System, device, and method for contention-based reservation in a shared medium network

• US 5,960,000 A
• Filed: 05/30/1997
• Issued: 09/28/1999
• Est. Priority Date: 05/30/1997
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: ARRIS Enterprises LLC (CommScope Holding Company, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.)
• Inventors: Lee, Whay Chiou, Ruszczyk, Chester A., Chlamtac, Imrich
• Primary Examiner(s): Nguyen, Chau
• Assistant Examiner(s): VANDERPUYE, KENNETH N
• Application Number:
  US08/866,865
• Time in Patent Office: 851 Days
• Field of Search: 370/437, 370/447, 370/461, 370/462, 370/445, 370/449, 370/450, 370/451, 370/443, 370/458, 370/459, 370/346, 370/345, 370/348, 340/825.5, 340/825.07, 340/825.08
• US Class Current: 370/447
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 12/2801 Broadband local area networks
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 12/40163 by assigning priority to messages according to a message field
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 12/4035 in which slots of a TDMA packet structure are assigned based on a contention resolution carried out at a master unit TDM/TDMA multiplex systems per se H04J3/1694; hybrid switching systems H04L12/64
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 28/26 Resource reservation
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 74/085 collision avoidance

Abstract

A system, device, and method for contention-based reservation in a shared medium network resolves collisions resulting from contention access using a combination of probabilistic tree splitting and first-come-first-served splitting techniques. The collision resolution procedure utilizes the first-come-first-served splitting technique to select a collision resolution interval, and provides two contention mini-slots to improve the likelihood of successful reservations. Each contending user transmits a reservation request in a randomly selected contention mini-slot. Two contention mini-slots are provided for a predetermined maximum number of collision resolution iterations, after which only one contention mini-slot is provided.

Claims

1. A method for allocating a number of contention mini-slots for a current contention cycle as part of a Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol, said MAC protocol having a MAC protocol state equal to one of a normal state and a collision resolution state, the method comprising the steps of:

determining an aggregate feedback state for a previous contention cycle based on individual feedback states for a number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle, wherein the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots represents the result of contention for the contention mini-slot, and wherein the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE, COLLISION, and SUCCESS;

updating a collision resolution interval; and

determining an allocation of contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle based on the aggregate feedback state and the updated collision resolution interval.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of determining the aggregate feedback state comprises the steps of:

determining the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle;

determining the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle;

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to IDLE if the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that no transmission occurred in the contention mini-slot;

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to COLLISION if the individual feedback state for at least one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that a collision occurred in the contention mini-slot; and

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to SUCCESS if none of the individual feedback states indicate that a collision occurred and at least one of the individual feedback states indicates that a successful transmission occurred.

3. The method of claim 1 wherein the collision resolution interval includes a transmitting sub-interval equal to one of an older sub-interval and a newer sub-interval and wherein the steps of updating the collision resolution interval and determining the allocation of contention mini-slots comprise the steps of:

determining the MAC protocol state;

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the normal state;

allocating one contention mini-slot for the current contention cycle, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS; and

allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle, setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the collision resolution state;

allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to SUCCESS;

allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

allocating one contention mini-slot for the current contention cycle and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS.

4. The method of claim 3 further comprising the steps of:

setting an iteration counter equal to one upon setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state;

incrementing the iteration counter, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

incrementing the iteration counter, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

setting the iteration counter equal to zero upon setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state.

5. The method of claim 4 further comprising the step of, after allocating two contention mini-slots for the contention cycle, changing the allocation to one contention mini-slot for the contention cycle, if the iteration counter exceeds a predetermined maximum number of iterations.

6. The method of claim 5 wherein the predetermined maximum number of iterations is equal to two.

7. A method for processing an entry poll message received by an Access Interface Unit (AIU) as part of a Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol, said MAC protocol having a MAC protocol state equal to one of a normal state and a collision resolution state, said AIU supporting a number of MAC Users, each of said MAC Users having a MAC User state equal to one of INACTIVE, CONTENTION, and ACTIVE, and wherein the entry poll message contains individual feedback states for a number of contention mini-slots in a previous contention cycle and an allocation of contention mini-slots for a current contention cycle, the method comprising the steps of:

determining an aggregate feedback state from the individual feedback states contained in the entry poll message, wherein the aggregate feedback state is a function of the individual feedback states and is equal to one of IDLE, COLLISION, and SUCCESS;

updating a collision resolution interval; and

executing a contention access procedure for each MAC User.

