System and method of dynamically prioritized electronic mail graphical user interface, and measuring email productivity and collaboration trends

US 8,161,122 B2
Filed: 11/13/2007
Issued: 04/17/2012
Est. Priority Date: 06/03/2005
Status: Expired due to Fees

First Claim

Patent Images

1. A method for graphical user interface (“

GUI”

) based management of electronic communications, comprising the steps of;

receiving an electronic communication containing a message;

computing a situational prioritization value for an electronic communication dependent on a filter implementing a curve modeling a time-dependent equation representing the message'"'"'s relative priority, where a weight is given to the importance of the type of curve in comparison to other curves, and an efficiency representing the validity of the filter at a particular time, wherein the situational prioritization value is updated during a lifecycle of the electronic communication;

computing an inherent prioritization value for the electronic communication dependent on a first factor based on message attributes, message content analysis, and personal or organizational rules and policies, a second factor representing an importance of the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed, and a third factor representing an estimated accuracy and validity based on an amount of information for the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzes;

wherein the message content analysis includes consideration of;

an intended number of recipients, a status of the message'"'"'s initiator in an organization in which the message initiator is a member, a status of at least one of the message'"'"'s active participant, a number of intermediate paths encountered by the electronic message before being received, at least one keyword in at least one of the subject and body of the message, a formatting of one of the electronic communication and the message and, if present, consideration of a name, file type and content of an attachment or an embedded message;

assigning a dynamic prioritization score to the electronic communication, wherein the dynamic prioritization score is a quantitative metric obtained using an overall combined situational and inherent prioritization model based on the situational prioritization value and the inherent prioritization value, the quantitative metric is based at least on user-defined criteria including a particular instant of time; and

determining a prioritization category for each electronic communication based on the dynamic prioritization score.

View all claims

5 Assignments

Timeline View

Assignment View

0 Petitions

Accused Products

Abstract

A system and method for managing electronic communications more effectively utilizes electronic communications. The method assigns a prioritization score and category to each electronic communication so that a user can more effectively manage the communications. The user interacts with a graphical user interface to effectively manage electronic communications. The system arranges and displays the electronic communications according to prioritization scores and categories, and includes interactive modules to override a system assigned prioritization scores and assign any score or category the user selects. The method also measures productivity of users as a function of at least three different metrics, a decision-making metric; a communication metric; and a processing metric, and takes into account prioritization scores and the amount of time it takes users to effectively utilize the electronic communications. The method also generates reports of the productivity of individual users, and the productivity of relationships between multiple users of electronic communications.

Citations

28 Claims

1. A method for graphical user interface (“
- GUI”
  
  ) based management of electronic communications, comprising the steps of;
  
  receiving an electronic communication containing a message;
  
  computing a situational prioritization value for an electronic communication dependent on a filter implementing a curve modeling a time-dependent equation representing the message'"'"'s relative priority, where a weight is given to the importance of the type of curve in comparison to other curves, and an efficiency representing the validity of the filter at a particular time, wherein the situational prioritization value is updated during a lifecycle of the electronic communication;
  
  computing an inherent prioritization value for the electronic communication dependent on a first factor based on message attributes, message content analysis, and personal or organizational rules and policies, a second factor representing an importance of the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed, and a third factor representing an estimated accuracy and validity based on an amount of information for the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzes;
  
  wherein the message content analysis includes consideration of;
  
  an intended number of recipients, a status of the message'"'"'s initiator in an organization in which the message initiator is a member, a status of at least one of the message'"'"'s active participant, a number of intermediate paths encountered by the electronic message before being received, at least one keyword in at least one of the subject and body of the message, a formatting of one of the electronic communication and the message and, if present, consideration of a name, file type and content of an attachment or an embedded message;
  
  assigning a dynamic prioritization score to the electronic communication, wherein the dynamic prioritization score is a quantitative metric obtained using an overall combined situational and inherent prioritization model based on the situational prioritization value and the inherent prioritization value, the quantitative metric is based at least on user-defined criteria including a particular instant of time; and
  
  determining a prioritization category for each electronic communication based on the dynamic prioritization score.
- View Dependent Claims (2, 3)
- - 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the prioritization category comprises graphical images.
  - 3. The method of claim 1, wherein the prioritization category comprises color codes.

