Electronic learning system

• US 8,506,305 B2
• Filed: 12/23/2008
• Issued: 08/13/2013
• Est. Priority Date: 12/23/2008
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Deck Chair Learning Systems Inc.
• Original Assignee: Deck Chair Learning Systems Inc.
• Inventors: Sura, Allan A., Graham, David Jeffrey
• Primary Examiner(s): Thai, Xuan
• Assistant Examiner(s): Zaman, Sadaruz
• Application Number:
  US12/342,281
• Publication Number:
  US 20100159433A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,694 Days
• Field of Search: 434/118, 434/322, 434/323, 434350-353, 434/362, 434/363
• US Class Current: 434/323
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/00 Electrically-operated teaching apparatus or devices working with questions and answers mechanically operated G09B3/00; computing arrangements G06F
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/08 characterised by modifying the teaching programme in response to a wrong answer, e.g. repeating the question, supplying further information

Abstract

A question item comprising: textual, visual or auditory subject matter; a query or instruction pertaining to the subject matter; and a representation of a response mechanism for receiving a user response to the query or instruction, may be retrieved from a data store. The subject matter, query or instruction and response mechanism may be presented in a presentation sequence, wherein a presentation duration of each of the subject matter, query or instruction and response mechanism is controlled by user input. Based on the user input, a presentation duration of each of the subject matter, query or instruction, and response mechanism may be determined. Each of the three presentation durations may be stored. A completion time may be determined based on one or more of the presentation durations and may be stored along with response accuracy, for use in calculating a user competency measure for the question item. An algorithm for advancing through an electronic learning curriculum comprising multiple question items may also be provided.

Claims

1. A non-transitory machine-readable medium storing instructions for presenting a question item of an electronic learning curriculum, said instructions, when executed by a processor of a computing device, causing said computing device to:

(a) retrieve from a data store a question item comprising;

textual, visual or auditory subject matter;

a query or instruction pertaining to said subject matter; and

a representation of a response mechanism for receiving a user response to said query or instruction;

(b) present said subject matter, said query or instruction and said response mechanism in a presentation sequence, wherein a presentation duration of each of said subject matter, said query or instruction and said response mechanism in said presentation sequence is controlled by, and is measured on the basis of, user input for advancing through the presentation sequence;

(c) based on said user input, determine;

a presentation duration of said subject matter by measuring a duration of display of the subject matter;

a presentation duration of said query or instruction by measuring a duration of display of the query or instruction; and

a presentation duration of said response mechanism by measuring a duration of display of the response mechanism;

(d) store indicators of each of said three presentation durations;

(e) receive a user response to said query or instruction via said response mechanism;

(f) ascertain a response accuracy based on said response and at least one predetermined correct response;

(g) determine a completion time for said question item based on one or more of said presentation duration of said subject matter, said presentation duration of said query or instruction and said presentation duration of said response mechanism; and

(h) store said response accuracy and said completion time for said current trial,

wherein said instructions cause said computing device to present said question item S times by performing (b)-(h) for each of S trials, S being an integer greater than one, and to;

(i) calculate an average response accuracy for said question item based on the stored response accuracies of said S trials;

(j) calculate an average completion time for said question item based on the stored completion times of only the ones of said S trials in which a correct user response was given;

(k) calculate a relative average completion time for said question item based on said average completion time and either one or both of a predetermined minimum completion time for said question item and a predetermined maximum completion time for said question item; and

(I) calculate a user competency measure for said question item based on said average response accuracy and said relative average completion time.

2. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating said average response accuracy comprises calculating a weighted average of the S stored response accuracies by weighting stored response accuracies of more recent trials more heavily than stored response accuracies of less recent trials.

3. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating said average completion time comprises calculating a weighted average of stored completion times by weighting stored completion times of more recent trials more heavily than stored completion times of less recent trials.

4. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to:

redetermine said completion time in (g) for each of said S trials based on a different one or more of said presentation duration of said subject matter, said presentation duration of said query or instruction and said presentation duration of said response mechanism;

store said redetermined completion times for said S trials; and

perform (j), (k) and (I) based on said stored redetermined completion times of said S trials.

5. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating said relative average completion time comprises dividing a computed difference between said predetermined maximum completion time and said average completion time by a computed difference between said predetermined maximum completion time and said predetermined minimum completion time, said dividing resulting in a quotient, and exponentiating said quotient.

6. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating said relative average completion time comprises dividing said predetermined minimum completion time by said average completion time, said dividing resulting in a quotient, and exponentiating said quotient.

7. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating said relative average completion time comprises computing a difference between one and a quotient, said quotient computed by dividing said average completion time by said predetermined maximum completion time, and exponentiating said difference.

8. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said calculating a user competency measure comprises scaling said response accuracy by a first scalar value, scaling said relative completion time by a second scalar value, and summing the scaled results.

