Method and system for annotating and/or linking documents and data for intellectual property management

• US 9,710,467 B2
• Filed: 09/14/2012
• Issued: 07/18/2017
• Est. Priority Date: 08/28/2001
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Eugene M. Lee
• Original Assignee: Eugene M. Lee
• Inventors: Lee, Eugene M.
• Primary Examiner(s): Corrielus, Jean M
• Application Number:
  US13/617,607
• Publication Number:
  US 20130047066A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,768 Days
• Field of Search: 707923, 707727, 707930, 707768, 707736, 707608, 707609, 707823, 715230, 715232, 715234
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/93 Document management systems
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/10 Office automation; Time management
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/923 Intellectual property
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/93 intellectual property analysis
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/934 Analyzing patent activity
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/937 intellectual property searching

Abstract

A computer-enabled system, method, and medium is provided to support analyzing intellectual property documents by linking and annotating patents, copyrights, trademarks, license agreements, and other types of intellectual property documents. The invention is suitable for use by intellectual property professionals in memorializing their thought processes, work products, and reasoning, whether in preliminary or final form, and is flexible to support development and use of a rich linked set representing complex relationships in an intellectual property portfolio. Optionally, marked up, linked documents are divided into data streams, one of the data streams containing the original document for mark-up, and one other data stream containing the annotation data. The marked-up document may be further revised and/or annotated, even by multiple users. The system provides that the same document such as a patent may be centrally stored but independently marked-up by different users (or groups of users). The system further extracts from such a marked-up document such annotation data with any changes thereto, and provides one or more data streams, containing the annotation data for storage and or later use.

Claims

1. A computer-implemented system for providing annotated electronic documents, the annotations which are applied to the documents being stored in a first data storage, the documents being stored in a second data storage, the first data storage and the second data storage being at least one of physically separate and logically separate, said system comprising:

a processor which is hardware;

an annotation component configured to determine, responsive to at least one user, at least one annotation to apply to at least one document, the annotation component including (i) selection resource to select at least a portion of the at least one document and associate the at least one annotation with the at least one portion which is selected, and (ii) a mark-up resource to at least one of add and edit the at least one annotation, wherein the at least one annotation is permitted to be different from every other annotation,

a reference component, responsive to the at least one user, configured to at least one of establish, traverse, indicate, and remove, at least one reference between (i) the at least one portion which is selected and (ii) at least one of an other portion of the at least one document, an other document, and at least one other portion of the other document;

a merge component, responsive to a request from the at least one user for the at least one document, configured to;

retrieve the at least one document from the second data storage as document data,

retrieve the at least one annotation to apply to said at least one document from the first data storage as annotation data, and

combine the annotation data and the document data to form a unitary single logical document, the single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) a predetermined section of plural variable-length sections within the document as stored in the second data storage into which the annotation is embedded as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) a content-portion of the predetermined section with which the annotation is associated, and

a split component, responsive to a request from the at least one user to store the combined annotation data and document data, configured to;

extract the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document,

update the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and

update the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data.

2. The system of claim 1, further comprising:

a view component operatively connected to the annotation component to edit, responsive to the at least one user, the at least one portion of the at least one document selected by the selection resource.

3. The system of claim 1, wherein the merge component is further configured to display the single logical document as a representation of the at least one document.

4. The system of claim 1, wherein at least one of the single logical document, and the document data is at least one of:

text, XML format, binary format, image data, video data, and audio data.

5. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least one annotation indicates an evaluation of at least one legal property relative to the at least one document.

6. The system of claim 1, further comprising:

at least one version component, configured to at least one of manage a history of changes and maintain at least one separate version for the at least one document and the at least one annotation applied thereto.

7. The system of claim 1, further comprising:

at least one schema configured to identify at least one tag in at least one of the at least one portion, the at least one document, and the at least one annotation.

8. The system of claim 1, the at least one annotation being associated with the at least one user, the at least one document being accessible by the plurality of users including the at least one user, and wherein the merge component is further configured to, responsive to a request for the at least one document from the at least one user, to limit the annotation data included in the single logical document to annotations associated with the at least one user.

9. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least one annotation further includes at least one of:

a pre-defined notation, a user-provided text, a user-defined attribute, a reference to a URL, and a reference to an other file.

10. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least one document is representative of at least one of:

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a contract document, a license document, a sui generis protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document.

