Shareholder value tool

• US 7,899,723 B2
• Filed: 07/01/2003
• Issued: 03/01/2011
• Est. Priority Date: 07/01/2003
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Accenture Global Services Limited (Accenture PLC)
• Original Assignee: Accenture Global Services GmbH (Accenture PLC)
• Inventors: Anslinger, Patricia, Ballow, John Joseph, Ostergard, Michael Kirk
• Primary Examiner(s): Kalinowski; Alexander
• Assistant Examiner(s): Johnson; Gregory
• Application Number:
  US10/609,690
• Publication Number:
  US 20050004832A1
• Time in Patent Office: 2,800 Days
• Field of Search: None
• US Class Current: 705/35
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/00 Finance; Insurance; Tax strategies; Processing of corporate or income taxes
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/02 Banking, e.g. interest calculation or account maintenance credit or loans G06Q40/03
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/03 Credit; Loans; Processing thereof
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/06 Asset management; Financial planning or analysis
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 40/10 Tax strategies

Abstract

The present invention provides and system and related method for automatically examining a company'"'"'s financial data and evaluating factors affecting the company'"'"'s stock value. Specifically, the present invention evaluates a company'"'"'s spread through that company'"'"'s debt and equity costs. The present invention further measures returns to investors from company growth, either organic growth or growth through Mergers and acquisitions. The present invention may further evaluate the financial data of other publicly traded companies, such as those in the same industry, and compares the various factors affecting stock value. The present invention also includes a system for determining the return to investors. The system may be a software-based application that collects receives financial data and uses this information to calculate the return to inventor through the company'"'"'s spreads and growth. The system is connected to a distributed network such as the Internet.

Claims

1. A computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization, the system comprising:

a processor;

a computerized database storing financial information on the organization;

computer-readable medium encoding instructions for automated performance evaluation in light of the financial information in said database; and

communication means connecting said processor, said database and said computer-readable medium;

wherein said instructions in said medium include;

1) an investment return evaluation module, said investment return evaluation module receiving the financial information from said communication means and calculating a return on invested capital;

2) an organization β

value determination module, said organization β

value determination module determining a β

value of the organization by (1) identifying comparable businesses that operate in the same field as the organization, (2) determining the β

values of the comparable businesses, (3) averaging the β

values of the comparable businesses to determine an unlevered β

value, (4) estimating an effect of the financing structure of the organization using the unlevered β

value, and (5) determining a relevered β

value for the organization by adding in the estimated effect of the financing structure;

3) an investment costs evaluation module, said investment costs evaluation module receiving the financial information from said communication means and calculating a weighted average cost of capital using said β

value;

4) a growth estimation module, said growth estimation module receiving the financial information from said communication means and calculating organic growth and growth through mergers and acquisitions, said growth through mergers and acquisitions being calculated by comparing the performance of the organization to the size or book value of the organization and assessing the organization using acquirer and non-acquirer strategies;

5) an economic performance calculation module, said economic performance calculation module calculating a total return to shareholders using the calculated return on invested capital, the calculated weighted average cost of capital, and the calculated growth;

6) a value determination module, said value determination module determining value drivers for the organization using the calculated total return to shareholders; and

7) a target capital structure development module, the target capital structure development module (1) estimating a current capital structure of the organization by identifying financing values associated with the organization, converting the financing values to market values, and calculating a market-based capital structure, (2) reviewing comparable businesses of the organization, and (3) reviewing a management approach of the organization.

2. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 1, wherein the investment return evaluation module calculates the return on invested capital by calculating an operating margin, by calculating a capital utilization, and by multiplying the operating margin by the capital utilization.

3. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 2, wherein the investment return evaluation module calculates the return on invested capital (ROIC) using the following equation:

4. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 3, wherein the investment return evaluation module calculates NOPLAT using the following equation:

NOPLAT =EBITA−

Cash Taxes

where EBITA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, and Amortization) is calculated by determining revenue and adjusting for costs.

5. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 1, whereby Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) calculated by the investment costs evaluation module comprises a weighted sum of costs of debt holders and costs of equity holders.

6. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 5, wherein the investment costs evaluation module calculates Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) using the following equation:

WACC=K_d* (1−

t)* D/(D+E)+K_e* E/(D+E)

where K_d is a cost of debt,

t is a tax rate on the debt,

D is a market value of the debt,

E is a market value of the equity,

K_e is a cost of equity, and

E/(D+E), a ratio of a value of equity to a value of the total debt and equity is a weighting factor for the cost of equity.

7. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 6, wherein the investment costs evaluation module calculates the cost of equity, K_e, using the following equation:

K_e=r_f+(r_m - r_f) * β

, where;

r_f is a risk-free rate of return available to investors;

r_m is a historic market risk premium; and

β

is a factor that returns differ from the returns of a market portfolio.

8. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 7, wherein the investment costs evaluation module calculates the β

value using the following equation;

9. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 1, wherein the investment costs evaluation module adjusts the calculated Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) to reflect an equipment lease.

10. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 1, wherein the investment costs evaluation module adjusts the calculated Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) to reflect a retirement liability.

11. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 1 further comprising a competitor model for calculating a competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders.

12. The computer-based system for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 11 further comprising a graphing model, said graphing model preparing a visual comparison of said organizations'"'"' return to shareholders and said competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders.

29. The computer-based system according to claim 1, wherein the performance of the organization to the size or book value of the organization is compared using a strategic control map.

30. The computer-based system according to claim 1, wherein the reviewing the comparable businesses comprises identifying financing values associated with the comparable businesses, converting the financing values associated with the comparable businesses to comparable business market values, and calculating a comparable businesses market-based capital structure.

13. A computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization, the method comprising the steps of:

accessing, by a computer, a computerized database storing financial information on the organization;

calculating, by said computer, a return on invested capital using said stored financial information;

determining, by said computer, a β

value of the organization by (1) identifying comparable businesses that operate in the same field as the organization, (2) determining the β

values of the comparable businesses, (3) averaging the β

values of the comparable businesses to determine an unlevered β

value, (4) estimating an effect of the financing structure of the organization using the unlevered β

value, and (5) determining a relevered β

value for the organization by adding in the estimated effect of the financing structure;

calculating, by said computer, a weighted average cost of capital using said stored financial information and said β

value;

calculating, by said computer, total growth using said stored financial information, said total growth comprising organic growth and mergers and acquisitions growth, said growth through mergers and acquisitions being calculated by comparing the performance of the organization to the size or book value of the organization and by assessing the organization using acquirer and non-acquirer strategies;

calculating, by said computer, a total return to shareholders using the calculated return on invested capital, the calculated weighted average cost of capital, and the calculated total growth;

calculating, by said computer, determining value drivers for the organization using the calculated total return to shareholders;

estimating, by said computer, a current capital structure of the organization by identifying financing values associated with the organization, converting the financing values to market values, and calculating a market-based capital structure,

reviewing, by said computer, comparable businesses of the organization, and

reviewing, by said computer, a management approach of the organization.

14. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 13, wherein the step of calculating a return on invested capital comprises calculating an operating margin, calculating a capital utilization, and multiplying the operating margin and the capital utilization.

15. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 14, wherein the step of calculating the return on invested capital (ROIC) comprises using the following equation:

16. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 15, wherein the step of calculating the return on invested capital (ROIC) further comprises determining NOPLAT using the following equation:

NOPLAT =EBITA−

Cash Taxes

where EBITA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, and Amortization) is calculated by determining revenue and adjusting for costs.

17. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 13, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) comprises determining a weighted sum of costs of debt holders and costs of equity holders.

18. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 17, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) comprises using the following equation:

WACC=K_d * (1−

t) * D/(D+E)+K_e* E/(D+E)

where K_d is a cost of debt,

t is a tax rate on the debt,

D is a market value of the debt,

E is a market value of the equity,

K_e is a cost of equity, and

E/(D+E), a ratio of a value of equity to a value of the total debt and equity is a weighting factor for the cost of equity.

19. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 18, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) further comprises calculating the cost of equity, K_e, using the following equation:

K_e=r_f+(r_m - r_f)*β

, where;

r_f is a risk-free rate of return available to investors;

r_m is a historic market risk premium; and

β

is a factor that returns differ from the returns of a market portfolio.

20. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 16, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) further comprises calculating the β

value using the following equation;

21. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 13, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) further comprises adjusting to reflect an equipment lease.

22. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 13, wherein the step of calculating the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) further comprises adjusting to reflect a retirement liability.

23. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 13 further comprising the step of calculating a competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders.

24. The computer-implemented method for automated performance evaluation of an organization of claim 23 further comprising the step of preparing a visual comparison of said organizations'"'"' return to shareholders and said competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders.

25. A computer-readable storage medium containing a set of instructions for evaluating performance of an organization, the set of instructions when executed by a computer implement a process comprising:

accessing a computerized databases storing financial information on the organization;

calculating a return on invested capital using said stored financial information;

determining a β

value of the organization by (1) identifying comparable businesses that operate in the same field as the organization, (2) determining the β

values of the comparable businesses, (3) averaging the β

values of the comparable businesses to determine an unlevered β

value, (4) estimating an effect of the financing structure of the organization using the unlevered β

value, and (5) determining a relevered β

value for the organization by adding in the estimated effect of the financing structure;

calculating a weighted average cost of capital using said stored financial information and said β

value;

calculating total growth using said stored financial information, said total growth comprising organic growth and mergers and acquisitions growth, said mergers and acquisitions growth being calculated by comparing the performance of the organization to the size or book value of the organization and by assessing the organization using acquirer and non-acquirer strategies;

calculating a total return to shareholders using the return on invested capital, the weighted average cost of capital, and the total growth;

determining value drivers for the organization using the total return to shareholders;

estimating a current capital structure of the organization by identifying financing values associated with the organization, converting the financing values to market values, and calculating a market-based capital structure;

reviewing comparable businesses of the organization; and

reviewing a management approach of the organization.

26. The computer-readable storage medium of claim 25 wherein the process implemented by the set of instructions further comprises:

calculating a competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders; and

preparing a visual comparison of said organizations'"'"' return to shareholders and said competitor'"'"'s total return to shareholders.

27. An automated performance evaluation system comprising:

a data storage device storing financial information on an organization;

a network enabling access to the data storage device;

a computer connected to the network; and

a program resident on said computer, said program comprising a set of instructions comprising;

calculating a return on invested capital using said stored financial information;

determining a β

value of the organization by (1) identifying comparable businesses that operate in the same field as the organization, (2) determining the β

values of the comparable businesses, (3) averaging the β

values of the comparable businesses to determine an unlevered β

value, (4) estimating an effect of the financing structure of the organization using the unlevered β

value, and (5) determining a relevered β

value for the organization by adding in the estimated effect of the financing structure;

calculating a weighted average cost of capital using said stored financial information and said β

value;

calculating growth through mergers and acquisitions using said stored financial information, said growth through mergers and acquisitions being calculated by comparing the performance of the organization to the size or book value of the organization and by assessing the organization using acquirer and non-acquirer strategies;

calculating total growth using said stored financial information;

calculating a total return to shareholders using the return on invested capital, the weighted average cost of capital, and the total growth;

determining value drivers for the organization using the total return to shareholders;

estimating a current capital structure of the organization by identifying financing values associated with the organization, converting the financing values to market values, and calculating a market-based capital structure;

reviewing comparable businesses of the organization; and

reviewing a management approach of the organization.

28. The automated performance evaluation system of claim 27, wherein the return on invested capital (ROIC) equals the organization'"'"'s total operating profit, adjusted for taxes, and divided by investor-provided capital.