Methods and systems for detecting coin fraud in coin-counting machines and other devices

• US 7,014,029 B2
• Filed: 12/05/2002
• Issued: 03/21/2006
• Est. Priority Date: 12/05/2001
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Coinstar Asset Holdings, LLC
• Original Assignee: Coinstar Incorporated (Outerwall Inc.)
• Inventors: Winters, Gregory
• Primary Examiner(s): Walsh, Donald P.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Beauchaine, Mark J.
• Application Number:
  US10/313,944
• Publication Number:
  US 20030111316A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,202 Days
• Field of Search: 731/63, 194/303, 194/217, 194/216, 194/215, 194/302, 194/317
• US Class Current: 194/302
• CPC Class Codes: G07D 5/00 Testing specially adapted to determine the identity or genuineness of coins, e.g. for segregating coins which are unacceptable or alien to a currency
• CPC Class Codes: G07D 9/04 Hand- or motor-driven devices for counting coins counting mechanisms in general G06M

Abstract

Methods and systems for detecting coin fraud in coin-counting machines and other devices that count and/or sort coins and other objects. In one embodiment, the method includes discriminating multiple coins to determine a number of real coins and a number of faux coins. In one aspect of this embodiment, the faux coins can have one or more coin characteristics falling generally close to corresponding characteristics of the real coins. The method can further include determining a quotient based on the number of real coins and faux coins. If the determined quotient is greater than or equal to a selected threshold value, then the transaction can be identified as being possibly fraudulent. In the event of a possibly fraudulent transaction, the method can include controlling the transaction, for example, by returning any uncounted coins to a user, or by halting the transaction.

Claims

1. A method for detecting coin fraud in a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

defining a first coin criterion associated with acceptable coins of a selected denomination;

defining a second coin criterion at least partially associated with both acceptable and unacceptable coins of the selected denomination;

receiving multiple coins of the selected denomination from a user for counting;

discriminating a portion of the coins of the selected denomination received from the user;

counting a first number of the discriminated portion of coins that satisfy the first criterion;

counting a second number of the discriminated portion of coins that satisfy the second criterion; and

detecting coin fraud in the coin-counting machine based on the first and second numbers.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

determining a quotient using the first and second numbers; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein detecting coin fraud includes detecting coin fraud in the coin-counting machine based on the comparison of the quotient to the threshold number.

3. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

determining a quotient using the first and second numbers;

comparing the quotient to a threshold value;

when the quotient is less than the threshold value, allowing the transaction to proceed; and

when the quotient is greater than the threshold value, stopping the transaction.

4. The method of claim 1 wherein defining the first coin criterion includes defining a first range of a coin characteristic, and wherein defining the second coin criterion includes defining a second range of the coin characteristic.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein defining the first coin criterion includes defining a first range of a coin characteristic, wherein defining the second coin criterion includes defining a second range of the coin characteristic, and wherein the first and second ranges define a continuous range of the coin characteristic.

6. A method for controlling a transaction in a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

receiving multiple coins;

discriminating at least a portion of the received coins;

counting a first number of the discriminated portion of coins that fall within a first range of a coin characteristic, the first range being related to an acceptable coin type;

counting a second number of the discriminated portion of coins that fall within a second range of the coin characteristic, the second range being related to an unacceptable coin type; and

controlling the transaction based on the first and second numbers.

7. The method of claim 6, further comprising:

determining a quotient by dividing the second number by the sum of the second number plus the first number; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes stopping the transaction and returning an uncounted portion of the received coins to a user when the quotient is greater than or equal to the threshold value.

8. The method of claim 6, further comprising:

determining a quotient by dividing the second number by the sum of the second number plus the first number; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction based on the comparison of the quotient to the threshold value.

9. The method of claim 6 wherein controlling the transaction includes stopping the transaction and returning an uncounted portion of the received coins to a user.

10. The method of claim 6 wherein controlling the transaction includes activating a camera positioned at least proximate to the coin-counting machine to obtain a photographic image of a user who deposited the multiple coins.

11. The method of claim 6 wherein controlling the transaction includes transmitting a signal related to the transaction to a remote computer using a computer network.

12. The method of claim 6, further comprising:

determining a quotient using the first and second numbers; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction based on the comparison of the quotient to the threshold value.

