Collision avoidance apparatus

• US 4,623,966 A
• Filed: 02/15/1984
• Issued: 11/18/1986
• Est. Priority Date: 02/19/1983
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: O'SULLIVAN, JAMES P., 7 CROHAM CLOSE, SOUTH CROYDON, SURREY CR2 ODA, A BRITISH SUBJECT
• Original Assignee: Sperry Corporation
• Inventors: O'Sullivan, James P.
• Primary Examiner(s): Chin, Gary
• Application Number:
  US06/580,510
• Time in Patent Office: 1,007 Days
• Field of Search: 364/460, 364/461, 364/443, 340/904, 340/901, 340/902, 340/903, 180/167, 180/168, 180/169, 343/7 A, 343/455, 343/5 EM
• US Class Current: 701/301
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 13/937 of marine craft
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 7/22 Producing cursor lines and indicia by electronic means
• CPC Class Codes: G01S 7/24 the display being orientated or displaced in accordance with movement of object carrying the transmitting and receiving apparatus, e.g. true-motion radar

Abstract

Apparatus for assessing maneuvers of a first vehicle (6) so fitted relative to other vehicles (58, 68, 71-74) comprises sensing means for providing signals representative of the positions and velocities of the other vehicles relative to the first vehicle (6), computing means responsive to said signals for computing symbology respectively associated with the other vehicles, and display means coupled to the computing means for displaying the symbology relative to the position of the first vehicle, thereby providing indicia to assess maneuvers of the first vehicle which will avoid collision with the other vehicles, and which will ensure that the first vehicle will not pass closer to the other vehicles than a predetermined distance for all relative positions and velocities thereof, the symbology associated with each of the other vehicles in all encounter circumstances comprises at least a final escape point (FEP) (40) which, if reached by the first vehicle (6), will allow the first vehicle still to avoid the associated other vehicle by said predetermined distance, and two vectors (49, 50), originating at the FEP, for the first vehicle, which will take the latter clear ahead or clear astern of said other vehicle by said predetermined distance.

Claims

1. In apparatus for assessing maneuvers of a first vehicle relative to other vehicles comprising sensing means for providing signals representative of the positions and velocities of the other vehicles relative to the first vehicle, symbology generating means responsive to said signals for generating symbology respectively associated with the other vehicles, and display means coupled to the symbology generating means for displaying the symbology relative to the position of the first vehicle so as to provide indicia to assess maneuvers of the first vehicle which will avoid collision with the other vehicles, and which will ensure that the first vehicle will not pass closer to the other vehicles than a predetermined distance for all relative positions and velocities thereof, said symbology generating means comprising means for generating symbology associated with each of the other vehicles in all encounter circumstances with at least a final escape point (FEP) which, if reached by the first vehicle, will allow the first vehicle still to avoid the associated other vehicle by said predetermined distance, and two vectors, originating at the FEP, which if taken by the first vehicle at the FEP, will take the first vehicle clear ahead or clear astern of said other vehicle by said predetermined distance.

2. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein said symbology generating means comprises means for generating said symbology associated with each of the other vehicles in the form of at least one closed region representing a predicted area of danger (PAD area), the periphery of the region being defined by lines joining points which are determined according to the hazard category of the other vehicles but in each case said points including the FEP and end points of said vectors representing the two clearing headings originating at the FEP, said end points representing the position of the vehicle when the closest point of approach (CPA) occurs with respect to the other vehicle, said CPA being determined by said predetermined distance.

3. Apparatus according to claim 2, wherein said points include a possible point of collision (PPC) of the first vehicle with the other vehicle if said PPC exists.

4. Apparatus according to any of claims 1 to 3, wherein said symbology generating means comprises means for symbology generating said symbology with the FEP determined according to the following rules:

1. for faster intruding vehicles possessing duplex PAD areas, the FEPs are located at the particular point along the directions of headings towards either PPC representing the final position from which a heading is available to the first vehicle from which the first vehicle can pass clear ahead of the intruding vehicle with the predetermined CPA distance,

2. for a slower intruding vehicle, the ratio of the speed of which with respect to the speed of the first vehicle is greater than a predetermined constant, and the aspect angle of which is less than a right angle, the FEP is the particular point along the direction of the heading towards the single PPC at which the range to the intruding vehicle bears a fixed ratio with respect to the preselected CPA distance,

6. Apparatus according to claim 4, wherein the predetermined constant and said fixed ratio of Rule 2 are 1/8 and 1.5:

1, respectively, the predetermined constant and fixed ratio of Rule 3 are 1/8 and 1.1;

1, respectively, the fixed ratio of Rule 4 is 1.1;

1, and the predetermined amount of Rule 5 is 1.1 times the selected CPA distance.

7. Apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the two vectors originating at the FEP are in the form of straight lines representing the actual length and direction of vectors of the first vehicle which are necessary to achieve the predetermined CPA, assuming that the first vehicle has reached the FEP.

8. Apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the nearside periphery, with respect to the first vehicle, of the PAD area maintains fixed proportions throughout the time that the first vehicle heads towards the PAD area on the identified most critical heading.

9. Apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the form of the PAD area is such as to confirm the presence or absence of one or two points of possible collision.

10. Apparatus according to claim 2 wherein said symbology generating means includes means for eliminating the option of the first vehicle passing in front of a faster other vehicle on an evasive heading that passes between the primary and dual PAD areas of the other vehicle in those circumstances in which the first vehicle has not selected the option to pass in front of the other vehicle, the option being eliminated at a time earlier than that required by the geometry of the encounter and the appropriate FEP Rule for faster targets.

11. Apparatus according to claim 2, wherein said symbology generating means includes predictive mode means for providing predictive symbology resulting from initiating a trial heading or a trial repositioning of the symbology of the first vehicle relative to the symbology of another vehicle, said predictive symbology being displayed simultaneously with real situation symbology for a predetermined time interval, together with appropriate predictive relocation of any digital map element being displayed at that time.

12. Apparatus according to claim 10, wherein the predictive symbology is displayed differently from the real situation symbology, whereby the two symbologies are readily distinguished.

13. Apparatus according to claim 10 or 11 in which said predictive mode means includes means for trial repositioning of the symbology of the first vehicle relative to the symbology of another vehicle in a single-step or multi-step operation.

14. Apparatus according to claim 2 wherein said symbology generating means includes means for establishing predetermined ratios to link the dimensions of a PAD area to the risk potential of the associated vehicle and for moderating said predetermined ratios by applying preselected additional ratio to increase the margin of safety.

15. Apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the symbology generating means comprise a computer having a two way link with a track-while-scan system, and a timer, an output from the computer being connected to a symbol generator having an output in turn connected to the display means and having a two-way link with the timer, the symbology generating means further comprising control means connected between the display means, on the one hand, and the track-while-scan system and the computer, on the other hand.

5. for a slower intruding vehicle the ratio of the speed of which with respect to the speed of the first vehicle is less than a predetermined constant, or the aspect angle of which is greater than a right angle, the FEP is the particular point along the direction of the heading towards the PPC at which the range to the intruding vehicle bears a fixed ratio to the preselected CPA distance, which fixed ratio is less than that of Rule 2,for a faster intruding vehicle displaying duplex PAD areas, each having a FEP, at the moment when the nearer of the two FEPs approaches to a range from the first vehicle which bears a fixed ratio to the pre-selected CPA distance in a situation in which the heading of the first vehicle lies outside the sector established by the primary and dual CPA positions related to the target passing astern, entering which sector is equivalent to the first vehicle crossing the bow of the faster intruding vehicle, the Rule for the range to the target at FEP will be changed from that established by Rule 1 to one which will ensure that the final CPA distance which will result from the first vehicle altering its heading on reaching the FEP to a heading parallel to the intruder'"'"'s heading will bear a fixed ratio to the pre-selected CPA distance,if the heading of the first vehicle lies within the sector defined in Rule 4, indicating the intention of the first vehicle to cross ahead of the intruding vehicle, as the range to the nearer FEP reaches a predetermined amount greater than the preselected CPA distance, Rule 1 will be maintained or re-established if possible until the duplex PAD areas of the intruding vehicle merge at a position along its trackline which is determined by the intersection of the trackline with the predicted heading of the first vehicle, which will occur some time after the first vehicle has crossed the bow of the intruding vehicle, thereupon the FEP Rule will be changed to the relationships established by Rule 4.