11. The system of claim 1, further comprising:

a report component, responsive to the at least one user, configured to provide a report listing (i) each annotation in the at least one document, and (ii) in visual correspondence to each annotation, a summary of each portion in the at least one document that is associated with each annotation; and

a map component, responsive to the at least one user, configured to list (i) a summary of each portion in the at least one document, (ii) each annotation in the at least one document including the at least one annotation, and (iii) each reference from the at least one portion of the document, including the at least one reference, wherein each annotation and each reference is visually linked to a corresponding portion listed in the summary.

12. The system of claim 1, wherein the at least one document is an intellectual property document.

13. A computer-implemented system for providing annotated electronic documents, the annotations which are applied to the documents being stored in a first data storage, the documents being stored in a second data storage, the first data storage and the second data storage being at least one of physically separate and logically separate, said system comprising:

a processor which is hardware;

a merge component, responsive to a request from a user for at least one document, configured to;

retrieve the at least one document from a second data storage as document data,

retrieve at least one annotation to apply to said at least one document from the first data storage as annotation data, said document data including at least one element corresponding to a location of the at least one annotation within said document, wherein the annotation data is image data or text, wherein the at least one annotation is permitted to be different from every other annotation; and

combine the document data and the annotation data to form a unitary single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data at the location;

a split component, responsive to a request from the user to store the combined annotation data and document data, configured to;

extract the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document,

update the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and

update the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data; and

at least one version component, configured to at least one of manage a history of changes and to maintain a separate version for the document data and the annotation data applied thereto,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) a predetermined section of plural variable-length sections within the document as stored in the second data storage into which the annotation is embedded as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) a content-portion of the predetermined section with which the annotation is associated,

wherein the merge component, the split component, and the version component, include executable instructions executing in the processor.

14. The system of claim 13, further comprising:

an annotation tool, responsive to the user, configured to receive input of the annotation data to apply to the at least one document, the annotation tool including (i) a selection resource to select at least one element of the document data for annotation, and (ii) a mark-up resource to at least one of add and edit the annotation data corresponding to the at least one element which is selected;

an edit tool, responsive to the user, configured to select the at least one element, and to edit the at least one element, the edit tool including (i) a representation of the at least one selected element, and (ii) a representation of the annotation data; and

a reference tool, configured to (i) determine at least one reference to the at least one element that is selected and at least an other element of at least one document, and (ii) enable the at least one reference that is selected for traversal by the user.

15. The system of claim 13, wherein at least one of the logical single document, and the document data is at least one of:

text, XML format, binary format, image data, video data, and audio data.

16. The system of claim 13, further comprising (i) a schema configured to identify at least one tag in the at least one element, and (ii) logic to determine tags for at least one of the document data, the annotation data, and the at least one marked-up representation.

17. The system of claim 13, wherein the annotation data further includes (i) at least one of:

a pre-defined notation, a user-provided text, a user-defined attribute, and (ii) the at least one reference which is to at least one of;

an element in the document, an element in an other document, a URL, and an other file.

18. The system of claim 13, wherein the document data is representative of at least one of:

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a contract document, a license document, a sui generis protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document.

19. The system of claim 13 further comprising:

a report tool, configured to provide, from the single logical document, a report listing (i) a summary of elements in the single logical document and (ii) in visual correspondence to each of the elements which is listed, each annotation in the single logical document; and

a map tool, responsive to the user, configured to list, from the single logical document, (i) a summary of each element in the single logical document, (ii) each annotation in the single logical document including the at least one annotation, and (i ii each reference in the single logical document including the at least one reference, wherein each annotation and each reference are visually linked to a corresponding element listed in the summary.

20. A method, in a computer-implemented system for providing annotated electronic documents, the annotations which are applied to the documents being stored in a first data storage, the documents being stored in a second data storage, for annotating documents, implemented by a computer system, said method comprising the at least one of sequential, non-sequential and sequence-independent steps of:

determining, by the computer system and responsive to a user, at least one annotation to apply to at least one document, including (i) selecting at least a portion of the at least one document for annotation, (ii) associating the at least one annotation with the at least one portion, and (iii) editing the at least one annotation associated with the at least one portion, wherein the annotation is image data or text, wherein the at least one annotation is permitted to be different from every other annotation; and

responsive to the user, at least one of establishing, traversing, indicating, and removing at least one reference between (i) the at least one portion and (ii) at least one of an other portion of the at least one document, an other document, and at least one other portion of the other document; and

by a merge component of the computer system, responsive to a request from the user for the at least one document, retrieving the at least one document from a second data storage as document data, (i) retrieving the at least one annotation to apply to said at least one document from a first data storage as annotation data, and (ii) combining the annotation data and the document data to form a unitary single logical document, the single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data,

by a split component of the computer system, responsive to a request from the user to store the combined annotation data and document data;

extracting the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document,

updating the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and

updating the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) a predetermined section of plural variable-length sections within the document as stored in the second data storage into which the annotation is embedded as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) a content-portion of the predetermined section with which the annotation is associated.