8. The method of claim 7 wherein the step of determining the aggregate feedback state comprises the steps of:

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to IDLE if the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that no transmission occurred in the contention mini-slot;

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to COLLISION if the individual feedback state for at least one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that a collision occurred in the contention mini-slot; and

setting the aggregate feedback state equal to SUCCESS if none of the individual feedback states indicate that a collision occurred and at least one of the individual feedback states indicates that a successful transmission occurred.

9. The method of claim 7 wherein the collision resolution interval includes a start time, an end time, and a transmitting sub-interval equal to one of an older sub-interval and a newer sub-interval, and wherein the step of updating the collision resolution interval comprises the steps of:

determining the MAC protocol state;

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the normal state;

advancing the collision resolution interval, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS; and

splitting the collision resolution interval, setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the collision resolution state;

setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to SUCCESS;

splitting the collision resolution interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

splitting the collision resolution interval and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

advancing the collision resolution interval and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS.

10. The method of claim 9 wherein the step of advancing the collision resolution interval comprises setting the new start time equal to the end time and setting the new end time equal to the earlier of a present time and a time that is a predetermined increment from the new start time.

11. The method of claim 9 wherein the step of splitting the collision resolution interval comprises the step of setting the new end time to a split time which is between the start time and the end time.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein the split time is equal to the midpoint between the start time and the end time.

13. The method of claim 9 wherein the step of setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval comprises the steps of:

determining an interval duration equal to the difference between the end time and the start time;

advancing the start time by the interval duration; and

advancing the end time by the interval duration.

14. The method of claim 7 wherein the step of executing the contention access procedure for each MAC User comprises the steps of:

determining the MAC User state for the MAC User;

if the MAC User is in the CONTENTION state, determining whether the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle;

if the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle, determining whether the contention resulted in a collision;

if the MAC User did not contend in the previous contention cycle or the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle and the contention resulted in a collision, determining whether the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval; and

if the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval;

selecting one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated for the current contention cycle with equal probability; and

transmitting a reservation request in the selected contention mini-slot.

15. The method of claim 14 wherein the step of determining whether the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval comprises determining whether the oldest data awaiting transmission was received during the transmitting sub-interval.

16. The method of claim 14 further comprising the step of setting the MAC User state equal to ACTIVE, if the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle and the contention did not result in a collision.

17. A device for allocating contention mini-slots for a current contention cycle as part of a Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol, said MAC protocol having a MAC protocol state equal to one of a normal state and a collision resolution state, the device comprising:

logic for determining an aggregate feedback state for a previous contention cycle based on individual feedback states for a number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle, wherein the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots represents the result of contention for the contention mini-slot, and wherein the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE, COLLISION, and SUCCESS;

logic for updating a collision resolution interval; and

logic for determining the allocation of contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle based on the aggregate feedback state and the updated collision resolution interval.

18. The device of claim 17 wherein the logic for determining the aggregate feedback state comprises:

logic for determining the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle;

logic for determining the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle;

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to IDLE if the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that no transmission occurred in the contention mini-slot;

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to COLLISION if the individual feedback state for at least one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that a collision occurred in the contention mini-slot; and

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to SUCCESS if none of the individual feedback states indicate that a collision occurred and at least one of the individual feedback states indicates that a successful transmission occurred.

19. The device of claim 17 wherein the collision resolution interval includes a transmitting sub-interval equal to one of an older sub-interval and a newer sub-interval and wherein the logic for updating the collision resolution interval and determining the allocation of contention mini-slots comprise the steps of:

logic for determining the MAC protocol state;

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the normal state;

logic for allocating one contention mini-slot for the current contention cycle, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS; and

logic for allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle, setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the collision resolution state;

logic for allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to SUCCESS;

logic for allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

logic for allocating two contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

logic for allocating one contention mini-slot for the current contention cycle and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS.

20. The device of claim 19 further comprising:

logic for setting an iteration counter equal to one upon setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state;

logic for incrementing the iteration counter, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

logic for incrementing the iteration counter, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

logic for setting the iteration counter equal to zero upon setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state.

21. The device of claim 20 further comprising logic for changing the allocation to one contention mini-slot for the contention cycle, if the iteration counter exceeds a predetermined maximum number of iterations.

