Method for predicting tire performance on rain groove roadways

• US 6,155,110 A
• Filed: 04/24/1997
• Issued: 12/05/2000
• Est. Priority Date: 04/24/1997
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Bridgestone Firestone North American Tire LLC (Bridgestone Corporation)
• Original Assignee: Bridgestone Firestone North American Tire LLC (Bridgestone Corporation)
• Inventors: Clothiaux, John D., Lightner, John G., Schlabaugh, Larry L., Neimes, Karl J., Yurjevich, Martin A., Christy, David C.
• Primary Examiner(s): DOMBROSKE, GEORGE M
• Application Number:
  US08/847,449
• Time in Patent Office: 1,321 Days
• Field of Search: 73/8, 73/117, 73/146, 73/146.2, 73/146.3, 73/146.4, 73/146.5
• US Class Current: 73/146
• CPC Class Codes: G01M 17/022 the tyre co-operating with rotatable rolls

Abstract

A method of testing a tire for rain groove wander is provided which allows a tire to be objectively tested in a laboratory wherein the objective test results closely correlate with subjective field analysis type data, thereby allowing for the subjective tire performance to be predicted while precluding the need for subjective field analysis of the particular tire. The method also allows objective testing of a single tire size by varying the radial loading in the laboratory test set, thereby precluding the construction of multiple tire sizes each having the same tread design. The method simulates rain groove road conditions and correlates objective analysis data obtained via the laboratory test methodology with subjective field analysis data of rain groove wander tire performance of other tires, thereby providing a substantially accurate technique for identifying the subjective performance of the tire without having to conduct the field testing to obtain such subjective field analysis data. The method substantially reduces the cost required is to design and test a prototype tire design and the time required to implement tire design testing.

Claims

1. A method of testing a tire for rain groove wander, comprising the steps of:

simulating rain groove road conditions on calibrated equipment;

measuring one or more forces acting on the tire which is operating in the simulated road conditions;

identifying a correlation between the measured forces and subjective tire performance data collected from a field testing of one or more other tires; and

predicting a subjective tire performance of the tire based on the correlation, thereby effectively gauging the subjective performance of the tire on rain groove roadways without having to perform field testing.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of simulating the rain groove road conditions comprises the steps of:

placing the tire in rotatable contact with a grooved surface; and

moving the grooved surface such that the tire rotates and remains in contact with the grooved surface, thereby simulating the tire traveling on a rain groove roadway.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein the grooved surface is a cylindrical drum having a grooved circumferential surface and wherein the step of moving the grooved surface comprises rotating the drum.

4. The method of claim 2, further comprising the step of applying a variable radial loading on the tire, thereby simulating the tire performance when used by various vehicle types.

5. The method of claim 2, further comprising the step of translating the tire axially across the moving grooved surface, thereby simulating a lateral vehicle movement on the rain groove roadway.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of measuring the one or more forces acting on the tire comprises measuring a lateral force.

7. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of identifying a correlation comprises processing data corresponding to the one or more measured forces to place the processed data in a format so that the formatted data correlates substantially closely with the subjective tire performance.

20. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of identifying a correlation comprises calculating a peak-to-peak force difference for use in correlating the measured forces to the subjective tire performance data.

21. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of identifying a correlation comprises extracting Fourier coefficients for use in correlating the measured forces to the subjective tire performance data.

8. A method of testing a tire for rain groove wander, comprising the steps of:

simulating rain groove road conditions;

measuring one or more forces acting on the tire which is operating in the simulated road conditions;

identifying a correlation between the measured forces and subjective tire performance data collected from a field testing of one or more other tires; and

predicting a subjective tire performance of the tire based on the correlation, thereby effectively gauging the subjective performance of the tire on rain groove roadways without having to perform field testing;

wherein the step of identifying a correlation comprises processing data corresponding to the one or more measured forces to place the processed data in a format so that the formatted data correlates substantially closely with the subjective tire performance;

wherein the step of processing the data comprises the steps of;

time filtering the data, wherein the data within each of a plurality of prescribed time periods are averaged;

compressing the data such that each piece of data associated with a lateral position of the tire with respect to a groove on the grooved surface is graphically overlaid;

normalizing the compressed data with respect to a mean lateral force across the grooved surface; and

calculating a peak-to-peak force difference of the normalized data for use in correlating the measured forces to the subjective tire performance data.

