System and method for improving integrity of internet search

• US 8,046,346 B2
• Filed: 01/15/2010
• Issued: 10/25/2011
• Est. Priority Date: 02/01/2007
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: John Nagle
• Original Assignee: John Nagle
• Inventors: Nagle, John
• Primary Examiner(s): Fleurantin; Jean B.
• Assistant Examiner(s): Ly; Anh
• Application Number:
  US12/657,253
• Publication Number:
  US 20100121835A1
• Time in Patent Office: 648 Days
• Field of Search: 707/706, 707/709, 707/723, 707/748, 707/770, 715/230, 715/234, 715/237, 705/14.11, 705/14.19
• US Class Current: 707/706
• CPC Class Codes: G06F 16/951 Indexing; Web crawling techniques
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/018 Certifying business or products
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0208 Trade or exchange of goods or services in exchange for incentives or rewards
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0217 involving input on products or services in exchange for incentives or rewards
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0256 User search
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/0282 Rating or review of business operators or products

Abstract

A system and method are provided to receive a search query from a user, typically via a web browser, the Internet, and a web server. A search engine obtains a set of potential search results based on the search query. For each Internet domain or web site mentioned in the search results, a set of data sources is accessed to obtain information concerning the legitimacy of the business associated with the Internet domain or web site. The legitimacy information is used to reorder or to change or to augment the appearance or presentation of the search result for the Internet domain or web site. The processed search results are returned to the user.

Claims

1. A computer-implemented method for providing a search for information available on the World Wide Web on the Internet having enhanced integrity, comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

generating a search query;

transmitting the search query via the Internet to a search engine using a web browser;

providing the search query to the search engine;

performing initial processing of the search query by the search engine;

performing the search and accumulating a set of search results by the search engine, each of which contains at least a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) identifying an Internet domain and page on the World Wide Web selected by the search;

receiving the search results;

extracting a list of URLs and domains;

performing domain processing on the list of URLs and domains to associate a physical business address or business entity with each URL or domain, wherein the domain processing comprises the steps of using a computer system for;

checking a domain name included as part of a URL against a database of domains;

if the domain is in the database, bypassing further processing;

if the domain is not in the database, using name and address extraction to attempt to obtain a physical name and address associated with the domain;

if a reliable name and address are obtained, collecting business information,

wherein collecting business information comprises querying one or more sources of business information consisting of corporate registration information, business rating information, negative information comprising regulatory information, and, for the special case of well-recognized auction web sites and payment systems which undertake to rate, or at least reliably identify, their affiliated merchants, rating information is obtained from the auction or payment site using the cleaned-up name and address information;

computing domain integrity ratings;

using the integrity ratings to at least one of reorder and annotate the search results so as to move results with relatively lower integrity ratings downward in the results; and

returning the at least one of reordered and annotated search results to the web browser via the Internet.

2. The method of claim 1, further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

formatting the reordered and annotated search results for display; and

displaying the reordered and annotated search results.

3. The method of claim 2 wherein web sites rated as having relatively high integrity are identified with a check mark in a circle, web sites for which insufficient information is obtained are identified with a question mark in a circle, and web sites rated as having relatively low integrity are identified with an “

X”

in a circle and wherein the web sites rated with relatively high integrity are moved to the top of the search results and web sites with relatively low integrity are moved down and displayed in smaller type in the search results.

4. The method of claim 1 wherein the search query is entered manually by an end user and transmitted through a personal computer running a web browser able to handle the search query.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein the database is

a local database of known domains for which integrity ratings are available to eliminate unnecessary reprocessing of domains already evaluated and

if the domain is in the database indicating an integrity rating is already available, bypassing further processing and returning an integrity rating immediately.

6. The method of claim 1 wherein in the event that the name and address of the business cannot be located, further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

sending control to a commerce site test where an attempt is made to determine whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce; and

if the web site appears to be engaged in commerce, but a name and address cannot be reliably associated with the site, considering the site to be a less than legitimate business and assigning a relatively low integrity rating, thereby having the effect of substantially degrading search result placement and thus encouraging Internet businesses to comply with disclosure requirements.

7. The method of claim 6 wherein the commerce site test is performed to determine whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

examining the text of web pages originated by a quick web site crawl for indications that the web site is selling something; and

returning a yes/no decision.

