System, method and article of manufacture for increasing the user value of recommendations

• US 6,321,221 B1
• Filed: 07/17/1998
• Issued: 11/20/2001
• Est. Priority Date: 07/17/1998
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Callstat Solutions LLC (Jeffrey M. Gross)
• Original Assignee: Net Perceptions, Inc. (Stamford Industrial Group, Inc.)
• Inventors: Bieganski, Paul
• Primary Examiner(s): Coulter, Kenneth R.
• Application Number:
  US09/118,025
• Time in Patent Office: 1,222 Days
• Field of Search: 707/4, 707/5, 705/10, 705/27
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/335 Filtering based on additional data, e.g. user or group profiles filtering in web context G06F16/9535, G06F16/9536
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/02 Marketing; Price estimation or determination; Fundraising
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0631 Item recommendations
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99935 Query augmenting and refining, e.g. inexact access

Abstract

The invention includes a system, method and article of manufacture for generating a serendipity-weighted recommendation output set to a user based, at least in part, on a serendipity function. The system includes a processing system of one or more processors configured to receive applicable data that includes item recommendation data and community item popularity data. The processing system is also configured to produce a set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity function and the community item popularity data, and to combine the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce a serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set. The method includes receiving applicable data by the processing system, including inputting item recommendation data and community item popularity data. The method further includes generating a set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and a serendipity function, using the processing system, and combining the item recommendation data and the set of item serendipity control values to produce a serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set, also using the processing system. The invention also includes a computer readable medium having a having a set of program instructions physically embodied thereon, executable by a computer, to perform a method similar to the method described above.

Claims

1. An electronic processing system for generating a serendipity-weighted recommendation output set to a user based, at least in part, on a serendipity function, the system comprising a processing system of one or more processors configured to:

a. receive applicable data including

i. item recommendation data, and

ii. community item popularity data,

b. produce a set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity function and the community item popularity data, and

c. combine the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce a serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

2. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system is further configured to

a. receive the serendipity control function and

b. produce the set of item serendipity control values in response to the received serendipity function and the community item popularity data.

3. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system is further configured to

a. receive an input from one of a serendipity filter system administrator and the user relating to the serendipity control function,

b. select the serendipity function in response to the input received from the one of the serendipity filter system administrator and the user, and

c. produce the set of item serendipity control values in response to the selected serendipity function and the community item popularity data.

4. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising an input interface operatively coupled to the processing system in order to receive the applicable data and transmit the applicable data to the processing system.

5. A system as recited in claim 4, wherein

a. the applicable data further includes the serendipity function,

b. the input interface is configured to be further coupled to a memory system, and

c. the processing system is configured to

i) receive the serendipity function from the memory system, and

ii) produce the set of serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function received from the memory system.

6. A system as recited in claim 4, wherein

a. the input interface is configured to be further coupled to receive a request from the user for serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendations, and

b. the processing system combines the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set in response to the request received from the user.

7. A system as recited in claim 4, wherein

the input interface is further configured to receive item recommendation data that includes at least one of unary values, binary values, and numerical values, and

the processing system is further configured to combine the at least one of the unary values, binary values and numerical values with

the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

8. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising an output interface operatively coupled to the processing system in order to receive the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

9. A system as recited in claim 8, further comprising a display device operatively coupled to the output interface in order to display the serendipity-weighted recommendation output set.

10. A system as recited in claim 8, further comprising a memory system operatively coupled to the output interface in order to receive and store the serendipity-weighted recommendation output set.

11. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising

a memory system configured to be operatively coupled to the processing system,

wherein the processing system is configured to receive community item popularity data from the memory system.

12. A system as recited in claim 1, further comprising

a) a recommender system configured to be operatively coupled to transmit the item recommendation data to the processing system,

b) wherein the processing system is further configured to combine the item recommendation data received from the recommender system with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

13. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system includes a single processor configured to

a) receive the item recommendation data,

b) receive the community item popularity data,

c) produce the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function and the received community item popularity data, and

d) combine the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

14. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system includes

a) a first processor configured to

i) receive the community item popularity data, and

ii) produce the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function and the community popularity data, and

b) a second processor, configured to be operatively coupled to the first processor and configured to

i) receive the item recommendation data

ii) receive the set of item serendipity control values from the first processor, and

iii) combine the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

15. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system is configured to produce the serendipity-weighted recommendation output under real-time, interactive time constraints.

16. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the processing system is further configured to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set as at least one of unary, unordered recommendations and priority-ordered recommendations.

17. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein the serendipity function is at least one of:

a) a fixed function having controllable parameters;

b) a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency greater than a pre-selected upper frequency value;

c) a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency less than a pre-selected lower frequency value;

d) a continuous function having a value that reduces with increasing frequency of occurrence in the community item popularity data; and

e) a function assigning a constant value to items having an occurrence frequency in the community item popularity data less than a selected frequency and a value that reduces with an occurrence frequency higher than the selected frequency.

18. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein

a. the processing system is further configured to select the serendipity function using feedback data, the feedback data including one of a rate at which the user accepts items from the serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation set, a rate at which the user requests additional predictions, and a rate at which the user accepts non-recommended items, and

b. the processing system produces the set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function selected using the feedback data.

19. A system as recited in claim 1, wherein

a. the item recommendation data relate to one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable goods, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, automobile-related goods, automobile related services, travel-related goods, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of art, computer-related hardware, computer software and computer-related service products, and

b. the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set relates respectively to the one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable goods, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, automobile-related goods, automobile related services, travel-related goods, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of art, computer-related hardware, computer software and computer-related service products.

20. A method of producing a serendipity-weighted recommendation to a user, the method using a computer having a memory unit, a processing system having one or more processors and an input/output interface, the method comprising:

a. receiving, by the processing system, applicable data including inputting,

i. item recommendation data and

ii community item popularity data;

b. generating, using the processing system, a set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and a serendipity function; and

c. combining, using the processing system, the item recommendation data and the set of item serendipity control values to produce a serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set.

21. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a. receiving, by the processing system, the serendipity control function, and

b. generatin the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function received by the processing system and the community item popularity data.

22. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a. receiving, by the processing system, an input from one of a serendipity filter system administrator and the user relating to the serendipity control function,

b. selecting, by the processing system, the serendipity function in response to the input received from the one of the serendipity filter system administrator and the user, and

c. producing, by the processing system, the set of item serendipity control values in response to the selected serendipity function and the community item popularity data.

23. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising receiving, by the input/output interface the applicable data and transmitting the applicable data, by the input/output interface, to the processing system.

24. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a. receiving, with the processing system, the serendipity function from the memory system, and

b. generating, with the processing system, the set of serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function received from the memory system.

25. A method as recited in claim 24, further comprising

a. receiving a request, with the processing system, from the user for serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendations, and

b. combining, with the processing system, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set in response to the request received from the user.

26. A system as recited in claim 20, further comprising

receiving, with the processing system, item recommendation data that includes at least one of unary values, binary values, and numerical values, and

combining, with the processing system, the at least one of the unary values, binary values and numerical values with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

27. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising outputting, using the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set to the input/output interface.

28. A method as recited in claim 27, further comprising transmitting, using the input/output interface, the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set to a display device and displaying the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set on the display device.

29. A method as recited in claim 27, further comprising transmitting, using processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set to the memory system for storage therein.

30. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

receiving, using the processing system, the community item popularity data from the memory system.

31. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a) generating item recommendation data with a recommender system and

b) receiving, by the processing, the item recommendation data generated by the recommender system, and

c) combining the item recommendation data received from the recommender system with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

32. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a) receiving the applicable data with a single processor of the one or more processors,

b) producing the set of item serendipity control values with the single processor in response to the serendipity control function and the community item popularity data, and

c) combining, with the single processor, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

33. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a) receiving the applicable data with a first processor of the one or more processors,

b) producing, with the first processor, the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function and the community popularity data,

c) receiving the item recommendation data with a second processor of the one or more processors,

d) receiving, with the second processor, the set of item serendipity control values from the first processor, and

e) combining, with the second processor, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

34. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising producing, with the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set under real-time, interactive constraints.

35. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising producing, with the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set as at least one of unary, unordered recommendations and priority-ordered recommendations.

36. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising receiving, with the processing system, the item recommendation data as at least one of unary values, binary values, and numerical values.

37. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising generating, using the processing system, the set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function, where the serendipity function is at least one of:

a fixed function having controllable parameters;

a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency greater than a pre-selected upper frequency value;

a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency less than a pre-selected lower frequency value;

a continuous function having a value that reduces with increasing frequency of occurrence in the community item popularity data; and

a function assigning a constant value to items having an occurrence frequency in the community item popularity data less than a selected frequency and a value that reduces with an occurrence frequency higher than the selected frequency.

38. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising

a. receiving, through the input/output interface, a serendipity function selection control input from one of a recommender system administrator and the user, and

b. selecting, using the processing system, the selectable serendipity function in response to the received serendipity function selection control input.

39. A method as recited in claim 20, further comprising controlling the serendipity function, using the processing system, with feedback data received through the input/output interface, the feedback data including one of a rate at which the user accepts serendipity-weighted and filtered recommended items, a rate at which the user requests additional serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendations, and a rate at which the user accepts non-recommended items.

40. A method as recited in claim 20, wherein

a. the item recommendation data relate to one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable goods, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, automobile-related goods, automobile related services, travel-related goods, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of art, computer-related hardware, computer software and computer-related service products, and

b. the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set relates respectively to the one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable goods, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, automobile-related goods, automobile related services, travel-related goods, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of art, computer-related hardware, computer software and computer- related service products.

