Method for adjusting braking parameters of a train to account for train characteristic parameter variations

• US 9,108,608 B2
• Filed: 09/20/2011
• Issued: 08/18/2015
• Est. Priority Date: 09/21/2010
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Ansaldo STS SPA
• Original Assignee: Ansaldo STS SPA
• Inventors: Cutright, Eric Dale, Mokkapati, Chinnarao, Pascoe, Robert Dennis
• Primary Examiner(s): Olszewski, John R
• Assistant Examiner(s): MELTON, TODD M
• Application Number:
  US13/237,060
• Publication Number:
  US 20120072088A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,428 Days
• Field of Search: 701/70
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: B60T 13/665 the systems being specially adapted for transferring two or more command signals, e.g. railway systems B60T13/662 takes precedence
• CPC Class Codes: B60T 17/228 for railway vehicles

Abstract

A method of adjusting one or more of braking parameters used in a braking function to control braking of a train includes determining an adjustment factor based on a joint stopping distance probability distribution, the joint stopping distance probability distribution representing the composite effect on stopping distance of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, and applying the adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters. Also, a method of adjusting braking parameters that includes determining an adjustment factor based on a nominal value, a worst case limit value and a best case limit value of each of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, and applying the adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters.

Claims

1. A method of adjusting one or more of braking parameters used in a braking function to control braking of a train, comprising:

determining an adjustment factor based on a joint stopping distance probability distribution, the joint stopping distance probability distribution representing the composite effect on stopping distance of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, wherein the determining the adjustment factor comprises applying a probability threshold to the joint stopping distance probability distribution to determine a safe braking offset distance, and calculating the adjustment factor based on the safe braking offset distance; and

applying the adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the one or more of braking parameters comprise brake propagation delay time (T_d), brake build-up time (T) and maximum brake rate (α

_max).

3. The method according to claim 1 wherein the calculating the adjustment factor comprises calculating the adjustment factor as a ratio of a nominal stopping distance plus the safe braking offset distance to the nominal stopping distance.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters has a predetermined nominal value, and wherein the nominal stopping distance is a stopping distance determined based on each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters being set to its predetermined nominal value.

5. The method according to claim 1, wherein each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters has a nominal value, a worst case limit value and a best case limit value, the method further comprising determining the joint stopping distance probability distribution by:

assigning a probability density function to each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters using its nominal value as the mode and the best case limit value and the worst case limit value as the extreme boundaries;

converting each probability density function to a corresponding stopping distance probability distribution representing change in stopping distance front nominal as the associated train characteristic parameter varies per its probability density function; and

convolving the corresponding stopping distance probability distributions to generate the joint stopping distance probability distribution.

6. The method according to claim 5, further comprising determining a nominal stopping distance based on each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters being set to its nominal value, wherein for each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters, the best case limit value will result in a stopping distance decrease from the nominal stopping distance and the worst case limit value will result in a stopping distance increase from the nominal stopping distance.

7. The method according to claim 6, further comprising selecting a set of train characteristic parameters, the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters being a subset of the set of train characteristic parameters, and selecting the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters based on a determination that each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters has at least a predetermined effect on stopping distance.

8. A train-borne component of a positive train control system comprising an on-board computer for a train, the on-board computer being programmed to control braking of the train using one or more of braking parameters by:

applying an adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters to obtain one or more adjusted braking parameters, the adjustment factor being based on a joint stopping distance probability distribution, the joint stopping distance probability distribution representing the composite effect on stopping distance of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, wherein the adjustment factor is determined by applying a probability threshold to the joint stopping distance probability distribution to determine a safe braking offset distance, and calculating the adjustment factor based on the safe braking offset distance; and

controlling braking of the train in the on-board computer using the one or more adjusted braking parameters.

9. The train-borne component according to claim 8, wherein the one or more of braking parameters comprise brake propagation delay time (T_d), brake build-up time (T) and maximum brake rate (α

_max).

10. The train-borne component according to claim 8, wherein the adjustment factor is a ratio of a nominal stopping distance plus the safe braking offset distance to the nominal stopping distance.

11. The train-borne component according to claim 10, wherein each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters has a predetermined nominal value, and wherein the nominal stopping distance is a stopping distance determined based on each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters being set to its predetermined nominal value.

12. The train-borne component according to claim 8, wherein each of the plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters has a nominal value, a worst case limit value and a best case limit value, and wherein the joint stopping distance probability distribution is determined using the nominal value, the worst case limit value and the best case limit value of each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters.

13. A method adjusting one or more of braking parameters used in a braking function to control braking of a train, comprising:

determining an adjustment factor based on a nominal value, a worst case limit value and a best case limit value of each of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, wherein the determining the adjustment factor comprises determining a joint stopping distance probability distribution using the nominal value, the worst case limit value and the best case limit value of each the predetermined train characteristic parameters, the joint stopping distance probability distribution representing the composite effect on stopping distance of the predetermined train characteristic parameters, and wherein the determining the adjustment factor comprises applying a probability threshold to the joint stopping distance probability distribution to determine a safe braking offset distance, and calculating the adjustment factor based on the safe braking offset distance; and

applying the adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters.

14. The method according to claim 13, wherein the one or more of braking parameters comprise brake propagation delay time (T_d), brake build-up time (T) and maximum brake rate (α

_max).

15. The method according to claim 13, wherein the calculating the adjustment factor comprises calculating the adjustment factor as a ratio of a nominal stopping distance plus the safe braking offset distance to the nominal stopping distance.

16. A train-borne component of a positive train control system comprising an on-board computer for a train, the on-board computer being programmed to control braking of the train using one or more of braking parameters by:

applying an adjustment factor to each of the one or more of braking parameters to obtain one or more adjusted braking parameters, the adjustment factor being based on a nominal value, a worst case limit value and a best case limit value of each of a plurality of predetermined train characteristic parameters, each of the predetermined train characteristic parameters being variable, wherein the adjustment factor is based on a joint stopping distance probability distribution that is determined using the nominal value, the worst case limit value and the best case limit value of each the predetermined train characteristic parameters, the joint stopping distance probability distribution representing the composite effect on stopping distance of the predetermined train characteristic parameters, wherein the adjustment factor is determined by applying a probability threshold to the joint stopping distance probability distribution to determine a safe braking offset distance, and calculating the adjustment factor based on the safe braking offset distance; and

controlling braking of the train in the on-board computer using the one or more adjusted braking parameters.

17. The train-borne component according to claim 16, wherein the adjustment is calculated as a ratio of a nominal stopping distance plus the safe braking offset distance to the nominal stopping distance.

18. The train-borne component according to claim 16, wherein the one or more of braking parameters comprise brake propagation delay time (T_d), brake build-up time (T) and maximum brake rate (α

_max).