System, method, and computer program product for developing and maintaining documents which includes analyzing a patent application with regards to the specification and claims

• US 5,754,840 A
• Filed: 01/23/1996
• Issued: 05/19/1998
• Est. Priority Date: 01/23/1996
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: F Poszat Hu LLC (Intellectual Ventures LLC)
• Original Assignee: Smartpatents Incorporated
• Inventors: Rappaport, Irving S., Rivette, Kevin G., O'Brien, Patrick
• Primary Examiner(s): Black, Thomas G.
• Assistant Examiner(s): RONES, CHARLES
• Application Number:
  US08/590,082
• Time in Patent Office: 847 Days
• Field of Search: 395/605, 395/606, 395/798, 395/703, 395/778, 395/751, 395/760, 395/777, 395/773, 395/602, 382/174, 382/138, 382/229
• US Class Current: 1/1
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/30 of unstructured textual data document management systems G06F16/93
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/93 Document management systems
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 40/166 Editing, e.g. inserting or deleting
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/917 Text
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99932 Access augmentation or optimizing
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99933 Query processing, i.e. searching
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99934 Query formulation, input preparation, or translation
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99935 Query augmenting and refining, e.g. inexact access
• CPC Class Codes: Y10S 707/99936 Pattern matching access

Abstract

A system and method for assisting in the preparation of a document, and for analyzing a document, such as a patent or patent application, are described herein. The system aids a user to verify that terms in a patent application are being used consistently. The system also facilitates editing of the patent application so as to achieve terminology consistency. The system operates by allowing a user to select a document containing a patent application. The user then selects the specification portion of the patent application, and also selects the claims portion of the patent application. The system indexes the specification portion and the claims portion to thereby generate a merged index table. The system analyzes the merged index table to identify terms in the claims portion that are not present in the specification portion, and then displays these terms (called claim terms). A user can then edit the patent application so as to properly describe these terms in the specification.

Claims

1. A system for assisting in the analysis of a patent application, comprising:

means for allowing a user to select a document containing a patent application;

means for allowing said user to select a specification portion of said patent application;

means for allowing said user to select a claims portion of said patent application;

means for indexing said specification portion and said claims portion to thereby generate a merged index table;

means for analyzing said merged index table to identify terms in said claims portion that are not present in said specification portion; and

means for displaying said terms in said claims portion that are not present in said specification portion.

2. A method for verifying terminology consistency in a document, comprising the steps of:

(1) indexing terms contained in a first portion of a document to thereby generate a first index table;

(2) indexing terms contained in a second portion of a document to thereby generate a second index table;

(3) merging said first and second index tables to thereby generate a merged index table;

(4) determining by reference to said merged index table terms that are present in said second portion of said document, but not present in said first portion of said document; and

(5) displaying in a hit matrix said terms that are present in said second portion of said document, but not present in said first portion of said document.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application.

4. A method for developing and maintaining documents, comprising the steps of:

(1) displaying a document;

(2) enabling a user to select a first portion and a second portion of said document;

(3) indexing, after receiving an appropriate command from the user, said first portion and said second portion to generate a merged index table, said merged index table storing data representing the number of occurrences of each term in said first portion and said second portion; and

(4) enabling the user to develop and maintain said first and second portions by reference to said merged index table, comprising;

(a) retrieving information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

(b) indicating in a hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said first portion;

(c) indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said second portion;

(d) enabling the user to select a zero hits option;

(e) when the user selects said zero hits option, selecting a next term in said hit matrix having one or more occurrences in said second portion but no occurrences in said first portion; and

(f) displaying text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected next term in said document.

5. The method of claim 4, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

retrieving information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said specification; and

indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said claims section.

6. The method of claim 4, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

enabling the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

displaying text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected term in said document;

enabling the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document; and

displaying text from said document containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document.

7. The method of claim 4, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

enabling the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

displaying in a first window text from said first portion containing an occurrence of said selected term; and

displaying in a second window text from said second portion containing an occurrence of said selected term.

8. The method of claim 4, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

(g) enabling the user to select text from the document;

(h) displaying said selected text in a first window and a second window; and

(i) enabling the user to edit said selected text in said second window.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein step (4) further comprises the step of:

(j) incrementally indexing said document.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein step (j) comprises the steps of:

(I) selecting a word from said second window;

(II) determining the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window, and the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window;

(III) if the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window is not equal to the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window, then updating an index using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window; and

(IV) performing steps (I)-(III) for each word in said second window.

