Interactive instructional system using adaptive cognitive profiling

• US 6,164,975 A
• Filed: 12/11/1998
• Issued: 12/26/2000
• Est. Priority Date: 12/11/1998
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Marshall Weingarden
• Original Assignee: Marshall Weingarden
• Inventors: Griffor, Edward Ronald, Weingarden, Marshall
• Primary Examiner(s): Martin-Wallace, Valencia
• Assistant Examiner(s): Rovnak, John Edmund
• Application Number:
  US09/210,483
• Time in Patent Office: 746 Days
• Field of Search: 434/118, 434/236, 434/307 R, 434/322, 434/323, 434/353, 434/354, 434/362
• US Class Current: 434/322
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/04 characterised by modifying the teaching programme in response to a wrong answer, e.g. repeating the question, supplying a further explanation

Abstract

An interactive instructional system realizing an eventstream based educational methodology and enabling an interactive, adaptive learning environment. Continuously tracking and evaluating learner interaction, the system creates and updates a profile of the learner'"'"'s cognitive style and achievement level. Using this cognitive profile, the system adapts its presentations to the learner'"'"'s cognitive style and demonstrated ability. Presentations take the form of eventstreams, which are branching sequences of multimedia objects called events. Some of the events contain substantially similar content presented in differing ways so that, using the learner'"'"'s cognitive profile, the system can select the event that results in the greatest comprehension of the presented material. This selection is accomplished using a utility function that is based on the cognitive profile and that provides a measure of the teaching utility of each of the different cognitive styles. The system can adapt to the learner by updating the utility function through the use of preference relations which are determined through testing and that indicate that of the cognitive styles results in the greatest comprehension by the learner of the content contained within the presentations. The system includes an eventstream development environment which allows the content developer to use accessible libraries of events to create new eventstreams. The eventstreams are structured to follow the paradigm of observed history so that each topic can be presented in the historical context in which it developed.

Claims

1. A method of computerer-based learning, comprising the steps of:

providing a plurality of related event objects, each of which includes different content that is topically related to the content of the other of said event objects, and each of which has one or more attributes including at least an audio, textual, or visual component that can be presented via a computer workstation;

providing a number of additional event objects, each of which includes content that is substantially the same as the content of a corresponding one of the related event objects, and each of which provides a presentation of content that is different than the presentation provided by the corresponding related event object;

wherein each of said event objects has an associated cognitive index that includes data representing the attributes utilized in the presentation provided by the event object;

generating a cognitive profile for a learner using a plurality of parameters, at least some of which are each associated with one or more of the attributes and are each indicative of a cognitive utility of its associated attributes(s) for the learner;

creating an eventsream having the structure of a branching sequence of nodes, each of the nodes representing one of the related event objects and any of the additional event objects corresponding to that related event object; and

presenting a number of the event objects to the learner starting with an event object located at a first one of the nodes, and, for any node having two or more event objects, selecting at least one of the event objects for presentation to the learner from among all of the event objects at the node using the learner'"'"'s cognitive profile and the event objects'"'"' cognitive indices.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein said step of creating the eventstream comprises creating a script that identifies the event objects within the eventstream and that defines the branching sequence of event objects.

3. The method of claim 1, wherein different event objects having substantially the same content have differing emphases on the audio, textual, and visual components used in their presentations.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein the data used in the cognitive index of each event object comprises quantitative data that provides a weighted measure of the attributes of the event object and wherein at least some of the parameters of the cognitive profile that are associated with one or more of the attributes comprise numeric values indicative of the degree of cognitive utility of its associated attribute(s) for learner.

5. A method of computer-based learning, comprising the steps of:

providing a plurality of computer-based presentations, wherein some presentations provide different topically-related educational content and other presentations utilize different cognitive styles to present substantially similar content, and wherein the other presentations that utilize different cognitive styles each has a cognitive index associated therewith that includes quantitative data representative of attributes utilized in the presentation with the quantitative data each indicating the extent to which its associated attribute is present in the presentation;

providing a cognitive profile for a learner, with the cognitive profile comprising a set of parameters, each of which can be associated with at least one of the attributes and has a numeric value indicative of the cognitive utility of its associated attribute(s) for the learner;

selecting at least one of the other presentations using a mathematical function that, using the leaner'"'"'s cognitive profile and at least some of the other presentations'"'"' cognitive indices, determines which of those other presentations best matches the cognitive style of the learner; and

providing the learner with an ordered sequence of the presentations that includes the selected presentations.

