Water hardness monitoring via fluorescence

• US 8,956,875 B2
• Filed: 03/14/2013
• Issued: 02/17/2015
• Est. Priority Date: 03/14/2013
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Ecolab USA Incorporated (Ecolab, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: Ecolab USA Incorporated (Ecolab, Inc.)
• Inventors: Kahaian, Arthur J., Knoth, Alexandra, Li, Hui, Banks, Rodney H., Schwartz, Joe L., Welz, Sascha J.
• Primary Examiner(s): Wallenhorst, Maureen
• Application Number:
  US13/804,655
• Publication Number:
  US 20140273243A1
• Time in Patent Office: 705 Days
• Field of Search: 436/43, 436/50, 436/55, 436/73, 436/79, 436/164, 436/172, 422/68.1, 422/82.05, 422/82.08, 510/365
• US Class Current: 436/79
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 21/643 non-biological material
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 31/22 using chemical indicators G01N31/02 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/1813 specific cations in water, e.g. heavy metals electrochemical analysis G01N27/26; detection of ions by colorimetry G01N31/22
• CPC Class Codes: G01N 33/1853 hardness of water
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 436/11 Automated chemical analysis
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 436/115831 Condition or time responsive
• CPC Class Codes: Y10T 436/12 Condition responsive control

Abstract

Provided are automated methods for measuring soluble magnesium concentration in water using fluorescence. The methods employ the use of a pH-buffered liquid and a magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent. In certain embodiments, the methods may further employ measuring total hardness concentration of the water by displacing any soluble calcium with soluble magnesium and then re-measuring the soluble magnesium concentration. Optionally, the soluble calcium concentration can be determined by subtracting the measured soluble magnesium concentration from the measured total hardness concentration.

Claims

1. An automated method of monitoring soluble magnesium concentration in water containing soluble magnesium, the method comprising:

combining an aliquot of water and a quantity of (1) a pH-buffered liquid and (2) a magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent to produce a buffered water sample;

whereby the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent coordinates with the soluble magnesium present in the buffered water sample to produce a coordinated magnesium compound; and

quantifying the soluble magnesium concentration in the aliquot of water via fluorescence measurement of the coordinated magnesium compound in the buffered water sample;

wherein the (1) pH-buffered liquid comprises a water soluble, non-coordinating base capable of buffering the (1) pH-buffered liquid to a pH from 8 to 12;

wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is selected from the group consisting of a water soluble, aromatic, ortho hydroxyl substituted azo dye;

a water soluble, fused-ring heterocycle; and

combinations thereof; and

wherein the water soluble, non-coordinating base is 1,2 diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane.

2. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is present in the (1) pH-buffered liquid when combined with the aliquot of water.

3. The automated method of claim 2, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is a dry powder combined with the (1) pH-buffered liquid on site.

4. The automated method of claim 2, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is present in the (1) pH-buffered liquid at a concentration from 1 to 50 ppm.

5. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the water has a total hardness concentration greater than zero and not more than 2000 ppb as calcium carbonate.

6. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the (1) pH-buffered liquid is buffered to a pH from 9 to 11.

7. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is a water soluble, aromatic, ortho hydroxyl substituted azo dye selected from the group consisting of Plasmocorinth B, Eriochrome Black T, Calmagite, 8-hydroxyquinolone-5-sulfonic acid, and combinations thereof.

8. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is 8-hydroxyquinolone-5-sulfonic acid.

9. The automated method of claim 1, wherein (3) an inert fluorescing agent is additionally combined with the aliquot of water at a known (3) inert fluorescing agent-to-(1) pH-buffered liquid ratio, and concentration of the (1) pH-buffered liquid in the aliquot of water is confirmed by fluorescence measurement of the (3) inert fluorescing agent.

10. The automated method of claim 1, wherein the water is boiler feed water.

11. An automated method of monitoring and optionally controlling total hardness concentration in water containing soluble calcium and soluble magnesium, the method comprising:

combining an aliquot of water with (4) a magnesium-containing reagent whereby the soluble calcium within the aliquot of water is displaced by soluble magnesium, thereby creating a modified water sample having an increased soluble magnesium content;

combining the modified water sample with a quantity of (1) a pH-buffered liquid and (2) a magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent to produce a buffered water sample containing soluble magnesium;

whereby the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent coordinates with the soluble magnesium present in the buffered water sample to produce a coordinated magnesium compound;

quantifying the increased soluble magnesium content in the buffered water sample via fluorescence measurement of the coordinated magnesium compound thereby determining the total hardness concentration of the water;

wherein the (1) pH-buffered liquid comprises a water soluble, non-coordinating base capable of buffering the (1) pH-buffered liquid and the buffered water sample to a pH from 8 to 12;

and wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is selected from the group consisting of a water soluble, aromatic, ortho hydroxyl substituted azo dye;

a water soluble, fused-ring heterocycle; and

combinations thereof.

12. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is present in the (1) pH-buffered liquid when the pH buffered liquid is combined with the aliquot of water.

13. The automated method of claim 12, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is a dry powder combined with the (1) pH-buffered liquid on site.

