Quantitative visual system for comparing parameters which characterize multiple complex entities

• US 5,960,443 A
• Filed: 10/28/1997
• Issued: 09/28/1999
• Est. Priority Date: 07/25/1997
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Oxford Innovative Ventures, Ltd.
• Original Assignee: Oxford Innovative Ventures, Ltd.
• Inventors: Young, David E., Lowell, DeWitt J.
• Primary Examiner(s): Lintz, Paul R.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Shah, Sanjiv
• Application Number:
  US08/995,576
• Time in Patent Office: 700 Days
• Field of Search: 707/100, 707/200, 707/104, 364/222.81, 364/225, 364/227.3, 364/286, 395/500, 606/1, 600/476, 250/339.08, 514/302, 435/4, 623/11
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 18/40 Software arrangements specially adapted for pattern recognition, e.g. user interfaces or toolboxes therefor
• CPC Class Codes: G06T 11/206 Drawing of charts or graphs
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 10/40 for data related to laboratory analysis, e.g. patient specimen analysis
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99945 Object-oriented database structure processing
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99948 Application of database or data structure, e.g. distributed, multimedia, or image

Abstract

A system for comparing two complex entities, particularly appropriate for assisting in matching recipients with potential organ transplant donors or prostheses, utilizes a set of data corresponding to multiple diverse parameters representing a first complex entity, graphically represented on a helical structure having a discrete primary zone for each parameter and a series of secondary zones within each primary zone to establish scale means for quantitative representation of the data. The data is represented in a visual manner by means of shading in the secondary zones, with the shading increasing in hue and density with increasing distance of the secondary zones from the longitudinal axis of the helical structure, and terminating at a quantitative value for each parameter. Other sets of data corresponding to other complex entities are similarly represented on additional helical structures, and the helixes, or sections thereof, are superimposed on one another to determine the suitability of a match, with differences in values for each parameter being readily visible to an observer by looking at the differences in termination of the shaded regions.

Claims

1. A system for comparing a plurality of complex entities wherein a first set of data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters is used to characterize a first complex entity and one or more additional sets of data concerning said set of parameters is used to characterize one or more additional complex entities, said system comprising:

a separate helical structure for representing each of said complex entities, said helical structure being defined by an outer bounding cylinder, an inner bounding cylinder coaxial with said outer bounding cylinder and a pitch between complete revolutions of said helical structure;

each of said helical structures having adaptive means for receiving data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters used to characterize the complex entity which said helical structure represents,

said data concerning said set of parameters being superimposed upon said adaptive means,

said adaptive means comprising radially and sequentially disposed primary zones of substantially equal area and substantially similar shape within the helical structure, each of said primary zones being defined by

first and second sequential radial lines between said inner and outer bounding cylinders on said helical structure,

said inner and outer bounding cylinders, and

an included angle between said radial lines, and each of said primary zones being allocated for superimposition of a representation of data thereon and relating to a single one of said parameters used to characterize said complex entities.

2. The system of claim 1 wherein each of said primary zones further includes a series of secondary zones, each of said secondary zones being defined by a pair of segments of said first and second radial lines of said primary zone, a pair of lines extending between said segments, and said included angle between the radial lines of said primary zone.

3. The system of claim 2 in which said pair of segments of said first and second radial lines of said primary zone, and said lines extending therebetween further constitute scale means for quantitative representation of said data.

4. The system of claim 3, wherein said representation of said data includes superimposing discrete shaded areas upon said secondary zones, said shaded areas extending over a portion of said primary zones corresponding to a graphical representation of a numerical value associated with said related parameter.

5. The system of claim 4, wherein said shaded areas are of progressively increased hue and density with increased radial disposition of said secondary zones from said inner bounding cylinder of said helical structures, whereby said shaded areas provide means for visual comparison of said represented data relating to the parameter to which said primary zone relates.

6. The system of claim 2, wherein said lines partially defining said secondary zones are straight lines and said inner and outer bounding cylinders are polygonal having a number of sidewalls equal to a quantity of primary zones included in a single rotation of said helical structure, whereby said secondary zones of each primary zone form a series of substantially trapezoidal areas within said primary zone, progressively increasing in size with increasing distance from said inner bounding cylinder.

7. The system of claim 2, wherein said lines partially defining said secondary zones are curved lines, whereby said secondary zones of each primary zone form a series of substantially annular sectors, progressively increasing in size with increasing distance from said inner bounding cylinder.

8. The system of claims 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7, wherein said scale means is a linear scale means for quantitative representation of said data.

9. The system of claims 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7, wherein said scale means is a logarithmic scale means for quantitative representation of said data.