21. The method of claim 20, further comprising:

providing, from the single logical document, a report listing (i) each annotation in the at least one document, and (ii) in visual correspondence thereto a summary of each portion in the at least one document that is associated with each annotation; and

providing a map listing (i) a summary of each portion in the at least one document, (ii) each annotation in the at least one document including the at least one annotation, and each reference from the at least one portion of the document, including the at least one reference, wherein each annotation and each reference is visually linked to a corresponding portion listed in the summary.

22. The method of claim 20, wherein the at least one annotation further includes at least one of:

a pre-defined notation, a user-provided text, a user-defined attribute, a reference to a URL, and a reference to an other file.

23. The method of claim 20, wherein the at least one document is representative of at least one of:

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a contract document, a license document, a sui generis protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document.

24. A system for retrieving and storing a plurality of electronic documents and a plurality of annotations applied to the documents, the plurality of documents for access by a plurality of users, the plurality of annotations for access by at least a portion of the users, the system comprising:

at least one storage portion, to store at least one document and at least one annotation associated with the at least one document;

at least one server to determine respective locations of (i) the plurality of documents including the at least one document, and (ii) the plurality of annotations including the at least one annotation;

at least one manager, (i) to determine a location of the at least one document and at least one annotation to apply to the at least one document stored in the at least one storage portion;

(ii) to at least one of retrieve from and store in, via the at least one server, the at least one document as document data and the at least one annotation to apply to said at least one document as annotation data, in the at least one storage portion; and

(iii) to provide the at least one document with the at least one annotation applied to a content-portion of a pre-determined section of the document as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema;

a merge component, responsive to a request from a user for the at least one document, configured to;

retrieve the at least one document from a second data storage as document data, retrieve the at least one annotation to be applied to said at least one document from a first data storage as annotation data, and combine the annotation data and the document data to form a unitary single logical document, the single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data; and

a split component, responsive to a request from the user to store the combined annotation data and document data, configured to;

extract the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document, update the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and update the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) the predetermined section of plural variable-length sections within the document as stored in the storage portion into which the annotation is embedded as indicated by the document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) the content-portion of the predetermined section with which the annotation is associated.

25. The system of claim 24, the at least one annotation being associated with the at least one user, the at least one document being accessible by the plurality of users including the at least one user, and wherein access to the at least one annotation applied to the at least one document is limited to the at least one user associated with the at least one annotation.

26. The system of claim 24, wherein the at least one manager determines, if the at least one document is read-only, to not store a further copy of the at least one document.

27. The system of claim 24, further comprising a version control to maintain at least one separate version of the at least one document and the at least one annotation.

28. The system of claim 24, further comprising at least one analyzer to at least one of manage, traverse, search, view, report and edit, via the at least one manager, the at least one document and the at least one annotation associated therewith.

29. The system of claim 24, wherein the at least one manager associates at least one reference with at least one of the at least one document and the at least one annotation, the at least one reference being to at least one of:

an element in the document, an element in an other document, a URL, and a file.

30. The system of claim 24, wherein at least one of the marked-up representation, the document data and the annotation data is at least one of:

text, XML format, binary format, image data, and audio data.

31. The system of claim 24, wherein the at least one annotation indicates an evaluation of at least one legal property relative to the at least one document.

32. The system of claim 24, wherein the at least one annotation includes at least one of:

a pre-defined notation, a user-provided text, a user-defined attribute, a reference to a URL, and a reference to an other file.

33. The system of claim 24, wherein the at least one document is representative of at least one of:

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a license document, a sui generic protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document.

