Wireless device link metric for effective comparison of multi-hop routes in wireless mesh networks

• US 9,860,819 B2
• Filed: 01/29/2013
• Issued: 01/02/2018
• Est. Priority Date: 01/29/2013
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: Natbreway Pty Ltd
• Original Assignee: Cooper Technologies Company (Eaton Corporation PLC.)
• Inventors: Courtice, Harry John
• Primary Examiner(s): Yang, James
• Application Number:
  US13/752,744
• Publication Number:
  US 20140213191A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,799 Days
• Field of Search: None
• CPC Class Codes: H04L 45/125 based on throughput or bandwidth
• CPC Class Codes: H04W 40/12 based on transmission quality or channel quality

Abstract

Link metrics for communication paths in multi-hop wireless mesh networks of industrial radio device are determined based on signal strength and traffic level performance of each link in the communication paths. A path metric is determined from the link metrics and path metrics are compared and utilized for optimal routing of messages through the network.

Claims

1. An input/output device comprising:

a radio frequency transmitter;

a radio frequency receiver; and

a processor-based control element configured to;

iteratively and dynamically determine a path metric for each of a plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths established with and between a plurality of neighbouring input/output devices to route a message to a desired destination in a radio transmission network, wherein the path metric for each of a plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths in the radio transmission network is based upon an approximate signal strength performance and an approximate traffic level performance associated with the neighbouring input/output devices without calculating an actual performance of each signal path, whereby the determined path metrics facilitate an estimated performance comparison of multi-hop signal paths of varying length in the radio transmission network; and

select, based on the determined path metrics for each of the respective multi-hop signal paths and regardless of the path length of the multi-hop signal paths, a preferred one of the multi-hop signal paths to route the message to the desired destination in the radio transmission network.

2. The input/output device of claim 1, wherein the processor-based control element in order to interactively and dynamically determine the path metric for each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths is further configured to:

successively select each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

for each selected one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths;

successively select each one of a plurality of communication links that defines a part of the selected multi-hop signal path;

determine an approximate signal strength performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

determine an approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links; and

based upon the approximate signal strength performance metric and the approximate traffic level performance metric, determine a link metric for each selected one of the plurality of communication links.

3. The input/output device of claim 2, wherein the processor-based control element is, for each selected one of the plurality of communication links, further configured to:

obtain a measured actual signal strength value for the selected one of the plurality communication links; and

compare the obtained measured actual signal strength value to a plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels to determine the approximate signal strength performance metric for the selected one of the plurality communication links.

4. The input/output device of claim 3, wherein the plurality of predetermined and approximate signal strength performance levels are provided in a signal strength performance table accessible by the processor-based control element.

5. The input/output device of claim 4, wherein the plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels are each respectively arranged in positions 1 through x in the signal strength performance table, and the approximate signal strength performance metric corresponds to the position of the predetermined signal strength performance level in the signal strength performance table that is closest to but higher than the obtained measured actual signal strength value.

6. The input/output device of claim 2, wherein the processor-based control element is, for each selected one of the plurality of communication links, further configured to:

obtain a measured actual traffic level value of a respective one of the neighbouring input/output devices at a remote end of the selected one of the plurality communication links; and

compare the obtained measured actual traffic level value to a plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds to determine the approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality communication links.

7. The input/output device of claim 6, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds are provided in a traffic level performance table accessible by the processor-based control element.

8. The input/output device of claim 7, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds are each arranged in positions 1 through y in the traffic level performance table, and the approximate traffic level performance metric corresponds to the position of the traffic level performance threshold in the traffic level performance table that is closest to but lower than the obtained measured actual traffic level value.

9. The input/output device of claim 2, wherein the processor-based control element is further configured to multiply the approximate signal strength performance metric by the approximate traffic level performance metric to determine the link metric for each selected one of the plurality communication links.

10. The input/output device of claim 2, wherein the processor-based control element is configured to determine the link metric for each selected one of the communication links in reference to a two dimensional lookup table according to the approximate signal strength performance metric and the approximate traffic level performance metric.

11. The input/output device of claim 2, wherein at least one of the determined approximate signal strength performance metric and the determined approximate traffic level performance metric is an integer value.

27. The input/output device of claim 1, wherein the processor-based control element is further configured to select a preferred one of the multi-hop signal paths while accounting for cross-correlation between signal strength performance and traffic level performance.

