Controlling pumps for improved energy efficiency

• US 9,181,953 B2
• Filed: 10/01/2009
• Issued: 11/10/2015
• Est. Priority Date: 10/01/2009
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Specific Energy
• Original Assignee: Specific Energy
• Inventors: Steger, Perry C., Pierce, David Mark
• Primary Examiner(s): KRAMER, DEVON C
• Application Number:
  US12/571,895
• Publication Number:
  US 20110081255A1
• Time in Patent Office: 2,231 Days
• Field of Search: 417/43, 417/44.11, 417/45, 417/426, 702/50, 702/100, 700/282
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: F04D 15/0066 by changing the speed, e.g. of the driving engine

Abstract

A method for improving the energy efficiency of a pump system. The method includes measuring an instantaneous power consumption of the pump system, measuring an instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system, and determining an instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the instantaneous power consumption and the instantaneous fluid flow rate. The method then adjusts the speed of a pump in response to the determined SEC. The above steps may be performed a number of times to seek a reduced value of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

Claims

1. A method for improving energy efficiency of a pump system, wherein the pump system comprises one or more pumps, the method comprising:

measuring instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

measuring instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

determining an instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

automatically adjusting speed of the one or more pumps according to a change direction in response to said determining, wherein the change direction is increasing or decreasing;

waiting for the pump system to stabilize after said adjusting; and

in response to the pump system stabilizing, repeating said measuring instantaneous power consumption, said measuring instantaneous fluid flow rate, said determining, and said adjusting to seek a reduced value of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

wherein said determining the instantaneous SEC of the pump system includes;

determining whether the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system, and

setting the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is determined to be greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

2. The method of claim 1,

wherein the one or more pumps are centrifugal pumps;

and

wherein said adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps further comprises;

increasing rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction is set to increasing; and

decreasing the rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction is set to decreasing.

3. The method of claim 1, wherein said adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps further comprises:

clamping the speed of the one or more pumps to fall between a low speed threshold and a high speed threshold;

adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps by a speed adjustment size;

increasing the speed adjustment size if it is determined that the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is not greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system; and

decreasing the speed adjustment size if it is determined that the instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein the method is performed without any prior knowledge of:

1) a pump curve associated with the one or more pumps;

     2) a pump efficiency curve associated with the one or more pumps;

or

     3) a system curve associated with the pump system.

5. The method of claim 1,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more adjustable speed drives (ASDs);

wherein said adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps comprises adjusting one or more speeds associated with the one or more ASDs.

6. The method of claim 1,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more variable transmissions;

and

wherein said adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps comprises adjusting effective gear ratios associated with the one or more variable transmissions.

7. A computer-readable tangible non-transitory memory medium comprising program instructions for improving energy efficiency of a pump system, wherein the pump system comprises one or more pumps, wherein the program instructions are executable to:

receive a measurement of instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

receive a measurement of instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

determine an instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the measurement of instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the measurement of instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

provide an output to adjust speed of the one or more pumps according to a change direction in response to the determination of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system, wherein the change direction is increasing or decreasing;

wait for the pump system to stabilize after said adjusting; and

wherein the program instructions are configured to execute a plurality of times, in response to said waiting, to seek a reduced value of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

wherein to determine the instantaneous SEC of the pump system, the program instructions are further executable to;

determine whether the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system, and

set the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

8. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 7,

wherein the one or more pumps are centrifugal pumps;

and

wherein, to provide the output to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the program instructions are further executable to;

provide an output to increase rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction is set to increasing; and

provide an output to decrease the rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction is set to decreasing.

9. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 7,

wherein, to provide the output to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the program instructions are further executable to provide the output to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps so that:

a) the speed of the one or more pumps is clamped between a low speed threshold and a high speed threshold;

b) the size of the speed adjustment is increased relative to the size of a previous speed adjustment if it is determined that the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is not greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system; and

c) the size of the speed adjustment is decreased relative to the size of the previous speed adjustment if it is determined that the instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

10. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 7,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more ASDs;

wherein, to provide the output to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the program instructions are further executable to provide one or more outputs to adjust one or more speeds associated with the one or more ASDs.

11. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 7,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more variable transmissions;

wherein, to provide the output to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the program instructions are further executable to provide one or more outputs to adjust one or more effective gear ratios associated with the one or more variable transmissions.

12. A pump system comprising:

one or more pumps;

a pump control unit coupled to the one or more pumps;

a power meter coupled to the pump control unit, wherein the power meter is configured to measure instantaneous power consumption of the pump system; and

a flow meter coupled to the pump control unit, wherein the flow meter is configured to measure instantaneous flow rate of the pump system;

wherein the pump control unit is configured to;

obtain from the power meter a measurement of the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

obtain from the flow meter a measurement of the instantaneous flow rate of the pump system;

determine an instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the measurement of the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the measurement of the instantaneous flow rate of the pump system;

automatically adjust speed of the one or more pumps according to a change direction in response to the determination of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system, wherein the change direction is increasing or decreasing; and

wait for the pump system to stabilize after said adjusting;

wherein, in response to the pump system stabilizing, the pump control unit is configured to repeat;

said obtaining the measurement of the instantaneous power consumption, said obtaining the measurement of the instantaneous flow rate, said determining the instantaneous SEC, and said adjusting the speed of the one or more pumps to seek a reduced value of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

wherein, to determine the instantaneous SEC of the pump system, the pump control unit is further configured to;

determine whether the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system, and

set the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

13. The pump system of claim 12,

wherein the one or more pumps are centrifugal pumps;

and

wherein, to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the pump control unit is further configured to;

increase rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction change is set to increasing; and

decrease the rotational speed of the one or more pumps if the change direction is set to decreasing.

