Method and apparatus for accurate estimation and disbursement in a reverse distribution environment

• US 8,719,048 B1
• Filed: 09/09/2009
• Issued: 05/06/2014
• Est. Priority Date: 09/09/2009
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Returns 'R' US LLC
• Original Assignee: Returns R. US, Inc.
• Inventors: Zaccaro, Michael J., Malecki, David
• Primary Examiner(s): RANGREJ, SHEETAL
• Application Number:
  US12/556,391
• Time in Patent Office: 1,700 Days
• Field of Search: 705 2- 3
• US Class Current: 705/2
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/06 Resources, workflows, human or project management; Enterprise or organisation planning; Enterprise or organisation modelling
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/08 Logistics, e.g. warehousing, loading or distribution; Inventory or stock management
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/30 Administration of product recycling or disposal
• CPC Class Codes: Y02W 90/00 Enabling technologies or technologies with a potential or indirect contribution to greenhouse gas [GHG] emissions mitigation

Abstract

An efficient and accurate technique for facilitating reverse distribution of pharmaceutical items between customers and manufacturers includes receiving, from the customers, pharmaceutical items returnable for credit to the corresponding manufacturers, identifying similar items based on the national drug code and possibly other criteria to define line items, grouping items according to manufacturer identity, and sending the items to the appropriate manufacturers. The technique further includes receiving credit memoranda from the manufacturers specifying the amount of credit due for the returned items, generating actual amount payable for each item based on the line items and the credit memoranda, and generating disbursement statements for the customers.

Claims

1. A method implemented by a third party for conducting reverse distribution of pharmaceutical items between a plurality of customers and a set of manufacturers, the method comprising:

receiving at the third party a respective multiplicity of pharmaceutical items from each of the plurality of customers to obtain an aggregate set of pharmaceutical items, wherein at least several in the aggregate set of pharmaceutical items are returnable for credit to respective ones in the set of manufacturers;

associating each pharmaceutical item with one of the respective customers;

identifying similar items in each multiplicity of pharmaceutical items to define a plurality of line items, wherein the similar items are associated with a same national drug code (NDC), lot number, and expiration date, and wherein each line item defines a number of the similar items associated with one or more customers;

grouping items in the aggregate set of pharmaceutical items according to a manufacturer identity identifying a respective one in the set of manufacturers;

sending the aggregate set of pharmaceutical items to the set of manufacturers;

receiving at the third party a credit memorandum issued by each manufacturer included in the set of manufacturers, wherein each credit memorandum indicates an amount payable by the manufacturer for each of the pharmaceutical items in the aggregate set returned to the manufacturer;

retrieving the previously defined line items associated with each of the plurality of customers;

calculating an actual amount payable for each of the retrieved line items to the respective customers based on the amount payable by the manufacturer for each of the pharmaceutical items returned as indicated by the credit memorandum and based on the pharmaceutical items that define the respective line items; and

generating a disbursement statement for each of the plurality of customers based on the calculated actual amounts payable, wherein the disbursement statements provide each respective customer with a precise accounting for the actual amount payable by the manufacture for the pharmaceutical items received from that customer;

wherein each of the steps of identifying similar items, grouping items in the aggregate set, sending the aggregate set, retrieving the line items, calculating the amount payable, and generating the disbursement statement is performed by the third party.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising prior to sending the aggregate set:

sorting each multiplicity of pharmaceutical items based on the manufacturer identity; and

sorting each multiplicity of pharmaceutical items based on the plurality of item categories.

3. The method of claim 1, further comprising generating a plurality of database records for the respective ones of the plurality of line items, wherein each of the plurality of database records stores at least:

an item identity specifying a respective one of the plurality of item categories;

an identity of the one of plurality of customers associated with the line item; and

a quantity of items in the aggregate set of pharmaceutical items associated with the line item.

4. The method of claim 1, further comprising generating a refund estimate as a set of item refund estimates for a selected one of the plurality of customers, wherein each in the set of item refund estimates corresponds to one of the plurality of line items and one of the plurality of item categories, and wherein generating an item refund estimate includes:

storing historical refund data specifying previous amounts of credit received for the one of the plurality of item categories;

retrieving a refund rule that specifies a refund policy for the one of the plurality of item categories;

applying the refund rule to generate an initial refund estimate; and

adjusting the initial refund estimate using the historical refund data.

5. The method of claim 1, further comprising:

separating the grouped items into class-of-trade sets according to a respective class of trade of each of the grouped items, wherein each class of trade is associated with a respective one of a plurality of pricing strategies; and

wherein

sending the aggregate set of pharmaceutical items includes separately sending each class-of-trade set.

6. The method of claim 1, further comprising adjusting the historical refund data based on the obtained actual amounts if the historical refund data does not match the respective actual amounts.

