System and method for interactive scoring of standardized test responses

• US 6,120,299 A
• Filed: 06/06/1997
• Issued: 09/19/2000
• Est. Priority Date: 06/06/1997
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Educational Testing Service
• Original Assignee: Educational Testing Service
• Inventors: Zuckerman, Daniel Israel, Trenholm, Harriet Priscilla
• Primary Examiner(s): Martin-Wallace, Valencia
• Assistant Examiner(s): FLEMING, DAVID
• Application Number:
  US08/870,182
• Time in Patent Office: 1,201 Days
• Field of Search: 434/323, 434/322, 434/118, 434/324, 434/325, 434/326, 434/327, 434/346, 434/347, 434/348, 434/349, 434/350, 434/351, 434/353, 434/358, 434/359
• US Class Current: 434/323
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/04 characterised by modifying the teaching programme in response to a wrong answer, e.g. repeating the question, supplying a further explanation
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/066 with answer indicating cards, blocks

Abstract

A system and associated method for interactively scoring standardized test responses. The system maintains a database of tests, items that make up the tests, and features that make up the items. A user of the system requests a list of items in the database, and the system responds by presenting a list from which the user selects a plurality of items to be scored. The user selects a scoring mode, and the system scores the selected items according to the selected scoring mode. In an interactive scoring mode, the system scores the features of a selected item and presents to the user the feature scores, as well as an overall item score computed based on these feature scores. The user either accepts the scores as presented, changes one or more feature scores, or changes the overall item score. The system then rescores the item based on the user-entered scores and stores the new score in the database. This process is repeated for the remaining selected items. The user can interrupt one scoring mode and change to another at any time.

Claims

1. A method of scoring examinees'"'"' responses to standardized tests, each test having at least one item and each item having at least one feature, the scoring being performed by a computer that uses preexisting scoring engines that execute predefined scoring rubrics where each scoring rubric is associated with a particular item, said tests, items, and features, being stored in a database, the method comprising the steps of:

the user selecting from a list of predefined items displayed by the computer a number of items to be scored;

said computer generating a list of said selected items in said database; and

scoring each said selected item in said list of selected items, said scoring step comprising the steps of;

(a) said computer generating an item score for a first selected item in said list of selected items using a scoring rubric associated with said first selected item, storing said item score in said database for said first selected item, and displaying said item score for review by the user,

(b) the user determining whether said item score for said first selected item is valid,

(c) if the user determines that said item score for said first selected item is invalid, the user changing the score for said first item,

(d) if the user has changed the item score for said first selected item, said computer storing in said database the item score entered by the user for said first selected item, and

(e) said computer determining whether any selected items remain unscored, and if any selected items remain unscored, said computer repeating steps (a)-(d) to score a second selected item in said list of selected items.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the scoring step comprises the steps of:

said computer generating a feature score for each feature of said selected item using a scoring rubric associated with said selected item, storing said feature scores in said database for each said feature of said selected item, and displaying said feature scores for review by the user;

the user determining whether each said feature score for said selected item is valid;

if the user determines that one or more said features scores are invalid, the user changing said invalid feature scores for said selected item;

if the user has changed one or more feature scores for said selected item, said computer storing in said database the feature scores entered by the user for each said feature of said selected item; and

said computer rescoring said selected item using the feature scores entered by the user for said selected item.

3. The method of claim 1, comprising the additional step of:

said computer scoring a test based on weighted item scores of the items that make up said test, according to a predefined weighting formula, said weighting formula being stored in said database for said test.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein the selecting step comprises the step of the user selecting said number of items to be scored in one of a plurality of selection modes, including:

a first mode wherein the user selects items individually,

a second mode wherein the user selects items by test, and

a third mode wherein the user selects items by examinee.

