Method and apparatus for a universal certification process for food products

• US 9,619,761 B2
• Filed: 07/12/2012
• Issued: 04/11/2017
• Est. Priority Date: 11/02/2000
• Status: Active Grant

• Current Assignee: SureHarvest, Inc. (Where Food Comes From, Inc.)
• Original Assignee: SureHarvest, Inc. (Where Food Comes From, Inc.)
• Inventors: Dlott, Jeffrey W., Rosenberg, Harry W., Ohmart, Clifford P., Connolly, Rebecca
• Primary Examiner(s): Allen, Akiba
• Application Number:
  US13/547,596
• Publication Number:
  US 20120273569A1
• Time in Patent Office: 1,734 Days
• Field of Search: 705 11, 705 711, 13711802, 701468, 701494, 701 50, D15 25
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 10/063 Operations research, analysis or management
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/018 Certifying business or products
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 30/02 Marketing; Price estimation or determination; Fundraising
• CPC Class Codes: G06Q 50/02 Agriculture; Fishing; Forestry; Mining

Abstract

Various embodiments of the present disclosure include methods and apparatus for a universal certification process for food products. In an example embodiment, an apparatus comprises a hand-held device including a display and one or more input devices to sense product identification indicia associated with or affixed to a food product that is grown or raised in an agricultural operation. The hand-held device includes at least one processor to determine a machine-readable identification code from the product identification indicia; send the identification code to at least one remote server; receive, from the at least one remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product, the certification information indicating compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements; and display the certification information on the display in human readable form.

Claims

1. An apparatus, comprising:

a hand-held device including;

a display; and

one or more input devices to sense product identification indicia associated with or affixed to a food product that is grown or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product,

the hand-held device including at least one processor to;

determine a machine-readable identification code from the product identification indicia;

send the identification code to at least one remote server, the at least one remote server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in a report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

receive, from the at least one remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product at one or more of the series of agricultural operations in the series of agricultural operations in the chain of custody of the food product, the certification information based on information derived from at least one agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations and indicating compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements, wherein the at least one agricultural certification is generated by a universal computerized certification process that determines compliance of the agricultural product with at least one of the different certifications by comparing machine-readable product data associated with the product with respective machine-readable certification requirements for the different certifications; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

2. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

a keyboard;

bar code reader;

an imaging camera; and

, a radio frequency identification means.

3. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

optical, radio, infrared, audio, and video input devices.

25. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

4. An apparatus, comprising:

a computer including;

a display;

one or more input devices; and

at least one processor to;

receive an identification code from one or more of the input devices, the identification code corresponding to a food product grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product;

send the identification code to at least one remote server, the at least one remote server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

receive, from the at least one remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product at one or more of the series of agricultural operations in the series of agricultural operations in the chain of custody of the food product, the certification information based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations and indicating compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements, wherein the at least one agricultural certification is generated by a universal computerized certification process that determines compliance of the agricultural product with at least one of the different certifications by comparing machine-readable product data associated with the product with respective machine-readable certification requirements for the different certifications; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

5. The apparatus of claim 4, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

a keyboard;

a bar code reader;

an imaging camera; and

, a radio frequency identification means.

6. The apparatus of claim 4, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

optical, radio, infrared, audio, and video input devices.

7. A system comprising one or more processors to:

receive an identification code from one or more input devices, the identification code corresponding to a food product grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product;

receive or store, at a remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product at one or more of the series of agricultural operations in the chain of custody of the food product, the certification information based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations and indicating compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements, wherein the at least one agricultural certification is generated by a universal computerized certification process that determines compliance of the agricultural product with at least one of the different certifications by comparing machine-readable product data associated with the product with respective machine-readable certification requirements for the different certifications, the remote server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

8. The system of claim 7, wherein the system further includes a computer or hand-held device comprising at least one of the processors, and wherein the at least one processor is further to receive, from the one or more remote servers, at least some of the agricultural certification information that is associated with the product.

9. The system of claim 7, wherein the computer or hand-held device includes the display to which at least some of the agricultural certification information is sent.

10. The system of claim 7, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

a keyboard;

a bar code reader;

an imaging camera; and

, a radio frequency identification means.

11. The system of claim 7, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

optical, radio, infrared, audio, and video input devices.

26. The system of claim 7, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

12. A system comprising:

a network;

at least one database, accessible on the network, the database including agricultural certification information that is associated with a food product grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product, the certification information based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations and indicating compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements, wherein the at least one agricultural certification is generated by a universal computerized certification process that determines compliance of the agricultural product with at least one of the different certifications by comparing machine-readable product data associated with the product with respective machine-readable certification requirements for the different certifications; and

a server, operatively connected to the network, wherein the server includes one or more modules implemented by one or more processors;

a memory,

software operable on the processor to;

receive an identification code from one or more input devices, the identification code corresponding to the food product;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

13. The system of claim 12, wherein the software is further operable to receive, from the one or more remote servers, at least some of the agricultural certification information that is associated with the product.

14. The system of claim 12, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

a keyboard;

a bar code reader;

an imaging camera; and

, a radio frequency identification means.

15. The system of claim 12, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

optical, radio, infrared, audio, and video input devices.