8. The method of claim 7 wherein the quick web site crawl comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

limiting examination to the first few web pages of a web site beginning with a starting domain name or URL to determine if the site is selling something, which is added to a list of URLs to fetch;

for each domain name or URL, fetching the relevant web page by a web page reader via the Internet from the target web site to obtain a local copy of the web page;

examining the fetched web page for links to other web pages;

passing the fetched web page to a relevance tester, which uses a set of relevance rules to determine which links are relevant;

feeding back relevant links into the list of URLs to fetch and ignoring links which are not relevant; and

returning the web pages that are collected.

9. The method of claim 1 wherein in the event that the name and address of the business cannot be located, further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

sending control to a commerce site test where an attempt is made to determine whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce; and

if the web site is not selling anything, but is simply informational, returning a neutral integrity rating.

10. The method of claim 1 wherein name and address extraction comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

performing one or more of the following;

accessing the domain name associated with a URL to obtain a name and address of the owner of the domain and the web site based on information provided for domain registration using the standard WHOIS protocol;

retrieving any available Secure Sockets Layer certificate also known as a “

X.509 certificate”

issued by certification authorities; and

examining the web site itself including prominent pages of the site for name and address information using a quick web site crawl; and

normalizing, comparing, and noting inconsistencies in addresses;

thereby producing cleaned-up name and address information.

11. The method of claim 10 wherein the step of normalizing, comparing, and noting inconsistencies in the addresses, thereby producing cleaned-up name and address information, comprises crosschecking name and address information comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

processing raw names and addresses through a cleanup and standardization procedure which utilizes a database of postal information;

comparing the addresses, once standardized, with each other; and

if addresses disagree, tagging the address information with lower confidence to be reflected in the integrity rating for the web site.

12. The method of claim 1, further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

scoring the business information; and

using the scored information to update the integrity rating in the database of domains so that future similar queries can be quickly processed.

13. The method of claim 5 wherein the step of scoring the business information comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

scoring the business information based on the information collected about a business;

computing a web site integrity rating from the scored business information; and

determining an annotation based on the web site integrity rating.

14. The method of claim 13, further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

coloring the annotation result returned to an end user for display in red, yellow, or green; and

returning the annotation result.

15. The method of claim 1 wherein the corporate registration information is obtained directly from public records, which are accessible via on-line query systems operated by states, provinces, and countries, and further comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

determining the appropriate jurisdiction to query; and

querying the appropriate jurisdiction for the corporate registration information.

16. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of querying business information comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a business rating service query generator, which, via the Internet, queries credit report data sites and business rating data sites; and

parsing the results by a rating service reply parser.

17. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of querying corporate registration information comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a corporate filing service query generator, which, via the Internet, queries corporate filing data sites; and

parsing the results by a filing service reply parser.

18. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of querying negative information comprises the steps of using a computer system for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a negative information query generator, which, via the Internet, queries negative information sources; and

parsing the results by a parser.

19. A computer-implemented method for providing a search for information available on the World Wide Web on the Internet having enhanced integrity, comprising the steps of using a computer system for:

generating a search query;

transmitting the search query via the Internet to a search engine using a web browser;

providing the search query to the search engine;

performing initial processing of the search query by the search engine;

performing the search and accumulating a set of search results by the search engine, each of which contains at least a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) identifying an Internet domain and page on the World Wide Web selected by the search;

receiving the search results;

extracting a list of URLs and domains mentioned in the search results;

using the list of domains to generate a domain query to send via the Internet to a web site integrity rating system;

receiving the domain query;

performing domain processing on the list of URLs and domains to associate a physical business address or business entity with each URL or domain;

returning a set of web site integrity ratings via the Internet;

using the web site integrity ratings to at least one of reorder and annotate the search results so as to move results with relatively low integrity ratings downward in the results;

returning the at least one of reordered and annotated search results to the web browser via the Internet;

whereby the search engine and the evaluation of web site integrity are performed by separate services and integrated from within the web browser;

formatting the at least one of reordered and annotated search results for display; and

displaying the at least one of the reordered and annotated search results.

20. The method of claim 19 wherein the browser-side processing is performed using a browser toolbar or as a web page containing code which reprocesses information from another web site, using “

Active-X Controls,”

“

Java Applets,”

or “

AJAX techniques.”

21. The method of claim 19 wherein web sites rated as having relatively high integrity are identified with a check mark in a circle, web sites for which insufficient information is obtained are identified with a question mark in a circle, and web sites rated as having relatively low integrity are identified with an “

X”

in a circle and wherein the web sites rated with relatively high integrity are moved to the top of the search results and web sites with relatively low integrity are moved down and displayed in smaller type in the search results.

