Method and apparatus for attribute selection

• US 7,200,583 B1
• Filed: 01/10/2005
• Issued: 04/03/2007
• Est. Priority Date: 01/08/1997
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Versata Development Group, Inc. (ESW Capital, LLC)
• Original Assignee: Trilogy Development Group Incorporated (ESW Capital, LLC)
• Inventors: Shah, Ashish, Wells, Mark
• Primary Examiner(s): DAVIS, GEORGE B
• Application Number:
  US11/032,422
• Time in Patent Office: 813 Days
• Field of Search: 706/47, 706/48
• US Class Current: 706/47
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 30/00 Computer-aided design [CAD]

Abstract

The invention provides a method and apparatus for selecting desired attributes for system configuration. The invention uses one or more rule sets to define rules that are met when a configuration is valid. A rule set may specify the interrelation of attribute values within a product or between two or more products. If the combination of attribute values that specify a product conform to at least one rule in each of the rule sets that apply to that product, that combination of attribute values is considered to specify a valid product. If the combination of attribute values that specify all of the products of an assembly conform to at least one rule in each of the rule sets that apply to that assembly, that combination of attribute values is considered to specify a valid assembly.

Claims

1. A method for selecting attribute values comprising the steps of:

accessing a rule set comprising rules;

creating a working set comprising a representation of selectable attribute values;

accepting proposed selected attribute values;

identifying valid attribute values in said rules;

providing a first indication associated with each of said valid attribute values;

identifying attributes referenced in said rule set; and

determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set, if said values are present in said working set and said second first indication is not associated with said values, removing said values from said working set.

2. The method of claim 1 further comprising:

adding said values to said working set, if said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are not present in said working set and said first indication is associated with said values.

3. The method of claim 1 further comprising:

for each of a plurality of rule sets, repeating (i) identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, (ii) identifying attributes, and (iii) determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

4. The method of claim 1 further comprising:

configuring a product, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation for said product of said attribute values referenced in said rule set.

5. The method of claim 1 further comprising:

configuring a plurality of products using interproduct rule sets, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation between said products of said attribute values referenced in said rule sets.

6. The method of claim 5 wherein said products are included in an assembly of products, the method further comprising the steps of:

identifying bindings of said rule set, wherein said bindings define relations between said products in said assembly; and

for each of said bindings of said rule set, repeating (i) identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, (ii) identifying attributes, and (iii) determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

7. A data storage medium comprising computer readable code, wherein the computer readable code is executable by a computer for:

accessing a rule set comprising rules;

creating a working set comprising a representation of selectable attribute values;

accepting proposed selected attribute values;

identifying valid attribute values in said rules;

providing a first indication associated with each of said valid attribute values;

identifying attributes referenced in said rule set; and

determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set, if said values are present in said working set and said first indication is not associated with said values, removing said values from said working set.

8. The computer readable medium of claim 7 wherein the computer readable code is further executable by a computer for:

adding said values to said working set if said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are not present in said working set and said first indication is associated with said values.

9. The computer readable medium of claim 7 wherein the computer readable code is further executable by a computer for:

repeating, for each of a plurality of rule sets, identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, identifying attributes, and determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

10. The computer readable medium of claim 7 wherein the computer readable code is further executable by a computer for:

configuring a product, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation for said product of said attribute values referenced in said rule set.

11. The computer readable medium of claim 7 wherein the computer readable code is further executable by a computer for:

configuring a plurality of products using interproduct rule sets, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation between said products of said attribute values referenced in said rule sets.

12. The computer readable medium of claim 11 wherein said products are included in an assembly of products, the computer readable code is further executable by a computer for:

identifying bindings of said rule set, wherein said bindings define relations between said products in said assembly; and

for each of said bindings of said rule set, repeating identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, identifying attributes, and determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

13. A system comprising:

a processor; and

a memory coupled to the processor, the memory having code executable by the processor for;

accessing a rule set comprising rules;

creating a working set comprising a representation of selectable attribute values;

accepting proposed selected attribute values;

identifying valid attribute values in said rules;

providing a first indication associated with each of said valid attribute values;

identifying attributes referenced in said rule set; and

determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set, if said values are present in said working set and said first indication is not associated with said values, removing said values from said working set.

14. The system of claim 13 wherein the code is further executable by the processor for:

adding said values to said working set if said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are not present in said working set and said first indication is associated with said values.

15. The system of claim 13 wherein the code is further executable by the processor for:

repeating, for each of a plurality of rule sets, (i) identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, (ii) identifying attributes, and (iii) determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

16. The system of claim 13 wherein the code is further executable by the processor for:

configuring a product, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation for said product of said attribute values referenced in said rule set.

17. The system of claim 13 wherein the code is further executable by the processor for:

configuring a plurality of products using interproduct rule sets, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation between said products of said attribute values referenced in said rule sets.

18. The system of claim 17 wherein said products are included in an assembly of products, the code is further executable by the processor for:

identifying bindings of said rule set, wherein said bindings define relations between said products in said assembly; and

for each of said bindings of said rule set, repeating identifying valid attribute values, providing a first indication, identifying attributes, and determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set.

19. An apparatus comprising:

means for accessing a rule set comprising rules;

means for creating a working set comprising a representation of selectable attribute values;

means for accepting proposed selected attribute values;

means for identifying valid attribute values in said rules;

means for providing a first indication associated with each of said valid attribute values;

means for identifying attributes referenced in said rule set; and

means for determining whether values of said attributes referenced in said rule set are present in said working set and whether said first indication is associated with said values of said attributes referenced in said rule set, if said values are present in said working set and said first indication is not associated with said values, removing said values from said working set.

20. The apparatus of claim 19 further comprising:

means for configuring a product, wherein said rules of said rule set specify an interrelation for said product of said attribute values referenced in said rule set.