12. A multi-path radio communications network for monitoring and controlling an industrial process, the network comprising:

a plurality of processor-based radio devices configured to wirelessly communicate in a mesh communication network, wherein each processor-based radio device communicates with multiple other ones of the plurality of processor-based radio devices in the mesh communication network; and

wherein at least one of the plurality of processor-based radio devices is configured to iteratively determine a path metric for each of a plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths established between neighbouring input/output devices in the mesh communication network, wherein at least one of the processor-based radio devices in order to iteratively determine the path metric is configured to;

successively select each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

successively select each one of a plurality of communication links in the selected multi-hop signal path, and for each selected one of the plurality of communication links;

obtain a measured actual signal strength value for the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

compare the obtained measured actual signal strength value to a plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels to determine an approximate signal strength performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

obtain a measured actual traffic level value of a respective one of the neighbouring input/output devices at a remote end of the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

compare the obtained measured actual traffic level value to a plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds to determine an approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links; and

determine, without calculating an actual performance of the selected communication link, a link metric utilizing both of the approximate signal strength performance metric and the approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links.

13. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 12, wherein the at least one of the processor-based radio devices is further configured to:

utilize the determined link metric for the selected communication links in each selected multi-hop signal path to evaluate an estimated performance of each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

select, based upon the evaluated estimated performance of each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths and without regard to path length, a preferred multi-hop signal path to route a message to a destination in the mesh communication network.

14. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 13, wherein the at least one of the processor-based radio devices is further configured to:

add the determined link metrics for each communication link in each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to determine a path metric for each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

compare the added determined path metrics of each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to select a preferred one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to route the message to the destination.

15. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 12, wherein the processor-based control element is further configured to multiply the approximate signal strength performance metric by the approximate traffic level performance metric to determine the link metric for the selected communication link.

16. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 12, wherein the processor-based control element is configured to determine the link metric for each selected communication link in reference to a two dimensional lookup table according to the approximate signal strength performance metric and the approximate traffic level performance metric.

17. The multi-path radio communications network device of claim 12, wherein the plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels are provided in a signal strength performance table accessible by the processor-based control element.

18. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 17, wherein the plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels are each respectively arranged in positions 1 through x in the signal strength performance table, and the approximate signal strength performance metric corresponds to the position of the predetermined signal strength performance level in the signal strength performance table that is closest to but higher than the obtained measured actual signal strength value.

19. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 12, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds are provided in a traffic level performance table accessible by the processor-based control element.

20. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 19, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds are each arranged in positions 1 through y in the traffic level performance table, and the approximate traffic level performance metric corresponds to the position of the traffic level performance threshold in the traffic level performance table that is closest to but lower than the obtained measured actual traffic level value.

21. The input/output device of claim 12, wherein at least one of the determined approximate signal strength performance metric and the determined approximate traffic level performance metric is an integer value.

28. The multi-path radio communications network of claim 12, wherein the at least one of the plurality of processor-based radio devices is configured to determine a link metric while accounting for cross-correlation between signal strength performance and traffic level performance.

22. A multi-path radio communications system comprising:

a plurality of processor-based radio devices configured to wirelessly communicate with one another in a mesh communication network having a frequency hopping spread spectrum topology, each of the plurality of processor-based radio devices being configured to;

successively select each one of a plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to route a message to a desired destination in the mesh communication network;

successively select each one of a plurality of communication links in the selected one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths, and for each selected one of the plurality of communication links;

obtain a measured actual signal strength value for the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

compare the obtained measured actual signal strength value to a plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels to determine an approximate signal strength performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

obtain a measured actual traffic level value of a respective one of the neighbouring input/output devices at a remote end of the selected one of the plurality of communication links;

compare the obtained measured actual traffic level value to a plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds to determine an approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links; and

determine a link metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links utilizing both of the approximate signal strength performance metric and the approximate traffic level performance metric for the selected one of the plurality of communication links; and

utilize the determined link metric for the selected communication links in each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to evaluate an estimated performance of each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths without calculating an actual performance each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

select, based upon the evaluated estimated performance of each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths and without regard to path length, a preferred one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to route the message to the desired destination in the mesh communication network.

23. The multi-path radio communications system of claim 22, wherein each of the processor-based radio devices is further configured to:

add the determined link metrics for each one of the plurality of communication links in each of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to determine the path metric for each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths; and

compare the path metrics of each one of the plurality of possible multi-hop signal paths to the desired destination.

24. The multi-path radio communications system of claim 23, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds and the plurality of predetermined signal strength thresholds are each provided in a table accessible by each of the processor-based radio devices.

25. The multi-path radio communications system of claim 24, wherein the table is a two dimensional lookup table.

26. The multi-path radio communications system of claim 24, wherein the plurality of predetermined traffic level performance thresholds and the plurality of predetermined signal strength performance levels are each arranged in positions 1 through n in the table, wherein the approximate traffic level performance metric corresponds to the position of the traffic level performance threshold in the traffic level performance table that is closest to but lower than the obtained measured actual traffic level value, and wherein the approximate signal strength performance metric corresponds to the position of the predetermined signal strength performance level in the signal strength performance table that is closest to but higher than the obtained measured actual signal strength value.

29. The multi-path radio communications system of claim 22, wherein each of the plurality of processor-based radio devices is further configured to determine a link metric while accounting for cross-correlation between signal strength performance and traffic level performance.