22. A computer system including a web server and at least one other computer connected to the Internet for executing computer code stored in a computer readable storage medium to perform a search for information available on the World Wide Web on the Internet having enhanced integrity, comprising:

first code for generating a search query;

second code for transmitting the search query via the Internet to a search engine using a web browser;

third code for providing the search query to the search engine;

fourth code for performing initial processing of the search query by the search engine;

fifth code for performing the search and accumulating a set of search results by the search engine, each of which contains at least a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) identifying an Internet domain and page on the World Wide Web selected by the search;

sixth code for receiving the search results;

seventh code for extracting a list of URLs and domains;

eighth code for performing domain processing on the list of URLs and domains to associate a physical business address or business entity with each URL or domain,

wherein the eighth code comprises code for;

checking a domain name included as part of a URL against a database of domains;

if the domain is in the database, bypassing further processing;

if the domain is not in the database, using name and address extraction to attempt to obtain a physical name and address associated with the domain;

if a reliable name and address are obtained, collecting business information, wherein collecting business information comprises querying one or more sources of business information consisting of corporate registration information, business rating information, negative information comprising regulatory information, and, for the special case of well-recognized auction web sites and payment systems which undertake to rate, or at least reliably identify, their affiliated merchants, rating information is obtained from the auction or payment site using the cleaned-up name and address information;

ninth code for computing domain integrity ratings;

tenth code for using the integrity ratings to at least one of reorder and annotate the search results so as to move results with relatively lower integrity ratings downward in the results; and

eleventh code for returning the at least one of reordered and annotated search results to the web browser via the Internet.

23. The system of claim 22, further comprising:

a display device;

twelfth code for formatting the reordered and annotated search results for display; and

thirteenth code for displaying the reordered and annotated search results.

24. The system of claim 23 wherein web sites rated as having relatively high integrity are identified with a check mark in a circle, web sites for which insufficient information is obtained are identified with a question mark in a circle, and web sites rated as having relatively low integrity are identified with an “

X”

in a circle and wherein the web sites rated with relatively high integrity are moved to the top of the search results and web sites with relatively low integrity are moved down and displayed in smaller type in the search results.

25. The system of claim 22 wherein the search query is entered manually by an end user and transmitted through the computer running the web browser.

26. The system of claim 22 wherein the database is a local database of known domains and wherein the eighth code comprises:

twelfth code for checking a domain name included as part of a URL against the local database of known domains for which integrity ratings are available to eliminate unnecessary reprocessing of domains already evaluated and

if the domain is in the database indicating an integrity rating is already available, thirteenth code for bypassing further processing and returning an integrity rating immediately.

27. The system of claim 26 wherein in the event that the name and address of the business cannot be located, further comprising:

eighteenth code for sending control to a commerce site test where an attempt is made to determine whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce; and

if the web site appears to be engaged in commerce, but a name and address cannot be reliably associated with the site, nineteenth code for considering the site to be a less than legitimate business and assigning a relatively low integrity rating, whereby the effect is produced of substantially degrading search result placement and thus encouraging Internet businesses to comply with disclosure requirements.

28. The system of claim 27 wherein the commerce site test comprises code for determining whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce comprising code for:

examining the text of web pages originated by a quick web site crawl for indications that the web site is selling something; and

returning a yes/no decision.

29. The method of claim 28 wherein the quick web site crawl comprises code for:

limiting examination to the first few web pages of a web site beginning with a starting domain name or URL to determine if the site is selling something, which is added to a list of URLs to fetch;

for each domain name or URL, fetching the relevant web page by a web page reader via the Internet from the target web site to obtain a local copy of the web page;

examining the fetched web page for links to other web pages;

passing the fetched web page to a relevance tester, which uses a set of relevance rules to determine which links are relevant;

feeding back relevant links into the list of URLs to fetch and ignoring links which are not relevant; and

returning the web pages that are collected.

30. The system of claim 26 wherein in the event that the name and address of the business cannot be located, further comprising:

eighteenth code for sending control to a commerce site test where an attempt is made to determine whether or not the web site appears on its face to be engaged in commerce; and

if the web site is not selling anything, but is simply informational, nineteenth code for returning a neutral integrity rating.