11. The method of claim 10, wherein step (III) comprises the steps of:

determining whether said selected word is in a delta index table;

if said selected word is in said delta index, then updating a count of said selected word in said delta index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window;

if said selected word is not in said delta index table, then determining if said selected word is in said merged index table;

if said selected word is in said merged index table, then updating a count of said selected word in said merged index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window; and

if said selected word is not in said merged index table, then adding said selected word to said delta index table.

12. The method of claim 11, further comprising the step of:

merging said merged index table with said delta index table to form a new merged index table.

13. The method of claim 4, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

(g) sorting terms in said patent application to generate a sorted list;

(h) calculating the number of occurrences of each reference number in said patent application by reference to said sorted list;

(i) determining an element name for each reference number; and

(j) storing, for each reference number, the number of hits for said each reference number and an element name for said each reference number in an element index table.

14. The method of claim 13, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

(k) indicating in an element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, the number of occurrences of a reference number in the specification; and

(l) indicating in said element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, an element name for said reference number.

15. The method of claim 13, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

(k) enabling the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

(l) displaying text from said patent application containing an occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application;

(m) enabling the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application; and

(n) displaying text from said patent application containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application.

16. The method of claim 13, wherein step (4) further comprises the steps of:

(k) enabling the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

(l) enabling the user to select text from said patent application; and

(m) storing in said element index table said selected text as a new element name for said selected reference number.

17. A system for developing and maintaining documents, comprising the steps of:

means for displaying a document;

means for enabling a user to select a first portion and a second portion of said document;

means for indexing, after receiving an appropriate command from the user, said first portion and said second portion to generate a merged index table, said merged index table storing data representing the number of occurrences of each term in said first portion and said second portion; and

enabling means for enabling the user to develop and maintain said first and second portions by reference to said merged index tables

wherein said enabling means comprises;

means for retrieving information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

means for indicating in a hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said first portion;

means for indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said second portion;

means for enabling the user to select a zero hits option;

means for when the user selects said zero hits option selecting a next term in said hit matrix having one or more occurrences in said second portion but no occurrences in said first portion; and

means for displaying text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected next term in said document.

18. The system of claim 17, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for retrieving information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

means for indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said specification; and

means for indicating in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said claims section.

19. The system of claim 17, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

means for displaying text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected term in said document;

means for enabling the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document; and

means for displaying text from said document containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document.

20. The system of claim 17, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

means for displaying in a first window text from said first portion containing an occurrence of said selected term; and

means for displaying in a second window text from said second portion containing an occurrence of said selected term.

21. The system of claim 17, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the user to select text from the document;

means for displaying said selected text in a first window and a second window; and

means for enabling the user to edit said selected text in said second window.

22. The system of claim 21, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

incremental indexing means for incrementally indexing said document.

23. The system of claim 22, wherein said incremental indexing means comprises:

means for selecting a word from said second window;

means for determining the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window, and the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window; and

index updating means for updating an index using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window is not equal to the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window.

24. The system of claim 23, wherein said index updating means comprises:

means for determining whether said selected word is in a delta index table;

means for updating a count of said selected word in said delta index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if said selected word is in said delta index;

means for determining if said selected word is in said merged index table if said selected word is not in said delta index table;

means for updating a count of said selected word in said merged index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if said selected word is in said merged index table; and

means for adding said selected word to said delta index table if said selected word is not in said merged index table.

25. The system of claim 24, further comprising:

means for merging said merged index table with said delta index table to form a new merged index table.

26. The system of claim 17, wherein said document is a patent application, said

first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein said enabling means comprises:

means for sorting terms in said patent application to generate a sorted list;

means for calculating the number of occurrences of each reference number in said patent application by reference to said sorted list;

means for determining an element name for each reference number; and

means for storing, for each reference number, the number of hits for said each reference number and an element name for said each reference number in an element index table.

27. The system of claim 26, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for indicating in an element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, the number of occurrences of a reference number in the specification; and

means for indicating in said element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, an element name for said reference number.