22. The device of claim 21 wherein the predetermined maximum number of iterations is equal to two.

23. A device for processing an entry poll message received by an Access Interface Unit (AIU) as part of a Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol, said MAC protocol having a MAC protocol state equal to one of a normal state and a collision resolution state, said AIU supporting a number of MAC Users, each of said MAC Users having a MAC User state equal to one of INACTIVE, CONTENTION, and ACTIVE, and wherein the entry poll message contains individual feedback states for a number of contention mini-slots in a previous contention cycle and an allocation of contention mini-slots for a current contention cycle, the device comprising:

logic for determining an aggregate feedback state from the individual feedback states contained in the entry poll message, wherein the aggregate feedback state is a function of the individual feedback states and is equal to one of IDLE, COLLISION, and SUCCESS;

logic for updating a collision resolution interval; and

logic for executing a contention access procedure for each MAC User.

24. The device of claim 23 wherein the logic for determining the aggregate feedback state comprises:

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to IDLE if the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that no transmission occurred in the contention mini-slot;

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to COLLISION if the individual feedback state for at least one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle indicates that a collision occurred in the contention mini-slot; and

logic for setting the aggregate feedback state equal to SUCCESS if none of the individual feedback states indicate that a collision occurred and at least one of the individual feedback states indicates that a successful transmission occurred.

25. The device of claim 23 wherein the collision resolution interval includes a start time, an end time, and a transmitting sub-interval equal to one of an older sub-interval and a newer sub-interval, and wherein the logic for updating the collision resolution interval comprises:

logic for determining the MAC protocol state;

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the normal state;

logic for advancing the collision resolution interval, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS; and

logic for splitting the collision resolution interval, setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the collision resolution state, if the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

where the MAC protocol state is equal to the collision resolution state;

logic for setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to SUCCESS;

logic for splitting the collision resolution interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the older sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and COLLISION;

logic for splitting the collision resolution interval and setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the older sub-interval, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to COLLISION; and

logic for advancing the collision resolution interval and setting the MAC protocol state equal to the normal state, if the transmitting sub-interval is equal to the newer sub-interval and the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE and SUCCESS.

26. The device of claim 25 wherein the logic for advancing the collision resolution interval comprises logic for setting the new start time equal to the end time and logic for setting the new end time equal to the earlier of a present time and a time that is a predetermined increment from the new start time.

27. The device of claim 25 wherein the logic for splitting the collision resolution interval comprises logic for setting the new end time to a split time which is between the start time and the end time.

28. The device of claim 27 wherein the split time is equal to the midpoint between the start time and the end time.

29. The device of claim 25 wherein the logic for setting the transmitting sub-interval equal to the newer sub-interval comprises:

logic for determining an interval duration equal to the difference between the end time and the start time;

logic for advancing the start time by the interval duration; and

logic for advancing the end time by the interval duration.

30. The device of claim 23 wherein the logic for executing the contention access procedure for each MAC User comprises:

logic for determining the MAC User state for the MAC User;

if the MAC User is in the CONTENTION state, logic for determining whether the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle;

if the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle, logic for determining whether the contention resulted in a collision;

if the MAC User did not contend in the previous contention cycle or the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle and the contention resulted in a collision, logic for determining whether the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval; and

if the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval;

logic for selecting one of the number of contention mini-slots allocated for the current contention cycle with equal probability; and

logic for transmitting a reservation request in the selected contention mini-slot.

31. The device of claim 30 wherein the logic for determining whether the MAC User is associated with the transmitting sub-interval comprises logic for determining whether the oldest data awaiting transmission was received during the transmitting sub-interval.

32. The device of claim 30 further comprising logic for setting the MAC User state equal to ACTIVE, if the MAC User contended in the previous contention cycle and the contention did not result in a collision.

33. A system having a single headend unit in communication with a plurality of Access Interface Units (AIUs) by means of a shared medium, each AIU supporting at least one MAC User, the system utilizing a method for coordinating access by the MAC Users to the shared medium comprising the steps of:

by the headend unit;

determining an aggregate feedback state for a previous contention cycle based on individual feedback states for a number of contention mini-slots allocated in the previous contention cycle, wherein the individual feedback state for each of the number of contention mini-slots represents the result of contention for the contention mini-slot, and wherein the aggregate feedback state is equal to one of IDLE, COLLISION, and SUCCESS;

updating a collision resolution interval maintained by the headend unit;

determining an allocation of contention mini-slots for a current contention cycle based on the aggregate feedback state and the updated collision resolution interval maintained by the headend unit; and

transmitting an entry poll message containing the individual feedback states for the number of contention mini-slots in the previous contention cycle and the allocation of contention mini-slots for the current contention cycle; and

by the AIU;

receiving the entry poll message;

determining an aggregate feedback state from the individual feedback states contained in the entry poll message;

updating a collision resolution interval maintained by the AIU; and

executing a contention access procedure for each MAC User supported by the AIU.