4. A GUI system for managing electronic communications, comprising:
- a computer configured to operate a prioritization engine that assigns a prioritization score and a prioritization category to each electronic communication;
  
  the prioritization engine further configured to;
  
  compute a situational prioritization value for the electronic communication dependent on a filter implementing a curve modeling a time-dependent equation representing a message'"'"'s relative priority, where a weight is given to the importance of the type of curve in comparison to other curves, and an efficiency representing the validity of the filter at a particular time, wherein the situational prioritization value is updated during a lifecycle of the electronic communication;
  
  compute an inherent prioritization value for the electronic communication dependent on a first factor based on message attributes, message content analysis, and personal or organizational rules and policies, a second factor representing an importance of the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed, and a third factor representing an estimated accuracy and validity based on an amount of information for the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed;
  
  wherein the message content analysis includes consideration of;
  
  an intended number of recipients, a status of the message'"'"'s initiator in the organization, a status of at least one of the message'"'"'s active participant, a number of intermediate paths encountered by the electronic message before being received, at lease one keyword in at least one of the subject and body of the message, a formatting of one of the electronic communication and the message and, if present, consideration of a name, file type and content of an attachment or an embedded message;
  
  assign a dynamic prioritization score to the electronic communication, wherein the dynamic prioritization score is a quantitative metric obtained using an overall combined situational and inherent prioritization model based on the situational prioritization value and the inherent prioritization model based on the situational prioritization value and the inherent prioritization value, the quantitative metric is based at least on user-defined criteria including a particular instant of time;
  
  a database configured to store the prioritization score; and
  
  the computer further controlling an interactive module configured to provide a user interaction to allow a user to assign a user-defined prioritization score to any of the plurality of the electronic communications;
  
  wherein the electronic communications are arranged and displayed in GUI description.
- View Dependent Claims (5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19)
- - 5. The system of claim 4, wherein the prioritization score is based on a system-calculated prioritization score.
  - 6. The system of claim 5, wherein the user can use a single click to provide the user-defined prioritization score which overrides the system-calculated prioritization score, and the user-defined prioritization score is used in determining the prioritization score.
  - 7. The system of claim 6, wherein the database stores the overridden prioritization score based on the system-calculated prioritization score so that the user can reset the prioritization score of an electronic communication back to the overridden prioritization score based on the system-calculated prioritization score.
  - 8. The system of claim 5, wherein user action provides feedback to the prioritization engine which the prioritization engine uses in assigning prioritization scores and categories.
  - 9. The system of claim 4, further comprising:
    - a set of folders customizable according to a set of time duration and workflow rules; and
      
      wherein the GUI depiction displays a prioritization category of each of the plurality of electronic communications.
  - 10. The system of claim 4, wherein the interactive module further comprises a feature where the user may assign a prioritization category for a sender or a recipient of an electronic communication.
  - 11. The system of claim 10, wherein the interactive module further comprises a lock function allowing the user to select a prioritization category for a given sender or a given recipient so that all electronic communications with the given sender or the given recipient is assigned the user selected prioritization category.
  - 12. The system of claim 4, wherein the interactive module further comprises a plurality of single-click workflow action buttons that allow the user to take a plurality of actions in response to at least one of the electronic communications and update the system according to the user interaction.
  - 13. The system of claim 12, wherein the plurality of single-click workflow action buttons comprises a “
    - Defer”
      
      function, allowing the user to select a date by which to respond to the electronic communication.
  - 14. The system of claim 12, wherein the plurality of single-click workflow action buttons comprises a “
    - To Do”
      
      function, allowing the user to mark the electronic communication so that the user is reminded to take action in response to the electronic communication.
  - 15. The system of claim 12, wherein the plurality of single-click workflow action buttons comprises a “
    - Complete”
      
      function, allowing the user to mark that an action associated with at least one of the electronic communications has been completed and the electronic communication is moved to a Completed Items folder or a prioritized archiving system, or any other processing specified by the user.
  - 16. The system of claim 12, wherein the plurality of single-click workflow action buttons comprises a quick action function, allowing the user to select one of a plurality of canned responses, wherein a type of response and content of response are customizable by the user.
  - 17. The system of claim 16, wherein the plurality of canned responses includes at least one of “
    - Call Me” and
      
      “
      
      See Me.”
  - 18. The system of claim 4, wherein the plurality of electronic communications are archived in different folders based on the prioritization score of the communication.
  - 19. The system of claim 4, further comprising a search function that arranges a result of a search based on the prioritization score of the electronic communication where the result was found.