27. The system of claim 12, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

16. A computer-implemented method comprising using one or more processors at a computer server to:

receive an identification code from one or more input devices, the identification code corresponding to a food product grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product;

receive or store, at the computer server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product, the agricultural certification information indicating based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations and compliance of the product with at least one of a plurality of different agricultural certifications, each from different certification authorities and each having different requirements, wherein the at least one agricultural certification is generated by a universal computerized certification process that determines compliance of the agricultural product with at least one of the different certifications by comparing machine-readable product data associated with the product with respective machine-readable certification requirements for the different certifications, the computer server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

17. The method of claim 16, further comprising receiving at a computer or hand-held device, from the one or more remote servers, at least some of the agricultural certification information that is associated with the product.

18. The method of claim 16, wherein the computer or hand-held device includes the display to which at least some of the agricultural certification information is sent.

19. The method of claim 16, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

a keyboard;

a bar code reader;

an imaging camera; and

, a radio frequency identification means.

20. The method of claim 16, wherein the one or more input devices includes one or more of the following:

optical, radio, infrared, audio, and video input devices.

28. The method of claim 16, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

21. A method for producing a certification data product, the method comprising:

storing, by a server, machine-readable certification requirement data in a computer database, the requirement data specifying certification requirements received from a respective plurality of different certification authorities for a respective plurality of product certifications;

storing machine-readable agricultural production data in the computer database, the agricultural production data received for a respective plurality of different agricultural products grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product, the server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

determining compliance of at least one of the agricultural products with at least one of the product certifications using the machine-readable certification requirement data and the machine readable agricultural production data; and

producing a certification data product including certification data indicating compliance of the at least one agricultural product with the at least one product certification, the certification data based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation, the one or more modules incorporated into the server to configure a capability of the server to automatically generate or display the certification data product based on the receiving of the first agricultural data from the single agricultural operation, and the receiving of the second agricultural data from the plurality of agricultural operations, the one or more modules implemented by one or more processors of the server.

29. The method of claim 21, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

22. A certification apparatus, comprising:

a machine-readable computer database;

to store by a server machine-readable certification requirement data in a computer database, the requirement data specifying certification requirements received from a respective plurality of different certification authorities for a respective plurality of product certifications; and

to store machine-readable agricultural production data in the computer database, the agricultural production data received for a respective plurality of different agricultural products grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product the server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

one or more programmed computers operable to;

determine compliance of at least one of the agricultural products with at least one of the product certifications using the machine-readable certification requirement data and the machine-readable agricultural production data; and

produce a certification data product including certification data indicating compliance of the at least one agricultural products with the at least one product certification, the certification data product based on information derived by at least one agricultural operation, and the one or more modules incorporated into the server to configure a capability of the server to automatically generate or display the certification data product based on the receiving of the first agricultural data from the single agricultural operation, and the receiving of the second agricultural data from the plurality of agricultural operations, the one or more modules implemented by one or more processors of the server.

30. The apparatus of claim 22, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

23. An apparatus, comprising:

a hand-held device including;

a display; and

one or more input devices to sense product identification indicia associated with or affixed to a food product that is grown or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product,

the hand-held device including at least one processors to;

determine a machine-readable identification code from the product identification indicia;

send the identification code to at least one remote server, the at least one remote server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

receive, from the at least one remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product, the agricultural certification information being associated with the product using the machine-readable identification code, the certification information based on information derived by at least one agricultural operation; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

31. The apparatus of claim 23, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.

24. An apparatus, comprising:

a computer including;

a display; and

one or more input devices; and

at least one processor to;

receive an identification code from one or more of the input devices, the identification code corresponding to a food product grown, produced or raised in an agricultural operation, the agricultural operation being one in a series of agricultural operations in a chain of custody of the food product;

send the identification code to at least one remote server, the at least one remote server including one or more modules implemented by one or more processors, the one or more modules configured to, at least;

receive first agricultural data from a single agricultural operation in the series of agricultural operations, the first received data including a first data record from a first custodian device located at a first location in the series of agricultural operations at which the first custodian device read a first code that pairs a data type with the first location, the first data record pairing a first value that quantifies the data type with the first code that pairs the data type with the first location;

receive second agricultural data from a plurality of agricultural locations in the series of agricultural operations, the second received data including a second data record from a second custodian device located at a second location in the plurality of locations in the series of agricultural operations at which the second custodian device read a second code that pairs the data type with the second location, the second data record pairing a second value that quantifies the data type with the second code that pairs the data type with the second location;

generate an aggregate result for the data type based on at least the first and second data and a determination or condition that an aggregated set of data records that includes the first and second data records is basis for automatic generation of a report about the data type; and

generate and include in the report comparative agricultural information using the aggregate result and at least some of the first or second data and indicate in the report whether the data type that is paired with the first and second locations by the first and second codes meets or does not meet the aggregate result for the data type;

receive, from the at least one remote server, agricultural certification information that is associated with the product, the agricultural certification information being associated with the product using the machine-readable identification code and based on information derived by the at least one agricultural operation; and

cause a user device to receive and display the generated report about the data type, the user device being distinct from the first and second custodian devices from which the first and second data records are collectively received.

32. The apparatus of claim 24, wherein the chain of custody includes an authentication system that verifies the authenticity of the chain of custody information using one or more of a custodial identifier, certification agent identifier, accreditation agent identifier, third-party representative identifier, government representative identifier, certification authority identifier, unique location identifier, custodial location identifier, custodial time and date stamp, or custodial witness digital signature.