Frequency, phase and modulation control system which is especially useful in simulcast transmission systems

• US 5,031,230 A
• Filed: 10/24/1988
• Issued: 07/09/1991
• Est. Priority Date: 10/24/1988
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Motorola, Inc. (Motorola Solutions, Inc.), Simulcomm Partnership of Cellular Technology Incorporated A NY Partnership
• Original Assignee: Simulcomm Partnership
• Inventors: Sandahl, Joel, O'Brien, Michael P., Donaher, Thomas P.
• Primary Examiner(s): Eisenzopf, Reinhard J.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Urban, Edward
• Application Number:
  US07/261,530
• Time in Patent Office: 988 Days
• Field of Search: 455/50, 455/51, 455/63, 455/24, 455/53, 455/67, 455/102, 455/103, 455/119, 455/118, 455/101, 455/116, 455/182, 455/183, 328/134, 328/155, 375/107, 375/109, 331/17, 324/79
• US Class Current: 455/501
• CPC Class Codes: H03L 7/18 using a frequency divider or counter in the loop H03L7/20, H03L7/22 take precedence
• CPC Class Codes: H04B 2001/0491 with frequency synthesizers, frequency converters or modulators
• CPC Class Codes: H04H 20/67 Common-wave systems, i.e. using separate transmitters operating on substantially the same frequency

Abstract

A system enabling the frequency, and if desired, phase control of an oscillator which generates a standard signal useful as a carrier which is modulated by modulation signals. A multiplicity of such oscillators and associated transmitters may be used in a simulcast transmission system. The transmissions originate from a station which may be remote from the transmitters. The station has a system controller and the transmitters have transmitter controllers. For frequency control a reference signal generated in the system controller is transmitted over the same link and band width (e.g. the voice band width) with the voice modulating signals to the transmitter controllers of all of the transmitters. At the transmitter controllers, multiplicities of phase measurements are made from which statistical values of phase, deviations and times of occurrence are collected and used to provide error control signals in terms of the ratio of phase difference to time, notwithstanding that the reference signals may jitter in phase and amplitude due to noise and other errors and also notwithstanding that the phase measured at various of the times may include a multiplicity of phase wraps (the phase difference being greater than one cycle or 360°.) The frequency errors may be applied to the standard oscillator to lock the phase thereof in predetermined relationship with the reference. For modulation control codes representing deviations from matched correlation characteristics (delay, gain and frequency spectrum) are transmitted to each transmitter where modulation signal correction circuits are conditioned to process the modulating signals so that the transmissions from each transmitter will be matched in modulation characteristics.

Claims

1. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least greater than the period of said standard signal, means for computing a frequency error signal in terms of the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times and means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means.

2. The system according to claim 1 further comprising means for varying said frequency error signal until said phase measurement at the end of said duration between said two times reaches a predetermined phase measurement thereby locking said standard source and reference source in phase relationship corresponding to said predetermined phase measurement.

3. The system according to claim 1 further comprising means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least of the order of minutes.

4. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, means for making a plurality of said phase measurements over an interval occurring at each of said times, means for deriving from said plurality of measurements over said intervals the means of said phase managements during said intervals and the variances of said measurements from said means, and means for enabling said applying means when said variances are within certain bounds.

5. The system according to claim 4 including means for deriving said bounds from the standard deviations of said variances of said measurements from said mean at said times which are spaced by said duration.

6. The system according to claim 5 wherein the duration of said interval is at least equal to the period of the lowest frequency component of jitter in said phase measurements.

7. The system according to claim 6 wherein said rate is about every 2 cycles of said reference signal and said interval is from about 50 to 100 milliseconds (ms).

8. The system according to claim 4 wherein said bounds is the measurement error of said phase measurements at said times which is equal to a predetermined multiple of the sum of the standard deviations of said variances at said times which are spaced by said duration.

9. The system according to claim 4 wherein said means for making said plurality of phase measurements is operative at a rate which is a multiple of the bandwidth of said reference signal and said interval has a duration where in the integral of noise in said reference signal is non-zero.

10. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, and wherein said plurality of items is at least 3, one of which is at a time intermediate said duration, and correlation determining means for determining whether the phase measurement at said intermediate time correlates with the phase measurements at the times spaced by said duration.