20. A method for determining a productivity score for an individual'"'"'s use of electronic communications, comprising the steps of:
- computing a situational prioritization value for an electronic communication dependent on a filter implementing a curve modeling a time-dependent equation representing a message'"'"'s relative priority, where a weight is given to the importance of the type of curve in comparison to other curves, and an efficiency representing the validity of the filter at a particular time, wherein the situational prioritization value is updated during a lifecycle of the electronic communication;
  
  computing an inherent prioritization value for the electronic communication dependent on a first factor based on message attributes, message content analysis, and personal or organizational rules and policies, a second factor representing an importance of the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed, and a third factor representing an estimated accuracy and validity based on an amount of information for the message'"'"'s dimension being analyzed;
  
  wherein the message content analysis includes consideration of;
  
  an intended number of recipients, a status of the message'"'"'s initiator in an organization in which the message initiator is a member, a status of at least one of the message'"'"'s active participant, a number of intermediate paths encountered by the electronic message before being received, at least one keyword in at least one of the subject and body of the message, a formatting of one of the electronic communication and the message and, if present, consideration of a name, file type and content of an attachment or an embedded message;
  
  assigning a prioritization score to each of a plurality of electronic communications, wherein the dynamic prioritization score is a quantitative metric obtained using an overall combined situational and inherent prioritization model based on the situational prioritization value and the inherent prioritization value, the quantitative metric is based at least on user-defined criteria including a particular instant of time;
  
  determining a prioritization category for each of the plurality of electronic communications based on the prioritization score;
  
  determining values for at least a decision-making metric, a processing metric and a communication metric based on the individual'"'"'s use of electronic communications; and
  
  calculating the productivity score as a function of at least one of the decision-making, the processing metric, and communication metric.
- View Dependent Claims (21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28)
- - 21. The method of claim 20, wherein the productivity score is calculated according to the following:
    - function(Email Productivity)_T=function(working on email in decreasing order of email priority)_T;
      
      wherein T is a period of time over which the measure of productivity is measured.
  - 22. The method of claim 20, wherein the decision-making metric comprises:
    - a calculation based on the prioritization score associated with an electronic communication;
      
      a length of time taken by the individual to complete an action associated with the electronic communication; and
      
      prioritization scores associated with electronic communications upon which the user has not completed an action.
  - 23. The method of claim 22, wherein the decision-making metric is calculated according to the following:
    - R_D=function(S_D,M_D)×
      
      100;
      
      $S_{D} = (\frac{\sum_{p > n}^{w} (Number of email COMPLETE)}{\sum_{p > n}^{w} (Number of email for TO - DO)}) \times (\frac{\sum_{p = n}^{n} (Number of email COMPLETE)}{\sum_{p = n}^{n} (Number of email for TO - DO)})$
      M_D=function(t_D/t_Davg);
      
      wherein t_Dis an Actual Time to Complete an email;
      
      wherein t_Davg is an Overall Average Time to Complete based on T1, whereinT1 is a number of days a given prioritization category email is kept in a respective Prioritized View Folder;
      
      wherein M_Dis efficiency;
      
      wherein R_Dis the decision-making metric;
      
      wherein S_Dis the effectiveness;
      
      n is the prioritization category of an electronic communication completed;
      
      p is the prioritization category;
      
      w is a positive integer;
      
      wherein Σ
      
      (number of email COMPLETE) is a cumulative number of emails set to COMPLETE in duration of T;
      
      wherein Σ
      
      (number of email TO-DO) is a cumulative number of emails which are set to TO-DO in a duration T;
      
      T is a duration (T2−
      
      T1), T2 being an instant of time when a user marked a given email to COMPLETE; and
      
      wherein integers p, n, and w are based on a numerical value of the prioritization category of the email, and the integer w is a maximum on the numerical value of the email prioritization category.
  - 24. The method of claim 20, wherein the processing metric comprises:
    - a calculation based on the prioritization score associated with an electronic communication;
      
      a length of time taken by the individual to read the electronic communication; and
      
      prioritization scores associated with unread electronic communications.
  - 25. The method of claim 24, wherein the processing metric is calculated according to the following:
    - R_D=function(S_D,M_D)×
      
