Interactive configuration via network

• US 5,987,473 A
• Filed: 12/29/1997
• Issued: 11/16/1999
• Est. Priority Date: 09/09/1997
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Baan Development BV
• Original Assignee: Beologic A/S
• Inventors: Jorgensen, Nielss
• Primary Examiner(s): Amsbury, Wayne
• Assistant Examiner(s): HAVAN, THU THAO
• Application Number:
  US08/998,727
• Time in Patent Office: 687 Days
• Field of Search: 707/104, 707/7, 707/101, 707/10, 707/203, 707/102, 707/205, 707/6, 379/111, 379/34, 706/45, 706/60, 706/46, 706/52, 706/56, 706/47, 364/229, 364/221, 705/26, 345/329, 345/335, 345/333
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: G06N 5/04 Inference or reasoning models
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99936 Pattern matching access
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99945 Object-oriented database structure processing
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99948 Application of database or data structure, e.g. distributed, multimedia, or image

Abstract

There is provided a method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule base is processed, comprising the steps of: providing request information, resulting from a first client interaction; transferring said request information to the server; collecting intermediate information, resulting from at least one second client interaction succeeding said first client interaction; creating response information on the server responsive to said request information; transferring said response information to the client; determining whether said response information indicates conformity with said rule base; creating merged information responsive to said intermediate information and said response information; determining whether said intermediate information represents a higher level of knowledge than said response information; selecting at least one of the following actions according to said determinations: use said merged information to update said client or transmit said merged information as a request.

Claims

1. A method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule base is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a first client interaction;

transferring said request information to the server;

collecting intermediate information, resulting from at least one second client interaction succeeding said first client interaction;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response information to the client;

determining whether said response information indicates conformity with said rule base;

creating merged information responsive to said intermediate information and said response information;

determining whether said intermediate information represents a higher level of knowledge than said response information;

selecting at least one of the following actions according to said determinations;

use said merged information to update said client or transmit said merged information as a request.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein said request, response, and intermediate information comprise state information for at least one element.

3. The method according to claim 2, wherein said states comprise client states which may be changed as a result of a client interaction and server states which may be changed as a result of server processing.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein said states further comprise free states which may be changed by the client as well as the server and overruled by said client and server states.

5. The method according to claim 1, wherein said determination of whether said response information is in conformity with said rule base is performed by testing whether said response information comprises a contradiction indication.

6. The method according to claim 3, wherein said client states and said server states may comprise states which are mutually exclusive.

7. The method according to claim 3, wherein at least one of said client states is equivalent with at least one of said server states.

8. The method according to claim 3, wherein said client states comprise the states `selected` and `deselected`, and wherein said server states comprise the states `concluded` and `discarded`.

9. The method according to claim 7, wherein said `selected` and `concluded` states are equivalent and wherein said `deselected` and `rejected` states are equivalent.

10. The method according to claim 5, wherein a higher level of knowledge may be assumed at least if a free state in said response information is changed to a client state in said intermediate information.

11. The method according to claim 6, wherein a higher level of knowledge may be assumed at least if a contradiction indication is detected and if a client state for an element in said intermediate information excludes a client state for said element in said response information.

12. The method according to claim 9, wherein said further client interaction may be activated if there is contradiction in said response information.

13. The method according to claim 12, wherein said further client interaction may result in a solution to said contradiction, that is, change a state causing said contradiction to another client state.

14. The method according to claim 6, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is contradiction in said response information, and if a first client state in said response information for a given element excludes a second client state in said intermediate information for said given element.

15. The method according to claim 14, wherein said merged information is said intermediate information.

16. The method according to claim 9, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if said client states in said intermediate information are not equivalent to said states in said response information.

17. The method according to claim 8, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if a client state in said response information is changed to a free state in said intermediate information.

18. The method according to claim 8, wherein said client is updated with the merged information, and wherein said merged information is transmitted as a further request if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if a free state in said response information is changed to a client state in said intermediate information.

19. The method according to claim 9, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said client states in said intermediate information are equivalent to said response information.

20. The method according to claim 8, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information.

21. The method according to claim 8, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said server states in said intermediate information overrule said response information.

22. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said response information is equivalent to said intermediate information, then said merged state information may be set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

23. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information are not equivalent to said server states in said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

24. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said client states in said intermediate information overrule said response information, then said merged state information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

25. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information may be set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

26. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state information occur in said response information and said server state occur in said intermediate information, then said merged information may set to free state information in at least some occurrences.

27. The method according to claim 8, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state occurs in said response information and said client state occurs in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

28. The method according to claim 2, wherein said elements are merged individually, and wherein each element is associated with an action according to said set of rules.

29. The method according to claim 28, wherein said action is determined for a whole state vector as that action which maximizes client selections while fulfilling system/model constraints.

