality of unprioritized code words having a signal quality metric that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a signal quality metric of any other unprioritized code word of the plurality of unprioritized code words.

13. A method comprising the steps of:

a) receiving a first signal frame from a first signal source and a second signal frame from a second signal source, each signal frame including a plurality of code words, a prioritized code word of the first signal frame occupying a particular frame position in the first signal frame and having a first signal quality metric associated therewith and a prioritized code word of the second signal frame occupying the particular frame position in the second signal frame and having a second signal quality metric associated therewith;

b) determining whether the first signal quality metric accurately represents a signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame and whether the second signal quality metric accurately represents a signal quality of the prioritized code word of the second signal frame;

c) when the first signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame and the second signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the second signal frame,

1) determining a supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the first signal frame;

2) determining a supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the second signal frame;

3) selecting the prioritized code word of the first signal frame to produce a voted code word when the supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the first signal frame is indicative of a higher signal quality than the supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the second signal frame; and

d) when the first signal quality metric accurately represents the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame, selecting the prioritized code word of the first signal frame to produce the voted code word when the first signal quality metric is indicative of a higher signal quality than the second signal quality metric.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein step (d) comprises the step of:

d1) when the first signal quality metric accurately represents the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame, selecting the prioritized code word of the first signal frame to produce the voted code word when the first signal quality metric is less than the second signal quality metric.

15. The method of claim 13, wherein step (b) comprises the step of:

b1) determining that the first signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame and that the second signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the second signal frame when the first signal quality metric is of equal or lower signal quality than a predetermined quality threshold and the second signal quality metric is of equal or lower signal quality than the predetermined quality threshold.

16. The method of claim 13, wherein step (b) comprises the step of:

b1) determining that the first signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the first signal frame and that the second signal quality metric does not accurately represent the signal quality of the prioritized code word of the second signal frame when the first signal quality metric is substantially equal to the second signal quality metric.

17. The method of claim 13, wherein each signal frame has a signal quality metric associated therewith and wherein step (c1) comprises the step of determining the supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the first signal frame as being a signal quality metric of the first signal frame and wherein step (c2) comprises the step of determining the supplemental signal quality metric for the prioritized code word of the second signal frame as being a signal quality metric of the second signal frame.

18. The method of claim 13, wherein each signal frame has a signal quality metric associated therewith and wherein at least one unprioritized code word of each signal frame occupies at least one respective frame position in each signal frame, the method further comprising the steps of:

e) determining a signal quality metric for the at least one unprioritized code word of the first signal frame based on the first signal quality metric and a signal quality metric of the first signal frame;

f) determining a signal quality metric for the at least one unprioritized code word of the second signal frame based on the second signal quality metric and a signal quality metric of the second signal frame; and

g) selecting the at least one unprioritized code word of the first signal frame to produce at least a second voted code word when the signal quality metric of the at least one unprioritized code word of the first signal frame indicates that the at least one unprioritized code word of the first signal frame is of a higher signal quality than the at least one unprioritized code word of the second signal frame, the at least a second voted code word occupying the at least one respective frame position in a signal frame of voted code words.

19. In a comparator of a digital radio communication system that utilizes diversity techniques to produce a plurality of voted signal frames, each of the plurality of voted signal frames including a plurality of voted code words, a method for selecting the plurality of voted code words to be inputted into a voted signal frame of the plurality of voted signal frames, the method comprising the steps of:

a) receiving a signal frame from each of a plurality of signal sources to produce a plurality of signal frames, each signal frame of the plurality of signal frames including a group of prioritized code words and a group of unprioritized code words that together constitute improved multi-band excitation (IMBE) encoding of an audio signal, each group of prioritized code words including a first prioritized code word and a second prioritized code word to produce a plurality of first prioritized code words and a plurality of second prioritized code words, each first prioritized code word of the plurality of first prioritized code words occupying a first frame position in a respective signal frame and having a corresponding signal quality metric associated therewith to produce a plurality of first signal quality metrics, each second prioritized code word of the plurality of second prioritized code words occupying a second frame position in a respective signal frame and having a corresponding signal quality metric associated therewith to produce a plurality of second signal quality metrics;

b) determining whether the plurality of first signal quality metrics indicate that the plurality of first prioritized code words are of a higher signal quality than a predetermined quality threshold;

c) when the plurality of first signal quality metrics indicate that the plurality of first prioritized code words are not of a higher signal quality than the predetermined quality threshold,

1) determining a supplemental signal quality metric for each first prioritized code word of the plurality of first prioritized code words to produce a first plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics;

2) selecting a first prioritized code word of the plurality of first prioritized code words having a supplemental signal quality metric associated therewith that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a supplemental signal quality metric associated with any other first prioritized code word of the plurality of first prioritized code words to produce a first voted code word, the first voted code word occupying a first frame position of the voted signal frame;

d) determining whether the plurality of second signal quality metrics are substantially equal;

e) when the plurality of second signal quality metrics are substantially equal,

1) determining a supplemental signal quality metric for each second prioritized code word of the plurality of second prioritized code words to produce a second plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics;

2) selecting a second prioritized code word of the plurality of second prioritized code words having a supplemental signal quality metric associated therewith that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a supplemental signal quality metric associated with any other second prioritized code word of the plurality of second prioritized code words to produce a second voted code word, the second voted code word occupying a second frame position of the voted signal frame;

f) determining a signal quality metric for each group of unprioritized code words; and

g) selecting a group of unprioritized code words having a signal quality metric associated therewith that is indicative of a higher signal quality than a signal quality metric associated with any other group of unprioritized code words to produce a group of voted unprioritized code words, each unprioritized code word of the group of voted unprioritized code words occupying a respective frame position of the voted signal frame.

20. A diversity radio communication system, comprising:

a plurality of base stations, each of the plurality of base stations receiving a digital communication signal from a communication unit and parsing the digital communication signal into a plurality of signal frames, wherein each of the plurality of signal frames includes a plurality of code words, each of the plurality of base stations further determining a signal quality metric for a prioritized code word of the plurality of code words in each signal frame, the prioritized code word of each signal frame occupying a particular frame position in each signal frame; and

a comparator, coupled to the plurality of base stations, that receives a first signal frame of the plurality of signal frames from each base station of the plurality of base stations, that determines whether the signal quality metric of each prioritized code word accurately represents a signal quality of each prioritized code word, and that (i) determines a supplemental signal quality metric for each prioritized code word to produce a plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics and (ii) selects a prioritized code word to produce a voted code word based on a comparison of the plurality of supplemental signal quality metrics when the signal quality metric of each prioritized code word does not accurately represent the signal quality of each prioritized code word, the voted code word occupying the particular frame position in a voted signal frame.