Virtual metering

• US 7,937,247 B2
• Filed: 08/12/2008
• Issued: 05/03/2011
• Est. Priority Date: 08/12/2008
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Square D Company (Schneider Electric SE)
• Original Assignee: Square D Company (Schneider Electric SE)
• Inventors: Hasan, Amjad, Bickel, Jon A., Carter, Ronald W.
• Primary Examiner(s): Raymond; Edward
• Application Number:
  US12/228,394
• Publication Number:
  US 20100042372A1
• Time in Patent Office: 994 Days
• Field of Search: 702/189, 702182-185, 702/188, 714/25
• US Class Current: 702/189
• CPC Class Codes: G01D 4/004 Remote reading of utility meters to a fixed location
• CPC Class Codes: G01R 22/10 using digital techniques
• CPC Class Codes: Y02B 90/20 Smart grids as enabling technology in buildings sector smart grids supporting the management or operation of end-user stationary applications in general, or like technologies with no associated climate change mitigation effect Y04S20/00
• CPC Class Codes: Y04S 20/30 Smart metering, e.g. specially adapted for remote reading

Abstract

Methods for improving the accuracy of characterizing unmonitored paths or virtual meters in a utility system. The hierarchical arrangement of IEDs in the utility system is determined. Measured quantities of a characteristic of the utility being monitored are received and error-adjusted using statistical or absolute methods. The statistical method accounts for the mean and standard deviation associated with error measurements of the subject IED, and the absolute method uses the absolute value of the error measurement, expressed as a percentage, to produce ranges of measured quantities within an error tolerance. The differences between the error-adjusted quantities are analyzed to determine whether an unmonitored path exists, and if so, whether the virtual meter is consuming or supplying the utility. The order in which IEDs are read is determined so that a parent and its children are read in sequence to increase synchronicity of the received data and the virtual meter evaluation.

Claims

1. A method of automatically determining whether an unmonitored portion exists in a utility system, comprising:

determining a hierarchy of the utility system, the hierarchy indicating how a number of intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) are linked to one another in the utility system, each of the IEDs monitoring one or more characteristics of a utility;

automatically storing a data representation of the hierarchy;

identifying, from the hierarchy, a parent IED in the hierarchy that is directly linked to at least one child IED;

identifying, from the hierarchy, all of one or more child IEDs that are directly linked in the hierarchy to the parent IED;

receiving from the parent IED a measured quantity, P_P, of the characteristic of the utility measured by the parent IED;

receiving from each of the one or more child IEDs respective measured quantities of the characteristic of the utility measured by each of the one or more child IEDs;

adjusting the measured quantities measured by the parent IED and by the one or more child IEDs as a function of respective measurement errors associated with the parent IED and with the one or more child IEDs to produce respective error-adjusted quantities; and

based on the error-adjusted quantities, determining whether an unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system, and, if so, storing an indication that a virtual device directly linked to the parent IED exists in the hierarchy.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the determining the hierarchy is carried out automatically, the method further comprising:

calculating a difference between (a) the error-adjusted quantity associated with the parent IED and (b) the sum of the error-adjusted quantities associated with the one or more child IEDs, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system includes determining whether the calculated difference is within an error tolerance, and, if not, carrying out the storing; and

storing the unmonitored quantity and an indication that the virtual device is consuming or producing the unmonitored quantity.

3. The method of claim 1, wherein the function for producing the error-adjusted quantity associated with the parent includes calculating a minimum quantity, P_PTMIN, and a maximum quantity, P_PTMAX, based on at least P_P, a mean of measurement error associated with the parent IED, and a standard deviation of measurement error associated with the parent IED.

4. The method of claim 3, wherein the function for producing the error-adjusted quantities associated with the one or more child IEDs includes:

calculating a minimum quantity, P_SMIN, based on P_PTMIN, an aggregate mean associated with a mean of measurement error of each of the one or more child IEDs, and an aggregate standard deviation associated with a standard deviation of measurement error of each of the one or more child IEDs;

calculating a maximum quantity, P_SMAX, based on P_PTMAX, the aggregate mean, and the aggregate standard deviation;

calculating a minimum difference quantity, P_DMIN, between P_PTMIN and P_SMAX; and

calculating a maximum difference quantity, P_DMAX, between P_PTMAX and P_SMIN.

5. The method of claim 4, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system includes, responsive to P_P−

P_S being greater than or equal to P_DMIN and P_P−

P_S being less than or equal to P_DMAX, determining that no unmonitored quantity exists.

6. The method of claim 4, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system further includes, responsive to P_P−

P_S being less than P_DMIN, determining that the unmonitored quantity does exist and storing an indication that the virtual device is supplying the characteristic of the utility to the utility system.