      100;
      
      $S_{D} = (\frac{\sum_{p > n}^{w} (Number of email READ)}{\sum_{p > n}^{w} (Number email RECEIVED)}) \times (\frac{\sum_{p = n}^{n} (Number of email READ)}{\sum_{p = n}^{n} (Number email RECEIVED)})$
      M_D=function(t_D/t_Davg);
      
      wherein t_Dis an Actual Time to read an email;
      
      wherein t_Davg is an Overall Average Time to read based on T1, wherein T1 is a number of days a given prioritization category email is kept in a respective Prioritized View Folder;
      
      wherein M_Dis efficiency;
      
      wherein R_Dis the processing metric;
      
      wherein S_Dis the effectiveness;
      
      n is the prioritization category of an electronic communication read;
      
      p is the prioritization category;
      
      w is a positive integer;
      
      wherein Σ
      
      (number of email COMPLETE) is a cumulative number of emails set to READ in duration of T;
      
      wherein Σ
      
      (number of email TO-DO) is a cumulative number of emails which are set to RECEIVED in a duration T;
      
      T is a duration (T2−
      
      T1), T2 being an instant of time when a user marked a given email to READ; and
      
      wherein integers p, n, and w are based on a numerical value of the prioritization category of the email, and the integer w is a maximum on the numerical value of the email prioritization category.
  - 26. The method of claim 20, wherein the communication metric comprises:
    - a calculation based on the prioritization score associated with an electronic communication;
      
      a length of time taken by the individual to respond to the electronic communication;
      
      prioritization scores associated with electronic communications not yet responded to.
  - 27. The method of claim 26, wherein the communication metric is calculated according to the following:
    - R_C=function(S_C,M_C,Ac)×
      
      100;
      
      M_C=function(t_D/t_Davg),wherein R_Cis the communication metric;
      
      wherein S_Cis effectiveness, and a value of Sc is a function of the numerical value of one of the prioritization category and the prioritization score;
      
      wherein A_Cis a same email thread efficiency, and a value of A_Cis a function of a number of email sent on the same thread to the same sender in a duration of T_Chours, wherein T_Cis based on a user-behavior specific and a user'"'"'s work environment specific factors;
      
      wherein M_Cis efficiency and a value of M_Cis a function of t/t avg, and Actual Time (t) to reply and an Overall Average Time (t avg) to reply to an email for one of a corresponding prioritization category and a corresponding prioritization score;
      
      wherein t_Cis an Actual Time to reply to an email; and
      
      wherein t_Cavg is an Overall Average Time to reply based on T1, wherein T1 is a number.
  - 28. The method of claim 20, wherein the productivity score is computed according to the following:
    - wherein W is a weight defined as a long-term effectiveness of a filter in productivity;
      
      wherein R is a result defined as a productivity score given to each message by a dimension analysis;
      
      wherein E is an efficiency defined as certainty regarding measure the accuracy of the result;
      
      Productivity f(Decision Making)=f(W_D, R_D, E_D);
      
      Productivity f(Processing)=f(W_P, R_P, E_P);
      
      Productivity f(Communication)=f(W_C, R_C, E_C); and

Specification

Resources

Litigation Campaign Assessment

Current Assignee
MessageMind LLC
Original Assignee
MessageMind LLC
Inventors
Ruan, Cheng-Rong, Oberrotman, Alain, Sood, Manish Chander
Primary Examiner(s)
MACILWINEN, JOHN MOORE JAIN

Application Number

US11/939,396
Publication Number

US 20080126951A1
Time in Patent Office

1,617 Days
Field of Search

709/206
US Class Current

709/206
CPC Class Codes

G06Q 10/107 Computer-aided management o...

H04L 51/226 Delivery according to prior...

System and method of dynamically prioritized electronic mail graphical user interface, and measuring email productivity and collaboration trends

First Claim

5 Assignments

0 Petitions

Accused Products

Abstract

Citations

28 Claims

Specification

Solutions

Use Cases

Quick Links

System and method of dynamically prioritized electronic mail graphical user interface, and measuring email productivity and collaboration trends

First Claim

5 Assignments

Subscription Required

Subscription Required

0 Petitions

Subscription Required

Accused Products

Subscription Required

Abstract

Citations

28 Claims

Specification

Subscription Required

Solutions

Use Cases

Quick Links