7. A method implemented by a third party for calculating an amount of credit due to each of a plurality of customers for a respective multiplicity of pharmaceutical items returnable to at least one manufacturer, wherein the multiplicity of pharmaceutical items associated with the plurality of customers defines an aggregate set;

the method comprising;

associating each of the pharmaceutical items with one of the respective customers;

defining a plurality of line items as computer-readable data, wherein each of the plurality of line items corresponds to one of the plurality of customers and one or more similar items in the aggregate set;

storing the plurality of line items in a computer-readable memory;

receiving a credit memorandum corresponding to the aggregate set, wherein the credit memorandum is issued by the at least one manufacturer and is indicative of an amount payable by the at least one manufacturer for each pharmaceutical item in the aggregate set; and

generating a respective disbursement statement for each of the plurality of customers based on the amount payable by the at least one manufacturer for each pharmaceutical item as indicated by the credit memorandum and the plurality of line items, wherein each disbursement statement specifies the amount of credit due to a respective one of the plurality of customers based on the amount payable for each pharmaceutical item corresponding to each line item thereby providing the customer with a precise accounting for the actual amount payable by the manufacture for the pharmaceutical items received from that customer;

wherein each of the steps of defining the plurality of line items, storing the plurality of line items, receiving a credit memorandum, and generating the disbursements is performed by the third party.

8. The method of claim 7, wherein the one or more similar items are associated with a same national drug code (NDC), lot number, and expiration date.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein the one or more similar items are further associated with a same pricing category defining a respective class of trade.

10. The method of claim 7, wherein defining the plurality of line items includes:

associating each of the plurality of line items with a respective customer identifier, wherein the customer identifier uniquely corresponds to one of the plurality of customers; and

associating each of the plurality of line items with a respective quantity indicator, wherein the quantity indicator specifies a number of similar items corresponding to the line item.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein the credit memorandum includes a plurality of entries, each specifying a total amount of credit associated with a respective group of similar items in the aggregate set;

and wherein generating the disbursement statement includes;

matching each of the plurality of line items to one of the plurality of entries; and

calculating an amount of credit corresponding to the line item based on the quantity indicator and the total amount of credit specified in the matching one of the plurality of entries.

12. The method of claim 7, further comprising:

assigning a unique identifier to each of the plurality of line items; and

storing the unique identifier in the computer-readable memory along with a corresponding one of the plurality of line items.

13. The method of claim 7, further comprising:

storing pricing records for at least some of the items in the aggregate set in the computer-readable memory, wherein each pricing record is indicative of an amount of credit expected to be received from the at least one manufacturer for the corresponding item in the aggregate set; and

generating a refund estimate for each of the plurality of customers prior to receiving the credit memorandum using the item refund estimates.

14. The method of claim 13, further comprising updating the pricing records based on the received credit memorandum.

15. A computer system for generating accurate disbursement information in a reverse distribution environment, the system comprising:

an item tracking interface to receive item data for an aggregate set of items returnable for credit from a plurality of customers to a plurality of suppliers;

an item tracking engine to generate a plurality of line item records, each line item corresponding to a group of similar items in the aggregate set of items for a particular one of the plurality of customers;

a database to store the plurality of line item records, wherein each line item is associated with at least one of the respective customers;

a credit processing module to process a credit memorandum issued by any one of the suppliers for the aggregate set of items, wherein the credit memorandum includes data indicative of an amount payable by the respective supplier for each item in the aggregate set of items; and

a disbursement calculator to generate refund information for each of the plurality of customers based on the amount payable for each item in the plurality of line item records indicated by the credit memorandum, wherein the refund information provides a precise accounting for the actual amount payable by the manufacture for the pharmaceutical items received from that customer.

16. The computer system of claim 15, wherein each item in the aggregate set of items is a pharmaceutical item, and wherein each group of similar items is associated with a single national drug code (NDC) and a common lot number.

17. The computer system of claim 16, wherein each of the plurality of line item records includes the NDC, the lot number, an identity of the respective one of the plurality of customers, a quantity indicator specifying a number of items in the group of similar items.

18. The computer system of claim 15, wherein the credit processing module includes a line item consolidation interface to receive a selection of one of the plurality of line item records, and an amount of credit payable by the respective suppliers for the item to which the line item record corresponds.

19. The computer system of claim 15, further comprising a refund estimate calculator to generate a refund estimate for a selected one of the plurality of customers, wherein the refund estimate is defined as an amount of credit expected to be received for the items in the aggregate set that are associated with the selected one of the plurality of customers.

20. The computer system of claim 15, wherein the database is a first database;

further comprising a second database to store item refund estimates for at least some of the items in the aggregate set, wherein each item refund estimate corresponds to an amount of credit expected to be received for the corresponding item.