10. The system of claims 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9, wherein said scale means for each primary zone is defined in the same units as the parameter to which said primary zone relates.

11. The system of claim 5, wherein said discrete shaded areas of said representation of data are in the form of a grey scale.

12. The system of claim 5, wherein said discrete shaded areas of said representation of data are in the form of a color scale.

13. The system of claims 1 or 12, wherein parameters naturally associated are allocated to a group of adjacent said primary zones.

14. The system of claim 13, wherein said parameters within any said group are allocated related colors.

15. A system for comparing a plurality of complex entities wherein a first set of data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters is used to characterize a first complex entity and one or more additional sets of data concerning said set of parameters is used to characterize one or more additional complex entities, said system comprising:

a separate helical structure for representing each of said complex entities, said helical structure being defined by an outer bounding cylinder, an inner bounding cylinder coaxial with said outer bounding cylinder and a pitch between complete revolutions of said helical structure;

each of said helical structures having adaptive means for receiving data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters used to characterize the complex entity which said helical structure represents,

said data concerning said set of parameters being superimposed upon said adaptive means,

said adaptive means comprising radially and sequentially disposed primary zones of substantially equal area and substantially similar shape within the helical structure, each of said primary zones being defined by

first and second sequential radial lines between said inner and outer bounding cylinders on said helical structure, said first and second sequential radial lines each having an innermost end and an outermost end,

an inner segment connecting said innermost ends of said radial lines,

an outer segment connecting said outermost ends of said radial lines,

an included angle between said radial lines, and each of said primary zones being allocated for superimposition of a representation of data thereon and relating to a single one of said parameters used to characterize said complex entities.

16. The system of claim 15, wherein each of said inner segments partially defining said primary zones is coplanar with a sidewall of a polygon, said polygon being coaxial with said inner bounding cylinder and having a number of sidewalls equal to a quantity of primary zones included in one revolution of said helical structure.

17. The system of claim 15, wherein each of said inner segments partially defining said primary zones is coextensive with a sidewall of said inner bounding cylinder.

18. The system of claim 17, wherein each of said outer segments partially defining said primary zones is coextensive with a sidewall of said outer bounding cylinder.

19. The system of claim 15, wherein each of said first and second sequential radial lines of said primary zone further has a plurality of equidistantly-spaced points thereon, each of said points defining an endpoint of a secondary zone segment and each of said primary zones further including a series of secondary zones, each of said secondary zones being defined by a pair of segments of said first and second radial lines of said primary zone, a pair of said secondary zone segments extending between a pair of said endpoints along said first radial line and a corresponding pair of said endpoints along said second radial line, and said included angle between the radial lines of said primary zone.

20. The system of claim 19, in which said sequential radial lines, said equidistantly-spaced points, and said pairs of secondary zone segments constitute scale means for quantitative representation of said data.

21. The system of claim 20, said adaptive means further comprising means for indicating on each primary zone a maximum data value of the parameter to which the primary zone is related, said maximum data value corresponding to a quantitative measure of said parameter in said complex entity.

22. The system of claim 21, wherein said means for indicating a maximum data value comprises a data value segment extending between a pair of data points on said first and second sequential radial lines, said data points and said data value segment positioned on said scale means at a location corresponding to said quantitative measure of said parameter in said complex entity, whereby when said data value segment is between a pair of said secondary zone segments, a partial zone is created within a secondary zone.

23. The system of claim 22, wherein said representation of said data includes superimposing discrete shaded areas upon said secondary zones, said shaded areas extending over a portion of said primary zones corresponding to a graphical representation of said quantitative value of said related parameter, and terminating at said data value segment.

24. The system of claim 23, wherein said shaded areas are of progressively increased hue and density with increased radial disposition of said secondary zones from said inner bounding cylinder of said helical structures, whereby said shaded areas provide means for visual comparison of said represented data relating to the parameter to which said primary zone relates.

25. The system of claim 24, and further comprising electronic means for generating said helical structures in a virtual format on a computer screen.

26. The system of claim 25, wherein said electronic means includes means for manipulating said helical structures, said manipulating including one or more of the group of:

duplicating one or more of said helical structures;

adjusting the size of one or more of said helical structures;

adjusting the scale of one or more parameters of said helical structures;

adjusting the orientation of said helical structures for viewing different parts thereof;

separating sections of said helical structures, each of said sections being one of said complete revolutions of said helical structures, in order to compare one revolution of a helical structure corresponding to a first complex entity with a corresponding revolution of a second helical structure corresponding to a second complex entity;

superimposing a helical structure representing one complex entity onto a second helical structure representing another complex entity;

superimposing separate sections of a helical structure representing one complex entity onto corresponding sections of a second helical structure representing another complex entity, each of said sections being one of said complete revolutions of said helical structures;

and selectively hiding said sequential radial lines, said data value lines, and said secondary zone segments.