9. A method of testing a tire for rain groove wander, comprising the steps of:

simulating rain groove road conditions;

measuring one or more forces acting on the tire which is operating in the simulated road conditions;

identifying a correlation between the measured forces and subjective tire performance data collected from a field testing of one or more other tires; and

predicting a subjective tire performance of the tire based on the correlation, thereby effectively gauging the subjective performance of the tire on rain groove roadways without having to perform field testing;

wherein the step of identifying a correlation comprises processing data corresponding to the one or more measured forces to place the processed data in a format so that the formatted data correlates substantially closely with the subjective tire performance;

wherein the step of processing the data comprises the steps of;

time filtering the data, wherein the data within each of a plurality of time periods are averaged;

compressing the data such that each piece of data associated with a lateral position of the tire with respect to a groove on a grooved surface is graphically overlaid;

normalizing the compressed data with respect to a mean lateral force across the grooved surface;

extracting a predetermined number of Fourier coefficients from the normalized compressed data; and

summing the squares of the predetermined number of Fourier coefficients for use in correlating the measured forces to the subjective tire performance data.

10. A method for correlating a subjective analysis of rain groove wander for tires to an objective analysis technique that does not require vehicle testing, comprising the steps of:

collecting subjective field measurements of rain groove wander for a particular tire;

collecting objective field measurements of forces acting on the tire concurrently with the collecting of the subjective field measurements;

correlating the subjective and objective field measurements;

objective lab measurements of forces acting on the tire under simulated driving conditions; and

identifying a correlation between the objective field measurements and the objective lab measurements, thereby effectively correlating the objective lab measurements to the subjective field measurements.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein the step of collecting subjective field measurements comprises the steps of:

driving a vehicle having a set of tires for evaluation on a rain groove roadway; and

providing a subjective rating during the driving, wherein the subjective rating reflects a composite handling and rideability characteristic of the vehicle sensed by a driver on the rain groove roadway.

12. The method of claim 10, wherein the step of collecting objective field measurements comprises the steps of:

driving a vehicle having a set of tires for evaluation on a rain groove roadway; and

measuring one or more forces exerted by the rain groove roadway on the tires.

13. The method of claim 10, wherein the step of collecting objective lab measurements of forces acting on the tire under simulated driving conditions comprises the steps of:

simulating rain groove road conditions; and

measuring one or more forces acting on a tire which is operating in the simulated road conditions.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein the step of simulating the rain groove road conditions comprises the steps of:

placing the tire in rotatable contact with a grooved surface; and

moving the grooved surface such that the tire rotates and remains in contact with the grooved surface, thereby simulating the tire traveling on a rain groove roadway.

15. The method of claim 14, wherein the grooved surface is a cylindrical drum having a grooved circumferential surface and wherein the step of moving the grooved surface comprises rotating the drum.

16. The method of claim 14, further comprising the step of applying a variable radial loading on the tire, thereby simulating the tire performance when used by various vehicle types.

17. The method of claim 14, further comprising the step of translating the tire axially across the moving grooved surface, thereby simulating a lateral vehicle movement on the rain groove roadway.

18. The method of claim 10, wherein the objective lab measurements comprise data and wherein identifying a correlation between the objective field measurements and the objective lab measurements further comprises processing the data to place the processed data in a format that correlates substantially closely with the objective field measurements.

19. A method of selecting a desired tire based on a subjective rain groove roadway characteristic without performing subjective tire evaluations, comprising the steps of:

selecting a desired subjective rain groove roadway tire performance;

identifying an objective force value that correlates with the desired subjective rain groove roadway tire performance;

identifying a required simulated force characteristic based on the identified objective force;

simulating one or more tires; and

selecting a tire that meets the required simulated force characteristic, thereby selecting a tire having the desired subjective rain groove roadway performance.