5. The method of claim 1, wherein the scoring step comprises the additional steps of:

the user determining whether the scoring rubric for said selected item is valid;

if the user determines that said scoring rubric for said selected item is invalid, the user changing the scoring rubric for said selected item; and

if the user has changed said scoring rubric for said selected item, said computer using said changed scoring rubric for said selected item to rescore said selected item.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein the scoring step comprises the step of the user selecting from among a plurality of scoring modes, including:

a first scoring mode in which the user and said computer interactively score said selected items one at a time;

a second scoring mode in which said computer continuously scores said selected items;

a third scoring mode in which said computer continuously scores said selected items and, if an alarm condition is identified, stops continuously scoring said selected items and notifies the user of said alarm condition; and

a fourth scoring mode in which said computer continuously scores said selected items, samples the number of selected items to be scored to create a subset, and displays the scores for said subset of selected items to the user.

7. The method of claim 6, wherein the scoring step comprises the additional steps of:

the user commanding the computer to stop scoring selected items;

the computer ceasing to score selected items, terminating the scoring mode previously selected by the user, and presenting the user with the option of selecting from among a plurality of scoring modes; and

the user selecting one of the plurality of scoring modes.

8. A system for scoring responses to standardized tests, each test having at least one item, and each item having at least one feature, the system interfacing with a preexisting database and a number of preexisting scoring engines, the system comprising:

an operator workstation which accepts input from a user for processing, accepts processed output, and presents said processed output to the user;

an item selection subsystem coupled to said operator workstation and said database which creates a list of items selected by the user to be scored by accepting retrieve commands from said user via said operator workstation, retrieving predetermined items identified in said retrieve commands and stored in said database, delivering said predetermined items to the user via said operator workstation, accepting from the user via said operator workstation a list of items selected by the user, and storing a list of said selected items in said database; and

an interactive scoring subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said scoring engines, and said database, which scores the respective selected items by;

(a) retrieving a first selected item from said database, (b) calling a scoring engine to score said first selected item, (c) storing an item score for said first selected item in the database, (d) delivering said item score for said first selected item to the operator workstation for display to the user, (e) if the user changes the item score for said first selected item, accepting said changed item score from the user via said operator workstation for said first selected item and storing said changed item score in said database for said first selected item, and (f) determining whether any items in said list of selected items remain unscored, and if any unscored items remain in said list of selected items, said interactive scoring subsystem scoring a second selected item by repeating steps (a)-(e) for said second selected item.

9. The system of claim 8, wherein the system further interfaces with a number of preexisting rescoring engines and wherein the interactive scoring subsystem is further coupled to said rescoring engines for rescoring a selected item by retrieving said selected item from said database, calling a scoring engine to score the features of said selected item, storing a feature score for each said feature and an item score for each said selected item in the database, delivering said feature scores and said item score to the operator workstation for display to the user, and, if the user determines one or more said feature scores to be invalid, accepting a changed feature score from the user via said operator workstation, updating the feature score for said feature in the database to said changed feature score, calling a rescoring engine to recompute the item score of said selected item, and storing said recomputed item score in said database.

10. The system of claim 8, wherein the item selection subsystem delivers said predetermined items to said operator workstation sorted one of three ways, by item, by test, or by examinee, and creates said item list in one of three modes, a first mode in which said item selection subsystem creates a list of individual items selected by the user, a second mode in which said item selection subsystem creates a list of items making up tests selected by the user, and a third mode in which said item selection subsystem creates a list of items allocated to examinees selected by the user.

11. The system of claim 8 further comprising:

a continuous scoring subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said scoring engines, and said database, for scoring the respective selected items by retrieving each said selected item from said database, calling a scoring engine to score each said selected item, and storing an item score for each said selected item in the database; and

a scoring mode selection subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said interactive scoring subsystem, and said continuous scoring subsystem for presenting to the user via said operator workstation a choice of scoring modes, one such scoring mode corresponding to each said scoring subsystem, accepting from the user via said operator workstation a scoring mode selected by the user, commanding the scoring subsystem corresponding to said user selected scoring mode to begin scoring said selected items, and commanding said selected scoring subsystem to stop scoring said selected items in response to an interrupt from the user.

