System, apparatus and method for compensating the sensitivity of a sequence element in a line current differential relay in a power system

• US 7,660,088 B2
• Filed: 01/23/2006
• Issued: 02/09/2010
• Est. Priority Date: 09/07/2005
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Incorporated
• Original Assignee: Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Incorporated
• Inventors: Benmouyal, Gabriel, Mooney, Joseph B.
• Primary Examiner(s): Jackson; Stephen W
• Assistant Examiner(s): BAUER, SCOTT ALLEN
• Application Number:
  US11/337,894
• Publication Number:
  US 20070070565A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,478 Days
• Field of Search: 361 63- 66
• US Class Current: 361/63
• CPC Class Codes: H02H 3/283 and taking into account saturation of current transformers
• CPC Class Codes: H02H 3/307 involving comparison of quantities derived from a plurality of phases, e.g. homopolar quantities; using mixing transformers
• CPC Class Codes: H02H 7/263 involving transmissions of measured values comparison of currents or voltages using pilot wires H02H3/30

Abstract

An apparatus and method compensate for the sensitivity of at least one line current differential element of a first current differential relay providing differential protection for a transmission line of a power system during a single-phase pole-open condition. The apparatus includes a first delta filter configured to remove a first pre-fault current from a first fault current of the transmission line to derive a compensated first current phasor. The apparatus also includes a second delta filter configured to remove a second pre-fault current from a second fault current of the transmission line to derive a compensated second current phasor. The compensated first and second current phasors are provided to the at least one line current differential element to compensate the sensitivity of the at least one line current differential element.

Claims

1. An apparatus for compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential element of a first current differential relay providing differential protection for a transmission line of a power system during a single-phase pole-open condition, the apparatus comprising:

a first delta filter configured to remove a first pre-fault current from a first fault current of the transmission line to form a compensated first current;

a second delta filter configured to remove a second pre-fault current from a second fault current of the transmission line to form a compensated second current, each of a first phasor representative of the compensated first current and a second phasor representative of the compensated second current provided to the line current differential element to compensate the sensitivity of the line current differential element; and

,

a circuit for interrupting operation of the first line current differential element upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition.

2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the line current differential element is configured to calculate a compensated phasor ratio of the first and second phasors, and compare the compensated phasor ratio to a stability area of an alpha plane of the line current differential element to provide the differential protection.

3. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the circuit for interrupting comprises a countdown timer configured to interrupt operation of the first line current differential element by a countdown time period of a number of power cycles of the power system upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition.

4. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the first current differential relay is operatively coupled to a first end of the transmission line and in communication with a second current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line.

5. The apparatus of claim 4, wherein the first current differential relay is further configured to:

derive a first pre-fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the first pre-fault current measured by the first current differential relay and derive a first fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the first fault current measured by the first current differential relay, subtraction of the first pre-fault current phasor from the first fault current phasor forming the first phasor, and

derive a second pre-fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the second pre-fault current measured by and received from the second current differential relay and derive a second fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the second fault current measured by and received from the second current differential relay, subtraction of the second pre-fault current phasor from the second fault current phasor forming the second phasor.

6. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of a zero-sequence current element and a negative-sequence current element.

7. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of an A-phase current element, a B-phase current element and a C-phase current element.

8. A method for compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential element of a first current differential relay providing differential protection for a transmission line of a power system during a single-phase pole-open condition, the method comprising:

(a) removing a first pre-fault current from a first fault current of the transmission line to form a compensated first current;

(b) removing a second pre-fault current from a second fault current of the transmission line to form a compensated second current; and

(c) providing a first phasor representative of the compensated first current and a second phasor representative of the second compensated current to the line current differential element to compensate the sensitivity of the line current differential; and

,

(d) calculating a compensated phasor ratio of the first phasor and the second phasor upon conclusion of an interrupt resulting from detection of the single-phase pole-open condition.

9. The method of claim 8, further comprising comparing the compensated phasor ratio to a stability area of an alpha plane of the line current differential element to provide the differential protection.

10. The method of claim 8, wherein the interrupt comprises a countdown period of a number of power cycles of the power system beginning upon detection of the single-phase pole-open condition.

11. The method of claim 8, wherein the first current differential relay is operatively coupled to a first end of the transmission line and in communication with a second current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line.