13. The method of claim 6, further comprising:

determining a quotient by dividing the second number by the sum of the second number plus the first number; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction based on the comparison of the quotient to the threshold value.

14. The method of claim 6 wherein the portion of the received coins is a first portion of the received coins, and wherein the method further comprises:

determining a first quotient using the first and second numbers;

comparing the first quotient to a first threshold value;

discriminating a second portion of the received coins;

counting a third number of the second portion of coins that fall within the first range of the coin characteristic;

counting a fourth number of the second portion of coins that fall within the second range of the coin characteristic;

determining a second quotient using at least the third and fourth numbers; and

comparing the second quotient to a second threshold value different than the first threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction based on the comparison of the second quotient to the second threshold value.

15. The method of claim 6 wherein the portion of the received coins is a first portion of the received coins, and wherein the method further comprises:

determining a first quotient using the first and second numbers;

comparing the first quotient to a first threshold value;

discriminating a second portion of the received coins;

counting a third number of the second discriminated portion of coins that fall within the first range of the coin characteristic;

counting a fourth number of the second discriminated portion of coins that fall within the second range of the coin characteristic;

determining a second quotient using at least the third and fourth numbers; and

comparing the second quotient to a second threshold value less than the first threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction when the second quotient is greater than or equal to the second threshold value.

16. The method of claim 6 wherein controlling the transaction includes stopping the transaction and returning an uncounted portion of the received coins to a user when the second number divided by the sum of the second number plus the first number is equal to or greater than a preselected value.

17. The method of claim 6 wherein the coin characteristic is associated with a selected coin denomination, wherein receiving multiple coins includes receiving coins of multiple denominations including the selected denomination, wherein discriminating the portion of the received coins includes discriminating coins of the selected denomination to determine the first and second numbers of the selected denomination, and wherein controlling the transaction includes stopping the transaction and returning an uncounted portion of the coins of the selected denomination to the user when the second number divided by the second number plus the first number is equal to or greater than a preselected value.

18. The method of claim 6 wherein the coin characteristic is related to at least one of a material characteristic and a dimensional characteristic.

19. A method for controlling a transaction in a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

receiving multiple coins;

discriminating at least a portion of the received coins;

counting a number of the discriminated portion of coins having characteristics falling within at least one of a first range of a coin characteristic and a second range of the coin characteristic, the first range being at least partially related to an acceptable coin type and the second range being at least partially related to an unacceptable coin type; and

controlling the transaction based on the number.

20. The method of claim 19, further comprising comparing the number to a threshold value, and wherein controlling the transaction includes initiating a coin-fraud detection routine if the number is greater than or equal to the threshold value.

21. The method of claim 19 wherein counting the number of the discriminated portion of coins includes counting the number of coins that fall within the second range, and wherein controlling the transaction includes initiating a coin-fraud detection routine if the number exceeds a minimum value.

22. The method of claim 19 wherein counting the number of the discriminated portion of coins includes counting a first number of the discriminated coins that fall within the first range and counting a second number of the discriminated coins that fall within the second range, and wherein controlling the transaction includes initiating a coin-fraud detection routine if the number exceeds the minimum value, the coin-fraud detection routine including determining a quotient based on the first and second numbers, and comparing the quotient to a threshold value.

23. A coin-counting apparatus comprising:

means for receiving multiple coins in a transaction;

means for discriminating at least a portion of the received coins;

means for counting a number of the discriminated portion of coins having characteristics that fall within a range of a coin characteristic at least partially related to an unacceptable coin type; and

means for controlling the transaction based on the number.

24. The apparatus of claim 23 wherein the means for discriminating the portion of received coins includes means for sequentially sensing characteristics of the portion of coins.

25. The apparatus of claim 23 wherein the means for counting a number of the discriminated portion of coins includes means for counting a number of the coins having characteristics associated with both acceptable and unacceptable coins.

26. A method for controlling a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

defining a preferred range associated with a measured characteristic for a selected coin denomination, wherein the preferred range has a lower threshold value and an upper threshold value;

defining at least one questionable range associated with the measured characteristic for the selected coin denomination, wherein the questionable range is approximately adjacent to at least the lower or upper threshold values; and

analyzing and disposing of a given coin by;

(a) accepting the given coin and incrementing a first counting value if the coin falls outside of the preferred range but inside the questionable range;

(b) rejecting the given coin if it fails outside of the preferred and questionable ranges; and

(c) accepting the given coin and incrementing a second counting value different than the first counting value if the coin falls within the preferred range.

