Method of negotiating an active or a passive role assignment to a control means of a network element, a control means, a program module and a network element therefor

• US 7,394,759 B2
• Filed: 01/23/2003
• Issued: 07/01/2008
• Est. Priority Date: 02/12/2002
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: WSOU Investments, LLC (WSOU Holdings, LLC)
• Original Assignee: Alcatel SA (Nokia Corporation)
• Inventors: Lohr, Jurgen
• Primary Examiner(s): Yao; Kwang Bin
• Assistant Examiner(s): Lai; Andrew
• Application Number:
  US10/348,949
• Publication Number:
  US 20030152026A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,986 Days
• Field of Search: 370/221, 370/252, 370/220
• US Class Current: 370/220
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13056 Routines, finite state machines
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13106 Microprocessor, CPU
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13109 Initializing, personal profile
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13167 Redundant apparatus
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13299 Bus
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 2213/13396 Signaling in general, in-band signalling
• CPC Class Codes: H04Q 3/54558 Redundancy, stand-by

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method of negotiating an active or a passive role assignment to a first and a second control means of a network element. The control means are redundant and operate dependent on their respective active or passive role. The invention furthermore relates to a control means therefor, a program module for a control means therefor and a network element therefor.

The method comprises the steps of:

• • determining an operability state parameter for each of said control means dependent on their respective ability to perform their respective functionality;
  • mutually transmitting said operability state parameters between said control means; and
  • determining an active role or a passive role by said control means dependent on said respective operability state parameters.

Claims

1. A method of negotiating an active or a passive role assignment to a first control means and to at least one second control means, both contained in a single network element, said first control means and said at least one second control means being redundant and operating dependent in a role that is active or passive with regard to controlling said network element, the method comprising the steps of:

determining an operability state parameter for each of said first control means and said at least one second control means dependent on the respective ability of said first control means and said at least one second control means to perform a first functionality and a second functionality, respectively;

mutually transmitting said operability state parameters between said first control means and said at least one second control means; and

determining an active role or a passive role by said first control means and by said at least one second control means dependent on said operability state parameter of the first control means and said operability state parameter of said at least one second control means;

wherein when a control means is assigned a passive role, it is in stand-by with regard to the controlled network element; and

when a control means is assigned an active role, it controls the controlled network element.

2. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means assigns the active role to the first control means if said operability state of the first control means is better than the operability state of said at least one second control means, and wherein said at least one second control means assigns the passive role to said at least one second control means if said operability state of said at least one second control means is worse than the operability state of said first control means.

3. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein values of a predetermined order are assigned to said operability state parameter of the first control means and said operability state parameter of the at least one second control means, said values representing the ability level of said first control means and said at least one second control means to perform the first functionality and the second functionality, respectively.

4. The method as claimed in claim 3, wherein said first control means compares the value of operability state parameter of the first control means with the value of the operability state parameter of said at least one second control means to determine whether to play the active role or the passive role.

5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein a unique identifier is assigned to each of said first control means and said at least one second control means, and wherein said unique identifiers are mutually transmitted between said first control means and said at least one second control means.

6. The method as claimed in claim 5, wherein said unique identifiers, and a value of the unique identifiers, are evaluated to determine the active role for said first control means and the passive role for said at least one second control means or vice versa to resolve at least one of an active-active role conflict and a passive-passive role conflict between said first control means and said at least one second control means.

7. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein said first control means changes from the active role to the passive role if the unique identifier of the first control means has a higher or a lower value than the unique identifier of said at least one second control means and if at least one of the operability state of the first control means and the operability state of said at least one second control means and roles of said first control means and said at least one second control means are equal.

8. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein if said first control means and said at least one second control means are not in the active role, at least one of the first control means and the at least one second control means with the highest or the lowest unique identifier value becomes active and the first control means or at least one second control means changes to or remains in the passive role.

9. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means assumes that said at least one second control means plays a passive role if said first control means does not receive the operability state parameter of said at least one second control means.

10. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein information about the respective roles of said control means is mutually transmitted between said control means.

11. The method as claimed in claim 10, wherein said first control means remains in a current role, passive or active, if a role of said at least one second control means is different from said current role and if the operability state of the first control means and the operability state of the at least one second control means are equal.

12. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein in addition to said active or passive role an undetermined role is defined, said undetermined role being the initial role of said first control means and said at least one second control means, at a first system start and a second system start.