12. The method of claim 11, further comprising:

deriving a first pre-fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the first pre-fault current measured by the first current differential relay and deriving a first fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the first fault current measured by the first current differential relay, subtraction of the first pre-fault current phasor from the first fault current phasor forming the first phasor; and

deriving a second pre-fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the second pre-fault current measured by and received from the second current differential relay and deriving a second fault current phasor from instantaneous values of the second fault current measured by and received from the second current differential relay, subtraction of the second pre-fault current phasor from the second fault current phasor forming the second phasor.

13. The method of claim 8, wherein the line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of a zero-sequence current element and a negative-sequence current element.

14. The method of claim 8, wherein the line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of an A-phase current element, a B-phase current element and a C-phase current element.

15. A system for compensating the sensitivity of a first line current differential sequence element of a local current differential relay, the local current differential relay operatively coupled to a first end of a transmission line of a power system and in communication with a remote current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line, the system comprising:

a first delta filter operatively coupled to the first line current differential sequence element, the first delta filter comprising a first delay filter configured to receive a first local sequence current phasor at a first time and to generate a first delayed local sequence current phasor at a second time, and a first adder configured to subtract the first delayed local sequence current phasor from a second local sequence current phasor received at the second time to form a compensated local sequence current phasor; and

a second delta filter operatively coupled to the first line current differential sequence element, the first second filter comprising a second delay filter configured to receive a first remote sequence current phasor at the first time and to generate a first delayed remote sequence current phasor at the second time, and a second adder configured to subtract the first delayed remote sequence current phasor from a second remote sequence current phasor received at the second time to form a compensated remote sequence current phasor,

wherein the first line current differential element is configured to receive each of the compensated local and remote sequence current phasors to compensate the sensitivity of the first line current differential element upon conclusion of a timer configured to interrupt operation of the first line current differential element upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line.

16. The system of claim 15, wherein the timer is a first countdown timer configured to interrupt operation of the first line current differential sequence element by a first predetermined number of power cycles of the power system upon detecting a single-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line.

17. The system of claim 16, wherein upon expiration of the first countdown timer, the first line current differential sequence element is configured to calculate a compensated phasor ratio of the compensated local and remote sequence current phasors, and compare the compensated phasor ratio to a stability area of an alpha plane to provide differential protection of the transmission line.

18. The system of claim 16, further comprising a second line current differential sequence element operable prior to detecting the single-phase pole-open condition, the second line current differential sequence element configured to calculate a phasor ratio of at least the first local and remote sequence current phasors, and compare the phasor ratio to the stability area to provide differential protection of the transmission line.

19. The system of claim 16, further comprising a second countdown timer configured to delay operation of the first line current differential sequence element by a second predetermined number of power cycles upon detecting cessation of a three-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line.

20. The system of claim 15, wherein the first line current differential sequence element comprises a zero-sequence current element.

21. The system of claim 15, wherein the first line current differential sequence element comprises a negative-sequence current element.

22. An apparatus for compensating the sensitivity of at least one line current differential sequence element of a local current differential relay during a single-phase pole-open condition of a transmission line of a power system, the local current differential relay operatively coupled to a first end of the transmission line and in communication with a remote current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line, the apparatus comprising:

a first delta filter configured to subtract a pre-fault local current phasor from each of a plurality a local current phasors derived from instantaneous local current values measured by the local current differential relay during a fault in the transmission line to form a plurality of compensated local current phasors, the pre-fault local current phasor latched into a memory of the first delta filter; and

a second delta filter configured to subtract a pre-fault remote current phasor from each of a plurality a remote current phasors derived from instantaneous remote current values measured by the remote current differential relay during the fault to form a plurality of compensated second current phasors, the pre- fault remote current phasor latched into a memory of the second delta filter,

wherein the at least one line current differential sequence element is configured to receive pairs of corresponding local and remote sequence current phasors of the plurality of compensated local and remote sequence current phasors to compensate the sensitivity of the at least one line current differential element upon conclusion of a timer configured to interrupt operation of the line current differential sequence element upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line.

23. The apparatus of claim 22, wherein the at least one line current differential sequence element is configured to calculate a plurality of compensated phasor ratios of respective pairs of corresponding local and remote sequence current phasors, and compare each of the plurality of compensated phasor ratios to a stability area of an alpha plane of the at least one line current differential sequence element to provide differential protection for the transmission line.