11. The system according to claim 10 wherein said correlation determining means comprises means responsive to the duration between the phase measurement at said intermediate time along the slope defined by said phase measurements at the time spaced by said duration and the phase measurement at said intermediate time.

12. The system according to claim 11 wherein said phase measurement providing means comprises means for making a multiplicity of said measurements during a predetermined interval at each of said times, means for deriving said phase measurements at each of said times as the mean of said multiplicity of measurements and for deriving a predetermined statistical deviation of said multiplicity of said measurements from said mean as said deviation.

13. The system according to claim 12 wherein said predetermined deviation is the standard deviation.

14. The system according to claim 11 wherein said means for determining whether said phase measurement at said intermediate time correlates, includes means for determining whether said deviation of said intermediate measurement is a predetermined multiple of said predetermined statistical deviation.

15. The system according to claim 14 wherein said phase measurement providing means further comprises means for making another phase measurement later in time than the end of said duration and extending said duration to the time of said later in time measurement when said correlation determining means determines the absence of correlation.

16. The system according to claim 15 wherein said correlation determining means includes means operative upon said another phase measurement and the one of said intermediate measurements and the one of said intermediate measurements and the measurement at the end of said duration which has the lesser time difference between it and its preceding phase measurement for determining correlation.

17. The system according to claim 16 wherein said phase measurement means includes means for providing a pair of said intermediate phase measurements which are spaced in time from each other.

18. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, and means responsive to said phase measurements for adjusting said measurement at the end of said duration to accommodate one or more wraps in said measurement where said phase difference exceeds one cycle or multiples thereof.

19. The system according to claim 18 wherein said phase wrap accommodating means comprises means for making at least one phase measurement at a time intermediate said duration, correlation means for correlating said phase measurement with the phase along a line having a slope extending between an initial one of said phase measurements at the beginning of said duration and the phase measurement at the end of said duration, and means for increasing and decreasing the phase measurement at the end of said duration until correlation exists or the frequency error exceeds the adjustment range of said standard source.

20. The system according to claim 19 wherein said phase measurement means comprises means for making a multiplicity of said measurements during a predetermined interval at each of said times, means for deriving said phase measurements at each of said times as the mean of said multiplicity of measurements and for deriving a predetermined statistical deviation of said multiplicity of measurements from said mean, said correlation means including means for determining the existence of correlation when said intermediate measurement differs from the phase along said slope at the time of said intermediate measurement by a predetermined multiple of said statistical deviation.

21. The system according to claim 19 wherein said phase adjustment means also includes means for adjusting the phase of said intermediate measurement by a phase difference equal to one or more wraps in phase when it occurs at a time when said slope exceeds a phase difference greater than one cycle.

22. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least greater than the period of said standard signal, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, and means for changing said frequency error signal by an amount corresponding to a predetermined frequency offset thereby locking said standard signal to a frequency which differs from the frequency of said reference source by said offset.

23. The method of deriving a measurement of the frequency error between a standard signal and a reference which may be corrupted by noise and other error signals, which method comprises the steps of collecting a multiplicity of sample phase measurements of the phase difference between said reference and standard signal at a predetermined rate during an initial interval of predetermined duration and at a plurality of other intervals each occurring later in time, generating a table for each of said measurements containing its mean value, its statistical deviation and the time of its occurrence, adjusting the mean phase values in the table except for the mean phase value for the initial interval until the values lie within a predetermined multiple of their standard deviation from a line between the last and initial ones of said mean phase values which line represents an indicated frequency error thereby indicating a correlation condition, outputting said indicated frequency error as said frequency error when said indicated frequency error is less than a predetermined multiple of the sum of the standard deviations of the initial and last of said standard deviation values in said table.

24. The method according to claim 23 further comprising the step of removing said table values for the one of said measurements which is closest in time to a phase measurement which proceeds it when said correlation condition is not achieved notwithstanding adjustment of said mean phase values except for said initial mean phase value by a predetermined number of wraps (corresponding to phase differences equal to a cycle or 360°

of phase difference) which exceeds the adjustment range of said standard signal, then replacing the last phase value in said table with a mean phase value for a multiplicity of phase measurements occurring at an interval later in time than the last occurring of said intervals.