34. A method, in a computer-implemented system, for annotating electronic documents in an intellectual property environment, comprising the at least one of sequential, non-sequential, and sequence independent steps performed by a computer of:

providing at least one document, as document data;

determining a content-portion within at least one section of the at least one document for annotation;

determining at least one annotation to apply to the determined content-portion within the at least one section as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema;

associating the determined at least one annotation with (i) the content-portion which is determined and (ii) the at least one section;

storing the determined at least one annotation for later retrieval, as annotation data, wherein the annotation is stored separately from the at least one document;

in a merge component, responsive to a request from a user for the at least one document;

retrieving the at least one document from a second data storage as document data, retrieving the at least one annotation to be applied to said at least one document from a first data storage as annotation data, and combining the annotation data and the document data to form a unitary single logical document, the single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data; and

in a split component, responsive to a request from the user to store the combined annotation data and document data;

extracting the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document, updating the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and updating the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) the at least one section of plural variable-length sections within the document into which the at least one annotation, which is determined, is embedded as indicated by the document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) a content-portion of the at least one section, which is determined, with which the annotation is associated.

35. The method of claim 34, wherein determining the content portion of the at least one section includes at least one of (i) indicating, responsive to the user, the content-portion of the at least one section and selecting the at least one section;

(ii) selecting, responsive to the user, the at least one section from a plurality of pre-determined sections, as the content-portion; and

(iii) automatically or semi-automatically pre-determining the content-portion of the at least one section, and automatically, manually or semi-automatically selecting the at least one section.

36. The method of claim 34, wherein determining the at least one annotation includes at least one of:

(i) selecting at least one pre-defined notation;

(ii) receiving input text;

(ii) selecting at least one user-defined attribute;

(iv) receiving a reference to a URL; and

(v) receiving a reference to a file.

37. The method of claim 34, further comprising the step of preliminarily determining a plurality of user-defined attributes including the at least one attribute.

38. The method of claim 34, further comprising storing the at least one document for later retrieval.

39. The method of claim 34, further comprising maintaining at least separate version for at least one of the at least one annotation and the at least one document.

40. The method of claim 34, wherein the at least one annotation is associated with at least one user, the at least one document being accessible by the plurality of users including the at least one user, further comprising limiting access to the at least one annotation to the at least one user associated with the at least one annotation.

41. The method of claim 34, wherein the at least one document is representative of at least one of:

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a license document, a sui generic protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document.

42. The method of claim 34, wherein the at least one annotation indicates an evaluation of at least one legal property relative to the at least one document.

43. A method, in a computer-implemented system, for annotating electronic documents in an intellectual property environment, the annotations indicating an evaluation of at least one legal property relative to at least the annotated electronic document, comprising the at least one of sequential, non-sequential, and sequence independent steps performed by a computer of:

providing at least one document as document data, wherein the at least one document is representative of at least one of;

a patent document, a trademark document, a copyright document, a product description document, a license document, a sui generic protection document, a design registration document, a trade secret document, and an opinion document;

determining at least one section of the at least one document for annotation as indicated by a document-image-independent data schema, including at least one of (i) indicating, responsive to a user, a content-portion of the at least one section and selecting the at least one section;

(ii) selecting, responsive to the user, as the content-portion, the at least one section from a plurality of pre-determined sections of the at least one document;

and (iii) automatically or semi-automatically pre-determining a content-portion of the at least one section, and automatically, manually or semi-automatically selecting the at least one section;

determining at least one annotation to apply to the content-portion, including at least one of;

(i) selecting at least one pre-defined notation;

(ii) receiving input text;

(ii) selecting at least one user-defined attribute;

(iv) receiving a reference to a URL; and

(v) receiving a reference to a file;

associating (i) the determined at least one annotation with (ii) the content-portion of the at least one section as indicated by the document-image-independent data schema;

storing the determined at least one annotation, for later retrieval, as annotation data, wherein the determined at least one annotation is stored separately from the at least one document;

in a merge component, responsive to a request from the user for the at least one document;

retrieving the at least one document from a second data storage as document data, retrieving the at least one annotation to be applied to said at least one document from a first data storage as annotation data, and combining the annotation data and the document data to form a unitary single logical document, the single logical document displaying the annotation embedded seamlessly in the document data; and

in a split component, responsive to a request from the user to store the combined annotation data and document data;

extracting the annotation data and the document data from the single logical document, updating the at least one annotation in the first data storage from the extracted annotation data, and updating the at least one document in the second data storage from the extracted document data,

wherein the annotation data indicates both (i) the at least one section of plural variable-length sections within the document into which the determined at least one annotation is embedded as indicated by the document-image-independent data schema, and (ii) the content-portion of the at least one section, with which the annotation is associated.

44. The method of claim 43, further comprising maintaining a separate version for the at least one annotation and the at least one document.