Decision feedback equalization implementation of partial-response signaling in a magnetic recording channel

• US 5,822,143 A
• Filed: 06/11/1996
• Issued: 10/13/1998
• Est. Priority Date: 06/11/1996
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Western Digital Corporation
• Original Assignee: Western Digital Corporation
• Inventors: Cloke, Robert Leslie, Lee, Patrick James
• Primary Examiner(s): Psitos, Aristotelis M.
• Assistant Examiner(s): WAMSLEY, PATRICK G
• Application Number:
  US08/661,573
• Time in Patent Office: 854 Days
• Field of Search: 360/46, 360/48, 360/51, 360/65, 360/25, 360/66, 360/45, 375/232, 375/233, 375/291, 375/355, 375/376, 364/488, 364/724.19, 327/79, 327/7, 327/156, 371/43.6, 371/21.1
• US Class Current: 360/65
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 20/10009 Improvement or modification of read or write signals
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 20/10046 filtering or equalising, e.g. setting the tap weights of an FIR filter
• CPC Class Codes: G11B 5/09 Digital recording

Abstract

A partial-response maximum-likelihood (PRML) sequence detector with decision feedback equalization (DFE) for a disk drive read channel. The symbol recovery method for a disk drive read channel produces a sequence of samples X_n of a magnetic readback signal with amplitudes representing the readback signal during corresponding sample intervals n=1-N. A DFE circuit generates a sequence of equalized samples y_n and includes a feed-forward filter that removes precursor ISI from the sequence of sample signals x_n to produce a sequence of feed-forward equalized samples w_n, detection logic that translates the sequence of equalized samples y_n into a sequence of detected symbols y_n, and a feedback filter that filters the sequence of detected symbols y_n to produce a sequence of equalization feedback values e_n to offset postcursor ISI remaining in the sequence of feed-forward equalized samples w_n. A combinational circuit receives the feed-forward equalized samples w_n and the feedback values e_n and combines a sample w_k with an equalization feedback value e_k to produce an equalized sample y_k for each sample interval k in the range of k=1-N. A PRML sequence detector, such as a Viterbi detector, is used with the DFE circuit to recover a user data symbol a_k for sample interval k corresponding to the equalized sample y_k in response to the sequence of equalized samples y_n. The detected symbols y_n used in the feedback path are generated using separate detectors, which allows for feedback with a delay of only one sample interval.

Claims

1. A method for recovering symbols from a magnetic recording medium, the method comprising the steps of:

producing a readback signal from the magnetic recording medium, the readback signal representing a sequence of the symbols during a sequence of timing intervals, the sequence of symbols including symbols that are adjacent in that they are represented by the readback signal during consecutive timing intervals, and are subject to inter-symbol interference;

sampling the readback signal to produce a sequence of samples {x_n } having amplitudes representing the readback signal during corresponding sample intervals n=1 through N;

processing the sequence of samples {x_n } with a feedforward and feedback arrangement to produce a sequence of equalized samples {y_n } that sequentially represent the symbols with substantially less inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols, the processing step including;

a. filtering the sequence of samples {x_n } with an asymmetrical feed-forward filter to produce a sequence of feed-forward equalized samples {w_n }, the asymmetrical feed-forward filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of precursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ;

b. producing a sequence of detected symbols from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n } such that each detected symbol corresponds to a successive timing interval;

c. filtering the sequence of detected symbols with an asymmetrical feedback filter to produce a sequence of equalization feedback values {e_n } such that each detected symbol affects a group of the immediately succeeding equalization feedback values substantially more than any equalization feedback value defined subsequent to the group, the asymmetrical feedback filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of postcursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ; and

d. sequentially subtracting the equalization feedback values e_n from the feed-forward equalized samples w_n to produce the sequence of equalized samples y_n ; and

processing the sequence of equalized samples {y_n } with a maximum-likelihood sequence detector to recover sequences of the symbols recovered from the magnetic recording medium.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of producing a sequence of detected symbols includes producing a sequence of symbols {y_n }, one at a time, from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a non-zero weight.

