Method for predicting recovery boiler leak detection system performance

• US 6,484,108 B1
• Filed: 06/05/2000
• Issued: 11/19/2002
• Est. Priority Date: 09/26/1997
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: GE Betz, Inc. (General Electric Company)
• Original Assignee: GE Betz, Inc. (General Electric Company)
• Inventors: Hong, Ke, Burgmayer, Paul R., Gunther, John C.
• Primary Examiner(s): Hilten, John S.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Lau, Tung S
• Application Number:
  US09/587,489
• Time in Patent Office: 897 Days
• Field of Search: 702/51, 702/49.7, 702/50, 702/29, 73/405, 364/509
• US Class Current: 702/51
• CPC Class Codes: F22B 37/421 Arrangements for detecting leaks

Abstract

A system and method for presenting the tradeoffs among the sensitivity, false alarms and off-line operation of recovery boiler leak detection systems. For any given recovery boiler, the system and method utilizes prior data from that recovery boiler to provide the operator of that boiler with the ability to balance how sensitive the recovery boiler leak detection system can be along with how many false alarms of the recovery boiler leak detection system will be tolerated and along with how much off-line operation of the recovery boiler leak detection system will be acceptable.

Claims

1. A method for presenting tradeoffs of the sensitivity and false alarms of a recovery boiler leak detection system, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) obtaining leak-free operational data from the recovery boiler;

(b) specifying a leak probability estimating filter that uses a statistical noise model and a model of how typical leaks grow over time;

(c) generating a numerical indicator from said filter and said operational data, said numerical indicator having an output that is a measure of leak likelihood;

(d) selecting an alarm limit for said recovery boiler leak detection system wherein if said output of said numerical indicator exceeds said limit, an alarm is activated in said recovery boiler leak detection system;

(e) determining the sensitivity of the leak detection system from one of a first sequence of numerical indicator outputs that exceeds said alarm limit in the least amount of time, said first sequence of numerical indicator outputs being generated from simulated recovery boiler inputs and an assumed leak that are fed into said filter;

(f) determining the number of false alarms from a second sequence of numerical indicator outputs that exceed said alarm limit, said second sequence of numerical indicator outputs being generated by a sequence of said operational leak-free data fed into said filter; and

(g) presenting tradeoffs among said sensitivity and false alarms.

2. The method of claim 1 further comprising:

(a) modifying said at statistical noise model or said model of how typical leaks grow over time;

(b) generating a new numerical indicator having an output that is a measure of leak likelihood from said modified statistical noise model or from said modified model of how typical leaks grow over time;

(c) selecting an alarm limit for said recovery boiler leak detection system wherein if said new numerical indicator output exceeds said limit, an alarm is activated in said recovery boiler leak detection system;

(d) inputting said simulated recovery boiler inputs into said modified statistical noise model or into said modified model of how typical leaks grow over time to generate a third sequence of numerical indicator outputs corresponding to said sequence of leak flow rates;

(e) determining the time it takes until the first one of said third sequence of numerical indicator outputs exceeds said alarm limit, thereby defining a new sensitivity;

(f) inputting said sequence of said operational leak-free data into said modified statistical noise model or into said modified model of how typical leaks grow over time to generate a fourth sequence of numerical indicator outputs corresponding to said sequence of said operational leak-free data;

(g) determining the number of times that said alarm limit is exceeded by said fourth sequence of numerical indicator outputs, thereby defining new false alarms; and

(h) presenting treadeoffs among said new sensitivity and new false alarms.

3. A method for presenting tradeoffs of the sensitivity and false alarms of a recovery boiler leak detection system, said method comprising the steps of:

(a) obtaining leak-free operational data from the recovery boiler;

(b) specifying a leak probability estimating filter;

(c) generating a numerical indicator from said filter and said operational data, said numerical indicator having an output that is a measure of leak likelihood and comprises a leak probability statistic, said leak probability statistic comprising a standardized maximum likelihood standardized leak flow;

(d) selecting an alarm limit for said recovery boiler leak detection system wherein if said output of said numerical indicator exceeds said limit, an alarm is activated in said recovery boiler leak detection system;

(e) determining the sensitivity of the leak detection system from one of a first sequence of numerical indicator outputs that exceeds said alarm limit in the least amount of time, said first sequence of numerical indicator outputs being generated from simulated recovery boiler inputs and an assumed leak that are fed into said filter;

(f) determining the number of false alarms from a second sequence of numerical indicator outputs that exceed said alarm limit, said second sequence of numerical indicator outputs being generated by a sequence of said operational leak-free data fed into said filter; and

(g) presenting tradeoffs among said sensitivity and false alarms.