Methods and systems for comparing storage area network configurations

• US 7,606,889 B1
• Filed: 06/30/2006
• Issued: 10/20/2009
• Est. Priority Date: 06/30/2006
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Emc IP Holding Company LLC (Dell Technologies Inc.)
• Original Assignee: EMC Corporation (Dell Technologies Inc.)
• Inventors: McBride, Mark M., Ogren, Paul, Kundala, Shankar
• Primary Examiner(s): LIN, WEN TAI
• Application Number:
  US11/479,556
• Time in Patent Office: 1,208 Days
• Field of Search: None
• US Class Current: 709/223
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/0866 Checking the configuration
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 41/22 comprising specially adapted graphical user interfaces [GUI]

Abstract

Methods and systems for comparing configurations of a storage area network are disclosed. A first configuration file and a second configuration file, each representing the configuration of a storage area network, are imported into a first configuration tree and a second configuration tree. An unordered comparison is then performed on the configuration trees. The unordered comparison produces a difference file that identifies changes in the configurations of the storage area networks. The configuration trees may be each processed into comparison trees before the unordered comparison is performed. The unordered comparison may produce two results files, one corresponding to the first comparison tree and the other corresponding to the second comparison tree; these may be combined to create the difference file. The identified changes in the difference file or in the results files may then be reported to a storage area network manager or administrator.

Claims

1. A computer-implemented method of comparing configurations of a storage area network in which a computer system performs operations comprising:

importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file into a first configuration tree and a second configuration tree, the first configuration file representing a first configuration of a storage area network and the second configuration file representing a second configuration of the storage area network;

processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree into a first comparison tree and a second comparison tree, wherein processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree comprises;

converting or modifying the format of the first and second configuration trees to one that is compatible with a comparison routine that performs an unordered comparison;

removing irrelevant information and/or inserting additional information into the first and second comparison trees; and

adding pointers to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree, each pointer in the first comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the first configuration tree and each pointer in the second comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the second configuration tree, wherein the pointers carry over regardless of any changes made to the format of the first and second comparison trees; and

performing the unordered comparison on the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree to produce a difference file, the difference file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

2. The method of claim 1:

wherein performing the unordered comparison comprises;

performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a difference file, the difference file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

3. The method of claim 2 wherein performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree comprises:

performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a first results file and a second results file, the first results file and a second results file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

4. The method of claim 3 wherein the pointers added to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree are present in the first results file and the second results file.

5. The method of claim 1 comprising:

mapping the identified changes in the first results file back to the first configuration tree through the pointers in the first results file; and

mapping the identified changes in the second results file back to the second configuration tree through the pointers in the second results file.

6. The method of claim 5 comprising:

reporting the identified changes in the configuration of the storage area network from the mapped first configuration tree and the mapped second configuration tree.

7. The method of claim 6, wherein importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file comprises:

importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file into a first configuration tree and a second configuration tree, the first configuration file representing a configuration of a storage area network at a first point in time and the second configuration file representing a configuration of the storage area network at a second point in time;

and wherein reporting the identified changes comprises;

reporting the changes in the configuration of the storage area network from the first point in time to the second point in time as identified in the first results file and in the second results file.

8. The method of claim 1 comprising:

reporting the changes in the configuration of the storage area network as identified in the difference file.

9. The method of claim 1 wherein importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file comprises:

importing a plurality of configuration files into a plurality of configuration trees, each configuration file representing the configuration of the storage area network at a different point in time for a comparison period of time;

and wherein performing comprises;

performing an unordered comparison on the plurality of configuration trees to produce a plurality of results files, the plurality of results files identifying changes in the configuration of the storage area network over the comparison period of time.

10. The method of claim 9 comprising:

processing each configuration tree into a comparison tree, resulting in a plurality of comparison trees;

wherein performing an unordered comparison on the plurality of configuration trees comprises;

performing an unordered comparison on the plurality of comparison trees to produce a plurality of results files, the plurality of results files identifying changes in the configuration of the storage area network over the comparison period of time;

and the method comprises;

reporting the changes in the configuration of the storage area network over the comparison period of time as identified in the plurality of results file to indicate changes in the configuration of the storage area network over the comparison period of time.

11. The method of claim 1 wherein importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file comprises:

identifying error data within at least one of the first configuration file and the second configuration file, the error data indicating at least one problem with at least one of;

i) the first configuration of the storage area network, and

ii) the second configuration of the storage area network.

12. The method of claim 6 wherein reporting the identified changes comprises:

converting a format of the difference file to a HTML format to create a report, wherein the converting comprises;

identifying an unknown descriptor within the difference file; and

accessing a translation file, the translation file changing the unknown descriptor into a known descriptor, the known descriptor identifiable in the report.

13. A computer system comprising:

a memory;

a processor;

a display;

an interconnection mechanism coupling the memory, the processor and the display allowing communication there between;

wherein the memory is encoded with a comparison application, that when executed in the processor, provides a comparison process that compares configurations of a storage area network, by causing the computer system to perform the operations of;

importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file into a first configuration tree and a second configuration tree, the first configuration file representing a first configuration of a storage area network and the second configuration file representing a second configuration of the storage area network;

processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree into a first comparison tree and a second comparison tree, wherein processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree comprises;

converting or modifying the format of the first and second configuration trees to one that is compatible with a comparison routine that performs an unordered comparison;

removing irrelevant information and/or inserting additional information into the first and second comparison trees; and

adding pointers to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree, each pointer in the first comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the first configuration tree and each pointer in the second comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the second configuration tree, wherein the pointers carry over regardless of any changes made to the format of the first and second comparison trees; and

performing the unordered comparison on the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree to produce a first results file and a second results file, the first results file and the second results file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

14. The computer system of claim 13 wherein performing the unordered comparison comprises:

performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a difference file, the difference file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

15. The computer system of claim 14 wherein performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree comprises:

performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a first results file and a second results file, the first results file and a second results file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

16. The computer system of claim 15 wherein the pointers added to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree are present in the first results file and the second results file.

17. A computer program product, including a computer-readable storage medium for comparing configurations of a storage area network at distinct points in time, comprising:

computer program code for importing a first configuration file and a second configuration file into a first configuration tree and a second configuration tree, the first configuration file representing a first configuration of a storage area network and the second configuration file representing a second configuration of the storage area network;

computer program code for processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree into a first comparison tree and a second comparison tree, wherein processing the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree comprises;

computer program code for converting or modifying the format of the first and second configuration trees to one that is compatible with a comparison routine that performs an unordered comparison;

computer program code for removing irrelevant information and/or inserting additional information into the first and second comparison trees; and

computer program code for adding pointers to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree, each pointer in the first comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the first configuration tree and each pointer in the second comparison tree referring back to the equivalent part of the second configuration tree, wherein the pointers carry over regardless of any changes made to the format of the first and second comparison trees; and

computer program code for performing the unordered comparison on the first configuration tree and the second configuration tree to produce a first results file and a second results file, the first results file and the second results file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

18. The computer program product of claim 17 wherein computer programming code for performing the unordered comparison comprises:

computer program code for performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a difference file, the difference file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

19. The computer program product of claim 18 wherein computer program code for performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree comprises:

computer program code for performing an unordered comparison on the first comparison tree and the second comparison tree to produce a first results file and a second results file, the first results file and a second results file identifying changes between the first configuration of the storage area network and the second configuration of the storage area network.

20. The computer program product of claim 19 wherein the pointers added to the first comparison tree and to the second comparison tree are present in the first results file and the second results file.