24. The apparatus of claim 22, wherein the timer comprises a first countdown timer configured to interrupt operation of the at least one line current differential sequence element by a first number of power cycles of the power system upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition.

25. The apparatus of claim 24, further comprising a second countdown timer associated with a second number of power cycles of the power system, the pre-fault local and remote current contributions latched into respective delta filter memories for the second number of power cycles upon detecting the occurrence of the fault.

26. The apparatus of claim 22, wherein the at least one line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of a zero-sequence current element and a negative-sequence current element.

27. The apparatus of claim 22, wherein the at least one line current differential element is selected from the group consisting of an A-phase current element, a B-phase current element and a C-phase current element.

28. A method for compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential sequence element of a local current differential relay during a single-phase pole-open condition of a transmission line of a power system, the local current differential relay operatively coupled to a first end of the transmission line and in communication with a remote current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line, the method comprising:

subtracting a pre-fault local current phasor from each of a plurality of local current phasors derived from instantaneous local current values measured by the local current differential relay during a fault in the transmission line to form a plurality of compensated local current phasors, the pre-fault local current phasor stored in a first memory location of the local current differential relay; and

subtracting a pre-fault remote current phasor from each of a plurality of remote current phasors derived from instantaneous remote current values measured by the remote current differential relay during the fault to form a plurality of compensated second current phasors, the pre-fault remote current phasor stored in a second memory location of the local current differential relay,

wherein pairs of corresponding local and remote sequence current phasors of the plurality of compensated local and remote sequence current phasors are provided to the line current differential element to compensate the sensitivity of the line current differential element upon conclusion an interrupt resulting from detection of the single-phase pole-open condition.

29. The method of claim 28, further comprising:

calculating a plurality of compensated phasor ratios of respective pairs of corresponding local and remote sequence current phasors; and

comparing each of the plurality of compensated phasor ratios to a stability area of an alpha plane of the line current differential sequence element to provide differential protection of the transmission line.

30. The method of claim 28, further comprising interrupting operation of the line current differential sequence element by a first number of power cycles of the power system upon detecting the single-phase pole-open condition.

31. The method of claim 28, further comprising storing the pre-fault local and remote current phasors into, respective first and second memories for a second number of power cycles of the power system.

32. The method of claim 28, wherein the line current differential sequence element is selected from the group consisting of a zero-sequence current element and a negative-sequence current element.

33. The method of claim 28, wherein the line current differential sequence element is selected from the group consisting of an A-phase current element, a B-phase current element and a C-phase current element.

34. A system for compensating the sensitivity of a first line current differential sequence element of a local current differential relay, the local current differential relay operatively coupled to a first end of the transmission line and in communication with a remote current differential relay operatively coupled to a second end of the transmission line, the system comprising:

a first adder, a first memory register and a first delay filter operatively coupled to the first adder and first memory register, the first delay filter configured to delay a local sequence current phasor calculated prior to detecting a fault in the transmission line, the first memory register configured to store the delayed local sequence current phasor to form a stored local sequence current phasor in response to receipt of a latching signal indicating the fault, the first adder configured to subtract one of the delayed local sequence current phasor and the stored local sequence current phasor from each of a plurality of local sequence current phasors calculated after detecting the fault to form a plurality of compensated local sequence current phasors; and

a second adder, a second memory register and a second delay filter operatively coupled to the second adder and the second memory register, the second delay filter configured to delay a remote sequence current phasor calculated prior to detecting the fault, the second memory register configured to store the delayed remote sequence current phasor to form a stored remote sequence current phasor in response to receipt of the latching signal, the second adder configured to subtract one of the delayed remote sequence current phasor and the stored remote sequence current phasor from each of a plurality of remote sequence current phasors calculated after detecting the fault to form a plurality of compensated remote sequence current phasors; and

,

a circuit for interrupting operation of the first line current differential sequence element upon detecting a single-phase pole-open condition,

wherein the first line current differential element is configured to receive pairs of corresponding compensated local and remote sequence current phasors of the plurality of compensated local and remote sequence current phasors to compensate the sensitivity of the first line current differential element.

35. The system of claim 34, wherein the circuit for interrupting comprises a first countdown timer configured to interrupt operation of the first line current differential sequence element by a first countdown time period upon detecting a single-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line to prevent inclusion of unwanted currents in the pairs of corresponding compensated local and remote sequence current phasors provided to the first line current differential element.