30. A method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule base is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a first client interaction;

transferring said request information to the server;

collecting intermediate information, resulting from a second client interaction succeeding said first client activation;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response information to the client;

said request, response, and intermediate information may comprise at least two types of information;

client states which are provided as a result of a client interaction and server states which are provided as a result of server calculations;

creating merged information responsive to said intermediate information and said response information;

determining an action according to a set of rules, at least comprising the following rules;

if said response information does not contain contradictions, then the client is updated with the merged information for at least some occurrences of request and response information;

if said response Information does not contain contradictions and said response information is not equivalent to said client states in said intermediate information, then the client generates a new server request;

if said response information contains contradictions, then a client interaction is requested for at least some combinations of said intermediate and said response information.

31. The method according to claim 30, wherein said state information is contained in a state vector with a number of elements and wherein each element has a state representation.

32. The method according to claim 31, wherein said elements in said request information are determined as the elements involved in said first client interaction.

33. The method according to claim 31, wherein said elements in said intermediate information are determined as the union of elements comprised by all intermediate information collected after transmission of said request information and before receiving said response information.

34. The method according to claim 31, wherein said elements in said response state vector are determined as the union of elements involved in said first client interaction and the elements which are included in said result of server calculations.

35. The method according to claim 30, wherein at least some combinations of response and request information are impossible.

36. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information contains a contradiction and said client states in said response information are different from said client states in said intermediate information, then said contradiction is possibly resolved and said intermediate information is transmitted as request information.

37. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information contains a contradiction and said client states occur in said response information and said free states occurs in said intermediate information, then said intermediate state information is transmitted as a server request.

38. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain contradictions and said response information in at least one occurrence contains free state information, then the merged information is further transmitted as a server request for at least one state outcome of said response information.

39. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information do not contain any contradictions and said client states occur in said response information and said free states occur in said intermediate information, then said intermediate state information is transmitted as a server request.

40. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain any contradictions and said free state information occurs in said response information and said client state information occurs in said intermediate information, then the merged information is further transmitted as a server request.

41. The method according to claim 30, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain any contradictions and said client or server states in said response information are not equivalent to said client states in said intermediate state information, then said merged state information is transmitted as a server request.

42. The method according to claim 31, wherein said server states and said client states overrule said free state information in said merging process.

43. The method according to claim 31, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said response information is equivalent to said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

44. The method according to claim 31, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information are not equivalent to said server states in said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

45. The method according to claim 42, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said client states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

46. The method according to claim 42, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

47. The method according to claim 31, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state information occur in said response information and said server state occur in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set to free state information in at least some occurrences.

48. The method according to claim 31, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state occurs in said response information and said client state occurs in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

49. The method according to claim 31, wherein said elements are merged individually, and wherein each element is associated with an action according to said set of rules.

50. The method according to claim 49, wherein said action is determined for a whole state vector as that action which maximizes client selections while fulfilling system/model constraints.

51. A method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a client interaction;

transferring said request information to a server;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response state information to the client;

creating merged information responsive to said request information and said response information;

determining an action according to a strategy, comprising the following strategy;

if said response information does not contain contradictions, then the client is updated with the merged information for at least some combinations of request and response information;

if said response information contains contradictions, then a client interaction is requested for at least some combinations of request and response information.

52. A computer readable medium encoded with a program for performing a method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule base is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a first client interaction;

transferring said request information to the server;

collecting intermediate information, resulting from at least one second client interaction succeeding said first client interaction;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response information to the client;

determining whether said response information indicates conformity with said rule base;

creating merged information responsive to said intermediate information and said response information;

determining whether said intermediate information represents a higher level of knowledge than said response information;

selecting at least one of the following actions according to said determinations;

use said merged information to update said client or transmit said merged information as a request.

53. The medium according to claim 52, wherein said request, response, and intermediate information comprise state information for at least one element.

54. The medium according to claim 53, wherein said states comprise client states which may be changed as a result of a client interaction and server states which may be changed as a result of server processing.

55. The medium according to claim 54, wherein said states further comprise free states which may be changed by the client as well as the server and overruled by said client and server states.

56. The medium according to claim 52, wherein said determination of whether said response information is in conformity with said rule base is performed by testing whether said response information comprises a contradiction indication.

57. The medium according to claim 54, wherein said client states and said server states may comprise states which are mutually exclusive.

58. The medium according to claim 54, wherein at least one of said client states is equivalent with at least one of said server states.

59. The medium according to claim 54, wherein said client states comprise the states `selected` and `deselected`, and wherein said server states comprise the states `concluded` and `discarded`.

60. The medium according to claim 58, wherein said `selected` and `concluded` states are equivalent and wherein said `deselected` and `rejected` states are equivalent.

61. The medium according to claim 56, wherein a higher level of knowledge may be assumed at least if a free state in said response information is changed to a client state in said intermediate information.

62. The medium according to claim 57, wherein a higher level of knowledge may be assumed at least if a contradiction indication is detected and if a client state for an element in said intermediate information excludes a client state for said element in said response information.

63. The medium according to claim 60, wherein said further client interaction may be activated if there is contradiction in said response information.

64. The medium according to claim 63, wherein said further client interaction may result in a solution to said contradiction, that is, change a state causing said contradiction to another client state.