28. The system of claim 26, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

means for displaying text from said patent application containing an occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application;

means for enabling the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application; and

means for displaying text from said patent application containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application.

29. The system of claim 26, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

means for enabling the user to select text from said patent application; and

means for storing in said element index table said selected text as a new element name for said selected reference number.

30. A computer program product comprising a computer useable medium having computer program logic recorded thereon for enabling a processor in a computer system to develop and maintain documents, said computer program logic comprising:

means for enabling the processor to display a document;

means for enabling the processor to enable a user to select a first portion and a second portion of said document;

means for enabling the processor to index, after receiving an appropriate command from the user, said first portion and said second portion to generate a merged index table, said merged index table storing data representing the number of occurrences of each term in said first portion and said second portion; and

enabling means for enabling the processor to enable the user to develop and maintain said first and second portions by reference to said merged index table;

wherein said enabling means comprises;

means for enabling the processor to retrieve information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

means for enabling the processor to indicate in a hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said first portion;

means for enabling the processor to indicate in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said second portion;

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a zero hits option;

means for enabling the processor to select a next term in said hit matrix having one or more occurrences in said second portion but no occurrences in said first portion when the user selects said zero hits option; and

means for enabling the processor to display text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected next term in said document.

31. The computer program product of claim 30, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to retrieve information pertaining to a term from said merged index table;

means for enabling the processor to indicate in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said specification; and

means for enabling the processor to indicate in said hit matrix, based on said retrieved information, whether said term appears in said claims section.

32. The computer program product of claim 30, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

means for enabling the processor to display text from said document containing an occurrence of said selected term in said document;

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document; and

means for enabling the processor to display text from said document containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected term in said document.

33. The computer program product of claim 30, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a term in said hit matrix;

means for enabling the processor to display in a first window text from said first portion containing an occurrence of said selected term; and

means for enabling the processor to display in a second window text from said second portion containing an occurrence of said selected term.

34. The computer program product of claim 30, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select text from the document;

means for enabling the processor to display said selected text in a first window and a second window; and

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to edit said selected text in said second window.

35. The computer program product of claim 34, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

incremental indexing means for enabling the processor to incrementally index said document.

36. The computer program product of claim 35, wherein said incremental indexing means comprises:

means for enabling the processor to select a word from said second window;

means for enabling the processor to determine the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window, and the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window; and

index updating means for enabling the processor to update an index using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if the number of occurrences of said selected word in said first window is not equal to the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window.

37. The computer program product of claim 36, wherein said index updating means comprises:

means for enabling the processor to determine whether said selected word is in a delta index table;

means for enabling the processor to update a count of said selected word in said delta index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if said selected word is in said delta index;

means for enabling the processor to determine if said selected word is in said merged index table if said selected word is not in said delta index table;

means for enabling the processor to update a count of said selected word in said merged index table using the number of occurrences of said selected word in said second window if said selected word is in said merged index table; and

means for enabling the processor to add said selected word to said delta index table if said selected word is not in said merged index table.

38. The computer program product of claim 37, further comprising:

means for enabling the processor to merge said merged index table with said delta index table to form a new merged index table.

39. The computer program product of claim 30, wherein said document is a patent application, said first portion is a specification of said patent application, and said second portion is a claims section of said patent application, and wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to sort terms in said patent application to generate a sorted list;

means for enabling the processor to calculate the number of occurrences of each reference number in said patent application by reference to said sorted list;

means for enabling the processor to determine an element name for each reference number; and

means for enabling the processor to store, for each reference number, the number of hits for said each reference number and an element name for said each reference number in an element index table.

40. The computer program product of claim 39, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to indicate in an element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, the number of occurrences of a reference number in the specification; and

means for enabling the processor to indicate in said element hit matrix, based on information in said element index table, an element name for said reference number.

41. The computer program product of claim 39, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

means for enabling the processor to display text from said patent application containing an occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application;

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application; and

means for enabling the processor to display text from said patent application containing said selected next or previous occurrence of said selected reference number in said patent application.

42. The computer program product of claim 39, wherein said enabling means further comprises:

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select a reference number in an element hit matrix;

means for enabling the processor to enable the user to select text from said patent application; and

means for enabling the processor to store in said element index table said selected text as a new element name for said selected reference number.