Error and manipulation resistant search technology

• US 10,706,092 B1
• Filed: 08/29/2019
• Issued: 07/07/2020
• Est. Priority Date: 07/28/2013
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: William S. Morriss
• Original Assignee: William S. Morriss
• Inventors: Morriss, William S.
• Primary Examiner(s): Adams, Charles D
• Application Number:
  US16/554,714
• Time in Patent Office: 313 Days
• Field of Search: None
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/355 Class or cluster creation or modification
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/367 Ontology
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/382 using citations hypermedia G06F16/94
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/9538 Presentation of query results
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 40/295 Named entity recognition
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 40/30 Semantic analysis

Abstract

Search may be provided using a database storing a plurality of documents comprising a first set of documents and a second set of documents, a set of vetting values and a computer readable medium. In such a system, for each document in the second set of documents, the first set of documents comprises a document for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as a subsequent related document. Additionally, the set of vetting values may comprise, for each document from the second set of documents, a vetting value for the document from the first set of documents for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as the subsequent related document. Additionally, the medium may store instructions to respond to a query by determining, based on the set of vetting values, a search result set comprising documents from the first set of documents.

Claims

1. A system comprising:

a) a database, the database storing a plurality of documents comprising;

i) a first set of documents;

ii) a second set of documents, wherein, for each document in the second set of documents, the first set of documents comprises a document for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as a subsequent related document;

b) a set of vetting values, wherein the set of vetting values comprises, for each document from the second set of documents, a vetting value for the document from the first set of documents for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as the subsequent related document; and

c) a non-transitory computer readable medium storing instructions to respond to a query by determining, based on the set of vetting values, a search result set comprising documents from the first set of documents, wherein the search result set does not comprise any documents from the second set of documents;

wherein;

A) the plurality of documents comprises a third set of documents, the third set of documents comprising, for each document in the first set of documents, a document identified as a preceding related document for that document from the first set of documents; and

B) the search result set does not comprise any documents from the third set of documents

C) the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions to;

I) generate the set of vetting values based on, for each document from the second set of documents;

a) a set of semantic items corresponding to that document; and

b) a set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the third set of documents identified as the preceding related document for the document from the first set of documents for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as the subsequent related document;

II) for each document from the second set of documents, identify the set of semantic items for that document by performing steps comprising identifying a set of topics for that document;

III) for each document from the third set of documents, identify the set of semantic items for that document by performing steps comprising identifying a set of topics for that document;

IV) for each document from the first set of documents for which a document from the second set of documents is identified as a subsequent related document;

a) for each topic for the document from the third set of documents identified as the previous related document for that document from the first set of documents;

i) generate a vetting value for that topic and that document from the first set of documents based on comparing a first subset of semantic items with a second subset of semantic items, wherein;

 

A) the first subset of semantic items comprises semantic items from the set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the third set of documents identified as the previous related document for that document from the first set of documents;

 

B) the second subset of semantic items comprises semantic items from the set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the second subset of documents identified as the related subsequent document for that document from the first set of documents; and

 

C) all semantic items comprised by the first and second subsets of semantic items are associated with that topic.

2. The system of claim 1, wherein the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions to:

a) receive a specified topic; and

b) determine the search result set to only include documents for which the set of topics for the document identified as the preceding related document includes the specified topic.

3. The system of claim 2, wherein the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions to define the specified topic based on:

a) a user uploading a input document via a user interface; and

b) identifying the specified topic as a topic for the input document.

4. The system of claim 1, wherein the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions to present a search result interface, wherein:

a) the search result interface is operable by a user to access one or more documents from the search result set; and

b) for each document from the search result set accessible by the user via the search result interface, the search result interface makes documents identified as related documents for that document from the search result set accessible by the user.

5. The system of claim 4, wherein the search result interface makes documents identified as related documents accessible by the user by:

a) providing, for each document from the search result set accessible by the user via the search result interface, a link to a list of related documents for that document from the search result set; and

b) responding to activation of the link to the list of related documents for a document from the search result set by providing a page comprising links to the documents identified as related documents for that document from the search result set.

6. The system of claim 1, wherein the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions to present a search result interface, wherein:

a) the search result interface comprises a tool operable to submit a request to filter the search result set based on the set of vetting values; and

b) the non-transitory computer readable medium stores instructions operable to, in response a request to filter the search result set based on the set of vetting values, present a result list of documents from the search result set that are both filtered and sorted based on the set of vetting values.

7. A method comprising:

a) storing, in a database, a plurality of documents, the plurality of documents comprising;

i) a first set of documents;

ii) a second set of documents, wherein, for each document in the second set of documents, the first set of documents comprises a document for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as a subsequent related document;

b) generating a set of vetting values, wherein the set of vetting values comprises, for each document from the second set of documents, a vetting value for the document from the first set of documents for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as the subsequent related document; and

c) responding to a query by determining, based on the set of vetting values, a search result set comprising documents from the first set of documents, wherein the search result set does not comprise any documents from the second set of documents;

wherein;

A) the plurality of documents comprises a third set of documents, the third set of documents comprising, for each document in the first set of documents, a document identified as a preceding related document for that document from the first set of documents;

B) the search result set does not comprise any documents from the third set of documents;

C) the set of vetting values is generated based on, for each document from the second set of documents;

I) a set of semantic items corresponding to that document;

II) a set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the third set of documents identified as the preceding related document for the document from the first set of documents for which that document from the second set of documents is identified as the subsequent related document;

D) the method comprises;

I) for each document from the second set of documents, identifying the set of semantic items for that document by performing steps comprising identifying a set of topics for that document;

II) for each document from the third set of documents, identifying the set of semantic items for that document by performing steps comprising identifying a set of topics for that document

III) for each document from the first set of documents for which a document from the second set of documents is identified as a subsequent related document;

a) for each topic for the document from the third set of documents identified as the previous related document for that document from the first set of documents;

i) generating a vetting value for that topic and that document from the first set of documents based on comparing a first subset of semantic items with a second subset of semantic items, wherein;

 

A) the first subset of semantic items comprises semantic items from the set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the third set of documents identified as the previous related document for that document from the first set of documents;

 

B) the second subset of semantic items comprises semantic items from the set of semantic items corresponding to the document from the second subset of documents identified as the related subsequent document for that document from the first set of documents; and

 

C) all semantic items comprised by the first and second subsets of semantic items are associated with that topic.

8. The method of claim 7, wherein the method comprises:

a) receiving a specified topic; and

b) determining the search result set to only include documents for which the set of topics for the document identified as the preceding related document includes the specified topic.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein the method comprises defining the specified topic based on:

a) a user uploading an input document via a user interface; and

b) identifying the specified topic as a topic for the input document.

10. The method of claim 7, wherein the method comprises executing instructions to present a search result interface, wherein:

a) the search result interface is operable by a user to access one or more documents from the search result set; and

b) for each document from the search result set accessible by the user via the search result interface, the search result interface makes documents identified as related documents for that document from the search result set accessible by the user.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein the search result interface makes documents identified as related documents accessible by the user by:

a) providing, for each document from the search result set accessible by the user via the search result interface, a link to a list of related documents for that document from the search result set; and

b) responding to activation of the link to the list of related documents for a document from the search result set by providing a page comprising links to the documents identified as related documents for that document from the search result set.

12. The method of claim 7, wherein the method comprises executing instructions to present a search result interface, wherein:

a) the search result interface comprises a tool operable to submit a request to filter the search result set based on the set of vetting values; and

b) the method comprises, in response a request to filter the search result set based on the set of vetting values, present a result list of documents from the search result set that are both filtered and sorted based on the set of vetting values.