Apparatus and method for verifying compatibility of system components

• US 5,579,509 A
• Filed: 02/08/1991
• Issued: 11/26/1996
• Est. Priority Date: 02/08/1991
• Status: Expired due to Fees

• Current Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Original Assignee: International Business Machines Corporation
• Inventors: Furtney, David A., Simonson, Douglas L., Ingebretson, Mark E.
• Primary Examiner(s): Lall, Parshotam S.
• Assistant Examiner(s): VU, VIET DUY
• Application Number:
  US07/652,820
• Time in Patent Office: 2,118 Days
• Field of Search: 395/500, 395/575, 395/600, 395/650, 395/700
• US Class Current: 703/27
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 8/71 Version control security arrangements therefor G06F21/57; Configuration management

Abstract

Each component of a plurality of interacting system components is associated with a version identifier. The version identifier is stored in a location accessible by the other components. Each component independently reads the version identifier of every other component with which it must interact, and compares this value to an internally stored compatibility record to determine whether the other component satisfies requirements for compatibility with the verifying component. Any component which detects an incompatibility signals an error to the system. In the preferred embodiment, the components are software modules, and the version identifier and compatibility record contain integer values. The compatibility record value represents the minimum level required of the module being verified for compatibility with the verifying module. Compatibility verification is accomplished by comparing the actual level of the module being verified with the minimum level in the compatibility record. If the actual level is equal to or greater than the minimum level, the module being verified satisfies compatibility requirements.

Claims

1. A method for verifying that a plurality of system components executing on a computer system are compatible with each other, wherein a component version is associated with each of said plurality of components, and wherein each of said components is associated with a component version identifier identifying the component version of said component, said method comprising steps of:

obtaining the component version identifier associated with a first of said plurality of components;

determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with a second of said plurality of components;

obtaining the component version identifier associated with said second of said plurality of components; and

determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier for associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first of said plurality of components, wherein the determination whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component is independent of the determination whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said second component.

2. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 1, wherein each component version identifier associated with a component is stored in a fixed externally accessible location within the respective component.

3. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 1, wherein each said component is a software module.

4. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 3, wherein:

said step of determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with a second component comprises steps of;

(a) accessing compatible component version identifier information in said second component, and (b) comparing said component version identifier associated with said first component with said compatible component version identifier information in said second component; and

said step of determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component comprises steps of;

(a) accessing compatible component version identifier information in said first component, and (b) comparing said component version identifier associated with said second component with said compatible component version identifier information in said first component.

5. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 4, wherein each component version identifier associated with a component is stored in a fixed externally accessible location within the respective component.

6. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 4, wherein said compatible component version identifier information in said first and second components comprises in each of said components a table of compatible component version identifier values.

7. The method for verifying compatibility of claim 4, wherein:

said component version identifier associated with each of said first and second components comprises an ordered value representing a component version level of the respective component;

said compatible component version identifier information contained in each of said first and second components comprises an ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level;

said step of comparing said component version identifier associated with said first component with said compatible version identifier information contained in said second component comprises comparing said ordered value representing the component version level of said first component with said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said second component and determining that said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said second component if said ordered value representing the component version level of said first component is greater than or equal to said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said second component; and

said step of comparing said component version identifier associated with said second component with said compatible version identifier information contained in said first component comprises comparing said ordered value representing the component version level of said second component with said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component and determining that said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component if said ordered value representing the component version level of said second component is greater than or equal to said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component.

8. A first system component of a plurality of interacting components of a computer system, wherein a component version is associated with each of said plurality of interacting components, said first system component comprising:

a storage area for storing the component version, identifier of said first system component, wherein said computer system includes means for providing said component version identifier of said first system component to a second component of said plurality of interacting components;

identifier fetching means for obtaining the component version identifier associated with said second component of said plurality of interacting components;

means for accessing compatible component version identifier information for said first component, said compatible component version identifier information comprising data other than said component version identifier associated with said first system component;

comparing means for comparing said component version identifier obtained by said identifier fetching means with said compatible component version identifier information to determine whether the component version identified by said component version identifier satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component.

9. The first system component of claim 8, wherein said component version identifier associated with said first component is stored in a fixed location within said first component accessible to means for accessing said component version identifier contained in said second component.

10. The first system component of claim 8, wherein said component is a software module.

11. The first system component of claim 8, wherein:

each said component version identifier associated with a component comprises an ordered value representing a component version level of the respective module;

said compatible component version identifier information associated with said first component comprises an ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level; and

said comparing means compares said ordered value representing the component version level with said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component and determines that said component version satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component if said ordered value representing the component version level is greater than or equal to said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component.

12. The first system component of claim 11, wherein said component version identifier associated with said first component is stored in a fixed location within said first component accessible to means for accessing said component version identifier contained in said second component.

13. The first system component of claim 11, wherein said component is a software module.

14. A computer system comprising:

at least one programmable processor;

a plurality of interacting system components, wherein a respective component version identifier is associated with each of said plurality of interacting components;

means for obtaining the component version identifier associated with a first of said plurality of components;

means for determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first module satisfies requirements for compatibility with a second of said plurality of components;

means for obtaining the component version identifier associated with said second of said plurality of components; and

means for determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first of said plurality of components, wherein the determination whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component is independent of the determination whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said second component.

15. The computer system of claim 14, wherein each component version identifier associated with a component is stored in a fixed externally accessible location within the respective component.

16. The computer system of claim 14, wherein each said interacting system component is a software module.

17. The computer system of claim 16, wherein:

said means for determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with a second component comprises;

(a) means for accessing compatible component version identifier information in said second component, and (b) means for comparing said component version identifier associated with said first component with said compatible component version identifier information in said second component; and

said means for determining whether the component version identified by said component version identifier associated with said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component comprises;

(a) means for accessing compatible component version identifier information in said first component, and (b) means for comparing said component version identifier associated with said second component with said compatible component version identifier information in said first component.

18. The computer system of claim 17, wherein each component version identifier associated with a component is stored in a fixed externally accessible location within the respective component.

19. The computer system of claim 17, wherein:

said component version identifier associated with each of said first and second components comprises an ordered value representing a component version level of the respective component;

said compatible component version identifier information contained in each of said first and second components comprises an ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level;

said means for comparing said component version identifier associated with said first component with said compatible version identifier information contained in said second component compares said ordered value representing the component version level of said first component with said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said second component and determines that said first component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said second component if said ordered value representing the component version level of said first component is greater than or equal to said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said second component; and

said means for comparing said component version identifier associated with said second component with said compatible version identifier information contained in said first component compares said ordered value representing the component version level of said second component with said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component and determines that said second component satisfies requirements for compatibility with said first component if said ordered value representing the component version level of said second component is greater than or equal to said ordered value representing a minimum compatible component version level in said first component.