27. A method for controlling a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

defining a preferred range associated with a measured characteristic for a selected coin denomination, wherein the preferred range has a lower threshold value and an upper threshold value;

defining at least one questionable range associated with the measured characteristic for the selected coin denomination, wherein the questionable range is approximately adjacent to at least the lower or upper threshold values; and

analyzing and disposing of a given coin by;

(a) accepting the given coin and incrementing a counting value if the coin falls outside of the preferred range but inside the questionable range;

(b) rejecting the given coin if it falls outside of the preferred and questionable ranges;

(c) accepting the given coin if it falls within the preferred range, and

(d) adjusting the questionable range or the preferred range after analyzing two or more coins during a given coin-counting transaction.

28. The method of claim 27 wherein accepting the given coin if it lies within the preferred range includes not incrementing the counting value.

29. A method for controlling a coin-counting machine, the method comprising:

defining a preferred range associated with a measured characteristic for a selected coin denomination, wherein the preferred range has a lower threshold value and an upper threshold value;

defining at least one questionable range associated with the measured characteristic for the selected coin denomination, wherein the questionable range is approximately adjacent to at least the lower or upper threshold values; and

analyzing and disposing of a given coin by;

(a) accepting the given coin and incrementing a counting value if the coin falls outside of the preferred range but inside the questionable range;

(b) rejecting the given coin if it falls outside of the preferred and questionable ranges; and

(c) accepting the given coin if it lies within the preferred range, wherein the preferred range is N number of standard deviations from a mean value for the measured characteristic for a preferred coin of the selected coin denomination, and wherein the questionable range is at least between N and N+1 standard deviations from the mean value.

30. A computer-readable medium whose contents cause a computer to detect coin fraud in a coin-counting machine, the coin fraud being detected by a method comprising:

receiving multiple coins;

discriminating at least a portion of the received coins;

counting a first number of the discriminated portion of coins that fall within a first range of a coin characteristic, the first range being related to an acceptable coin type;

counting a second number of the discriminated portion of coins that fall within a second range of the coin characteristic, the second range being related to an unacceptable coin type; and

controlling the transaction based on the first and second numbers.

31. The computer-readable medium of claim 30, wherein the method further comprises:

determining a quotient by dividing the second number by the sum of the second number plus the first number; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes stopping the transaction and returning an uncounted portion of the received coins to a user when the quotient is greater than or equal to the threshold value.

32. The computer-readable medium of claim 30 wherein the method further comprises:

determining a quotient by dividing the second number by the sum of the second number plus the first number; and

comparing the quotient to a threshold value, wherein controlling the transaction includes controlling the transaction based on the comparison of the quotient to the threshold value.

33. An apparatus for counting coins, the apparatus comprising:

a coin input region configured to receive multiple coins;

a coin discriminator positioned to receive at least a portion of the multiple coins from the coin input region and discriminate the portion of coins, the coin discriminator configured to discriminate a coin characteristic having at least a first range and a second range, the first range being related to an acceptable coin type and the second range being related to an unacceptable coin type;

a coin selector positioned to receive coins from the coin discriminator, the coin selector configured to count acceptable coins for retention within the apparatus and reject unacceptable coins; and

a fraud detection component connected to the coin discriminator to receive information from the coin discriminator, the fraud detection component configured to count a first number of the portion of coins having coin characteristics that fall within the first range of the coin characteristic, the fraud detection component further configured to count a second number of the portion of coins having coin characteristics that fall within the second range of the coin characteristic, the fraud detection component still further configured to control the coin selector based on the first and second numbers.

34. The coin-counting apparatus of claim 33 wherein the coin input region includes a tray for simultaneously receiving the multiple coins in random orientation.

35. The coin-counting apparatus of claim 33 wherein the coin fraud detection component calculates a ratio of the second number divided by the sum of the first and second numbers, wherein the first and second numbers of coins include coins of a selected denomination, and wherein the coin fraud detection component controls the coin selector to reject coins of the selected denomination based on a comparison of the ratio to a threshold value.