25. The method according to claim 23 further comprising the step of storing values in said table as the values for said initial interval only if the standard deviation thereof is less than a predetermined standard deviation thereby excluding measurements using said reference signal when it is badly corrupted to provide values for said initial interval in said table.

26. A communication system for matching signals transmitted simultaneously by a plurality of transmitters in their modulation characteristics which comprises a station for generating said signals, said station having system controller means for generating calibration signals, a plurality of transmitter controller means each connected to a different one of said transmitters, each of said transmitter controller means having means for controlling the modulation characteristics transmitted therethrough, means for transmitting said calibration signals at different times to different ones of said transmitters, means at said station for receiving said calibration signals from said transmitters, said system controller having means for correlating said calibration signals received from said transmitters with each other and for transmitting digital control signals to each of said transmitters representing differences in said modulation characteristics therebetween, and means in said transmitter controller means responsive to said digital control signals for operating said modulation characteristic controlling means to match said modulation characteristics of said transmitters.

27. The system according to claim 26 wherein said modulation characteristics are selected from the group consisting of delay, gain and spectral content, and said modulation characteristic control means includes circuit means in the path of signals for modulating said transmitters selected from the group consisting of delay insertion means, gain control means and filter means.

28. The system according to claim 26 wherein said transmitters are controlled in carrier frequency of the signals which are modulated therein, said system controller means including means for transmitting a reference signal at a frequency in the voice band to said transmitters, and means in said transmitter controller including a carrier frequency source responsive intermittently to said control signals for deriving measurements of the frequency error between said reference signal and a signal coherent with said carrier frequency for controlling the frequency of said carrier frequency source.

29. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least greater than the period of said standard signal, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, and means for selecting said times so that a plurality of said durations are unequal from each other and are not integral multiples.

30. A system for providing a signal controlled in frequency which comprises means for providing a source of reference signal, means for providing a standard signal, the frequency of which is responsive to a frequency error signal, means for providing measurements of the relative phase difference between said reference and standard signals at a plurality of times spaced in duration from each other, means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least greater than the period of said standard signal, means for translating the ratio of the difference in said phase measurements at at least two of said times to said duration between said two times into said frequency error signal, means for applying said frequency error signal to said standard signal providing means, and said means for providing a source of reference signal including means operative to provide said reference signal intermittently at times spaced in duration from each other corresponding to the times when said measurements are made.

31. In a communications system wherein information signals are transmitted over a certain bandwidth from a station for retransmission by transmitters remote from said station and each of which has an oscillator, a control system for controlling said oscillators of said transmitters which comprises means for transmitting reference signals in said bandwidth from said station to said transmitters at a plurality of times the interval between which is varied, means for selecting said times such that said times are spaced in duration by durations that are at least greater than the period of said reference signal, transmitter controlling means in each of said transmitters having means for providing measurements of the phase differences between said reference signals and signals from the oscillator thereof at each of said times, means for providing outputs corresponding to the slope of said phase measurements to provide frequency error signals, and means for providing said error signals to said oscillator.

32. The control system according to claim 31 further comprising means for making a plurality of said phase measurements over an interval occurring at each of said times, means for deriving from said plurality of measurements over said intervals, the means of said measurements during said intervals and the variances of said measurements from said means, and means for enabling said applying means when said variances are within certain bounds.

33. The system according to claim 32 wherein said variances are represented by the standard deviation of said measurements.

34. The control system according to claim 31 further comprising means responsive to the duration between successive ones of said phase measurements for determining the correlation therebetween.

35. In a communication system having a plurality of transmitters for transmitting signals simultaneously, said system having a station for generating said signals and also for generating control signals, apparatus for controlling the modulation characteristics of said signals, which said transmitters are transmitting comprising transmitter controllers in each of said transmitters, means for operating said transmitter controllers with said control signals, CODECS in said transmitter controllers for applying said signals which said transmitters are transmitting to said transmitters, said CODECS having means for converting said signals into PCM signals and back from PCM signals into said signals which said transmitters are transmitting, and means in said transmitter controllers for addressing said CODECS to interpose selective delay on said signals being applied to said transmitters.

36. The apparatus according to claim 35 wherein said addressing means is a CPU, and means for inputting data corresponding to said control signals to said CPU.