Systems and methods for inter-system sharing of satellite communications frequencies within a common footprint

• US 8,238,819 B2
• Filed: 09/21/2011
• Issued: 08/07/2012
• Est. Priority Date: 09/11/2003
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: ATC Technology Corporation (FedEx Corporation)
• Original Assignee: ATC Technology Corporation (FedEx Corporation)
• Inventors: Karabinis, Peter D.
• Primary Examiner(s): DOAN, PHUOC HUU
• Application Number:
  US13/238,480
• Publication Number:
  US 20120009920A1
• Time in Patent Office: 321 Days
• Field of Search: 455/13.2, 455/12.1, 455/13.1, 455/454, 455/427, 343/895, 370/338
• US Class Current: 455/12.1
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 7/18513 Transmission in a satellite or space-based system
• CPC Class Codes: Y02D 30/70 in wireless communication networks

Abstract

Two satellite communications systems can use the same frequency or frequencies in geographically overlapping footprints, without creating undue interference in a given system that is caused by the same frequency signal(s) that is/are used by the other system. In particular, an aggregate Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP) of the radioterminals and/or ancillary terrestrial components of a second satellite communications system in the common footprint is sufficiently low, and/or the receive antenna gain of a first satellite communications system is sufficiently low compared to the receive antenna gain of the second satellite communications system, so as to increase an aggregate receiver noise that is seen by the first satellite system receivers by an amount that does not substantially change a Quality of Service (QoS) of the first satellite communications system.

Claims

1. A frequency sharing system comprising:

a first satellite that communicates with first radioterminals using frequencies of a frequency band in a first service region; and

a second satellite that communicates with second radioterminals using frequencies of the frequency band in a second service region that is contained within the first service region,

wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite, the first satellite communicates with the first radioterminals by transmitting and receiving electro-magnetic energy of a first polarization, the second satellite communicates with the second radioterminals by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a second polarization and at least one of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a third polarization, wherein the first, second and third polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

2. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals is sufficiently low so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

3. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals is sufficiently low and a receive antenna gain of the first satellite is sufficiently low such that the aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals does not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

4. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals increases a noise level at the first satellite by about 3.5% or less.

5. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein a system that includes the second satellite also provides terrestrial communications between radioterminals and at least one ancillary terrestrial component using frequencies of the frequency band in the second service region.

6. A frequency sharing system according to claim 5 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the radioterminals and/or the at least one ancillary terrestrial component is sufficiently low so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

7. A frequency sharing system according to claim 5 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the radioterminals and/or the at least one ancillary terrestrial component increases a noise level at the first satellite by about 6.75% or less.

8. A frequency sharing system according to claim 5 in combination with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component.

9. A frequency sharing system according to claim 5 wherein at least one radioterminal of the second radioterminals communicates with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component and with the second satellite by radiating substantially linearly polarized electromagnetic energy.

10. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein the second service region is spaced apart from a waterway.

11. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein the second service region is spaced apart from a waterway by at least twice a width of a spot beam of the second satellite.

12. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 in combination with the radioterminals.

13. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is at least about 20 dB greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite.

14. A frequency sharing system according to claim 1 wherein at least one radioterminal of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite using a Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) waveform and/or any other waveform producing an interference at the first satellite that is substantially similar to interference produced at the first satellite by the CDMA waveform.

15. A frequency sharing system according to claim 14 wherein the Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) waveform is a Wideband Code division Multiple Access (W-CDMA) waveform.

16. A frequency sharing system comprising:

a plurality of first radioterminals that communicate with a first satellite at a first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power using frequencies of a frequency band in a service region; and

a plurality of second radioterminals that communicate with a second satellite at a second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power that is less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power using frequencies of the frequency band in the service region,

wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite, the first satellite communicates with the first radioterminals by transmitting and receiving electro-magnetic energy of a first polarization, the second satellite communicates with the second radioterminals by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a second polarization and at least one of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a third polarization, wherein the first, second and third polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

17. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power is sufficiently low so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

18. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power increases a noise level at the first satellite by about 3.5% or less.

19. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein at least some of the plurality of second radioterminals also communicate terrestrially with at least one ancillary terrestrial component in the service region using frequencies of the frequency band.

20. A frequency sharing system according to claim 19 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power, an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least one ancillary terrestrial component and/or an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least some of the plurality of second radioterminals that also communicate terrestrially with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component is/are sufficiently less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

21. A frequency sharing system according to claim 19 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power, an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least one ancillary terrestrial component and/or an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least some of the plurality of second radioterminals that also communicate terrestrially with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component increase a noise level at the first satellite by about 6.75% or less.

22. A frequency sharing system according to claim 19 in combination with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component.

23. A frequency sharing system according to claim 19 wherein at least one radioterminal of the plurality of second radioterminals communicates with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component and with the second satellite by radiating substantially linearly polarized electromagnetic energy.

24. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein a footprint of the second satellite in a footprint of the first satellite is spaced apart from a waterway.

25. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein a footprint of the second satellite in a footprint of the first satellite is spaced apart from a waterway by at least twice a width of a spot beam of the second satellite.

26. A frequency sharing system according to claim 16 wherein at least one radioterminal of the plurality of second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite using a Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) waveform and/or any other waveform producing an interference at the first satellite that is substantially similar to interference produced at the first satellite by the CDMA waveform.