4. The method of claim 2, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a substantial weight.

5. The method of claim 2, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j is 5 or less.

6. The method of claim 2, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j is 3 or less.

7. The method of claim 2, wherein the step of producing a sequence of detected symbols {y_n } includes converting an equalized sample y_n in the sequence of equalized samples in a multi-level detector to a detected symbol y_n.

8. The method of claim 7, wherein the multilevel detector detects three levels.

9. The method of claim 7, wherein the multilevel detector detects five levels.

10. The method of claim 7, wherein the readback signal is characterized by a channel transfer polynomial of the form P(D)=(1-D)(1+D)^m, where m is an integer and D is a delay operator.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein m equals 1.

12. The method of claim 10, wherein m is greater than or equal to 2.

13. The method of claim 1, wherein the maximum-likelihood sequence detector comprises a Viterbi detector.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein the Viterbi detector includes a plurality of detector paths including respective sequences of detector path symbols, the Viterbi detector associating state metrics with the plurality of detector paths.

15. The method of claim 14, wherein the step of producing a sequence of detected symbols includes selecting in response to the state metrics a detector path in the plurality of detector paths, and providing the sequence of detector path symbols of the selected detector path as a current sequence of detected symbols.

16. A disk drive comprising:

a magnetic recording disk;

a readback circuit, coupled with the magnetic recording disk, that produces a readback signal from the magnetic recording disk, the readback signal representing a sequence of symbols during a sequence of timing intervals, the sequence of symbols including symbols that are adjacent in that they are represented by the readback signal during consecutive timing intervals, and are subject to inter-symbol interference;

the readback circuit sampling the readback signal to produce a sequence of samples {x_n } having amplitudes representing the readback signal during corresponding sample intervals n=1 through N;

a decision feedback equalization circuit for processing the sequence of samples {x_n } with a feedforward and feedback arrangement to produce a sequence of equalized samples {y_n } that sequentially represent the symbols with substantially less inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols, the decision feedback equalization circuit including;

a. an asymmetrical feed-forward filter for filtering the sequence of samples {x_n } to produce a sequence of feed-forward equalized samples {w_n }, the asymmetrical feed-forward filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of precursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ;

b. symbol detection means for producing a sequence of detected symbols from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n } such that each detected symbol corresponds to a successive timing interval;

c. an asymmetrical feedback filter for filtering the sequence of detected symbols to produce a sequence of equalization feedback values {e_n } such that each detected symbol affects a group of the immediately succeeding equalization feedback values substantially more than any equalization feedback value defined subsequent to the group, the asymmetrical feedback filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of postcursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ; and

d. means for sequentially subtracting the equalization feedback values e_n from the feed-forward equalized samples w_n to produce the sequence of equalized samples y_n ; and

a maximum-likelihood sequence detector coupled to the decision feedback equalization circuit that recovers a symbol a_n corresponding to the equalized sample y_n in response to the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }.

17. The disk drive of claim 16, wherein the readback circuit includes:

a transducer that produces the readback signal from the disk;

an analog filter, connected to the transducer, which filters the readback signal to generate a filtered readback signal;

a sampler, connected to the analog filter, which produces the sequence of sample signals {x_n } from the filtered readback signal.

18. The disk drive of claim 16, wherein the symbol detection means further producing a sequence of detected symbols {y_n } one at a time, from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }.

19. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a non-zero weight.

20. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a substantial weight.

21. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j is 5 or less.

22. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j, is 3 or less.

23. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the symbol detection means comprises a three level detector that translates each of the equalized sample values into one of three symbols.

24. The disk drive of claim 18, wherein the symbol detector comprises a five level detector that translates each of the equalized sample values into one of five symbols.