36. The system of claim 35, wherein upon expiration of the first countdown timer, the first line current differential sequence element is configured to calculate a plurality of compensated phasor ratios of respective pairs of corresponding compensated local and remote sequence current phasors, and compare the plurality of compensated phasor ratios to a stability area of an alpha plane of the first line current differential sequence element to provide the differential protection.

37. The system of claim 35, further comprising a second line current differential sequence element operable prior to detecting the single-phase pole-open condition, the second line current differential sequence element configured to compare a phasor ratio of each pair of respective local and remote sequence current phasors to a stability area of an alpha plane of the first line current differential sequence element to provide differential protection for the transmission line.

38. The system of claim 35, further comprising:

a first toggle switch operatively coupled to the first adder, the first latched memory register and the first delay filter; and

a second toggle switch operatively coupled to the second adder, the second latched memory register and the second delay filter.

39. The system of claim 38, wherein a first position of the first toggle switch enables receipt of the delayed local sequence current phasor by the first adder in response to a toggle control signal indicating no fault in the transmission line, and a second position of the first toggle switch enables receipt of the stored local sequence current phasor by the first adder in response to a toggle control signal indicating the fault in the transmission line, and wherein the first position of the second toggle switch enables receipt of the delayed remote sequence current phasor by the second adder in response to the toggle control signal indicating no fault in the transmission line, and the second position of the second toggle switch enables receipt of the stored remote sequence current phasor by the second adder in response to the toggle control signal indicating no fault in the transmission line.

40. The system of claim 39, further comprising a second countdown timer configured cause the toggle switch to operate in the second position for a second predetermined number of power cycles upon receipt of the latching signal indicating the fault, and cause the toggle switch to operate in the first position upon completion of the second predetermined number of power cycles.

41. The system of claim 40, further comprising a third countdown timer configured to delay operation of the first line current differential sequence element by a third countdown time period upon detecting cessation of a three-phase pole-open condition of the transmission line.

42. The system of claim 34, further comprising an edge-triggered pulse generator configured to generate the latching signal.

43. The system of claim 34, wherein the first line current differential sequence element comprises a zero-sequence current element.

44. The system of claim 34, wherein the first line current differential sequence element comprises a negative-sequence current element.

45. An apparatus for compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential element of a protective relay providing differential protection for a transmission line of a power system, the apparatus comprising:

a delta filter arrangement configured to form compensated first and second current phasors based upon corresponding first and second pre-fault and fault current phasors; and

,

a circuit for interrupting an operation of the first line current differential element upon detecting a single-phase pole-open condition.

46. The apparatus of claim 45, wherein the delta filter arrangement comprises:

a first delta filter coupled to receive the first pre-fault and fault current phasors and to generate the compensated first current phasor; and

a second delta filter coupled to receive the second pre-fault and fault current phasors and to generate the compensated second current phasor.

47. The apparatus of claim 45, wherein the line current differential element is coupled to receive the compensated first and second current phasors thereby compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential element.

48. The apparatus of claim 47, wherein the line current differential element is configured to calculate a compensated phasor ratio using the compensated first and second current phasors, and to compare the compensated phasor ratio to a predefined value range to provide the differential protection.

49. The apparatus of claim 45, wherein each of the first and second pre-fault and fault current phasors is derived from corresponding measured currents at first and second locations of the transmission line.

50. A method for compensating the sensitivity of a line current differential element of a protective relay providing differential protection for a transmission line of a power system, the method comprising:

forming a compensated first signal based on a first pre-fault current and a first fault current measured at a first end of the transmission line;

forming a compensated second signal based on a second pre-fault current and a second fault current measured at a second end of the transmission line; and

providing compensated first and second current phasors to the current differential element upon conclusion of an interrupt resulting from detection of a single-phase pole-open condition, thereby compensating the line current differential element, each of the compensated first and second current phasors derived from corresponding compensated first and second signals.

51. The method of claim 50, wherein the forming steps comprise removing the first pre-fault current from the first fault current and removing the second pre-fault current from the second fault current.

52. The method of claim 50, wherein the line current differential element is configured to calculate a compensated phasor ratio using the compensated first and second current phasors, and to compare the compensated phasor ratio to a predefined value range to provide the differential protection.