41. A computer-readable program storage device, having a set of program instructions physically embodied thereon, executable by a computer, to perform a method for increasing user value of an item recommendation from a recommender system, the method comprising:

a. receiving, by a processing system, applicable data including,

i. item recommendation data and

ii community item popularity data;

b. generating, using the processing system, a set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and a serendipity function; and

c. combining, using the processing system, the item recommendation data and the set of item serendipity control values to produce a serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set.

42. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a. receiving, by the processing system, the serendipity control function, and

b. generating the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function received by the processing system and the community item popularity data.

43. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a. receiving, by the processing system, an input from one of a serendipity filter system administrator and the user relating to the serendipity control function,

b. selecting, by the processing system, the serendipity function in response to the input received from the one of the serendipity filter system administrator and the user, and

c. producing, by the processing system, the set of item serendipity control values in response to the selected serendipity function and the community item popularity data.

44. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising receiving, by an input/output interface the applicable data and transmitting the applicable data, by the input/output interface, to the processing system.

45. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a. receiving, by the processing system, the serendipity function from the memory system, and

b. generating the set of serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function received from a memory system.

46. A device as recited in claim 45, the method further comprising

a. receiving a request, with the processing system, from the user for serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendations, and

b. combining, with the processing system, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set in response to the request received from the user.

47. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

receiving, with the processing system, item recommendation data that includes at least one of unary values, binary values, and numerical values, and

combining, with the processing system, the at least one of the unary values, binary values and numerical values with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

48. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising outputting, using the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set to the input/output interface.

49. A device as recited in claim 48, the method further comprising transmitting, using an input/output interface, the serendipity-weighted recommendation output set to a display device and displaying the serendipity-weighted recommendation output set on the display device.

50. A device as recited in claim 48, the method further comprising transmitting, using the processing system, the serendipity-weighted recommendation output set to the memory system for storage therein.

51. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

receiving, using the processing system, the community item popularity data from the memory system.

52. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a) generating item recommendation data with a recommender system and

b) receiving, by the processing system, the item recommendation data generated by the recommender system, and

c) combining the item recommendation data received from the recommender system with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

53. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a) receiving the applicable data with a single processor of the one or more processors,

b) producing the set of item serendipity control values with the single processor in response to the serendipity control function and the community item popularity data, and

c) combining, with the single processor, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

54. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a) receiving the applicable data with a first processor of the one or more processors and

b) producing the set of item serendipity control values in response to the serendipity control function and the community popularity data, and

c) receiving the item recommendation data with a second processor of the one or more processors

d) receiving, with the second processor, the set of item serendipity control values from the first processor, and

e) combining, with the second processor, the item recommendation data with the set of item serendipity control values to produce the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set.

55. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising producing, with the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered item recommendation output set under real-time, interactive constraints.

56. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising producing, with the processing system, the serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendation output set as at least one of unary, unordered recommendations and priority-ordered recommendations.

57. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising receiving, with the processing system, the item recommendation data as at least one of unary values, binary values, and numerical values.

58. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising generating, using the processing system, the set of item serendipity control values in response to the community item popularity data and the serendipity function, where the serendipity function is at least one of:

a fixed function having controllable parameters;

a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency greater than a pre-selected upper frequency value;

a bi-level function that excludes items occurring in the community item popularity data with a frequency less than a pre-selected lower frequency value;

a continuous function having a value that reduces with increasing frequency of occurrence in the community item popularity data; and

a function assigning a constant value to items having an occurrence frequency in the community item popularity data less than a selected frequency and a value that reduces with an occurrence frequency higher than the selected frequency.

59. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising

a. receiving, through an input/output interface, a serendipity function selection control input from one of a recommender system administrator and the user, and

b. selecting, using the processing system, the selectable serendipity function in response to the received serendipity function selection control input.

60. A device as recited in claim 41, the method further comprising controlling the serendipity function, using the processing system, with feedback data received through an input/output interface, the feedback data including one of a rate at which the user accepts serendipity-weighted and filtered recommended items, a rate at which the user requests additional serendipity-weighted and filtered recommendations, and a rate at which the user accepts non-recommended items.

61. A device as recited in claim 41, wherein

a. the item recommendation data relate to one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable goods, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, automobile-related goods, automobile related services, travel-related goods, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of art, computer-related hardware, computer software and computer-related service products, and

b. the serendiptdy-wighted and filtered recommendation output set related respectively to the one of musical items, audio/visual items, written publications, articles from written publications, Internet documents, consumable good, dining and entertainment services, financial service products, real estate, architectural goods, architectural services, financial service products, real estate, related services, travel-related good, travel-related services, images, pictures, works of atr computer-related good, are, computer software and computer-related service products.