12. The system of claim 8 further comprising:

an alarm scoring subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said scoring engines, and said database, for scoring the respective selected items by retrieving each said selected item from said database, calling a scoring engine to score each said selected item, storing an item score in said database for each said selected item, determining whether said item score is valid, and, if said item score is determined to be invalid, communicating an alarm to the user; and

a scoring mode selection subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said interactive scoring subsystem, and said alarm scoring subsystem for presenting to the user via said operator workstation a choice of scoring modes, one such scoring mode corresponding to each said scoring subsystem, accepting from the user via said operator workstation a scoring mode selected by the user, commanding the scoring subsystem corresponding to said user selected scoring mode to begin scoring said selected items, and commanding said selected scoring subsystem to stop scoring said selected items in response to an interrupt from the user.

13. The system of claim 8 further comprising:

a sampling scoring subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said scoring engines, and said database, for scoring the respective selected items by retrieving each said selected item from said database, calling a scoring engine to score each said selected item, storing an item score for each said selected item in the database, and, for a subset of said selected items, delivering said item score to said operator workstation for display to the user, said subset being determined by a predefined item sampling period; and

a scoring mode selection subsystem coupled to said operator workstation, said interactive scoring subsystem, and said sampling scoring subsystem for presenting to the user via said operator workstation a choice of scoring modes, one such scoring mode corresponding to each said scoring subsystem, accepting from the user via said operator workstation a scoring mode selected by the user, commanding the scoring subsystem corresponding to said user selected scoring mode to begin scoring said selected items, and commanding said selected scoring subsystem to stop scoring said selected items in response to an interrupt from the user.

14. The system of claim 13 wherein said subset of selected items consists of every n-th item of said selected items, where n is an integer.

15. The system of claim 8 wherein the operator workstation is coupled to said scoring engines for changing the predefined scoring rubrics executed by said scoring engines by accepting one or more changes to one or more said scoring rubrics from the user at said operator workstation, transmitting said changes from said operator workstation to said scoring engines, and modifying said scoring engine to execute said changed scoring rubric.

16. A system using predefined scoring rubrics to score examinees'"'"' responses to standardized tests, each test having at least one item and each item having at least one feature, the system interfacing with said database and a number of preexisting scoring engines, the system comprising:

means for selecting a number of predefined items from said existing database;

means for scoring a first selected item using said preexisting scoring engines employing predefined scoring rubrics associated with said first selected item;

means for determining whether the item score for said first selected item is valid; and

means for interactively changing the item score for said first selected item if said item score is determined to be invalid and updating said database to include an updated item score for said first selected item without rescoring an entire test containing said first selected item.

17. The system of claim 16, further comprising:

means for scoring a second selected item using said preexisting scoring engines employing predefined scoring rubrics associated with said second selected item;

means for determining whether the item score for said second selected item is valid; and

means for interactively changing the item score for said second selected item if said item score is determined to be invalid and updating said database to include an updated item score for said second selected item without rescoring an entire test containing said second selected item.

18. The system of claim 16, further comprising:

means for scoring a test based on the weighted item scores of the items associated with said test, according to a predefined weighting formula, said weighting formula being stored in said database for said test.

19. The system of claim 16, wherein said selecting means comprises means for selecting said number of predefined items in one of three modes, a first mode wherein items are selected individually, a second mode wherein items are selected by test, and a third mode wherein items are selected by examinee.

20. The system of claim 16, further comprising means for changing the predefined scoring rubric executed by said scoring engine and for modifying said scoring engine to execute said changed scoring rubric.

21. The system of claim 16, further comprising means for selecting from among a plurality of scoring modes:

a first scoring mode wherein a computer scores a first selected item, solicits input from a user regarding the validity of the item score assigned by said computer, and accepts user entered changes to said item score, before the computer scores the next selected item;

a second scoring mode wherein the computer scores items continuously;

a third scoring mode in which said computer continuously scores said selected items and, if an alarm condition is identified, stops continuously scoring said selected items and notifies the user of said alarm condition; and

a fourth scoring mode in which said computer continuously scores said selected items, samples the number of selected items to be scored to create a subset, and displays the scores for said subset of selected items to the user.

22. The system of claim 21, further comprising means responsive to the user for interrupting one scoring mode and changing to another scoring mode.

23. The system of claim 16, further comprising:

means for scoring the features of a selected item and assigning feature scores to said features;

means for changing one or more of said assigned feature scores; and

means for rescoring said selected item using said changed feature scores.