Computer system and method for training, certifying or monitoring human clinical raters

• US 8,282,397 B2
• Filed: 12/06/2011
• Issued: 10/09/2012
• Est. Priority Date: 10/26/2001
• Status: Expired due to Term

• Current Assignee: Signant Health Global LLC
• Original Assignee: UBC Specialty Clinical Services, LLC (Signant Health)
• Inventors: Sachs, Gary Steven, Perlis, Roy Howard, DeBonis, Daniel Vincent II
• Primary Examiner(s): Thai, Xuan
• Assistant Examiner(s): PAGE, EVAN RANDALL
• Application Number:
  US13/311,676
• Publication Number:
  US 20120078653A1
• Time in Patent Office: 308 Days
• Field of Search: 434322-323, 434/350, 434/354
• US Class Current: 434/322
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 23/28 for medicine
• CPC Class Codes: G09B 7/00 Electrically-operated teaching apparatus or devices working with questions and answers mechanically operated G09B3/00; computing arrangements G06F
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 10/20 for electronic clinical trials or questionnaires
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 10/60 for patient-specific data, e.g. for electronic patient records
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 50/20 for computer-aided diagnosis, e.g. based on medical expert systems
• CPC Class Codes: G16H 70/60 relating to pathologies

Abstract

A method and system are disclosed for computerized training, monitoring, certification or re-certification of human raters in clinical trials. The invention provides an interactive computerized interview that can be compared scores obtained by human raters to monitor and train clinical raters on a continuing basis in order to reduce rater drift and variance during clinical trials. Remediation can be automatically flagged or provided to improve a deviating rater'"'"'s performance. Computerized assessment of symptom severity is provided without the need for human clinical raters. The system and method enable screening of prospective patients for inclusion or exclusion from a clinical trial by automatically obtaining computerized ratings of symptom severity.

Claims

1. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received via at least one of a keyboard, a numerical keypad, a dial, a touch screen, a touch pad, a pointing device, a microphone, a telephone, a joystick, a game pad, a satellite dish, fax or a scanner;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

2. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score, wherein the processor is included in at least one of a personal computer, a hand-held device, a multi-processor system, a network computer, a minicomputer, or a mainframe computer.

3. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score;

wherein at least one of the first question and the selected second question are presented via a display device.

4. The method of claim 3, wherein the display device is at least one of a screen, a monitor, a television, a loudspeaker, or a telephone.

5. The method of claim 3, wherein the display device is included on a hand-held device.

6. The method of claim 3, wherein the display device is a screen on a handheld device.

7. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received via a personal computer, a hand-held device, a multi-processor system, a network computer, or a minicomputer;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

8. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received via at least one of a universal serial bus (USB) or CD ROM;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

9. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received via a network;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein the network comprises at least one of a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN), or a wireless LAN (WLAN).

11. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score;

wherein at least one of the first question and the selected second question are presented via a network.

12. The method of claim 11, wherein the network comprises at least one of a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN), or a wireless LAN (WLAN).

13. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received via a web page;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

14. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score;

wherein at least one of the first input and the second input are received from the subject via a web page.

15. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject, wherein the one or more rater inputs are received in response to a display of at least one of an audio segment, a video segment, or multimedia segment of an interview with the subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject; and

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.

16. The method of claim 15, further comprising storing the at least one of the audio segment, the video segment, or the multimedia segment in a memory.

17. A method for recertifying or monitoring performance of a clinical rater participating in a clinical trial comprising:

receiving one or more rater inputs reflecting the rater'"'"'s clinical evaluation of a severity of a previously diagnosed condition in a subject;

performing a computerized assessment of the subject to quantify the severity of the previously diagnosed condition in the subject through a computerized interview that comprises;

(a) presenting a first question to the subject and receiving a first input from the subject in response thereto;

(b) based on the first input, selecting a second question from a plurality of questions;

(c) presenting the selected second question-to the subject and receiving a second input from the subject in response thereto; and

(d) based on one or more inputs received from the subject, determining in accordance with a clinical rating scale a computerized severity score for the previously diagnosed condition in the subject;

(e) determining, via a processor, whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score; and

(f) calculating an overall rating based on the one or more rater inputs, wherein the overall rating is used to determine whether the one or more rater inputs are in accordance with the computerized severity score.