13. The method as claimed in claim 12, wherein said first control means changes from the undetermined role to the active or the passive role after receiving the operability state parameter of said at least one second control means.

14. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means transmits the operability state parameter of the first control means and the unique identifier of the first control means and an information about the role of the first control means within one common message to said at least one second control means.

15. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means transmits said state parameter, said unique identifier and said information about the role, periodically and at a first system start and a second system start.

16. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means performs at least one finite state machine to determine the active or the passive role, and said operability state of said first control means and said operability state of said at least one second control means represents he respective states of said at least one finite state machine and said active, passive and undetermined roles represent the respective states of said at least one finite state machine.

17. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means control at least one common hardware device, especially contained in one rack of said network element, and in that said at least one common hardware device is actively controlled by said first control means if said first control means plays an active role or by said at least one second control means if said at least one second control means plays an active role.

22. The method according to claim 1, wherein the active role comprises actively controlling the first functionality of a device, and the passive role comprises being in a stand-by mode with respect to controlling the first functionality of the device.

23. The method according to claim 1, wherein the first functionality and the second functionality are different functions of a single device.

24. The method according to claim 23, wherein if the first control means is in the active role with respect to the first functionality of the device, then the at least one second control means is in a second active role with respect to the second functionality of the device.

18. A first control means of a single network element able to negotiate an active or a passive role assignment with at least one second control means, wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means are contained in said single network element, said first control means and said at least one second control means being redundant and operating dependent on a role that is active or passive with regard to controlling said network element, said first control means comprising means for carrying out a method comprising:

determining a first operability state parameter dependent on the ability of said first control means to perform a functionality;

transmitting said first operability state parameter to said at least one second control means;

receiving at least one second operability state parameter of said at least one second control means; and

determining an active role or a passive role dependent on said first operability state parameter and said at least one second operability state parameter;

wherein when a control means is assigned a passive role, it is in stand-by with regard to the controlled network element; and

when a control means is assigned an active role, it controls the controlled network element.

19. A program module for a first control means of a single network element, said program module enabling said first control means to negotiate an active or a passive role assignment with at least one second control means, wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means are contained in said single network element, said first control means and said at least one second control means being redundant and operating dependent on a role that is active or passive with regard to controlling said network element, said program module containing program instructions able to be executed by said first control means, said instructions comprising the steps of:

determining a first operability state parameter dependent on the ability of said first control means to perform its functionality;

transmitting said first operability state parameter to said at least one second control means;

receiving at least one second operability state parameter of said at least one second control means; and

determining the active role or the passive role dependent on said first operability state parameter and said at least one second operability state parameter;

wherein when a control means is assigned a passive role, it is in stand-by with regard to the controlled network element; and

when a control means is assigned an active role, it controls the controlled network element.

20. A single network element containing a first control means and at least one second control means negotiating an active role or a passive role assignment, said first control means and said at least one second control means being redundant and operating dependent on a role that is active or passive with regard to controlling said network element, said first control means and said at least one second control means adapted to carry out:

determining of operability state parameters for said first control means and said at least one second control means dependent on an ability of said first control means and said at least one second control means to perform a first functionality and a second functionality, respectively;

mutually transmitting said first operability state parameter and said second operability state parameter between said first control means and said at least one second control means; and

determining the active role or the passive role by said first control means and by said at least one second control means dependent on said first operability state parameter and said second operability state parameter;

wherein when a control means is assigned a passive role, it is in stand-by with regard to the controlled network element; and

when a control means is assigned an active role, it controls the controlled network element.

21. A computer readable medium having a program module for a first control means of a single network element, said program module enabling said first control means to negotiate an active or a passive role assignment with at least one second control means wherein said first control means and said at least one second control means are contained in said single network element, said first control means and said at least one second control means being redundant and operating dependent on a role that is active or passive with regard to controlling said network element, said program module containing program instructions able to be executed by said first control means, and said instructions comprising the steps of:

determining a first operability state parameter dependent on the ability of said first control means to perform its functionality;

transmitting said first operability state parameter to said at least one second control means;

receiving at least one second operability state parameter of said at least one second control means; and

determining the active role or the passive role dependent on said first operability state parameter and said at least one second operability state parameters;

wherein when a control means is assigned a passive role, it is in stand-by with regard to the controlled network element; and

when a control means is assigned an active role, it controls the controlled network element.