14. The automated method of claim 12, wherein the displacement of soluble calcium by soluble magnesium occurs simultaneously with the combination of the aliquot of water and the magnesium-containing reagent, and the (4) magnesium-containing reagent is present in the (1) pH-buffered liquid prior to the pH-buffered liquid being combined with the aliquot of water.

15. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the soluble magnesium concentration in the industrial water is known, but the soluble calcium concentration in the water is unknown, and the soluble calcium concentration is determined by subtracting the known magnesium concentration from the total hardness concentration.

16. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the water has a total hardness concentration greater than zero and not more than 2000 ppb as calcium carbonate.

17. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (1) pH-buffered liquid is buffered to a pH from 9 to 11.

18. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is a water soluble, aromatic, ortho hydroxyl substituted azo dye selected from the group consisting of Plasmocorinth B, Eriochrome Black T, Calmagite, 8-hydroxyquinolone-5-sulfonic acid, and combinations thereof.

19. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is 8-hydroxyquinolone-5-sulfonic acid.

20. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (2) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent is utilized in an amount sufficient to have a concentration from 1 to 50 ppm in the buffered water sample.

21. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (1) pH-buffered liquid comprises water and a water soluble non-coordinating base.

22. The automated method of claim 21, wherein the water soluble non-coordinating base is 1,2 diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane.

23. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the (4) magnesium-containing reagent comprises a magnesium-containing multidentate chelant.

24. The automated method of claim 23, wherein the magnesium-containing multidentate chelant comprises disodium magnesium 1,2-diaminecyclohexyl-N,N,N′

,N′

tetraacetate.

25. The automated method of claim 11, wherein the water is boiler feed water.

26. An automated method of monitoring and optionally controlling total hardness concentration of water containing soluble calcium and soluble magnesium, the method comprising:

A.

combining a first aliquot of water and quantities of (1a) a first pH-buffered liquid, (2a) a first magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent, and (3a) a first inert fluorescing agent to produce a buffered water sample;

whereby the (2a) first magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent coordinates with the soluble magnesium present in the first aliquot of water to create a coordinated magnesium compound within the buffered water sample;

determining by light absorbance the concentration of any uncoordinated (2a) first magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent in the buffered water sample;

determining by fluorescence the concentration of the (3a) first inert fluorescing agent in the buffered water sample;

determining the soluble magnesium concentration in the first aliquot of water via fluorescence measurement of the coordinated magnesium compound in the buffered water sample;

optionally correcting the soluble magnesium concentration determined via fluorescence measurement of the coordinated magnesium compound to account for one or more of the following;

variation in mixing ratio, variation in background effects, and variation in temperature, thereby allowing for the calculation of an adjusted soluble magnesium concentration in the water; and

B.

combining a second aliquot of water and quantities of (1b) a second pH-buffered liquid, (2b) a second magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent, (3b) a second inert fluorescing agent, and (4b) a magnesium-containing reagent to create a modified water sample,

whereby the (4b) magnesium-containing reagent reacts with soluble calcium in the second aliquot of water thereby displacing the soluble calcium with soluble magnesium and creating an increased soluble magnesium concentration in the modified water sample and the (2b) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent coordinates with the soluble magnesium present in the modified water sample creating a coordinated magnesium compound;

measuring by light absorbance the concentration of uncoordinated (2b) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent in the modified water sample;

measuring the fluorescence created by the (3b) inert fluorescing agent in the modified water sample in order to determine concentration of the inert fluorescing agent in the modified water sample;

measuring the soluble magnesium concentration in the modified water sample via fluorescence measurement of the coordinated magnesium compound, the measurement of which corresponds to measuring the total hardness concentration in the second aliquot of water and the total hardness concentration in the water;

optionally correcting the soluble magnesium concentration measured via fluorescence of the coordinated magnesium compound to account for one or more of the following;

variation in mixing ratio, variation in background effects, and variation in temperature, thereby allowing for the calculation of an adjusted total hardness concentration in the water; and

optionally subtracting the soluble magnesium concentration of the first aliquot of water from the total hardness concentration of the second aliquot of water to arrive at the soluble calcium concentration in the water;

optionally taking action to control at least one process variable as a result of the measurements; and

optionally repeating A and B;

wherein the (1a) first and (1b) second pH buffered liquids are the same or different compositions having buffered pH from 8 to 12, the (2a) first and (2b) second magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent are the same or different compositions, and the (3a) first and (3b) second inert fluorescing agent are the same or different compositions.

27. The automated method of claim 26, wherein the (4b) magnesium-containing reagent is present in the (1b) pH-buffered liquid at a concentration such that, when added to the second aliquot of water, the (4b) magnesium-containing reagent has a molar concentration from 10 to 10,000 times greater than the soluble calcium concentration.

28. The automated method of claim 26, wherein the quantities of the (2a) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent, and the (3a) inert fluorescing agent are present in the (1a) pH-buffered liquid prior to the combining.

29. The automated method of claim 26, wherein the quantities of the (2b) magnesium coordinating fluorescing reagent, the (3b) inert fluorescing agent, and the (4b) magnesium-containing reagent are present in the (1b) pH-buffered liquid prior to the combining.