6. The method of claim 5, further comprising the steps of:

providing a utility function that utilizes the learner'"'"'s cognitive profile and that provides a measure of the teaching utility of each of the cognitive styles;

testing the learner to determine which of the cognitive styles results in the greatest comprehension by the learner of content contained within a presentation;

determining one or more preference relations between cognitive styles based upon the testing; and

updating the utility function based upon the determined preference relations; and

wherein said selecting step further comprises selecting presentations to be presented to the learner using the utility function and the cognitive index associated with the presentations.

7. The method of claim 6, wherein the utility function represents the mathematical function used in selecting presentations and wherein said step of selecting at least one of the other presentations further comprises selecting the one of those presentations whose cognitive index maximizes the utility function.

8. The method of claim 6, further comprising the step of iteratively repeating said testing, determining, updating, and selecting steps to thereby adapt the presentation of content and increase the comprehension of the learner.

9. The method of claim 5, wherein the step of providing a cognitive profile further comprises testing the learner using presentations having different cognitive styles and determining the cognitive profile using the cognitive index associated with the cognitive style that resulted in the greatest comprehension by the learner of the content presented during testing, and wherein the method further comprises the step of aggregating information about a large number of learners'"'"' cognitive profiles.

10. The method of claim 9, further comprising the step of developing new presentations having a cognitive style that is selected based upon the aggregate information.

11. A method of presenting information to a user on a computer workstation, comprising the steps of:

providing a plurality of computer-displayable presentations, some of which provide different topically-related content and others of which utilize different cognitive styles to present substantially similar content, and wherein the other presentations that utilize different cognitive styles each has a cognitive index associated therewith that includes quantitative data representative of attributes utilized in the presentation with the quantitative data each indicating the extent to which its associated attribute is present in the presentation;

providing a cognitive profile for the user, with the cognitive profile comprising a set of parameters, each of which can be associated with at least one of the attributes and has a numeric value indicative of the cognitive utility of its associated attribute(s) for the learner;

selecting at least one of the other presentations using a mathematical function that, using the user'"'"'s cognitive profile and at least some of the other presentations'"'"' cognitive indices, determines which of those other presentations best matches the cognitive style of the user; and

providing the user with an ordered sequence of the presentations that includes the selected presentations.

12. The method of claim 11, wherein said computer-displayable presentations comprise web pages and wherein said providing step further comprises providing the web pages over a global computer network for display on the computer workstation.

13. The method of claim 12, wherein said assigning step further comprises storing information on the user'"'"'s computer workstation that identifies the cognitive profile associated with the user.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein said storing step further comprises storing a cookie on the user'"'"'s computer workstation, with said cookie providing information that identifies the cognitive profile associated with the user.

15. A method of generating a cognitive profile for a learner for use in selecting among different presentations of educational content delivered by a computer-based learning system, wherein the different presentations each have quantitative data representing the extent to which different attributes are present in the presentation, the method comprising the steps of:

(a) providing an initial set of coefficients that together form at least a portion of the cognitive profile, wherein the coefficients comprise numeric values each of which is associated with at least one of the attributes;

(b) providing feedback through iterations of the following steps (b1)-(b3);

(b1) presenting educational content to the learner using different presentations having varying emphasis on different ones of the attributes;

(b2) determining which of the presentations given to the learner results in the greatest comprehension of the educational content presented; and

(b3) updating the coefficients using the quantitative data associated with the presentation identified in step (b2).

16. The method of claim 15, further comprising the step of generating a utility function using the cognitive profile and wherein step (b3) further comprises updating the coefficients using both the utility function and an approximation of the utility function.

17. The method of claim 16, wherein step (b2) further comprises determining one or more preference relations and thereafter determining the approximation of the utility function using the preference relation(s).

18. The method of claim 15, wherein said numeric values comprise scaled settings of the cognitive profile and wherein step (a) further comprises providing at least one toggle setting that forms a portion of the cognitive profile, with said toggle setting representing at least one unweighted attribute of the learner'"'"'s cognitive style.

19. The method of claim 15, wherein step (a) further comprises providing learner-identifying data that forms a portion of the cognitive profile.

20. The method of claim 15, wherein step (b) further comprises using the learning system to perform steps (b1)-(b3) on a continuous basis.