65. The medium according to claim 57, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is contradiction in said response information, and if a first client state in said response information for a given element excludes a second client state in said intermediate information for said given element.

66. The medium according to claim 55, wherein said merged information is said intermediate information.

67. The medium according to claim 60, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if said client states in said intermediate information are not equivalent to said states in said response information.

68. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said transmission of said merged information as a further request may be activated if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if a client state in said response information is changed to a free state in said intermediate information.

69. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said client is updated with the merged information, and wherein said merged information is transmitted as a further request if there is no contradiction in said response information, and if a free state in said response information is changed to a client state in said intermediate information.

70. The medium according to claim 60, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said client states in said intermediate information are equivalent to said response information.

71. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information.

72. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said client may be updated with the merged information, and wherein the merged information is not transmitted as a request if said server states in said intermediate information overrule said response information.

73. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said response information is equivalent to said intermediate information, then said merged state information may be set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

74. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information are not equivalent to said server states in said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

75. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said client states in said intermediate information overrule said response information, then said merged state information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

76. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information may be set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

77. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state information occur in said response information and said server state occur in said intermediate information, then said merged information may set to free state information in at least some occurrences.

78. The medium according to claim 59, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state occurs in said response information and said client state occurs in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

79. The medium according to claim 53, wherein said elements are merged individually, and wherein each element is associated with an action according to said set of rules.

80. The medium according to claim 79, wherein said action is determined for a whole state vector as that action which maximizes client selections while fulfilling system/model constraints.

81. A computer readable medium encoded with a program for performing a method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule base is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a first client interaction;

transferring said request information to the server;

collecting intermediate information, resulting from a second client interaction succeeding said first client activation;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response information to the client;

said request, response, and intermediate information may comprise at least two types of information;

client states which are provided as a result of a client interaction and server states which are provided as a result of server calculations;

creating merged information responsive to said intermediate information and said response information;

determining an action according to a set of rules, at least comprising the following rules;

if said response information does not contain contradictions, then the client is updated with the merged information for at least some occurrences of request and response information;

if said response information does not contain contradictions and said response information is not equivalent to said client states in said intermediate information, then the client generates a new server request;

if said response information contains contradictions, then a client interaction is requested for at least some combinations of said intermediate and said response information.

82. The medium according to claim 81, wherein said state information is contained in a state vector with a number of elements and wherein each element has a state representation.

83. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said elements in said request information are determined as the elements involved in said first client interaction.

84. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said elements in said intermediate information are determined as the union of elements comprised by all intermediate information collected after transmission of said request information and before receiving said response information.

85. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said elements in said response state vector are determined as the union of elements involved in said first client interaction and the elements which are included in said result of server calculations.

86. The medium according to claim 81, wherein at least some combinations of response and request information are impossible.

87. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information contains a contradiction and said client states in said response information are different from said client states in said intermediate information, then said contradiction is possibly resolved and said intermediate information is transmitted as request information.

88. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information contains a contradiction and said client states occur in said response information and said free states occurs in said intermediate information, then said intermediate state information is transmitted as a server request.

89. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain contradictions and said response information in at least one occurrence contains free state information, then the merged information is further transmitted as a server request for at least one state outcome of said response information.

90. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information do not contain any contradictions and said client states occur in said response information and said free states occur in said intermediate information, then said intermediate state information is transmitted as a server request.

91. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain any contradictions and said free state information occurs in said response information and said client state information occurs in said intermediate information, then the merged information is further transmitted as a server request.

92. The medium according to claim 81, wherein the set of rules further comprises the following rule:

if said response information does not contain any contradictions and said client or server states in said response information are not equivalent to said client states in said intermediate state information, then said merged state information is transmitted as a server request.

93. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said server states and said client states overrule said free state information in said merging process.

94. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said response information is equivalent to said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

95. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information are not equivalent to said server states in said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

96. The medium according to claim 93, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said client states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

97. The medium according to claim 93, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said server states in said response information overrule said intermediate information, then said merged state information is set similar to said response state information in at least some occurrences.

98. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state information occur in said response information and said server state occur in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set to free state information in at least some occurrences.

99. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said merged state information is created according to the following rule:

if said free state occurs in said response information and said client state occurs in said intermediate information, then said merged information is set similar to said intermediate state information in at least some occurrences.

100. The medium according to claim 82, wherein said elements are merged individually, and wherein each element is associated with an action according to said set of rules.

101. The medium according to claim 100, wherein said action is determined for a whole state vector as that action which maximizes client selections while fulfilling system/model constraints.

102. A computer readable medium encoded with a program for performing a method of controlling the flow of information in a client/server system for interactive configuration, wherein a request to a rule is processed, comprising the steps of:

providing request information, resulting from a client interaction;

transferring said request information to a server;

creating response information on the server responsive to said request information;

transferring said response state information to the client;

creating merged information responsive to said request information and said response information;

determining an action according to a strategy, comprising the following strategy;

if said response information does not contain contradictions, then the client is updated with the merged information for at least some combinations of request and response information;

if said response information contains contradictions, then a client interaction is requested for at least some combinations of request and response information.