25. The disk drive of claim 16, wherein the data channel is characterized by a channel transfer polynomial of the form P(D)=(1-D)(1+D)^m, where m is an integer and D is a delay operator.

26. The disk drive of claim 25, wherein m equals 1.

27. The disk drive of claim 25, wherein m is greater than or equal to 2.

28. The disk drive of claim 16, wherein the maximum-likelihood sequence detector comprises a Viterbi detector.

29. The disk drive of claim 16, wherein the Viterbi detector includes a plurality of detector paths including respective sequences of detector path symbols, and associates state metrics with the plurality of detector paths, and the Viterbi detector selecting in response to the state metrics a detector path in the plurality of detector paths, and providing the sequence of detector path symbols of the selected detector path as a current sequence of detected symbols.

30. A read channel for recovering symbols from a data channel read from a magnetic recording disk, comprising:

a decision feedback equalization circuit for processing a sequence of sample signals {x_n } having amplitudes representing the data channel during corresponding sample intervals n=1 through N, and which produces a sequence of equalized samples {y_n }, the decision feedback equalization circuit including;

a. an asymmetrical feed-forward filter for filtering the sequence of samples {x_n } to produce a sequence of feed-forward equalized samples {w_n }, the asymmetrical feed-forward filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of precursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ;

b. symbol detection means for producing a sequence of detected symbols from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n } such that each detected symbol corresponds to a successive timing interval;

c. an asymmetrical feedback filter for filtering the sequence of detected symbols to produce a sequence of equalization feedback values {e_n } such that each detected symbol affects a group of the immediately succeeding equalization feedback values substantially more than any equalization feedback value defined subsequent to the group, the asymmetrical feedback filter having a response that is asymmetrically balanced to cause preferential reduction of postcursor inter-symbol interference between adjacent symbols represented by the samples y_n ; and

d. means for sequentially subtracting the equalization feedback values e_n from the feed-forward equalized samples w_n to produce the sequence of equalized samples y_n ; and

a maximum-likelihood sequence detector coupled to the decision feedback equalization circuit that recovers a symbol a_n corresponding to the equalized sample y_n, in response to the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }.

31. The read channel of claim 30, wherein the symbol detection means further producing a sequence of detected symbols {y_n } one at a time, from the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }.

32. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a non-zero weight.

33. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a detected symbol y_n-1 corresponding to an equalized sample y_n-1 preceding the equalized sample y_n by one sample interval has a substantial weight.

34. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j is 5 or less.

35. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the asymmetrical feedback filter has tap weights such that a set of detected symbols y_n-1 to y_n-j corresponding to equalized samples y_n-1 to y_n-j preceding the equalized sample y_n by one to j sample intervals have together greater weight than any equal number of detected symbols preceding the equalized sample by more than j sample intervals, and where j is 3 or less.

36. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the symbol detection means comprises a three level detector that translates each of the equalized sample values into one of three symbols.

37. The read channel of claim 31, wherein the symbol detection means comprises a five level detector that translates each of the equalized sample values into one of five symbols.

38. The read channel of claim 30, wherein the data channel is characterized by a channel transfer polynomial of the form P(D)=(1-D)(1+D)^m, where m is an integer and D is a delay parameter.

39. The read channel of claim 38, wherein m equals 1.

40. The read channel of claim 38, wherein m equals 2.

41. The read channel of claim 30, wherein the a maximum-likelihood sequence detector comprises a Viterbi detector.

42. The read channel of claim 41, wherein:

the Viterbi detector recovering a sequence of symbols {a_n } from the data channel in response to the sequence of equalized samples {y_n }, the Viterbi detector having a plurality of detector paths storing respective sequences of detector path symbols, and associating state metrics with the plurality of detector paths; and

the symbol detection means is coupled to the Viterbi detector, the symbol detection means selecting a detector path in the plurality of detector paths in response to the state metrics, and providing the sequence of detector path symbols of the selected detector path as the sequence of detected symbols.