27. The system of claim 23, wherein one of said separate helical structures further comprises a tolerance zone in each of said primary zones, said tolerance zone being defined by:

a low tolerance limit segment connecting said first and second sequential radial lines of the separate helical structure, corresponding to a lowest allowable value for the corresponding parameter represented by said primary zone;

a high tolerance limit segment connecting said first and second sequential radial lines of the separate helical structure at a greater distance from said inner bounding cylinder than said low tolerance limit segment and corresponding to a highest allowable value for said parameter; and

a pair of segments of said first and second sequential radial lines extending between said low and high tolerance limit segments, whereby when said helical structure corresponding to a first complex entity is superimposed on said separate helical structure a user can observe whether said first complex entity satisfies a set of tolerances for all of the represented parameters by determining whether said discrete shaded areas of each of the primary zones of said helical structure corresponding to a first complex entity terminates within said tolerance zone of each primary zone of said separate helical structure.

28. The system of claims 15, and further comprising means for communicating one or more of said sets of data concerning said set of multiple diverse parameters between a plurality of locations.

29. The system of claim 28, wherein said communicating means comprises electronic communication means selected from a group including telephones, facsimile machines, computers provided with modems, and satellite communication.

30. The system of claim 15, wherein said solid helical structures are provided with a label area for each of said radially disposed primary zones.

31. The system of claim 15, wherein the number of primary zones in each of said revolution of said helical structures is in the range of 10 to 25.

32. The system of claim 15, wherein said outer bounding cylinder has a radius of about 75 mm.

33. The system of claim 32, wherein the ratio between said pitch of one of the helical structures and said radius of the outer bounding cylinder is about 0.67:

1.0.

34. A method for use by one or more parties for comparing a plurality of complex entities wherein a first set of data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters is used to characterize a first complex entity and one or more additional sets of data concerning said set of parameters is used to characterize one or more additional complex entities, comprising the steps of:

generating a separate helical structure representing each of said complex entities, each of said helical structures being defined by an outer bounding cylinder, an inner bounding cylinder coaxial with said outer bounding cylinder and a pitch between complete revolutions of said helical structure, each of said helical structures having adaptive means for receiving data concerning a set of multiple diverse parameters used to characterize the complex entity which said helical structure represents, said data concerning said set of parameters being superimposed upon said adaptive means, said adaptive means comprising radially and sequentially disposed primary zones of substantially equal area and substantially similar shape within the helical structure, each of said primary zones being defined by first and second sequential radial lines between said inner and outer bounding cylinders on said helical structure, said inner and outer bounding cylinders, and an included angle between said radial lines, and each of said primary zones being allocated for superimposition of a representation of data thereon and relating to a single one of said parameters used to characterize said complex entities and including a series of secondary zones within each primary zone, each of said secondary zones being defined by a pair of segments of said first and second radial lines of said primary zone, a pair of lines extending between said segments, and said included angle between the radial lines of said primary zone;

assigning a quantitative scale to each of said primary zones of the helical structures, with said lines partially defining said secondary zones constituting scale means of said quantitative scale; and

superimposing one or more discrete shaded entities upon said secondary zones of each primary zone, said shaded entities progressively increasing in hue and density with increased radial disposition of said secondary zone from the axis of said bounding cylinders of said helical structure and extending over a number of secondary zones in the associated primary zone to correspond to a quantitative representation of a measurement of a parameter in the complex entity represented by said helical structure.

35. The method of claim 34, further comprising the step of:

comparing said discrete shaded entities in each parameter of one of said helical structures with corresponding discrete shaded entities in each parameter of another of said helical structures representing a separate complex entity.

36. The method of claim 34, further comprising the steps of:

manipulating two of said helical structures by separating each of said structures into a plurality of sections, each of said sections defined by one complete revolution of one of said helical structures;

placing each of said sections in a substantially similar orientation relative to one another; and

comparing said discrete shaded entities in each parameter of said superimposed sections.

37. The method of claim 36, further comprising the step of comparing said sections in their entirety.

38. The method of claim 34, further comprising the steps of:

manipulating two of said helical structures by separating each of said structures into a plurality of sections, each of said sections defined by at least one of said primary zones and by no more than one complete revolution of one of said helical structures;

superimposing one of said sections of a first helical structure onto a corresponding section of a second helical structure; and

comparing said discrete shaded entities in each parameter of said super imposed sections.