31. The system of claim 26 wherein the fourteenth code comprises:

eighteenth code for performing one or more of the following;

accessing the domain name associated with a URL to obtain a name and address of the owner of the domain and the web site based on information provided for domain registration using the standard WHOIS protocol;

retrieving any available Secure Sockets Layer certificate also known as a “

X.509 certificate”

issued by certification authorities; and

examining the web site itself including prominent pages of the site for name and address information using a quick web site crawl; and

nineteenth code for normalizing, comparing, and noting inconsistencies in addresses;

whereby cleaned-up name and address information is produced.

32. The system of claim 31, further comprising a database of postal information and wherein the nineteenth code comprises code for crosschecking name and address information comprising:

twentieth code for processing raw names and addresses through a cleanup and standardization procedure which utilizes a database of postal information;

twenty-first code for comparing the addresses, once standardized, with each other; and

if addresses disagree, twenty-second code for tagging the address information with lower confidence to be reflected in the integrity rating for the web site.

33. The system of claim 22, further comprising:

twelfth code for scoring the business information; and

thirteenth code for using the scored information to update the integrity rating in the database of domains so that future similar queries can be quickly processed.

34. The system of claim 33 wherein the eighth code for querying business information comprises code for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a business rating service query generator, which, via the Internet, queries credit report data sites and business rating data sites; and

parsing the results by a rating service reply parser.

35. The system of claim 33 wherein the eighth code for querying corporate registration information comprises code for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a corporate filing service query generator, which, via the Internet, queries corporate filing data sites; and

parsing the results by a filing service reply parser.

36. The system of claim 33 wherein the eighth code for querying negative information comprises code for:

providing cleaned-up name and address information to a negative information query generator, which, via the Internet, queries negative information sources; and

parsing the results by a parser.

37. The system of claim 33 wherein the twelfth code comprises code for:

scoring the business information based on the information collected about a business;

computing a web site integrity rating from the scored business information; and

determining an annotation based on the web site integrity rating.

38. The system of claim 37, wherein the sixteenth code further comprises code for:

coloring the annotation result returned to an end user for display in red, yellow, or green; and

returning the annotation result.

39. The system of claim 22 wherein the corporate registration information is obtained directly from public records, which are accessible via on-line query systems operated by states, provinces, and countries, and the further comprising twentieth code for:

determining the appropriate jurisdiction to query; and

querying the appropriate jurisdiction for the corporate registration information.

40. A computer system including a web server and at least one other computer connected to the Internet for executing computer code stored in a computer readable storage medium to provide a search for information available on the World Wide Web on the Internet having enhanced integrity, comprising:

first code for generating a search query;

second code for transmitting the search query via the Internet to a search engine using a web browser;

third code for providing the search query to the search engine;

fourth code for performing initial processing of the search query by the search engine;

fifth code for performing the search and accumulating a set of search results by the search engine, each of which contains at least a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) identifying an Internet domain and page on the World Wide Web selected by the search;

sixth code for receiving the search results;

seventh code for extracting a list of URLs and domains mentioned in the search results;

eighth code for using the list of domains to generate a domain query to send via the Internet to a web site integrity rating system;

ninth code for receiving the domain query;

tenth code for performing domain processing on the list of URLs and domains to associate a physical business address or business entity with each URL or domain;

eleventh code for returning a set of web site integrity ratings via the Internet;

twelfth code for using the web site integrity ratings to at least one of reorder and annotate the search results so as to move results with relatively low integrity ratings downward in the results;

thirteenth code for returning the at least one of reordered and annotated search results to the web browser via the Internet;

whereby the search engine and the evaluation of web site integrity are performed by separate services and integrated from within the web browser;

fourteenth code for formatting the at least one of reordered and annotated search results for display; and

fifteenth code for displaying the at least one of reordered and annotated search results.

41. The system of claim 40 wherein the browser-side processing is performed by code using a browser toolbar or as a web page containing code which reprocesses information from another web site, using “

Active-X Controls,”

“

Java Applets,”

or “

AJAX techniques.”

42. The system of claim 40 wherein web sites rated as having relatively high integrity are identified with a check mark in a circle, web sites for which insufficient information is obtained are identified with a question mark in a circle, and web sites rated as having relatively low integrity are identified with an “

X”

in a circle and wherein the web sites rated with relatively high integrity are moved to the top of the search results and web sites with relatively low integrity are moved down and displayed in smaller type in the search results.