Method and apparatus for filtering electronic messages

• US 7,519,674 B2
• Filed: 09/01/2006
• Issued: 04/14/2009
• Est. Priority Date: 09/01/2006
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: Nuxo Technologies, Inc.
• Original Assignee: Nuxo Technologies, Inc.
• Inventors: Regnier, Alain
• Primary Examiner(s): Nguyen; Quang N.
• Application Number:
  US11/514,658
• Publication Number:
  US 20080059589A1
• Time in Patent Office: 956 Days
• Field of Search: 709/206, 709/207, 709/203, 709/219, 709/224, 709/227, 713/170, 705/67
• US Class Current: 709/206
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 51/212 using filtering or selective blocking

Abstract

A method is provided for filtering electronic messages such as unsolicited bulk email. The method includes establishing a communications connection with the remote server under the Simple Email Transfer Protocol or other suitable protocol; accepting session data from the remote server; and determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages. If the data pertaining to the connection does not meet the criteria associated with legitimate messages, then one or more stimulus signals are sent to the remote server. If the server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol, then the session can be added to a database of known sessions. The session is then terminated by responding to the server with a temporary error message in accordance with the protocol. If the remote server is a legitimate server complying with the STMP, it will resend the message after a prescribed time period.

Claims

1. A method for processing an email message having message content and sent by a remote server in accordance with a communications protocol, the method comprising:

(a) establishing a communications connection with the remote server;

(b) exchanging a plurality of session messages defining a communications session with the remote server, at least some of which are separate from the message content;

(c) accepting from the remote server session data pertaining to the communications connection, including information pertaining to at least one of the following;

the remote server, the sender of the email message, the destination of the email message;

(d) determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages;

(e) if the session data does not meet the criteria associated with the legitimate messages, testing the behavior of the remote server by sending to the remote server at least one stimulus signal configured to generate a machine-originated response from the remote server in accordance with the communications protocol to determine if the remote server is operation in accordance with the communications protocol, the testing initiated during the communications session; and

(f) processing the communications connection in response to whether the remote server is operating in accordance with the communications protocol;

wherein the at least one stimulus signal is one of a command and a reply, the format and content of which are specified by the communications protocol.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein the communications protocol is the Simple Mail Transport Protocol, the email message includes a message envelope, and the session data includes data contained in the message envelope.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein the step of processing the connection includes accepting the message content if the remote server responds to a stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol.

4. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

providing a database of known connections, wherein the step of determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages is performed using the database of known connections; and

where in the criteria include primary criteria and secondary criteria;

accepting the email message if the session data meets the primary criteria; and

adding session data to the database of known connections if the session data does not meet the primary criteria but does meet the secondary criteria;

wherein if the remote server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol, then the step of processing the connection includes adding data about the connection to the database of known connections.

5. The method of claim 4, further comprising:

if the session data does not meet the primary criteria, then the stimulus signal includes sending an error code to the remote server which error code is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the email message after a period of time.

6. The method of claim 1, wherein if the remote server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol, then the step of processing the connection includes adding data about the connection to a database of known connections.

7. The method of claim 6, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages comprises comparing the session data to data in the database of known connections.

8. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

if the session data does not meet the criteria associated with legitimate messages, then sending an error code to the remote server which error code is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the email message after a period of time.

9. The method of claim 1, wherein if the step of processing the connection includes sending reply to the remote server which reply is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the email message after a period of time.

10. The method of claim 1, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages comprises at least one of:

determining if the connection is a priority connection, determining if the connection is a known connection, and determining if the connection context is favorable.

11. The method of claim 1, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages comprises:

providing a database of known connections;

wherein the criteria associated with legitimate messages is whether the connection is a known connection based on the database of known connections.

12. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

accepting the message content if the session data meets the criteria associated with legitimate messages.

13. The method of claim 1 wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages comprises:

providing a database of known connections;

determining if whether the connection is a known connection based on the database of known connections;

if the connection is a known connection, then determining if the history of the connection history meets the criteria of legitimate connection histories;

if the connection is a known connection and the history of the connection meets criteria of legitimate connection histories, then accepting the email message;

otherwise sending an error code to the remote server which error code is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the email message after a period of time.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages further comprises:

if the connection is not a known connection and the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages, then adding the connection to the database of known connections.

15. The method of claim 13, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages further comprises:

if the connection is not a known connection, then determining if he context of the connection meets criteria of favorable connection contexts; and

if the connection is not a known connection and the context of the connection meets the criteria of favorable connection contexts, then adding the connection and the context of the connection to the database of known connections.

