System and method for an automated scoring tool for assessing new technologies

• US 6,452,613 B1
• Filed: 03/01/2000
• Issued: 09/17/2002
• Est. Priority Date: 03/01/2000
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Bank One Delaware National Association (JP Morgan Chase & Co)
• Original Assignee: First USA Bank N.A. (JP Morgan Chase & Co)
• Inventors: Lefebvre, Christopher R., Schreiner, Stephen T.
• Primary Examiner(s): Kincaid, Kristine
• Assistant Examiner(s): Nguyen, Thomas T.
• Application Number:
  US09/517,062
• Publication Number:
  US 20020107823A1
• Time in Patent Office: 930 Days
• Field of Search: 345/348, 345/329, 345/339, 345/331, 345/352, 345/975, 345/835, 345/733, 345/764, 345/751, 345/810, 345/809, 709/201, 709/217, 709/203, 705/35, 705/36, 705/10
• US Class Current: 715/733
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/10 Office automation; Time management

Abstract

The invention comprises an apparatus and method for an automated invention submission and scoring tool for evaluating invention submissions. The system comprises a server system and a plurality of server systems. The server system presents submission questionnaires over a networked connection to submitters at user systems. The user completes the questionnaires, which are returned to the server system for processing. The server system processes the answers to provide a quantified evaluation of the submission based on patentability and at least one other parameter, such as impact or value. An evaluator at an evaluator system can view a presentation of the quantified assessment of the invention submission. The evaluator can also view the results of multiple invention submissions on a status overview page. Links between the status overview page, individual questionnaires, and individual assessment presentations are provided.

Claims

1. A system for providing an automated assessment of an invention submission, comprising:

a user system for providing responses to a series of inquiries regarding the invention submission, wherein the series comprises questions for which there exist selectable responses; and

a server system for processing said responses to provide a quantified assessment of said invention submission, wherein the quantified assessment is based on scoring at least some of the responses by assigning weighted values based on said responses, and wherein the server system is further adapted to combine said weighted values to present at least one composite score, wherein the at least one composite score represents an indicia of the likelihood of receiving a patent and an indicia of at least one other metric;

wherein said at least one composite score represents an indicia of the value that would be conferred by receiving a patent, the value comprising said at least one other metric;

wherein said quantified assessment is prepared before a patent application exists for the invention submission; and

whereby said quantified assessment is usable for determining whether a patent application should be prepared.

2. The system of claim 1, wherein said questions comprise at least one of multiple choice, true/false, and yes/no queries.

3. The system of claim 1, wherein the series of inquiries are presented as one or more graphical user interface pages by said server.

4. The system of claim 1, wherein said quantified assessment is used by the server system to create a graphical presentation of the results of said processing.

5. The system of claim 1, wherein said server system is adapted to present the results of a plurality of quantified assessments to enable a decision about said plurality by an evaluator.

6. The system of claim 5, wherein said results of a plurality of quantified assessments are presented on a graphical user interface page.

7. The system of claim 6, wherein a user can link from said page to view data associated with a single one of said plurality of quantified assessments.

8. A method for automatically evaluating an invention submission, comprising.

accessing a server system maintaining a standard set of queries;

viewing said queries on a user system, wherein the queries have selectable responses;

providing responses to said queries;

processing said responses; and

generating an objective assessment of said submission at said server system based on said step of processing, wherein said objective assessment is prepared before a patent application exists for the invention submission, wherein the objective assessment is based on scoring at least some of the responses and is usable for determining whether a patent application should be prepared,

wherein said objective assessment is computed by assigning weighted values based on said responses and combining said weighted values to present at least one composite score, wherein the at least one composite score represents an indicia of the likelihood of receiving a patent and an indicia of at least one other metric; and

wherein said at least one composite score represents an indicia of the value that would be conferred by receiving a patent, the value comprising said at least one other metric.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein said standard set of queries are presented as a browser page.

10. The method of claim 8, further comprising the step of presenting a graphical representation of the results of said objective assessment.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein said graphical representation includes the results for a plurality of submissions.

12. The method of claim 8, further comprising the step of approving the preparation of a patent application based at least in part on said objective assessment.

13. The method of claim 8, wherein said queries comprise at least one of:

multiple choice questions, true/false questions, and yes/no questions.

14. A method for automatically evaluating an invention submission, comprising:

selecting at least two metrics for evaluating the invention submission, a first of the metrics relating to patentability and a second of the metrics relating to another factor of interest;

identifying a plurality of questions for evaluating the invention submission, wherein the questions have selectable responses that are provided by a user system and from which a quantified assessment can be computed by a server system; and

assigning scores to the questions for the metrics such that at least some questions are capable of contributing to the first metric, and at least some questions are capable of contributing to the second metric, and at least some questions are capable of contributing to the at least two metrics,

wherein the quantified assessment is prepared before a patent application exists for the invention submission and the quantified assessment is used for determining whether a patent application should be prepared, and

wherein the quantified assessment is computed by assigning weighted values based on responses to the questions and combining said weighted values to present at least one composite score, wherein the at least one composite score represents an indicia of the first metric and an indicia of the second metric; and

wherein the second metric relates to the potential value or impact of securing a patent.

15. The method of claim 14, wherein the plurality of questions further comprises at least one informational question.

16. The method of claim 14, wherein the step of assigning scores is effectuated in a rank-order fashion so that different questions may have different maximum values that can be contributed to an overall score.

17. The method of claim 14, wherein the step of assigning scores is effectuated so that a maximum value of one hundred (100) is attainable for each of the metrics.

18. A system for automatically assessing an invention submission, comprising:

means for presenting to a user system a series of questions with selectable responses;

means for processing the responses to provide a quantified assessment of The invention submission, wherein the quantified assessment is based on scoring at least some of the responses by assigning weighted values based on said responses and combining said weighted values to present at least one composite score, wherein the at least one composite score represents an indicia of the likelihood of receiving a patent and an indicia of at least one other metric, wherein the means for processing includes a server system;

wherein said at least one composite score represents an indicia of the value that would be conferred by receiving a patent, the value comprising said at least one other metric;

wherein the quantified assessment is prepared before a patent application exists for the invention submission, and

wherein the quantified assessment is usable to determine whether to prepare a patent application.

19. The system of claim 18, further comprising means for providing a graphical presentation of the quantified assessment, wherein the graphical presentation presents the quantified assessment according to patentability and the at least one other metric.

20. The system of claim 19, wherein the graphical presentation includes a link to the underlying response data.

21. The system of claim 18, further comprising means for providing a graphical presentation of a plurality of quantified assessments for purposes of evaluating a plurality of invention submissions.

22. A computer memory for storing a computer program operative to perform the following steps for automatically evaluating an invention submission:

presenting a series of questions having selectable responses that are provided by a user system regarding the invention submission;

processing the responses at a server system to provide a quantified assessment of the invention submission, wherein the quantified assessment is based on scoring at least some of the responses by assigning weighted values based on said responses and combining said weighted values to present at least one composite score, wherein the at least one composite score represents an indicia of the likelihood of receiving a patent and an indicia of at least one other metric;

wherein said at least one composite score represents an indicia of the value that would be conferred by receiving a patent, the value comprising said at least one other metric;

wherein the quantified assessment is prepared before a patent application exists for the invention submission, and

wherein the quantified assessment is usable to determine whether to prepare a patent application.