14. The pump system of claim 12,

wherein, to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps, the pump control unit is further configured to:

limit the speed of the one or more pumps to fall between a low speed threshold and a high speed threshold;

increase the size of the speed adjustment relative to a previous size of speed adjustment if it is determined that the instantaneous SEC of the pump system is not greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system; and

decrease the size of the speed adjustment relative to the previous size of speed adjustment if it is determined that the instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

15. The pump system of claim 12,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more ASDs;

and

wherein the pump control unit is configured to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps by adjusting one or more speeds associated with the one or more ASDs.

16. The pumping system of claim 12,

wherein the speed of the one or more pumps is controlled by one or more variable transmissions;

and

wherein the pump control unit is configured to adjust the speed of the one or more pumps by adjusting effective gear ratios associated with the one or more variable transmissions.

17. A method for improving energy efficiency of a pump system, wherein the pump system comprises a plurality of pumps, the method comprising:

(a) setting a change direction to one of increasing or decreasing;

(b) measuring instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

(c) measuring instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(d) determining a current instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(e) comparing the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system to a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(f) setting the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(g) adjusting speed of a pump of the plurality of pumps according to the change direction;

(h) repeating steps (b)-(g) a plurality of times; and

(i) repeating steps (a)-(h) for each pump in the plurality of pumps, one pump at a time.

18. The method of claim 17, further comprising repeating steps (a)-(i) a plurality of times.

19. The method of claim 17,

wherein step (i) is repeated until the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system approaches a minimum.

20. The method of claim 17,

wherein said adjusting the speed of the pump in (g) comprises adjusting the speed of the pump according to the change direction and a step size;

wherein step (i) further comprises setting the step size to an initial value; and

wherein the method further comprises changing the step size based on the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system and one or more previous values of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

21. A computer-readable memory medium comprising program instructions for improving energy efficiency of a pump system, wherein the pump system comprises a plurality of pumps, wherein the program instructions are executable to:

(a) set a change direction to one of increasing or decreasing;

(b) obtain a measurement of instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

(c) obtain a measurement of instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(d) determine a current instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(e) compare the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system to a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(f) set the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than the previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(g) provide an output to adjust speed of a pump of the plurality of pumps according to the change direction;

(h) repeat (b)-(g) a plurality of times; and

(i) repeat (a)-(h) for each pump in the plurality of pumps, one pump at a time.

22. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 21, wherein the program instructions are executable to repeat (a)-(i) a plurality of times.

23. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 21,

wherein (i) is repeated until the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system approaches a minimum.

24. The computer-readable memory medium of claim 21,

wherein in (g) the program instructions are further executable to provide an output to adjust the speed of the pump according to the change direction and a step size;

wherein in (i) the program instructions are further executable to set the step size to an initial value; and

wherein the program instructions are further executable to change the step size based on the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system and one or more previous values of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system.

25. A pump system comprising:

one or more pumps;

a pump control unit coupled to the one or more pumps;

a power meter coupled to the pump control unit, wherein the power meter is configured to measure instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

a flow meter coupled to the pump control unit, wherein the flow meter is configured to measure instantaneous flow rate of the pump system; and

wherein the pump control unit is configured to;

(a) set a change direction to one of increasing or decreasing;

(b) receive a measurement of the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system;

(c) receive a measurement of the instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(d) determine a current instantaneous specific energy consumption (SEC) of the pump system based on the instantaneous power consumption of the pump system and the instantaneous fluid flow rate of the pump system;

(e) compare the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system to a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(f) set the change direction to the opposite direction if the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system is greater than a previous instantaneous SEC of the pump system;

(g) provide an output to adjust speed of a pump of the plurality of pumps according to the change direction;

(h) repeat steps (b)-(g) a plurality of times; and

(i) repeat steps (a)-(h) for each pump in the plurality of pumps, one pump at a time.

26. The pump system of claim 25, wherein the pump control unit is configured to repeat (a)-(i) a plurality of times.

27. The pump system of claim 25,

wherein the pump control unit is configured to repeat (i) until the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system approaches a minimum.

28. The pump system of claim 25,

wherein, in (g), the pump control unit is further configured to provide an output to adjust the speed of the pump according to the change direction and a step size;

wherein in (i) the pump control unit is further configured to set the step size to an initial value; and

wherein the pump control unit is further configured to change the step size based on the current instantaneous SEC of the pump system and one or more previous values of the instantaneous SEC of the pump system.