9. The machine-readable medium of claim 1 wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to perform (a)-(I) for each of a plurality of question items of a question item set and to calculate a collective user competency measure for said question item set based on the stored user competency measures of each of said plurality of question items comprising said set.

10. The machine-readable medium of claim 9 wherein said calculating said collective user competency measure comprises calculating an average user competency measure for the question item set.

11. The machine-readable medium of claim 10 wherein said calculating said collective user competency measure further comprises combining said calculated average user competency measure with a previously calculated average competency measure for said question item set.

12. The machine-readable medium of claim 11 wherein said combining of said calculated average user competency measure with said previously calculated average user competency measure comprises weighting said average user competency measure more heavily than said previously calculated average user competency measure.

13. The machine-readable medium of claim 9 wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to perform said calculating of a collective user competency measure for other question item sets and to select for repeated presentation the question item set whose collective user competency measure is closest to but below a threshold competency measure.

14. The machine-readable medium of claim 13 wherein said threshold is a first threshold and wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to, if the collective user competency measure for all question item sets meets or exceeds said first threshold but the collective user competency measure any question item set is below a second threshold that is higher than said first threshold, select for repeated presentation the question item set whose collective user competency measure is lowest.

15. The machine-readable medium of claim 9 wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to perform said calculating of a collective user competency measure for other question item sets and , if the collective user competency measure for any question item set is below a threshold, to select for repeated presentation the question item set whose collective user competency measure is lowest.

16. The machine-readable medium of claim 9 wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to perform said calculating of a collective user competency measure for other question item sets and, if the collective user competency measure for any question item set is below a threshold, to selected for repeated presentation N question items whose user competency measures are the lowest, where N is a positive integer and wherein said N question items are drawn from any of said question item sets.

17. The machine-readable medium of claim 16 herein said instructions further cause said computing device to select for repeated presentation M question items whose user competency measures meet or exceed said threshold, where M is a positive integer that is different from or the same as N and wherein said M question items are drawn from any of said question item sets.

18. A computing device having a processor in communication with memory storing instructions for presenting a question item of an electronic learning curriculum which, when executed by said processor, cause said computing device to:

(a) retrieve from a data store a question item comprising;

textual, visual or auditory subject matter;

a query or instruction pertaining to said subject matter; and

a representation of a response mechanism for receiving a user response to said query or instruction;

(b) present said subject matter, said query or instruction and said response mechanism in a presentation sequence, wherein a presentation duration of each of said subject matter, said query or instruction and said response mechanism in said presentation sequence is controlled by, and is measured on the basis of, user input for advancing through the presentation sequence, wherein said presentation sequence comprises;

i) presenting one of said subject matter and said query or instruction;

then

(ii) presenting the other of said subject matter and said query or instruction;

then

(iii) presenting said response mechanism;

(c) based on said user input, determine;

a presentation duration of said subject matter by measuring a duration of display of the subject matter;

a presentation duration of said query or instruction by measuring a duration of display of the subject matter; and

a presentation duration of said response mechanism by measuring a duration of display of the subject matter;

(d) store indicators of each of said three presentation durations,

(e) receive a user response to said query or instruction via said response mechanism;

(f) ascertain a response accuracy based on said response and at least one predetermined correct response;

(g) determine a completion time for said question item based on one or more of said presentation duration of said subject matter, said presentation duration of said query or instruction and said presentation duration of said response mechanism; and

(h) store said response accuracy and said completion time for said current trial,

wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to present said question item S times by performing (b)-(h) for each of S trials, S being an integer greater than one, and to;

(i) calculate an average response accuracy for said question item based on the stored response accuracies of said S trials;

(j) calculate an average completion time for said question item based on the stored completion times of only the ones of said S trials in which a correct user response was given;

(k) calculate a relative average completion time for said question item based on said average completion time and either one or both of a predetermined minimum completion time for said question item and a predetermined maximum completion time for said question item; and

(I) calculate a user competency measure for said question item based on said average response accuracy and said relative average completion time.

19. A non-transitory machine-readable medium storing instructions that, when executed by a processor of a computing device, cause said computing device to:

(a) calculate a user competency measure for each question item in each of a plurality of question item sets comprising an electronic learning curriculum, said calculating being based on an average response accuracy for said question item and an average completion time for said question item over a plurality of trials;

(b) for each question item set of said plurality, calculate a collective user competency measure for the set based on the user competency measures of the question items of said set; and

(c) automatically select for repeated presentation the question item set whose collective user competency measure is closest to but below a threshold.

20. The machine-readable medium of claim 19 wherein said threshold is a first threshold and wherein said instructions further cause said computing device to, if the collective user competency measure for all of said question item sets meets or exceeds said first threshold but the collective user competency measure of any of said question item sets is below a second threshold that is higher than said first threshold, select for presentation the question item set whose collective user competency measure is lowest.