27. A frequency sharing method for a first satellite that communicates with first radioterminals using frequencies of a frequency band in a first service region, the method comprising:

communicating between second radioterminals and a second satellite using frequencies of the frequency band in a second service region that is contained within the first service region,

wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite, the first satellite communicates with the first radioterminals by transmitting and receiving electro-magnetic energy of a first polarization, the second satellite communicates with the second radioterminals by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a second polarization and at least one of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a third polarization, wherein the first, second and third polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

28. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals is sufficiently low so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of the first satellite.

29. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals is sufficiently low and a receive antenna gain of the first satellite is sufficiently low such that the aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals does not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

30. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals is sufficiently low so as to increase a noise level at the first satellite by about 3.5% or less.

31. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 further comprising:

communicating terrestrially between at least some of the second radioterminals and at least one ancillary terrestrial component using frequencies of the frequency band in the second service region.

32. A frequency sharing method according to claim 31 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals and/or the at least one ancillary terrestrial component is sufficiently low so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

33. A frequency sharing method according to claim 31 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals and/or the at least one ancillary terrestrial component is sufficiently low so as to increase a noise level at the first satellite by about 6.75% or less.

34. A frequency sharing method according to claim 31 wherein at least one radioterminal of the second radioterminals communicates with the at least one ancillary terrestrial component and with the second satellite by radiating substantially linearly polarized electromagnetic energy.

35. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein the second service region is spaced apart from a waterway.

36. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein the second service region is spaced apart from a waterway by at least twice a width of a spot beam of the second satellite.

37. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is at least about 20 dB greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite.

38. A frequency sharing method according to claim 27 wherein at least one radioterminal of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite using a Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) waveform and/or any other waveform producing an interference at the first satellite that is substantially similar to interference produced at the first satellite by the CDMA waveform.

39. A frequency sharing method for a plurality of first radioterminals that communicate with a first satellite using frequencies of a frequency band in a service region at a first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power, the method comprising:

communicating between a plurality of second radioterminals and a second satellite using frequencies of the frequency band in the service region at a second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power that is less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power,

wherein an antenna gain of the second satellite is greater than an antenna gain of the first satellite, the first satellite communicates with the first radioterminals by transmitting and receiving electro-magnetic energy of a first polarization, the second satellite communicates with the second radioterminals by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a second polarization and at least one of the second radioterminals communicates with the second satellite by transmitting electro-magnetic energy of a third polarization, wherein the first, second and third polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

40. A frequency sharing method according to claim 39 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power is sufficiently less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

41. A frequency sharing method according to claim 39 wherein the second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power increases a noise level at the first satellite by about 3.5% or less.

42. A frequency sharing method according to claim 39 further comprising:

communicating terrestrially between at least some of the second radioterminals and at least one ancillary terrestrial component using frequencies of the frequency band in the service region.

43. A frequency sharing method according to claim 42 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals and/or an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least one ancillary terrestrial component is sufficiently less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power so as to not substantially degrade a quality of service of communications being provided by the first satellite.

44. A frequency sharing method according to claim 42 wherein an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the second radioterminals and/or an aggregate effective isotropic radiated power of the at least one ancillary terrestrial component increases a noise level at the first satellite by about 6.75% or less.

45. A frequency sharing method according to claim 39 wherein a footprint of the second satellite is spaced apart from a waterway.

46. A frequency sharing method according to claim 39 wherein a footprint of the second satellite is spaced apart from a waterway by at least twice a width of a spot beam of the second satellite.

47. A frequency sharing system comprising:

a first satellite that communicates with first radioterminals in a first service region over a global beam using frequencies of a frequency band; and

a second satellite that communicates with second radioterminals in a second service region that is contained within the first service region over one or more spot beams using frequencies of the frequency band,

wherein at least some of the first radioterminals communicate with the first satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a first polarization and at least some of the second radioterminals communicate with the second satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a second polarization, wherein the first and second polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

48. A frequency sharing system comprising:

a plurality of first radioterminals that communicate with a first satellite over a global beam at a first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power using frequencies of a frequency band in a service region; and

a plurality of second radioterminals that communicate with a second satellite over one or more spot beams at a second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power that is less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power using frequencies of the frequency band in the service region,

wherein at least some of the plurality of first radioterminals communicate with the first satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a first polarization and at least some of the plurality of second radioterminals communicate with the second satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a second polarization, wherein the first and second polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

49. A frequency sharing method for a first satellite that communicates with first radioterminals over a global beam using frequencies of a frequency band in a first service region, the method comprising:

communicating between second radioterminals and a second satellite over one or more spot beams using frequencies of the frequency band in a second service region that is contained within the first service region,

wherein at least some of the first radioterminals communicate with the first satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a first polarization and at least some of the second radioterminals communicate with the second satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a second polarization, wherein the first and second polarizations are different polarizations from one another.

50. A frequency sharing method for a plurality of first radioterminals that communicate with a first satellite over a global beam using frequencies of a frequency band in a service region at a first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power, the method comprising:

communicating between a plurality of second radioterminals and a second satellite over one or more spot beams using frequencies of the frequency band in the service region at a second aggregate effective isotropic radiated power that is less than the first aggregate effective isotropic radiated power,

wherein at least some of the first radioterminals communicate with the first satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a first polarization and at least some of the second radioterminals communicate with the second satellite by radiating electromagnetic energy of a second polarization, wherein the first and second polarizations are different polarizations from one another.