16. The method of claim 1, wherein the at least one stimulus signal comprises one of:

sending one of the plurality of session messages to the remote server in a manner that does nor comply with the protocol in terms of at least one of timing, format and content;

sending to the remote server at least one session message with a format and content as specified by the communications protocol;

sending a reply session message to the remote server in response to a command session message transmitted by the remote server, wherein the time that elapses between the receipt of the command session message and the sending of the reply session message is at least about five to ten seconds; and

terminating the communications connection.

17. The method of claim 1, wherein at least one of testing the behavior of the remote server and processing the connection comprises:

sending to the remote server at least one session message, the format and content of which are specified by the communications protocol, which session message .is configured to generate a machine-originated response from the remote server in accordance with the communications protocol; and

determining whether the remote server responds to the session message in accordance with the communications protocol.

18. A method for processing a message sent by a remote server in accordance with a communications protocol, wherein the message includes an envelope and a message content, comprising:

(a) establishing a communications connection with the remote server;

(b) accepting from the remote server session data pertaining to the connection, including information pertaining to at least one of the following;

the remote server;

the sender of the message;

the destination of the message;

(c) determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages;

(d) sending one or more stimulus signals to the remote server if the session does not meet the criteria associated with legitimate messages; and

(e) processing the connection in response to whether the remote server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol;

wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages further comprises;

determining if the connection is a priority connection;

accepting the message content if it is a priority connection;

providing a database of known connections;

if the connection is not a priority connection, then determining if the connection is a known connection by reference to the database of known connections;

if the connection is a known connection, then determining if the, connection meets criteria associated with legitimate messages;

if the connection is a known connection and if the connection meets criteria associated with legitimate messages, then accepting the connection;

if the connection is a known connection but does not meet the criteria associated with legitimate messages, then updating the database of information about known connections and sending an error code to the remote server which error code is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the message after a period of time.

19. The method of claim 18, wherein determining if the session data meets criteria associated with legitimate messages further comprises:

if the connection is not a priority connection and if the connection is not a known connection, then determining whether a context associated with the connection is favorable;

if the context associated with the connection is favorable, then adding the connection to the historical information about known connections and sending an error code to the remote server which error code is prescribed under the protocol as requiring the remote server to resend the message after a period of time; and

if the context associated with the connection is not favorable, then identifying the connection as a connection that does not meet the criteria associated with legitimate messages.

20. An apparatus for processing an email message having an envelope and a message content and sent by a remote server in accordance with the SMTP communications protocol, comprising:

a communications port adapted for establishing a communications connection with the remote server;

a database of known connections;

a processor coupled to the communications port and the database of known connections and adapted to;

exchange a plurality of session messages defining a communications session with the remote server, at least some of which are separate from the message content;

accept as input from the remote server session data pertaining to the communications connection, including information pertaining to at least one of the following;

the remote server, the sender of the email message, the destination of the email message;

use the database of known connections to determine if the session data pertaining to the communications connection meets criteria associated with legitimate messages;

if the session data does not meet the criteria associated with the legitimate messages, test the behavior of the remote server by sending to the remote server at least one stimulus signal configured to generate a response from the remote server in accordance with the SMTP communications protocol, wherein the at least one of stimulus signal is one of a command and a reply, the format and content of which are specified by the SMTP communications protocol, the testing initiated during the communications session; and

process the communications connection in response to whether the remote server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the SMTP communications protocol.

21. A computer program product for processing an email message having message content and sent by a remote server in accordance with a communications protocol, comprising:

a computer data storage medium;

computer program instructions, recorded on the computer data storage medium, executable by a computer processor to;

establish a communications connection with the remote server;

exchange a plurality of session messages defining a communications session, at least some of which are separate from the message content;

accept as input from the remote server session data pertaining to the communications connection, including information pertaining to at least one of the following;

the remote server, the sender of the email message, the destination of the email message;

use a database of known connections to determine if the session data pertaining to the communications connection meets criteria associated with legitimate messages;

if the session data does not meet the criteria associated with the legitimate messages, test the behavior of the remote server to determine if it complies with the communications protocol by sending to the remote server a stimulus signal configured to stimulate a response from the remote server in accordance with the communications protocol, the testing initiated during the communications session; and

process the communications connection in response to whether the remote server responds to the stimulus signal in the manner required by the communications protocol;

wherein the stimulus signal is one of a command and a reply, the format and content of which are specified by the communications protocol.