7. The method of claim 4, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system further includes, responsive to P_P−

P_S being greater than P_DMAX, determining that the unmonitored quantity does exist and storing an indication that the virtual device is consuming the characteristic of the utility to the utility system.

8. The method of claim 1, wherein the function for producing the error-adjusted quantity associated with the parent includes calculating a minimum quantity, P_PMIN, and a maximum quantity, P_PMAX, based on at least P_P and an absolute measurement error associated with the parent IED.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein the function for producing the error-adjusted quantities associated with the one or more child IEDs includes:

calculating a minimum quantity, P_SMIN, based on the sum of the measured quantities measured by the one or more child IEDs and an absolute measurement error associated with the one or more child IEDs;

calculating a maximum quantity, P_SMAX, based on the sum of the measured quantities measured by the one or more child IEDs and an absolute measurement error associated with the one or more child IEDs;

calculating an absolute minimum difference quantity, P_DMIN, between P_PMIN and P_SMAX;

calculating an absolute maximum difference quantity, P_DMAX, between P_PMAX and P_SMIN.

10. The method of claim 9, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system further includes, responsive to P_P−

P_S being greater than or equal to P_DMIN and P_P−

P_S being less than or equal to P_DMAX, determining that no unmonitored quantity exists.

11. The method of claim 9, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system further includes;

responsive to P_P−

P_S being less than P_DMIN, determining that the unmonitored quantity does exist and storing an indication that the virtual device is supplying the characteristic of the utility.

12. The method of claim 9, further comprising adding the respective measured quantities measured by the one or more IEDs to produce a total measured quantity, P_S, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system further includes, responsive to P_P−

P_S being greater than P_DMAX, determining that the unmonitored quantity does exist and storing an indication that the virtual device is consuming the characteristic of the utility.

13. The method of claim 1, wherein the IEDs are power meters, wherein the utility is electricity, and wherein the one or more characteristics includes power, current, or voltage.

14. The method of claim 1, wherein the utility is water, air, gas, electricity, or steam, and wherein the one or more characteristic includes power, voltage, current, voltage distortion, BTU per hour, MBTU per hour, energy, gallons per minute, or cubic feet per minute.

15. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining a reading order of the respective measured quantities from the parent IED and the one or more child IEDs such that, after the measured quantity is received from the parent IED, the measured quantities from each of the one or more child IEDs are received prior to receiving a measured quantity from any other IED in the hierarchy.

16. A method of automatically determining a reading order of respective quantities indicative of a characteristic of a utility monitored by intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) arranged in a hierarchy of a utility system, comprising:

receiving a data representation of a hierarchy of the utility system, the hierarchy indicating how a number of intelligent electronic devices (IEDs) are linked to one another in the utility system, each of the IEDs monitoring one or more characteristics of a utility;

identifying, from the hierarchy, a parent IED in the hierarchy that is directly linked to at least one child IED;

identifying, from the hierarchy, all of one or more child IEDs that are directly linked in the hierarchy to the parent IED;

automatically determining a reading order of respective quantities indicative of a characteristic of a utility measured by the IEDs such that, after a measured quantity is received from the parent IED, measured quantities from each of the one or more child IEDs are received prior to receiving a measured quantity from another IED in the hierarchy; and

automatically determining a quantity of a characteristic of a utility attributable to an unmonitored portion of the hierarchy.

17. The method of claim 16, further comprising:

receiving from the parent IED, according to the reading order, a measured quantity, P_P, of the characteristic of the utility measured by the parent IED;

receiving from each of the one or more child IEDs, according to the reading order, respective measured quantities of the characteristic of the utility measured by each of the one or more child IEDs;

adjusting the measured quantities measured by the parent IED and by the one or more child IEDs as a function of respective measurement errors associated with the parent IED and with the one or more child IEDs to produce respective error-adjusted quantities; and

based on the error-adjusted quantities, determining whether an unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system, and, if so, storing the unmonitored quantity and an indication that a virtual device corresponding to the unmonitored quantity is directly linked to the parent IED in the hierarchy.

18. The method of claim 16, further comprising calculating a difference between (a) the error-adjusted quantity associated with the parent IED and (b) the sum of the error-adjusted quantities associated with the one or more child IEDs, wherein the determining whether the unmonitored quantity exists in the utility system includes determining whether the calculated difference is within an error tolerance, and, if not, carrying out the storing.

19. The method of claim 16, wherein the IEDs are power meters, wherein the utility is electricity, and wherein the one or more characteristics includes power, current, or voltage.

20. The method of claim 16, wherein the utility is water, air, gas, electricity, or steam, and wherein the one or more characteristic includes power, voltage, current, voltage distortion, BTU per hour, MBTU per hour, energy, gallons per minute, or cubic feet per minute.